Wedding gift question

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Wedding gift question

I'd definitely give less money for a destination or backyard wedding.

Posted 3/28/11 9:53 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

AnnBrunoXO
2 Girls For Me!

Member since 5/05

4377 total posts

Name:
MaMMa

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.


Same for me.

Posted 3/28/11 10:04 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by caps612

I think gifts should be given based on the relationship and the location of the wedding and cost per plate are irrelevant.



Ditto

Posted 3/28/11 10:12 AM
 

isabelle2137
LIF Adult

Member since 12/06

1076 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

I would give back what they gave to me for my wedding.

It was my choice to have my wedding the way I wanted it. I don't believe in covering plates, but I don't short change people who choose to go the less expensive route either.

If you are my good friend, I share in your day with you and give the gift that is appropriate for the occasion, not the location.

Posted 3/28/11 10:17 AM
 

MrsYankeeGirl72
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

452 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Wedding gift question

I would say it is a combination of what type of relationship I have with the person and how much they gave me for my wedding.

If I would have heard that type of comment come out of his mouth, I would probably treat him a lesson and not give him as much, as i would have if he had not opened his mouth.


Posted 3/28/11 10:39 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.




Me too, but if I was going to the destination wedding, I might give a little less if i I couldn't afford both the gift & the travel expense.

If I was going to the BBQ I would give what I normally give--same thing if I didn't attend a wedding, or I knew the couple didn't pay a darn thing for it.

Posted 3/28/11 10:43 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by isabelle2137

I would give back what they gave to me for my wedding.

It was my choice to have my wedding the way I wanted it. I don't believe in covering plates, but I don't short change people who choose to go the less expensive route either.

If you are my good friend, I share in your day with you and give the gift that is appropriate for the occasion, not the location.



Here is the thing. DH and I were the first ones married almost 7 years ago. Friends gave us $200-300 a couple. We tend to give more then that because we're all older and in a different financial place. The norm amongst us has become $400-500 for close friends. I think $500 for a bbq is just too much. Obviously there are many of you who disagree, but that's my feelings on it.

Posted 3/28/11 11:23 AM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by headoverheels

1. I think it's tacky for someone to SAY that they expect the same amount despite the fact that it's a BBQ.

2. I think it's tacky for someone to consider giving less BECAUSE it's a BBQ. You're celebrating the wedding and marriage, not covering your plate.

So in the end, IMO, discussing gift amounts at all is tacky. Chat Icon





I agree with this..

Posted 3/28/11 11:27 AM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by isabelle2137

I would give back what they gave to me for my wedding.

It was my choice to have my wedding the way I wanted it. I don't believe in covering plates, but I don't short change people who choose to go the less expensive route either.

If you are my good friend, I share in your day with you and give the gift that is appropriate for the occasion, not the location.



Here is the thing. DH and I were the first ones married almost 7 years ago. Friends gave us $200-300 a couple. We tend to give more then that because we're all older and in a different financial place. The norm amongst us has become $400-500 for close friends. I think $500 for a bbq is just too much. Obviously there are many of you who disagree, but that's my feelings on it.



but you aren't giving 500 for a BBQ.. just like you weren't giving your other friends 500 for their reception hall. you were giving the COUPLE 500 as a congrats and good luck on their wedding.. where and how they have it should have no bearing on that imo

Posted 3/28/11 11:30 AM
 

PrincessVonTrockel
Trophy Wife in Training

Member since 11/09

2953 total posts

Name:
Natalie

Re: Wedding gift question

I'm not going to lie, in my mind I'd like to think I would give the same amount but in reality I think I'd probably end up giving just a little less.

Posted 3/28/11 11:32 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by bicosi

QUOTE]

but you aren't giving 500 for a BBQ.. just like you weren't giving your other friends 500 for their reception hall. you were giving the COUPLE 500 as a congrats and good luck on their wedding.. where and how they have it should have no bearing on that imo



Well I can tell you that amongst our friends, location has always dictated the amount. If we were all giving $300 for weddings and someone had there's at a super expensive place, we all bumped our gifts up to $400. It may not be right, or not be how you and your friends do it, but that is the way people I know have always done it.

Posted 3/28/11 11:33 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by bicosi

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by isabelle2137

I would give back what they gave to me for my wedding.

It was my choice to have my wedding the way I wanted it. I don't believe in covering plates, but I don't short change people who choose to go the less expensive route either.

If you are my good friend, I share in your day with you and give the gift that is appropriate for the occasion, not the location.



Here is the thing. DH and I were the first ones married almost 7 years ago. Friends gave us $200-300 a couple. We tend to give more then that because we're all older and in a different financial place. The norm amongst us has become $400-500 for close friends. I think $500 for a bbq is just too much. Obviously there are many of you who disagree, but that's my feelings on it.



but you aren't giving 500 for a BBQ.. just like you weren't giving your other friends 500 for their reception hall. you were giving the COUPLE 500 as a congrats and good luck on their wedding.. where and how they have it should have no bearing on that imo



I agree completely with this.

Posted 3/28/11 11:33 AM
 

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by headoverheels

1. I think it's tacky for someone to SAY that they expect the same amount despite the fact that it's a BBQ.

2. I think it's tacky for someone to consider giving less BECAUSE it's a BBQ. You're celebrating the wedding and marriage, not covering your plate.




I agree

Posted 3/28/11 11:35 AM
 

MrsRitaB
Love of my life! <3

Member since 4/10

4669 total posts

Name:
Ri

Re: Wedding gift question

no matter where is is or how much they are paying - for me - i never would go to a weeding without giving at least $75 pp (me and my guest)

Posted 3/28/11 11:44 AM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by bicosi

QUOTE]

but you aren't giving 500 for a BBQ.. just like you weren't giving your other friends 500 for their reception hall. you were giving the COUPLE 500 as a congrats and good luck on their wedding.. where and how they have it should have no bearing on that imo



Well I can tell you that amongst our friends, location has always dictated the amount. If we were all giving $300 for weddings and someone had there's at a super expensive place, we all bumped our gifts up to $400. It may not be right, or not be how you and your friends do it, but that is the way people I know have always done it.



Then why ask? You already made up your mind.

Posted 3/28/11 11:47 AM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by CarlieJLD7

Posted by J9-13

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



I agree.
I wouldn't be thrilled about the way this friend expressed his feelings though.



I agree 100%... Yes that is stupid that he actually said that out loud to more then just his spouse... But I tend to agree with him, if he went to everyone elses wedding and laid out such and such amount of money, just b/c they chose not to have a huge wedding, I do think the money should be receipted.




I get the sentiment, but the reality is they will be "making" a fortune for their bbq. Even if people gave $100pp they would still be clearing more then $20,000 with the amount of people they are inviting. My DS received a very small fraction of that at his recent 1st birthday party. And I hosted that at a hall and spent $$$. Way more then they will spend on this wedding.



I dont quite agree with the location argument. As a guest of any wedding, including an extravagant wedding, you usually have no idea who's paying for what. What if the parents are paying for the entire thing and the gifts that are going to the married couple are pure "profit"? Does that mean that you would give them less based on that?

I'd more likely go by what they gave me for my wedding than base it on their wedding locale. If they are a dear friend and they were generous at my wedding, i would be generous back regardless of the location.

Posted 3/28/11 11:54 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Wedding gift question

i would give the same amount if it was a BBQ in the backyard or in a big fancy hall - it is relative to the relationship you have with the person and how much you can afford.

For destination weddings I do give less because I have to factor in what i can afford/costs involved.

Posted 3/28/11 11:58 AM
 

jaykay216
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

73 total posts

Name:
Jax

Re: Wedding gift question

This is hard, especially given the tacky comment. Backyard BBQ or not, they would like to celebrate their wedding with friends who couldn't make the destination - I would give what you feel is appropriate, taking into account their financial situation.



Posted 3/28/11 12:37 PM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: Wedding gift question

For the BBQ I would probably give the same amount as I would if they had it at a reception hall.

For a destination wedding I would definitely give less. IMO, the added expense of just attending the wedding can't be ignored. They chose to have it away from home, and part of your gift to them is that you are paying $$$ to attend. The only exception is if it is for a VERY close relative or friend. Then I would try to give the same amount if at all possible.

Posted 3/28/11 1:05 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by bicosi

QUOTE]

but you aren't giving 500 for a BBQ.. just like you weren't giving your other friends 500 for their reception hall. you were giving the COUPLE 500 as a congrats and good luck on their wedding.. where and how they have it should have no bearing on that imo



Well I can tell you that amongst our friends, location has always dictated the amount. If we were all giving $300 for weddings and someone had there's at a super expensive place, we all bumped our gifts up to $400. It may not be right, or not be how you and your friends do it, but that is the way people I know have always done it.



wow

imo, a wedding is a wedding.. regardless of the bells and whistles involved.Chat Icon

Posted 3/28/11 2:55 PM
 

lakadema
LIF Adult

Member since 5/08

1180 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Wedding gift question

If this person is your friend, I would give what I normally give regardless of location. I don't give more or less based on where people "choose" to have their wedding.

Posted 3/28/11 3:20 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Wedding gift question

I would give what i normally give...which is an acceptable amount to give to a bbq wedding and an embarassing amount to hand over at a nice reception hallChat Icon

I just can't swing covering our plates most of the time. we are 175-200. I wish I could do more, but I can't. I can't stomach 300.00.

so, i should go to more bbq weddingsChat Icon

Posted 3/28/11 4:02 PM
 

Irishgrl13
Fingers Crossed...

Member since 6/09

1301 total posts

Name:
Colleen

Re: Wedding gift question

I would like to think I would give the same amount no matter where the venue was....but I think i'd only be kidding myself.. I guess i've never had to consider it....luckily.

I just think i'd have a hard time giving $300 - $400 for a BBQ. I understand you're "celebrating the event" of getting married...but I do take the venue into consideration when giving a gift. Flame away, but I also consider if the B&G are paying for it themselves, or if their parents are footing the bill.... I don't really think there is anything wrong with that....

Its not like my gift is the sole measurement of my friendship to the couple.....

Message edited 2011-03-28 22:50:25.933000.

Posted 3/28/11 10:49 PM
 

CarlieJLD7
I love my daughter!

Member since 7/07

3061 total posts

Name:
Carlie

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by bicosi

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by isabelle2137

I would give back what they gave to me for my wedding.

It was my choice to have my wedding the way I wanted it. I don't believe in covering plates, but I don't short change people who choose to go the less expensive route either.

If you are my good friend, I share in your day with you and give the gift that is appropriate for the occasion, not the location.



Here is the thing. DH and I were the first ones married almost 7 years ago. Friends gave us $200-300 a couple. We tend to give more then that because we're all older and in a different financial place. The norm amongst us has become $400-500 for close friends. I think $500 for a bbq is just too much. Obviously there are many of you who disagree, but that's my feelings on it.



but you aren't giving 500 for a BBQ.. just like you weren't giving your other friends 500 for their reception hall. you were giving the COUPLE 500 as a congrats and good luck on their wedding.. where and how they have it should have no bearing on that imo



Agree Exactly, Just b/c they are having a BBQ and will be profiting a lot more then someone who had an exctravagant wedding doesn't mean anything.

We got married and my friend who is a couple came to our wedding and gave us like $400 I think (this was in 07) They had a wedding ceremony low key, and we went out for sushi after... should I have given them 30$ to cover my plate? No. I gave them $400. And FYI... I don't eat Sushi... lol

Posted 3/29/11 1:00 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Wedding gift question

His poor manners aside..

If I went to the destination wedding, I would consider the expense part of the gift and that would effect how much I gave at the backyard bbq. If I did not go to the destination wedding, I would give the same amount that I would give if it were in a hall. You just never know what the expense/output will be - even at a backyard affair and I always find it a little off putting when people try to 'guess' how much it costs per plate. I mean - I know some backyard parties that actually cost more than some weddings held in halls.. Not to mention there are some weddings in nice locations where the couple put zero money out versus weddings in less expensive places that were covered entirely by the couple. I never thought I should give MORE to the couple whose parents paid simply because the plate costs more, ya know? I give what I can afford.

Message edited 2011-03-29 06:05:38.730000.

Posted 3/29/11 6:03 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Wedding Gift question.... Gertyrae 7/6/07 10 Families Helping Families ™
Question re: Wedding Gift... Lucky09 3/19/07 11 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding gift question? teacherwheart 7/14/06 16 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding gift question LuckySV 7/7/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding Gift Question jenny 6/7/06 21 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding Gift Question beena 6/7/06 11 Families Helping Families ™