what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

A flat tax makes no sense IMO. My family of origin (not me/my own family) is wealthy, so the Bush tax cuts "benefited" them. But the fact is, nobody actually NOTICED anything, because there's enough money going around that it made no actual difference in the lives of my family members. To now lower the taxes on the very wealthy another 20-25% seems beyond ridiculous to me.

Message edited 2010-12-11 13:27:23.557000.

Posted 12/11/10 7:37 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

We are in the highest tax bracket and we do not make ridiculous amounts of money. I would love to have a flat tax rate but know it would not be possible. We are probably that borderline middle class/upper middle class bracket. I find it unfair that DH and I worked hard in school and our careers and the government takes such a huge chunk from us every year.

Many republicans advocate a flat tax without deductions so that they can choose to spend their money the way that they want vs the guidelines that the IRS gives. The wealthiest (not just upper middle class) are usually the largest philanthropists. The Bill Gates and the Warren Buffets of the world pop into mind. I think the wealthy just want to be able to give where they want to give vs being forced to subsidize all the US government's financial problems.

I can see being republican is unpopular on these threads. Most republicans are not monsters. They try to be fiscally responsible. What I fear most is our growing deficit. I know people are screaming and very upset about the short-term budget problems. I am more focused on where the US will be in the future. What is happening over in the EU is right around the corner for us. I'm afraid the US government will become bankrupt one day soon and there will be no one to bail us out.

Message edited 2010-12-11 09:38:08.633000.

Posted 12/11/10 9:32 AM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by Bridex100

We are in the highest tax bracket and we do not make ridiculous amounts of money. I would love to have a flat tax rate but know it would not be possible. We are probably that borderline middle class/upper middle class bracket. I find it unfair that DH and I worked hard in school and our careers and the government takes such a huge chunk from us every year.

Many republicans advocate a flat tax without deductions so that they can choose to spend their money the way that they want vs the guidelines that the IRS gives. The wealthiest (not just upper middle class) are usually the largest philanthropists. The Bill Gates and the Warren Buffets of the world pop into mind. I think the wealthy just want to be able to give where they want to give vs being forced to subsidize all the US government's financial problems.

I can see being republican is unpopular on these threads. Most republicans are not monsters. They try to be fiscally responsible. What I fear most is our growing deficit. I know people are screaming and very upset about the short-term budget problems. I am more focused on where the US will be in the future. What is happening over in the EU is right around the corner for us. I'm afraid the US government will become bankrupt one day soon and there will be no one to bail us out.



ITA and this is exactly my thought process. It frustrates me that people aren't allowed to do whatevery they want with their own money. But I consider myself a libertarian so I do realize I have rather odd/unpopular beliefs Chat Icon

Posted 12/11/10 9:46 AM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by Bridex100

We are in the highest tax bracket and we do not make ridiculous amounts of money. I would love to have a flat tax rate but know it would not be possible. We are probably that borderline middle class/upper middle class bracket. I find it unfair that DH and I worked hard in school and our careers and the government takes such a huge chunk from us every year.

Many republicans advocate a flat tax without deductions so that they can choose to spend their money the way that they want vs the guidelines that the IRS gives. The wealthiest (not just upper middle class) are usually the largest philanthropists. The Bill Gates and the Warren Buffets of the world pop into mind. I think the wealthy just want to be able to give where they want to give vs being forced to subsidize all the US government's financial problems.

I can see being republican is unpopular on these threads. Most republicans are not monsters. They try to be fiscally responsible. What I fear most is our growing deficit. I know people are screaming and very upset about the short-term budget problems. I am more focused on where the US will be in the future. What is happening over in the EU is right around the corner for us. I'm afraid the US government will become bankrupt one day soon and there will be no one to bail us out.



The highest tax bracket is over $373000

While I do not think that $373,000 per year is ridiculous, I do think it is a lot of money. My dh and survive in the tax bracket just below yours. and we make less than half of what you make and only pay 7% less in taxes. In this scenario I get the worse deal...yet I will still never go for a flat tax.

Message edited 2010-12-11 17:09:04.677000.

Posted 12/11/10 9:49 AM
 

mommy2Alex
3 babies for me :)

Member since 5/05

6683 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by Bridex100

We are in the highest tax bracket and we do not make ridiculous amounts of money. I would love to have a flat tax rate but know it would not be possible. We are probably that borderline middle class/upper middle class bracket. I find it unfair that DH and I worked hard in school and our careers and the government takes such a huge chunk from us every year.

Many republicans advocate a flat tax without deductions so that they can choose to spend their money the way that they want vs the guidelines that the IRS gives. The wealthiest (not just upper middle class) are usually the largest philanthropists. The Bill Gates and the Warren Buffets of the world pop into mind. I think the wealthy just want to be able to give where they want to give vs being forced to subsidize all the US government's financial problems.

I can see being republican is unpopular on these threads. Most republicans are not monsters. They try to be fiscally responsible. What I fear most is our growing deficit. I know people are screaming and very upset about the short-term budget problems. I am more focused on where the US will be in the future. What is happening over in the EU is right around the corner for us. I'm afraid the US government will become bankrupt one day soon and there will be no one to bail us out.



ITA!!! The entitlements have to go, we can't afford it. Chat Icon DH and I were having this discussion last night because I am really really afraid for the future of the US. DH is from Argentina so he understands how a country can fall from grace. People in this country think Peron was great (with Madonna and Evita and all) but he destroyed Argentina and their weatlh by taking from the rich and giving to the poor along with a whole boatload of corruption. Yes, I am oversimplifying the example.

I don't think most people even understand the depth of the debt that this nation is in. Social Security alone has over $14 Trillion in unfunded liabitlies, meaning we promised to pay out this money to people in the future but have yet to find a way to pay for it. In total between SS, Medicare, Medicaid we have over $111Trillion in unfunded liabilites. That is mind boggling and taxing the rich isn't going to solve our problems. Europe is waking up to the realities of what Socialism is costing them and now soon our day will come too.Chat Icon The days of the US being the greatest nation in the world are numbered and I hope people are prepared for that.

Posted 12/11/10 9:53 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

With all of the deductions, we do not have a progressive tax rate.

Warren Buffet bet anyone $1 million to prove that the people on the Fortune 400 list (worth over 1.3 billion) pay a higher tax rate on average than their receptionist. Buffet claims that he pays 15%


I understand the reason that the wealthiest should pay a less percentage (they are still paying a lot more than I am in actual dollars). They are the people that invest in our economy to expand businesses, jobs and innovation. Honestly, even if I got an extra $10K in taxes back from tax breaks - it's not really going to make a difference if I invest it in the economy.

I understand why the poorest should pay less. they need every dollar to survive.

I do feel lucky to be middle class. We have good jobs and good health insurance. My family is fed and warm in their beds at the end of the day. I understand that one burden I must pay is a higher percentage of taxes.




What I think is the most unfair tax system - is the sales tax system.

Posted 12/11/10 10:12 AM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

One reason why I would never support a flat tax is because the progressiveness of the flat tax counteracts the regressiveness of pretty much every other tax.

Most of our taxes are regressive, meaning that they that do not depend on income and therefore represent a lower percentage of your income as your salary increases.

Sales tax is the worst because someone making $10k a year pays the same 8.625% tax (roughly) on $50 sneakers that someone making $250k does.

Real estate taxes are similar. You could argue that higher income people are going to buy bigger houses with more property so they'll pay higher real estate taxes, but it's still not proportionate.

Posted 12/11/10 10:40 AM
 

MikesBride
LIF Adult

Member since 12/09

1245 total posts

Name:
Ilana

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Anyone for the Fair Tax? One huge tax on consumption instead of income taxes on everyone. Whenever you shop, you pay taxes. That way even those with money in offshore accounts who spend money here will be paying taxes. The government would subsidize for those who are poor and give them they money they would need for essentials (food, etc) so that they wouldn't pay the tax, only the cost.

I don't think it'll ever go through but to me this seems like the best answer Fair Tax

Posted 12/11/10 1:04 PM
 

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by MikesBride

Anyone for the Fair Tax? One huge tax on consumption instead of income taxes on everyone. Whenever you shop, you pay taxes. That way even those with money in offshore accounts who spend money here will be paying taxes. The government would subsidize for those who are poor and give them they money they would need for essentials (food, etc) so that they wouldn't pay the tax, only the cost.

I don't think it'll ever go through but to me this seems like the best answer Fair Tax



Absolutely not. This would mean that someone who makes say $50,000 (most likely not poor enough to get the subsidies from the government) a year would pay the same taxes as someone who makes $100,000,000. How is that fair?

Message edited 2010-12-11 13:26:52.760000.

Posted 12/11/10 1:26 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by OStewarts

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.





Exactly! Not a fan of the flat tax idea--sounds fair, but it really isn't for people in the lower tax brackets.

Posted 12/11/10 3:10 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

so me who makes a combined income of 75kish would pay the same as someone who makes 500K or more? Nah sorry doesn't work.

to me globalization is what is destroying the world economy. if we had industry within our own countries and kept to ourselves we would be a lot better off. We keep supporting communist china, india and korea instead of allowing our own industry grow.

Posted 12/11/10 5:35 PM
 

MikesBride
LIF Adult

Member since 12/09

1245 total posts

Name:
Ilana

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by emilylives

Posted by MikesBride

Anyone for the Fair Tax? One huge tax on consumption instead of income taxes on everyone. Whenever you shop, you pay taxes. That way even those with money in offshore accounts who spend money here will be paying taxes. The government would subsidize for those who are poor and give them they money they would need for essentials (food, etc) so that they wouldn't pay the tax, only the cost.

I don't think it'll ever go through but to me this seems like the best answer Fair Tax



Absolutely not. This would mean that someone who makes say $50,000 (most likely not poor enough to get the subsidies from the government) a year would pay the same taxes as someone who makes $100,000,000. How is that fair?



It doesn't mean that at all...in fact, someone who makes $100,000,000 will probably be spending more on food and retail items and will therefore be paying more taxes than someone who makes $50,000 and is doing less spending.

Posted 12/11/10 7:44 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by MikesBride

Posted by emilylives

Posted by MikesBride

Anyone for the Fair Tax? One huge tax on consumption instead of income taxes on everyone. Whenever you shop, you pay taxes. That way even those with money in offshore accounts who spend money here will be paying taxes. The government would subsidize for those who are poor and give them they money they would need for essentials (food, etc) so that they wouldn't pay the tax, only the cost.

I don't think it'll ever go through but to me this seems like the best answer Fair Tax



Absolutely not. This would mean that someone who makes say $50,000 (most likely not poor enough to get the subsidies from the government) a year would pay the same taxes as someone who makes $100,000,000. How is that fair?



It doesn't mean that at all...in fact, someone who makes $100,000,000 will probably be spending more on food and retail items and will therefore be paying more taxes than someone who makes $50,000 and is doing less spending.




In this scenario we would depend too much on the rich putting back into our economy. It would be too unpredictable.

Posted 12/12/10 5:09 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by Nifheim

so me who makes a combined income of 75kish would pay the same as someone who makes 500K or more? Nah sorry doesn't work.




the same rate/percentage, but not the same dollar amount.

75K would pay 12,500 in taxes
500K would pay 85,000 in taxes

Posted 12/12/10 5:20 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Tax Free Week! christy 9/1/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
tax free??? momAGAIN 8/29/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
tax free week? CarrieAnn 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Tax question checka 8/26/05 3 Home
tax question Redhead 6/17/05 6 Home
Anyone file a tax grievance? Dani00518 6/15/05 1 Home