Would you sue?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Would you sue?

I'm just looking for some impartial input.

I don't know if anyone saw my previous post, but my son banged his head on a metal file cabinet in his classroom and ended up with a injury to his forhead that required plastic surgery (he severed tissue, the muscle and it was right down to the bone). It's about 3/4" horizontally in the middle of his forehead. The file cabinet is short metal one - only two drawers high. He went to bend over and whacked is head right into the corner.

I know the world is sue crazy, and my husband and I weren't really even thinking about, but several of out friends and aquaintances think we should.

The funny part is my husband is an attorney, but he told we could do whatever I want. I just don't want to look like greedy parents.

Message edited 2007-01-07 15:58:57.590000.

Posted 1/7/07 3:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?

What would you be sueing for? I'm not a lawyer but how was the school negligent? Chat Icon

Posted 1/7/07 3:59 PM
 

KPtoys
I'm getting old

Member since 5/05

8688 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Would you sue?

I would not sue. Yes, it was a metal filing cabinet and yes, your son hurt himself but it wasn't like he couldn't have avoided the situation himself. He caused it...

Posted 1/7/07 4:01 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Would you sue?

I wouldn't - kids fall and bang there heads on things- it's life

and if you sue the school where you child goes you are taking money and time away from what the school should be doing- teaching

Posted 1/7/07 4:02 PM
 

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Would you sue?

Just that they had a metal file cabinet in the room without some sort of corner guard of anything on it. The kids are only a little taller than the cabinet (1st grade).

Like I said, I am not greedy and I don't want to come off as greedy. But if my son would be entitled to anything for getting hurt on school property, than I feel as though maybe we should - at least to go into his college fund.

At the very least, if we don't do anything else, I was going to ask them to please find some type of protection for the corner of the file cabinet. He could have lost an eye if he moved a little differently, and that is scary to me.

Message edited 2007-01-07 16:05:17.550000.

Posted 1/7/07 4:04 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by Beth1210

I wouldn't - kids fall and bang there heads on things- it's life

and if you sue the school where you child goes you are taking money and time away from what the school should be doing- teaching



I agree 100%. Kids are kids and they are always getting hurt. I hope your son is feeling better.

Posted 1/7/07 4:05 PM
 

Kate07
Feel better my little guy!

Member since 5/05

4476 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by Beth1210

I wouldn't - kids fall and bang there heads on things- it's life

and if you sue the school where you child goes you are taking money and time away from what the school should be doing- teaching



I agree. I think you should have them do something about the cabinets though. Don't want something like that again!

Posted 1/7/07 4:08 PM
 

-Laurie-
Hi!

Member since 5/05

2536 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?

I could understand a possible lawsuit if you don't have insurance but at that point you could probably be covered by the school.

But besides that every classroom I have ever been in has those cabinets normally close to the teachers desk and I don't see why you would sue for an accident. Heck, I have one in my house if your son fell and that happened in my house would you sue me? Kids fall, I don't see the need for lawsuits.


Posted 1/7/07 4:08 PM
 

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Would you sue?

I also agree with all of you. The is the first thing that went through my head - kids fall and get hurt - it's part of being a kid.

It's just that some people hear your story and start putting thoughts in your head, and then you start second guessing what you should do. It never even came across our minds to sue - we are not like that (and as I said, my husband himself is a lawyer). We have a great relationship with the teacher and the school and abosolutely don't want to cause any problems.

Like I said, I was just looking for some impartial advice, because I was second guessing our original decision because too many people (some friends and family) like to give unsolicited advice and are a pain in the azz.

Message edited 2007-01-07 16:13:05.603000.

Posted 1/7/07 4:11 PM
 

MsMitcia
27 dresses.?.ha..TY everyone

Member since 8/06

1527 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Would you sue?

No, I wouldn't sue. But, I would tell the school what happened and you would like them to maybe do something in ensure it doesn't happen again (ie. putting guards on the corner, removing filing cab)

Posted 1/7/07 4:13 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by Beth1210

I wouldn't - kids fall and bang there heads on things- it's life

and if you sue the school where you child goes you are taking money and time away from what the school should be doing- teaching



Wouldn't it be covered by insurance? You wuld rally be suing an insurance co. no? I would just go with your first instinct, not to sue and then get the school to cover the corners

Posted 1/7/07 4:17 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Would you sue?

I think the only basis you would have to sue would be if there was not ample supervision. For example if the teacher wasnt in the room or if she were on her cell phone and may have been able to prevent the accident, then YES I would sue. But accidents do happen.


More often than not, in our school, the accidents happen in the gym or in the playground. However,due to the nature of the population we serve, we have to take extra precautions to assure safety of our students. We DO get audited from outside agencies. We need to have all sharp objects in drawers and electrical appliances out of reach. That worked REALLY well when I had a student who was 6 ft 4 and 300 poundsChat Icon

Posted 1/7/07 4:18 PM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?

I would not sue, accidents happen. He could have just as well bumped his head on a piece of furniture in your house or someone else's house.

I've been teaching for 13 years and I've never heard it be standard practice to have guards on cabinets. Even in the self-contained class that has kids with very special needs in my district there are no such things.

Do you have insurance?
Was your son permanently disabled from the accident?
If yes to first question and no to the second then it's a frivolous lawsuit IMO.

Posted 1/7/07 4:24 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Would you sue?

IF you were going to sue, I would only sue for the cost of the medical treatment. Kids to fall and get banged up from time to time but if you see fit but don't want to go to extremes than that's what I would do, sue for the cost of medical treatment.

good luck!

Posted 1/7/07 4:25 PM
 

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by CoopersMom01

IF you were going to sue, I would only sue for the cost of the medical treatment. Kids to fall and get banged up from time to time but if you see fit but don't want to go to extremes than that's what I would do, sue for the cost of medical treatment.

good luck!



We have good insurance, so we are okay on that end. The school said they would already pick up anything that wasn't covered.

Posted 1/7/07 4:31 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by 4ForMe
We have good insurance, so we are okay on that end. The school said they would already pick up anything that wasn't covered.



then i see no point in suing. and if you had no insurance, they would most likely cover it all anyway. he's a kid, he got hurt- it's what kids do. If the cabinet fell on him, maybe it would be a different story, but it didn't. I'm sorry- it jsut seems kind of silly to ask if you should sue for something, when you don't know what exactly you're going to sue for... it llooks kind of eager, i guess.

Posted 1/7/07 4:45 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: Would you sue?

I also see no point in suing - and forget all these people who are sue crazy...that's why our insurance bills are so high. When I got rear-ended everyone told me to sue and I actually contemplated it. But, in the long run all it does is cost money and if it's a frivolous lawsuit, what are you really proving?

Posted 1/7/07 4:56 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?

I wouldnt sue either but I would definitly be heading to the principals office about moving the filing cabinet to an area maybe behind the teachers desk on in a closet. I agree with kids getting hurt but your child was severly hurt and I think that is a big difference then getting a bump on the head with a minor scratch on the head.

Posted 1/7/07 4:56 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?

No. I would not sue.

Posted 1/7/07 4:58 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Would you sue?

i, also, don't understand what you would sue for. your medical bills were taken care of and no one was negligent.

metal filing cabinets are standard in a classroom. what else would you have? and almost all areas of a classroom are accessable by kids at some point. even having the cabinet behind the teacher's desk wouldn't necessarily prevent a future accident from happening--that's why they're called accidents! also, i've never seen a guard for a filing cabinet.

i am glad that your son is okay! that is the MOST important part!!!!


**************************
this is not aimed at you, it is a general comment about suing----i think the world we live in is way too sue happy. people don't take responsibility for things and always look to blame others, when sometimes it's not necessarily someone else's fault. i hate that you always have to look over your shoulder because you could be sued for just about anythingChat Icon

Posted 1/7/07 5:09 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by neenie

Posted by 4ForMe
We have good insurance, so we are okay on that end. The school said they would already pick up anything that wasn't covered.



then i see no point in suing. and if you had no insurance, they would most likely cover it all anyway. he's a kid, he got hurt- it's what kids do. If the cabinet fell on him, maybe it would be a different story, but it didn't. I'm sorry- it jsut seems kind of silly to ask if you should sue for something, when you don't know what exactly you're going to sue for... it llooks kind of eager, i guess.



I agree. It would also make the superintendent and teachers really hate you.

Posted 1/7/07 5:10 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by Seles81

I wouldnt sue either but I would definitly be heading to the principals office about moving the filing cabinet to an area maybe behind the teachers desk on in a closet.



make sure, if you do this, that you go to the TEACHER first. don't go over her head to the principal without giving the teacher the courtesy of a conversation about your son's safety

Posted 1/7/07 5:10 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by neenie

Posted by 4ForMe
We have good insurance, so we are okay on that end. The school said they would already pick up anything that wasn't covered.



then i see no point in suing. and if you had no insurance, they would most likely cover it all anyway. he's a kid, he got hurt- it's what kids do. If the cabinet fell on him, maybe it would be a different story, but it didn't. I'm sorry- it jsut seems kind of silly to ask if you should sue for something, when you don't know what exactly you're going to sue for... it llooks kind of eager, i guess.



I agree. I would talk to the classroom teacher about your concerns. If you didn't have insurance, I would react differently but thankfully, your child is safe and that is what matters.

Posted 1/7/07 5:25 PM
 

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by neenie

Posted by 4ForMe
We have good insurance, so we are okay on that end. The school said they would already pick up anything that wasn't covered.



then i see no point in suing. and if you had no insurance, they would most likely cover it all anyway. he's a kid, he got hurt- it's what kids do. If the cabinet fell on him, maybe it would be a different story, but it didn't. I'm sorry- it jsut seems kind of silly to ask if you should sue for something, when you don't know what exactly you're going to sue for... it llooks kind of eager, i guess.



I'm sorry if you think I came across as eager - because I definitely am not. It was never my intention to sue - and yes, I am not even sure what technicality I would sue for. I'm guess I am just trying to say other people today made me feel like I'm not doing the right thing by not pursuing this and I was just questioning the whole thing.

Nonetheless, I am going to request to the teacher to please do something about the edge of that file cabinet.



Posted 1/7/07 6:07 PM
 

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Would you sue?

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Seles81

I wouldnt sue either but I would definitly be heading to the principals office about moving the filing cabinet to an area maybe behind the teachers desk on in a closet.



make sure, if you do this, that you go to the TEACHER first. don't go over her head to the principal without giving the teacher the courtesy of a conversation about your son's safety



I have no problem with the teacher. This is my second child to have her and we absolutely love her. She has a very tough job - our district is on austerity and she has 32 5/6 year olds with no aide classroom.

Posted 1/7/07 6:09 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Bindy Sue Irwin gives speech at her Dad's tribute in Australia.... johnsae 9/20/06 24 Families Helping Families ™
Peggy Sue Got Married leighla 7/27/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
Sue has a new daughter michele31 3/6/06 10 Pregnancy