what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

what do you think about a flat tax?

To me it seems like the most logical, fair thing in the world.

For those who disagree, I would love to hear your point of view and reasoning.

Posted 12/10/10 9:16 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jasmine
little boy blue <3

Member since 10/10

1475 total posts

Name:
x

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

a flat amount or a flat percentage? and what percentage do you think is fair?

Posted 12/10/10 9:20 PM
 

LL514
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1901 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?

Posted 12/10/10 9:25 PM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon

Posted 12/10/10 9:30 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

I'm not for it at all.

I think tax percentages should be a ratio to what you make. that's the most fair way to do it.

17% is FAR too low to even support this country on. They usually talk about 20%... which I still don't see working.... considering most pay about 25% now... and those who make more pay about 30%.... so I can't imagine how paying less % across the board would be helpful. we would have even less money to spend and as is our government is having a difficult time funding things.

17% of someone who is making less than 20g is a HUGE cut compared to someone who is making 300g or more... or heck even less than 300 g.

I can't imagine making under 50g and paying the same amount of taxes as someone who is making well over 250g... and forget about someone who makes into the millions per year.

i prefer tax brackets to be honest. the more you make, the higher your percentage... it keeps the ratio of what you live off of more fair across the board.

I just read a whole article on this actually... part of that person's reasoning behind it was that "it forces middle-class taxpayers to subsidize the wealthy".

here is one article on it...
click me

I'm searching for the one I read earlier... i prefer that one....

here is another article on it...
click meee

this is a good one .... that might not be as offensive as the other one...
read me :)
One quote from the above article "In the U.S. Senate, Arlen Specter proposed a flat 20% tax on earned income (working people's wages), from which rich people's unearned income (capital gains, interest and dividends) would be exempt. Congressman **** Armey supports similar legislation in the House. Former presidential candidate Steve Forbes (who has exhibited virtually no entrepreneurial innovation in his life and became wealthy by inheriting his late father's publishing empire) made as a centerpiece of his failed campaigns a flat tax scheme that salutes the idle rich (as distinguished from hard-working innovators or entrepreneurs who actually earned their wealth) by exempting UNEARNED income gained as a return on investment (not merely protecting the value of the principal, but allowing those who gain wealth without working for it to avoid taxes while those who work hard for what they gain pay all the taxes). Since Forbes' plan reduces taxes on the poorest and especially favors the wealthy, but is supposed to be revenue-neutral (no loss of incoming tax revenues) once again it means the middle class working people would be the ones squeezed to make up for benefits to the rich."

Message edited 2010-12-10 21:54:32.893000.

Posted 12/10/10 9:38 PM
 

LL514
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1901 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!

Posted 12/10/10 9:39 PM
 

OStewarts
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1096 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.


Posted 12/10/10 9:46 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by OStewarts

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.





EXACTLY!

Posted 12/10/10 9:47 PM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by OStewarts

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.





EXACTLY!



I definitely get this point. But the person with the low income is still paying very low taxes in comparison (in terms of the dollar amount). So I guess I'm still not convinced Chat Icon

Posted 12/10/10 9:56 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by shadows

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by OStewarts

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.





EXACTLY!



I definitely get this point. But the person with the low income is still paying very low taxes in comparison (in terms of the dollar amount). So I guess I'm still not convinced Chat Icon



the flat tax proposal is that ONLY those who earn income will be taxed... meaning only the working... so those who are super super rich based on inheritance... will not have to pay a SINGLE penny to taxes!!!!! that's a huge problem.
I'm not talking about the death tax benefit here either. That's for inheritance up to 10 million dollars... this would be for ALL the people who don't earn wages from income.... even those who would earn money from stocks wouldn't pay taxes... it's ONLY taxing income wages.

Read the 3rd link I posted.

And overall... it's NOT enough money to keep this country going.... someone is going to have to pay more in taxes or we will have to give up A HECK OF A LOT of things... you think we have no funds now......

Message edited 2010-12-10 22:00:53.933000.

Posted 12/10/10 9:58 PM
 

LL514
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1901 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by shadows

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by OStewarts

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.





EXACTLY!



I definitely get this point. But the person with the low income is still paying very low taxes in comparison (in terms of the dollar amount). So I guess I'm still not convinced Chat Icon



the flat tax proposal is that ONLY those who earn income will be taxed... meaning only the working... so those who are super super rich based on inheritance... will not have to pay a SINGLE penny to taxes!!!!! that's a huge problem.
I'm not talking about the death tax benefit here either. That's for inheritance up to 10 million dollars... this would be for ALL the people who don't earn wages from income.... even those who would earn money from stocks wouldn't pay taxes... it's ONLY taxing income wages.

Read the 3rd link I posted.

And overall... it's NOT enough money to keep this country going.... someone is going to have to pay more in taxes or we will have to give up A HECK OF A LOT of things... you think we have no funds now......



how many "super super rich off of inheritance" people do you think there are in this country?

Posted 12/10/10 10:03 PM
 

LL514
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1901 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by MrsKS



I think tax percentages should be a ratio to what you make. that's the most fair way to do it.

"





what do you think a percent is?? it's a RATIO!!!!

Posted 12/10/10 10:04 PM
 

OStewarts
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1096 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by shadows

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by OStewarts

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.





EXACTLY!



I definitely get this point. But the person with the low income is still paying very low taxes in comparison (in terms of the dollar amount). So I guess I'm still not convinced Chat Icon



Yes, they turn over fewer dollars than the person making more, but I think the value of each particular dollar is far more important in the lower brackets, KWIM?

To be honest, I am inclined to agree with the progressive tax system, having lived at both ends of the spectrum. I had far more trouble paying my taxes and making ends meet on what was left when I was a student and a young professional than I do now that I am in one of the higher brackets.

Posted 12/10/10 10:07 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by LL514

Posted by MrsKS



I think tax percentages should be a ratio to what you make. that's the most fair way to do it.

"





what do you think a percent is?? it's a RATIO!!!!



not sure if you are trying to be snarky... if so it's not that serious... no need to react like this..if you aren't then disregard....

I firmly understand a percent is a ratio.... but

meaning you should pay more % in taxes based on what you make. not a flat tax across the board.

I think you should read more about all the details a flat tax would propose. there's a lot more to it than just people all paying the same rate. There would be A LOT of people NOT paying any taxes on loads of funds.

Honestly, it doesn't really matter... because flat tax isn't really going to take off... not at this time anyway.

Message edited 2010-12-10 23:36:33.923000.

Posted 12/10/10 10:07 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by LL514

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by shadows

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by OStewarts

I am no tax expert but I think that the point behind the increasing percentages in the brackets takes into account the fact that those with lower incomes NEED more of their take home money to provide for basic necessities. I suppose that is why we have a progressive tax system that increases the percentage of payroll tax you pay based on the amount of wages that you earn.





EXACTLY!



I definitely get this point. But the person with the low income is still paying very low taxes in comparison (in terms of the dollar amount). So I guess I'm still not convinced Chat Icon



the flat tax proposal is that ONLY those who earn income will be taxed... meaning only the working... so those who are super super rich based on inheritance... will not have to pay a SINGLE penny to taxes!!!!! that's a huge problem.
I'm not talking about the death tax benefit here either. That's for inheritance up to 10 million dollars... this would be for ALL the people who don't earn wages from income.... even those who would earn money from stocks wouldn't pay taxes... it's ONLY taxing income wages.

Read the 3rd link I posted.

And overall... it's NOT enough money to keep this country going.... someone is going to have to pay more in taxes or we will have to give up A HECK OF A LOT of things... you think we have no funds now......



how many "super super rich off of inheritance" people do you think there are in this country?



more than one would think,
and of those that are super rich... they own more than the rest of the country's wealth.... 85% of the country only owns about 15% of the wealth; the rest goes to the super rich. I wish I kept the AM NY today... they had a whole article in there with all the percentages of this.

Message edited 2010-12-10 22:12:16.357000.

Posted 12/10/10 10:09 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by LL514

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!




People already complain that the wealthy don't pay enough tax, even though they do in the current tax bracket system.

Implement a flat tax and it would cause a serious uproar with the middle (and lower) class.

Posted 12/10/10 10:42 PM
 

LL514
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1901 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by ave1024

Posted by LL514

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!




People already complain that the wealthy don't pay enough tax, even though they do in the current tax bracket system.

Implement a flat tax and it would cause a serious uproar with the middle (and lower) class.



an uproar isnt an explanation. i just want to know the thought process behind the tax brackets. honestly

Posted 12/10/10 10:57 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by LL514

Posted by ave1024

Posted by LL514

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!




People already complain that the wealthy don't pay enough tax, even though they do in the current tax bracket system.

Implement a flat tax and it would cause a serious uproar with the middle (and lower) class.



an uproar isnt an explanation. i just want to know the thought process behind the tax brackets. honestly



Have you been reading this thread?

Posted 12/10/10 11:03 PM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by LL514

Posted by ave1024

Posted by LL514

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!




People already complain that the wealthy don't pay enough tax, even though they do in the current tax bracket system.

Implement a flat tax and it would cause a serious uproar with the middle (and lower) class.



an uproar isnt an explanation. i just want to know the thought process behind the tax brackets. honestly



To me the current system involves way too much arbitrary line drawing.

I get the argument that a dollar might be "worth more" to a low income person, but I personally have trouble accepting that one person should pay 10% while another pays 35%.

Posted 12/10/10 11:08 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by twicethefun

Posted by LL514

Posted by ave1024

Posted by LL514

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!




People already complain that the wealthy don't pay enough tax, even though they do in the current tax bracket system.

Implement a flat tax and it would cause a serious uproar with the middle (and lower) class.



an uproar isnt an explanation. i just want to know the thought process behind the tax brackets. honestly



Have you been reading this thread?




Chat Icon

To put it in the simplest way possible, the poor would pay more taxes (percentage wise), and the wealthy would pay way less.

The only people who would probably pay the same in taxes (under a flat tax system) would be the upper middle class.

Posted 12/10/10 11:08 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

Posted by ave1024

Posted by LL514

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!




People already complain that the wealthy don't pay enough tax, even though they do in the current tax bracket system.

Implement a flat tax and it would cause a serious uproar with the middle (and lower) class.



an uproar isnt an explanation. i just want to know the thought process behind the tax brackets. honestly



To me the current system involves way too much arbitrary line drawing.

I get the argument that a dollar might be "worth more" to a low income person, but I personally have trouble accepting that one person should pay 10% while another pays 35%.




The weathy person who is paying 35% is only paying 35% on income earned starting at a ridiculous amount (like over 150k-200k). Both the rich person and the poor person are paying 10% on that first 16k of income.

Posted 12/10/10 11:10 PM
 

OStewarts
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1096 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Again, I am no tax expert, but I thought we all start in the bottom bracket each year and pay the low amount on that portion of our income. Only when our wages increase enough to put us in a higher bracket, do we jump into the next bracket on that portion of our wages. So, for example, we all pay the lowest % on the first 20k (estimate) and then when we make more than 20k, that portion is taxed in the next bracket and so on and so on.

Does anyone know if that's right? It's way past my bedtime....

Posted 12/10/10 11:17 PM
 

OStewarts
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1096 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by ave1024

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

Posted by ave1024

Posted by LL514

Posted by shadows

Posted by LL514

percentage obviously. i agree. and i really dont understand why this is not done. what am i missing?



Yup, percentage. I think when flat tax is discussed the percentage is usually around 17%.

That's how I feel - what am I missing? I'm curious to hear what the opponents have to say Chat Icon



me too. i am a math teacher so equal percentage just makes sense in my mind. each person pays the same portion. makes total sense to me!




People already complain that the wealthy don't pay enough tax, even though they do in the current tax bracket system.

Implement a flat tax and it would cause a serious uproar with the middle (and lower) class.



an uproar isnt an explanation. i just want to know the thought process behind the tax brackets. honestly



To me the current system involves way too much arbitrary line drawing.

I get the argument that a dollar might be "worth more" to a low income person, but I personally have trouble accepting that one person should pay 10% while another pays 35%.




The weathy person who is paying 35% is only paying 35% on income earned starting at a ridiculous amount (like over 150k-200k). Both the rich person and the poor person are paying 10% on that first 16k of income.




Oops, you answered my question in the time it took me to write my question out! Thanks!!

Posted 12/10/10 11:18 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

For those who believe a flat percentage tax should be implemented, you do realize that only the very rich will benefit?

Posted 12/10/10 11:19 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: what do you think about a flat tax?

Posted by twicethefun

For those who believe a flat percentage tax should be implemented, you do realize that only the very rich will benefit?



that's the point I think they are missing....

ETA: Thus making the rich EVEN RICHER!!!

Message edited 2010-12-10 23:35:11.720000.

Posted 12/10/10 11:32 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Tax Free Week! christy 9/1/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
tax free??? momAGAIN 8/29/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
tax free week? CarrieAnn 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Tax question checka 8/26/05 3 Home
tax question Redhead 6/17/05 6 Home
Anyone file a tax grievance? Dani00518 6/15/05 1 Home