Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten
Posted 10/26/2011 2:09:05 PM by pnbplus1


Posted by mamabear


Posted by Karen

Honestly, no - for the reasons you listed, I would not hold her back.

I am not sure I understand your reasoning - why is 2 years apart in school such a big deal?



It's not that 2 years is a big deal. It's that it doesn't reflect what they are. They are really just about 1 year apart. They are intellectually and socially very similar right now. You would never look at them or be around them and see kids that are 2 years apart. I'm worried that them being 2 years apart in school would change them to seem 2 years apart. I'm not even sure it matters if it does--it's just a forced change in their relationship that doesn't reflect reality. Does that make any sense?



I wouldn't do it for the reasons you listed. If anything, you holding one back so they can be only 1 yr apart in school is a "forced change" since you are in essence taking things into your own hands and changing their timelines. It's not about relecting what they are (about what, 13 months apart) but about reflecting WHO they are. If your DD is ready for kindergarten at age 4, you should send her and do what it best for HER without regard to the fact that your other DD will be 2 yrs behind in school. They are each their own person, and don't need to be only 1 yr apart in school. I think you should think about what it is that really bothers you and what you fear happening, if your one DD starts at age 4. Once you understand what is truly motivating you, then make a decision based solely on what is best for your child.

As for starting college at 17 vs 18, 18 yr olds can still be immature. 1 yr may or may not change that. You are trying to control too much and they haven't even grown up yet.
Print Post      Close Window