Would this annoy you?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

citywife
LIF Adult

Member since 10/10

994 total posts

Name:
Expecting #3

Would this annoy you?

When DS was born, MIL asked DH for his social security number to open a bank account for him with her as custodian, at her local bank that has no branches near us (closest is 1.5 hours away). I didn't know about it at the time but later she said it was so it would be easier for her to give him money. The account is held in his name with HER as custodian. He is now almost 4 and the only times she has deposited money is at birthdays and holidays, when everyone else would give a check (i.e. its not like she was putting money in every week). It has always bothered me that she did this.. not because I think she is going to take back the money she gave DS, it just seems like a way for her to be in control. Like why can't she just give a cash or check for us to deposit in the account we hold for him at our bank?

Fast forward to yesterday... DD is turning one next week and she texted me asking for her social so she can open an account for DD as well, again with MIL as custodian. I am just so bothered and annoyed by this. I haven't written back yet. What would you do? Should I reply and say "we already have accounts for the kids at our bank" or just go along with her?

Posted 6/25/15 5:46 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

MY inlaws did this. i swear it was a control issue or rather just them pretending to be the parents again. they just wanted to have her social. i feel sooo weird about them having it. my own parents dont even know her social and they lost it once and asked for it again, i have no idea what they are doing. but i feel like, especially if you gave her the social for one of them, you have to play along now and give her for the other one too.

Posted 6/25/15 5:51 PM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Would this annoy you?

I think it's weird. When dd was born we opened up market and banking accounts for her with dh as the custodian. He's in finance and that's his job so he's the one to buy stocks, etc. I literally would have no clue. Anyway, my fil gives is a check or cash for dd and we deposit it. Our kid, our custodial accounts.

I wouldn't want anyone other than me or dh as the custodian. We will do the same for dd2

As for your dd. talk to your husband since it's his mother but I would prefer to say we already have accounts for the kids (dd) and it would be easier to keep it all in once place and just to get a check that you an deposit etc

Posted 6/25/15 5:58 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

I get being annoyed but just be gracious that they are giving your son money and assume that she has the best intentions for him.

Like it or not They are the ones giving the gift so they should be able to do as the please.

Posted 6/25/15 6:25 PM
 

Strawberry2468
It's summatime

Member since 3/09

4739 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Would this annoy you?

That's weird. Definitely a control thing. Which is very annoying.

Posted 6/25/15 6:26 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Would this annoy you?

I think it's weird that you gave the birthday money etc for her to deposit. In that case I would've had my own account for my child and let MIL put in her money whenever she can to the account she has set up. Or did I read it wrong?

Posted 6/25/15 6:42 PM
 

citywife
LIF Adult

Member since 10/10

994 total posts

Name:
Expecting #3

Re: Would this annoy you?

Posted by Sash

I think it's weird that you gave the birthday money etc for her to deposit. In that case I would've had my own account for my child and let MIL put in her money whenever she can to the account she has set up. Or did I read it wrong?



We didn't give her anything to deposit. We set up our own accounts for our kids to give them money and to deposit checks from other people. The MIL accounts are for her gifts to the kids.

Posted 6/25/15 6:44 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Would this annoy you?

Posted by citywife

Posted by Sash

I think it's weird that you gave the birthday money etc for her to deposit. In that case I would've had my own account for my child and let MIL put in her money whenever she can to the account she has set up. Or did I read it wrong?



We didn't give her anything to deposit. We set up our own accounts for our kids to give them money and to deposit checks from other people. The MIL accounts are for her gifts to the kids.



Oh lol, I thought all his birthday money she was depositing. This wouldn't annoy me, I would just think she didn't trust I would hold on to the money. I would let her set up an account for DD.

Posted 6/25/15 6:51 PM
 

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

No, this wouldn't annoy me at all. We have accounts for DS and DD. My in-laws have their own accounts and my parents have their own as well. I know many people that have this situation, never even thought twice about it. I am just so grateful to have others putting aside money because with the cost of daycare, we barely have set aside any money for the kids yet ourselves. Please don't take this the wrong way, but it sounds like more of a control thing for you. As in, you want to control the money and don't like that she is. As long as the kids get it in the end, what does it matter?

Posted 6/25/15 7:05 PM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

I think it's a pride thing:
Like "look at how much money I've been able to save for child across the years".
Don't let it get to you: could be so much worse.

Posted 6/25/15 7:06 PM
 

Loveme
LIF Adult

Member since 6/11

3170 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Would this annoy you?

Nope wouldn't be annoyed at all. I'd be gracious that she's setting up accounts and putting $$$ into it.
My grandmother actually did something similar for all her grandchildren.

Posted 6/25/15 7:16 PM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

Posted by nycgirl

I think it's a pride thing:
Like "look at how much money I've been able to save for child across the years".
Don't let it get to you: could be so much worse.



I was thinking the same thing.

Posted 6/25/15 7:44 PM
 

IVFmiracle
Complete

Member since 12/12

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

It wouldn't annoy me at all. In fact, my father has a 529 plan for each of his grandchildren.

Posted 6/25/15 7:51 PM
 

OhBaby2
LIF Infant

Member since 1/15

309 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

This wouldn't annoy me at all and as someone who works for a financial institution, it's actually very common that grandparents come in and open custodial accounts for their grandchildren. My mom opened an investment account for my DS as her way of saving for his future (not just college, but if he had a big purchase/life event) and she makes contributions for birthdays, holidays, etc. I think it's generous and appreciate the offer.

Not sure how I would feel if it was an in-law (do you think MIL doesn't have good intentions?), but as long as I wasn't concerned about the account being abused in some way, I would think its a nice gesture.

Posted 6/25/15 8:30 PM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: Would this annoy you?

Posted by nycgirl

I think it's a pride thing:
Like "look at how much money I've been able to save for child across the years".
Don't let it get to you: could be so much worse.



Exactly!
It's her money she's depositing as gifts...I doubt she means harm.
She loves her granddaughter, just leave it at that!

Posted 6/25/15 8:43 PM
 

M514
Hi

Member since 8/10

6011 total posts

Name:

Would this annoy you?

It would annoy me just because it seems so unnecessary for her to do that since she's just depositing birthday/holiday money. Why can't she just give you a check or cash for you to deposit for your own kids??

Posted 6/25/15 8:56 PM
 

hopingforbaby
We made a wish & you came true

Member since 2/10

2695 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Would this annoy you?

I think the answer all depends on your ILs personalities and your relationship with them. My FIL did this and I have absolutely no problem with this. He has offered to change the custodians name to one of us but I actually prefer knowing that DS has money out there that I can't/won't touch (obviously I wouldn't do that regardless unless I was absolutely desperate but still). I don't believe for a second that he did this to have any sort of control over anyone. He is just extremely generous, adores his only grandson, and wants to give him all he can.

Posted 6/25/15 8:57 PM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

Sounds like a lot of grandparents are doing this. Basically, they don't want anyone touching the money.

Posted 6/25/15 8:58 PM
 

StarsStripes
LIF Adult

Member since 12/12

1192 total posts

Name:

Would this annoy you?

It wouldn't bother me because I also have my own for them. I would not be giving them the checks that other people gave my child.

Posted 6/25/15 9:00 PM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Would this annoy you?

Not the ideal situation but at the end of the day someone is nice enough to give my child a gift/money then I am thankful and let it be

Posted 6/25/15 9:18 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Would this annoy you?

Posted by StarsStripes

It wouldn't bother me because I also have my own for them. I would not be giving them the checks that other people gave my child.


I agree. They're not taking anything away from you. If that's the way they want to do it, if they're controlling or whatever, yeah maybe it's a little annoying that you can't have any control over it yourself, but look at it like they're saving money for your children & that's a good thing to be grateful for. Maybe they don't want to have to give you a check every time & they want to keep track of how much they've given your child over time... and that's their decision to make actually and their right as the ones giving the gift.
I wish my ILs would do this... they'd rather constantly waste a ton of money on more & more stuff/junk my kids don't need than save that $ in an account for their future (don't get me wrong I appreciate that they buy stuff for my kids, I really do, I just would love if they'd give them the cash instead sometimes). So I think it depends how you look at it.

Posted 6/25/15 9:58 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

Posted by StarsStripes

It wouldn't bother me because I also have my own for them. I would not be giving them the checks that other people gave my child.



I agree.

And actually exactly how I felt when my ex-SIL mentioned that her parents were doing this for my niece and nephew.

My niece got her money when she graduated high school. She was very happy about itChat Icon

My nephew still has a few years.


I really don't see the issue. I would do it for my grandkids.

Posted 6/25/15 10:04 PM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Would this annoy you?

My MIL did the same thing. She opened a 529 for DD even we told her we already had one set up for her. And then she put $25 in it, over 2 years ago, and hasn't deposited anything else to it since. We get the statements so we can see she hasn't contributed to it at all. So 8 don't see why she needed to create a separate account instead of just respecting that DH and I had already set one up.

Posted 6/25/15 11:18 PM
 

FirstMate
My lil cowboy

Member since 10/10

7790 total posts

Name:

Re: Would this annoy you?

It doesn't bother me at all. My parents did this for DS when he was born. They deposit money in it from time to time. I think it's nice.

Posted 6/26/15 12:21 AM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Would this annoy you?

it would annoy me because there is a bank account my kid can access the second he turns 18 and use that money to make some unwise decisions.

also, remind me if i got this right, but when considering students for loans and financial aid in college, don't they also consider any money the student has in their name? So the more they have, the less "in need" they seem? wouldn't having 2 bank accounts be detrimental?

Posted 6/26/15 6:12 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
things that really annoy you about being a homeowner... MeeshMosh 8/8/08 48 Home
Does it annoy you when people dont keep the "Christ" in Christmas? alnem 11/28/07 74 Families Helping Families ™
Candy Thief! Would This Annoy You?? Brittny817 11/1/07 45 Families Helping Families ™
My next question, I warned you! Does your husband mean well but ANNOY you? curliegirl 4/24/07 15 Pregnancy
The other dr. at my office is starting to annoy me. snuggleupagus 4/23/07 0 Pregnancy
Would this annoy you, or is it just me it annoys? MrsRbk 4/6/07 12 Families Helping Families ™