what to do...UPDATE
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: what to do...
Message edited 2011-11-22 22:25:26.307000. |
|
Posted 1/22/09 10:27 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: what to do... Posted by Kara Posted by ave1024 Posted by Kara Posted by ave1024 Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin that's a bit of a stretch don't you think. so those disclaimers on tickets to events, airlines etc. they don't mean diddly squat? Not at all. The complex was negligent. And I am not sure what you are talking about regarding disclaimers on tickets. Companies can write all the disclaimers they want. How can you possibly determine that the complex was negligent based solely on what has been posted? As a lawyer, I sure can't and I highly doubt a judge could either... I don't own the car. I don't know all the facts. But to say "the complex is not responsible because of a disclaimer in the lease"... that's ridiculous. I can tell you right off the bat if they have parking that's close enough to the large garbage gates, that's pretty negligent right there to allow that. Whether or not it was the complex or the sanitation that opened the gates and hit the car, having the gates there in the first place, and not having something to block the gates from hitting parked cars is pretty negligent. I would never park in that spot if this was the case. Is this assigned parking where you always have the same spot? or is it pick and choose? Actually, the disclaimer argument is NOT ridiculous and if you spent any time actually litigating, you'd know that disclaimers and liability releases OFTEN hold water. You're making a LOT of assumptions here and basically giving out legal advice - poor legal advice at that. None of us know what is in her lease. None of us know whether or not something in her lease will or will not hold water. None of us know what the complex's insurance coverage is. And CERTAINLY none of us know whether or not the complex was negligent. Heck, we can back up a step and even say that none of us knows if negligence is even the appropriate standard of liability in this situation. The simple fact is that none of us has enough information to say with the degree of certainty you are trying to imply that the complex was negligent and nothing in her lease can release them of liability. And, no, you can't tell me that having parking close to the garage is per se negligent... because it's not. If it's SO obvious that gates would damage a car, why do you think the court wouldn't find that anyone parking there assumes the risk of having their car damaged by the gates? Negligence is NEVER cut and dry. Sorry, but your blanket statements are simply NOT true and you are making far too many assumptions. Agreed. Since when are there absolutes in law? Everything is case specific but I believe that there is an obligation to notify your insurance company of any damage to your car. Then there is the issue of whether there is a lease or loan on the car, what kind of insurance you are obligated to have under that contract....and so on and so forth. |
|
Posted 1/22/09 10:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: what to do... Posted by Kerie-is-so-very Posted by Kara Posted by ave1024 Posted by Kara Posted by ave1024 Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin that's a bit of a stretch don't you think. so those disclaimers on tickets to events, airlines etc. they don't mean diddly squat? Not at all. The complex was negligent. And I am not sure what you are talking about regarding disclaimers on tickets. Companies can write all the disclaimers they want. How can you possibly determine that the complex was negligent based solely on what has been posted? As a lawyer, I sure can't and I highly doubt a judge could either... I don't own the car. I don't know all the facts. But to say "the complex is not responsible because of a disclaimer in the lease"... that's ridiculous. I can tell you right off the bat if they have parking that's close enough to the large garbage gates, that's pretty negligent right there to allow that. Whether or not it was the complex or the sanitation that opened the gates and hit the car, having the gates there in the first place, and not having something to block the gates from hitting parked cars is pretty negligent. I would never park in that spot if this was the case. Is this assigned parking where you always have the same spot? or is it pick and choose? Actually, the disclaimer argument is NOT ridiculous and if you spent any time actually litigating, you'd know that disclaimers and liability releases OFTEN hold water. You're making a LOT of assumptions here and basically giving out legal advice - poor legal advice at that. None of us know what is in her lease. None of us know whether or not something in her lease will or will not hold water. None of us know what the complex's insurance coverage is. And CERTAINLY none of us know whether or not the complex was negligent. Heck, we can back up a step and even say that none of us knows if negligence is even the appropriate standard of liability in this situation. The simple fact is that none of us has enough information to say with the degree of certainty you are trying to imply that the complex was negligent and nothing in her lease can release them of liability. And, no, you can't tell me that having parking close to the garage is per se negligent... because it's not. If it's SO obvious that gates would damage a car, why do you think the court wouldn't find that anyone parking there assumes the risk of having their car damaged by the gates? Negligence is NEVER cut and dry. Sorry, but your blanket statements are simply NOT true and you are making far too many assumptions. Agreed. Since when are there absolutes in law? Everything is case specific but I believe that there is an obligation to notify your insurance company of any damage to your car. Then there is the issue of whether there is a lease or loan on the car, what kind of insurance you are obligated to have under that contract....and so on and so forth. I also agree that there is likely an obligation to notify your insurance company of any damage. I don't think in practice everyone performs that obligation... but I'd bet your insurance company does require that. |
|
Posted 1/22/09 10:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: what to do...
Message edited 2011-11-22 22:25:42.270000. |
|
Posted 1/22/09 10:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: what to do...UPDATE update at top |
|
Posted 1/23/09 10:03 AM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: what to do...UPDATE Posted by Kara Actually, the disclaimer argument is NOT ridiculous and if you spent any time actually litigating, you'd know that disclaimers and liability releases OFTEN hold water. You're making a LOT of assumptions here and basically giving out legal advice - poor legal advice at that. None of us know what is in her lease. None of us know whether or not something in her lease will or will not hold water. None of us know what the complex's insurance coverage is. And CERTAINLY none of us know whether or not the complex was negligent. Heck, we can back up a step and even say that none of us knows if negligence is even the appropriate standard of liability in this situation. The simple fact is that none of us has enough information to say with the degree of certainty you are trying to imply that the complex was negligent and nothing in her lease can release them of liability. And, no, you can't tell me that having parking close to the garage is per se negligent... because it's not. If it's SO obvious that gates would damage a car, why do you think the court wouldn't find that anyone parking there assumes the risk of having their car damaged by the gates? Negligence is NEVER cut and dry. Sorry, but your blanket statements are simply NOT true and you are making far too many assumptions. So lets see. In this thread all you have done is try to bash my so-called "blanket statements" , yet you haven't offered anything constructive to the OP. So what would you suggest the OP do in this case since everything I have suggested to do has been "poor" according to you? ![]() Of course negligence is never cut and dry. But sitting around and doing nothing is the worst way to go about it. So your suggestion is to expect the OP to just pay her $500 deductable and eat the cost of them not locking the garbage gate? I am glad working as a lawyer you have money to burn because I am sure the OP doesn't which is why she made this thread in the first place. |
Posted 1/23/09 1:26 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: what to do...UPDATE Posted by PrincessP -called geico and gave them the info. They told me I have a 500 dollar deductibe to pay. So I guess I am paying for an accident that I didnt create. They cover after 500. Yeah they only cover after the deductable, which is why I mentioned that you should have just went after the complex directly for not locking the gate. Did they already assign a claim number to this or were you just calling for information? |
Posted 1/23/09 1:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: what to do...UPDATE Posted by ave1024 Posted by PrincessP -called geico and gave them the info. They told me I have a 500 dollar deductibe to pay. So I guess I am paying for an accident that I didnt create. They cover after 500. Yeah they only cover after the deductable, which is why I mentioned that you should have just went after the complex directly for not locking the gate. Did they already assign a claim number to this or were you just calling for information? I got a claim # but they asked me if I want to go forth through my collision. I tole them to let me see if the damage is even 500 bc if its not whats the point I am already paying. |
|
Posted 1/23/09 1:42 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: what to do...UPDATE Posted by PrincessP I got a claim # but they asked me if I want to go forth through my collision. I tole them to let me see if the damage is even 500 bc if its not whats the point I am already paying. Well for what it's worth, my car got hit a while back in a Starbucks parking lot and I filed a claim through their Collision (i have GEICO too). My rates didn't seem to go up. The only bad thing about this is since a claim number was issued, it's on your record now. So if you ever want to shop around with another insurance company, they may be able to see that you made a claim on this. I don't know if they can just remove the claim number from the system if you decide to not pursue the claim. |
Posted 1/23/09 1:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: what to do...UPDATE Was the gate left open or was it "broken"??? |
|
Posted 1/23/09 1:58 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |





