what to do...UPDATE

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

what to do...UPDATE

The complex I live in has a large garbage fenced in area. The gate opened up and hit my car in the middle of the night leaving slight damage. A police report was made bc my complex told me there was no mngmnt available. The cop came and told me that my complex has to go through their insurance. I sent a letter to mngmnt asking to fix my car and got no response. Today when i called they told me I will need to call my car ins.
first question...why my car insurance? And Geico told me they cant promise my rates wouldnt change. I am in a catch 22 what do I do??? TIA

-called geico and gave them the info. They told me I have a 500 dollar deductibe to pay. So I guess I am paying for an accident that I didnt create. They cover after 500.

Message edited 2009-01-23 09:55:13.323000.

Posted 1/22/09 6:27 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

strongisland
All you need is love

Member since 8/07

2474 total posts

Name:
T

Re: what to do...

i think you call your insurance first..they cover it and then they 'duke it out' with your complex's insurance to get reimbursed....not 100% certain though

Message edited 2009-01-22 18:50:56.170000.

Posted 1/22/09 6:43 PM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

send a certified letter to management that they must repair your car.

get an estimate and enclose that along with the letter.

do not go through your insurance it will raise your rates. and even if it doesn't why should your ins. pay for their damage. you live there, but its not your property. its the same thing if a tree fell on your car.

Threaten to deducte it from your next month's rent. send pictures along with the letter if you can.

Posted 1/22/09 6:48 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Message edited 2011-11-22 22:21:37.350000.

Posted 1/22/09 6:52 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what to do...

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

I don't think this will work. I'm sure somewhere in her lease it states that thy are not liable for any damage blah blah blah... at her own risk yakkity schmakkity yada yada...




The lease can also say they have the right to come up to her apartment in the middle of the night and sexually assult her.

Doesn't mean they can legally do it. If that clause is in the lease, it won't hold up in court.

Send the certified letter with the bill. When they don't pay... send them a court summons.

Posted 1/22/09 7:20 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Message edited 2011-11-22 22:21:51.817000.

Posted 1/22/09 7:23 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what to do...

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

that's a bit of a stretch don't you think.

so those disclaimers on tickets to events, airlines etc. they don't mean diddly squat?





Not at all. The complex was negligent. And I am not sure what you are talking about regarding disclaimers on tickets.

Companies can write all the disclaimers they want.

Posted 1/22/09 7:29 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Message edited 2011-11-22 22:22:04.627000.

Posted 1/22/09 7:33 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Message edited 2011-11-22 22:22:21.797000.

Posted 1/22/09 7:34 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what to do...

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

On the back of a ticket to any sporting event concert etc. it say something along the line that you attend this at your own risk any injury loss of personal property is not the liability of said venue etc. It's on the back of tickets you get when you park in a public lot, etc.

They wanyt her to go through the insurence because they will claim that the sanitation company was negligent for not properly securing the gate round and round she'll go.




They aren't liable if something were to happen that ISN'T THEIR FAULT. Like if a fight breaks out. Hell even then you can go after the venue for lack of security.

And no offense... but if lets say during a concert a large spotlight from above falls down and permanently injures you... only a fool wouldn't sue the venue because there was a disclaimer on the back of the ticket that says "they aren't responsible". Chat Icon

The disclaimers are there to try to get people to think how you are thinking.

They can blame all they want. If they don't want to pay, then a judge should decide who pays.

Posted 1/22/09 7:37 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what to do...

It's like you ever park at a valet and there is a huge sign there at the entrance that says "WE AREN'T RESPONSIBLE FOR DAMAGE TO YOUR CAR" bla bla bla yadda yadda yadda.

If the valet damages your car, believe me having a sign there will not save their azz.

Posted 1/22/09 7:39 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Personally, as a renter myself, I would send a letter to the management company certified and advise them any failure to respond within 10 days of receipt will result in legal action. I'm sure it would hold up in small claims courtChat Icon

The complex can not be held responsible for things like break ins and vandalism, but they are responsible for their own negligance...it may be tough to prove it was them and not the sanitation dept, but they should respond anyway. I would also put in the letter that this is your second request and all previous attempts to contact them up until this time have been ignored.

Posted 1/22/09 7:41 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Message edited 2011-11-22 22:23:12.380000.

Posted 1/22/09 7:42 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what to do...

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

Did you just imply that I'm a fool???Chat Icon

Seriously though, it's not how I think and yes I would sue in all the scenarios you presented.

All I'm saying is the reason they want her to go through her insurance is so they can drag this out. Trust me I'm very aware how these things work.

ETA ~ I would just let my insurance company deal with it after all you pay your premiums let them earn it. Why should she have to write and send certified letters. That's why you have insurance so they can handle things like this.




I don't disagree with you. It may be difficult to prove who actually caused this.

I was just commenting on idea of NOT going after them just because their lease says the tenant is not worthy of sueing.

They want her to go through her insurance because they don't want to go through THEIR insurance. They don't want to pay.

Theoretically you are supposed to report ALL hits to your car to your insurance company. That I betcha is in the OP's insurance policy and the insurance company found out there was an accident without them knowing about it, they can drop you from the policy.

But this is very minor so I would probably just handle it directly with the management first.

Posted 1/22/09 7:52 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: what to do...

Posted by ave1024

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

that's a bit of a stretch don't you think.

so those disclaimers on tickets to events, airlines etc. they don't mean diddly squat?





Not at all. The complex was negligent. And I am not sure what you are talking about regarding disclaimers on tickets.

Companies can write all the disclaimers they want.



How can you possibly determine that the complex was negligent based solely on what has been posted? As a lawyer, I sure can't and I highly doubt a judge could either...

Posted 1/22/09 7:54 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Message edited 2011-11-22 22:23:25.853000.

Posted 1/22/09 7:56 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Message edited 2011-11-22 22:23:45.950000.

Posted 1/22/09 7:57 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: what to do...

It's hard to prove that it was their fault.

They could claim it was another tenant who opened the gate and damaged your car.

If there is a history of prior damages with other tenants' car, that it's "knowns" that the gate opens itself up, etc. maybe you can have some sort of letters from other tenants to make your case. Otherwise, it will be hard to prove it.

Posted 1/22/09 8:48 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

not sure if this matters or not but there is a witness involved. I didnt see this. Some new person that moved in caught it at 3am then told me about 4 pm thats when i called the cops. The sanitation wasnt there at 3 am. It was the wind blowing the gate back and forth.
*the witness reported to the cop what he saw and it is written on the police report.

Message edited 2009-01-22 21:19:13.153000.

Posted 1/22/09 9:18 PM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Posted by PrincessP

not sure if this matters or not but there is a witness involved. I didnt see this. Some new person that moved in caught it at 3am then told me about 4 pm thats when i called the cops. The sanitation wasnt there at 3 am. It was the wind blowing the gate back and forth.
*the witness reported to the cop what he saw and it is written on the police report.



see since its wind, they may deem that "mother nature" and out of their control.

Posted 1/22/09 9:23 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: what to do...

Posted by HeatherRose

Posted by PrincessP

not sure if this matters or not but there is a witness involved. I didnt see this. Some new person that moved in caught it at 3am then told me about 4 pm thats when i called the cops. The sanitation wasnt there at 3 am. It was the wind blowing the gate back and forth.
*the witness reported to the cop what he saw and it is written on the police report.



see since its wind, they may deem that "mother nature" and out of their control.



Theres a lock that was just hanging. Mngmnt/maintenance whoever is supposed to lock the gate. I made sure to take pics of it and the cop wrote it as well.

Posted 1/22/09 9:24 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: what to do...

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by HeatherRose

Posted by PrincessP

not sure if this matters or not but there is a witness involved. I didnt see this. Some new person that moved in caught it at 3am then told me about 4 pm thats when i called the cops. The sanitation wasnt there at 3 am. It was the wind blowing the gate back and forth.
*the witness reported to the cop what he saw and it is written on the police report.



see since its wind, they may deem that "mother nature" and out of their control.



Theres a lock that was just hanging. Mngmnt/maintenance whoever is supposed to lock the gate. I made sure to take pics of it and the cop wrote it as well.



You might have a case for you then.

Is it their job to make sure it's locked at all times?

Posted 1/22/09 9:29 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what to do...

Posted by Kara

Posted by ave1024

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

that's a bit of a stretch don't you think.

so those disclaimers on tickets to events, airlines etc. they don't mean diddly squat?





Not at all. The complex was negligent. And I am not sure what you are talking about regarding disclaimers on tickets.

Companies can write all the disclaimers they want.



How can you possibly determine that the complex was negligent based solely on what has been posted? As a lawyer, I sure can't and I highly doubt a judge could either...




I don't own the car. I don't know all the facts. But to say "the complex is not responsible because of a disclaimer in the lease"... that's ridiculous.

I can tell you right off the bat if they have parking that's close enough to the large garbage gates, that's pretty negligent right there to allow that. Whether or not it was the complex or the sanitation that opened the gates and hit the car, having the gates there in the first place, and not having something to block the gates from hitting parked cars is pretty negligent.

I would never park in that spot if this was the case. Is this assigned parking where you always have the same spot? or is it pick and choose?

Posted 1/22/09 9:50 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what to do...

Posted by HeatherRose

Posted by PrincessP

not sure if this matters or not but there is a witness involved. I didnt see this. Some new person that moved in caught it at 3am then told me about 4 pm thats when i called the cops. The sanitation wasnt there at 3 am. It was the wind blowing the gate back and forth.
*the witness reported to the cop what he saw and it is written on the police report.



see since its wind, they may deem that "mother nature" and out of their control.




Mother nature? Wow. Chat Icon

I would laugh in their face if they tried to tell me that. If the gate was supposed to be locked, and it wasn't, that's negligence by the complex.

Having the witness and police report will definitely help.

Send a copy of the police report along with the certified letter and repair bill to the complex.

Posted 1/22/09 9:53 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: what to do...

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Kara

Posted by ave1024

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

that's a bit of a stretch don't you think.

so those disclaimers on tickets to events, airlines etc. they don't mean diddly squat?





Not at all. The complex was negligent. And I am not sure what you are talking about regarding disclaimers on tickets.

Companies can write all the disclaimers they want.



How can you possibly determine that the complex was negligent based solely on what has been posted? As a lawyer, I sure can't and I highly doubt a judge could either...




I don't own the car. I don't know all the facts. But to say "the complex is not responsible because of a disclaimer in the lease"... that's ridiculous.

I can tell you right off the bat if they have parking that's close enough to the large garbage gates, that's pretty negligent right there to allow that. Whether or not it was the complex or the sanitation that opened the gates and hit the car, having the gates there in the first place, and not having something to block the gates from hitting parked cars is pretty negligent.

I would never park in that spot if this was the case. Is this assigned parking where you always have the same spot? or is it pick and choose?



Actually, the disclaimer argument is NOT ridiculous and if you spent any time actually litigating, you'd know that disclaimers and liability releases OFTEN hold water.

You're making a LOT of assumptions here and basically giving out legal advice - poor legal advice at that.

None of us know what is in her lease. None of us know whether or not something in her lease will or will not hold water. None of us know what the complex's insurance coverage is. And CERTAINLY none of us know whether or not the complex was negligent. Heck, we can back up a step and even say that none of us knows if negligence is even the appropriate standard of liability in this situation.

The simple fact is that none of us has enough information to say with the degree of certainty you are trying to imply that the complex was negligent and nothing in her lease can release them of liability.

And, no, you can't tell me that having parking close to the garage is per se negligent... because it's not. If it's SO obvious that gates would damage a car, why do you think the court wouldn't find that anyone parking there assumes the risk of having their car damaged by the gates? Negligence is NEVER cut and dry.

Sorry, but your blanket statements are simply NOT true and you are making far too many assumptions.

Message edited 2009-01-22 22:26:05.827000.

Posted 1/22/09 10:22 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2