Wedding gift question

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Wedding gift question

A good friend of ours is getting married in July. They have realized that they simply can't afford a big wedding do they will be doing a destination wedding. They want people to come, but are fine if people can't swing it. They will be having a BBQ when they get back. Our friend has said that he expects people to give him the same amount of money as if it was at a hall. Most of us think that's kind I'd absurd. I know many of you will say "give what you can afford" but I don't know if that's fair. Pretty much everyone we know has paid for atleast some aspects of their wedding, which we all know can be expensive. Their parents will throw a BBQ and are we really expected to give $300-500? I don't know, it just doesn't sit right with me. It seems like they're just trying to sit back and collect their checks.

Posted 3/27/11 11:31 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Wedding gift question

>>>>>Our friend has said that he expects people to give him the same amount of money as if it was at a hall.<<<<<<<<<



Chat Icon I can't believe that he has actually come out and said something like this. Talk about tacky.

Honestly, DH and I would be tempted to not go and give a cheap gift if that's how he wants to act.

How did this come up in conversation btw?

Posted 3/27/11 11:35 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Wedding gift question

He had this conversation/arguement with another close friend. He said that he's gone to everyones wedding and given s generous gift and expects it in return. He didn't want to hear that many of us have planned for a tear, footed the bill for atleast some things, etc... He made it seem like this is his turn to recoup some of his money.

Posted 3/27/11 11:42 AM
 

MaZz
* Lovin my baby girl!!! *

Member since 2/09

6243 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Wedding gift question

Ive been in a similar situation.... DH's best man got married and threw together a small party at a restaurant... They skimped on alot... wasnt a variety of food, no centerpieces, favors, and the desserts were bought by them from costco... All fine and dandy bc thats just their personalities... Totally opposite end of spectrum from what we had though... We simply were not going to give them as much... They also didnt give us money for ours, instead they bought DH a skydiving GC and we got tix for a yankees game.... We ended up giving them a BBB GC and DH treated the his best man to a round of golf... In the end, it prob was something like us giving them $200 worth and they gave $300... IMO, we still gave them a decent amt for the type of party they threw

I honestly could not justify giving them as much as they gave us and we werent going to give them cash bc we didnt get cash

Message edited 2011-03-27 11:47:05.997000.

Posted 3/27/11 11:43 AM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Wedding gift question

I think it depends on what type of relationship you have with the couple but that sounds really tacky to expect the same gift dollar amount. To say you expect any type of gift is rude!

I usually try to cover my plate and give a little extra for a normal wedding.

If it was a good friend, I'd want to give a larger gift and it would not matter where they had the wedding. Like I have a good friend who isn't married yet but doesn't come from a wealthy family. She will probably have a very modest wedding. I would still give her probably a very $$$ wedding gift.

Posted 3/27/11 11:55 AM
 

Sweetlax22
LIF Adult

Member since 5/10

1904 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by Bridex100


If it was a good friend, I'd want to give a larger gift and it would not matter where they had the wedding. QUOTE]

I would probably give then same gift, esp if it was a close friend or family. This also goes for if people have a very expensive wedding, I give what I give, where you decide to have it is your choice. (I would give less if I attended the destination part depending on how much travel expenses were, I would consider that part of my gift.)

Posted 3/27/11 1:35 PM
 

Irishgrl1017
It happened :)

Member since 9/08

1872 total posts

Name:
Colleen

Re: Wedding gift question

He actually said that he expects the same?!!? TACKY!
I probably wouldnt give the same, but maybe like 100 or 150? Or buy them something nice off their registry

Posted 3/27/11 1:35 PM
 

JME78
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

3672 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.

Posted 3/27/11 2:26 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re: Wedding gift question

idk part of me feels that if they gave you a $$ gift for yours, you should just give them the same regardless of where they have it..it's a gift not a cover your plate thing, kwim?

i'd be slightly upset if i had spent a lot of $$ over the years on others weddings, and then had everyone skimp on mine just bc of the location

Posted 3/27/11 2:31 PM
 

KennysMommy
Never knew LOVE like it before

Member since 3/10

2640 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



Same.

Posted 3/27/11 2:40 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

I'd give them what they gave to us. DH & I give based on our relationship to the person, not the location of the wedding or anything, but that's just us.

However, it would rub me the wrong way that a comment was made by the couple about how much they are expecting.

Posted 3/27/11 2:43 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



ITA!

Our dear friend got married last year & her parents hosted a small party at their home for about 50 people, we gave her more than a former coworker of mine that had her reception in a top notch catering hall on a Saturday night. To me the gift is always based purely on my relationship with the couple, never on the level of extravagance of the affair. I give the gift to help the couple start their new life together, not to finance their party.
I do not think your friend is wrong for feeling like a smaller party makes him less worthy, I don't know if I agree with him voicing that opinion to guests.

Message edited 2011-03-27 15:56:47.993000.

Posted 3/27/11 3:55 PM
 

J9-13
We're gonna be big sisters!

Member since 6/06

14887 total posts

Name:
J9

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



I agree.
I wouldn't be thrilled about the way this friend expressed his feelings though.

Posted 3/27/11 4:12 PM
 

CarlieJLD7
I love my daughter!

Member since 7/07

3061 total posts

Name:
Carlie

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by J9-13

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



I agree.
I wouldn't be thrilled about the way this friend expressed his feelings though.



I agree 100%... Yes that is stupid that he actually said that out loud to more then just his spouse... But I tend to agree with him, if he went to everyone elses wedding and laid out such and such amount of money, just b/c they chose not to have a huge wedding, I do think the money should be receipted.

Posted 3/27/11 5:14 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by CarlieJLD7

Posted by J9-13

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



I agree.
I wouldn't be thrilled about the way this friend expressed his feelings though.



I agree 100%... Yes that is stupid that he actually said that out loud to more then just his spouse... But I tend to agree with him, if he went to everyone elses wedding and laid out such and such amount of money, just b/c they chose not to have a huge wedding, I do think the money should be receipted.




I get the sentiment, but the reality is they will be "making" a fortune for their bbq. Even if people gave $100pp they would still be clearing more then $20,000 with the amount of people they are inviting. My DS received a very small fraction of that at his recent 1st birthday party. And I hosted that at a hall and spent $$$. Way more then they will spend on this wedding.

Posted 3/27/11 6:19 PM
 

MrsMerlot
Unconditional Love

Member since 4/06

6005 total posts

Name:
Chrissy

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



exactly.

Posted 3/27/11 7:48 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Wedding gift question

1. I think it's tacky for someone to SAY that they expect the same amount despite the fact that it's a BBQ.

2. I think it's tacky for someone to consider giving less BECAUSE it's a BBQ. You're celebrating the wedding and marriage, not covering your plate.

So in the end, IMO, discussing gift amounts at all is tacky. Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/11 7:52 PM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by headoverheels

1. I think it's tacky for someone to SAY that they expect the same amount despite the fact that it's a BBQ.

2. I think it's tacky for someone to consider giving less BECAUSE it's a BBQ. You're celebrating the wedding and marriage, not covering your plate.

So in the end, IMO, discussing gift amounts at all is tacky. Chat Icon



Agreed!

Posted 3/27/11 8:40 PM
 

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by CarlieJLD7

Posted by J9-13

Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



I agree.
I wouldn't be thrilled about the way this friend expressed his feelings though.



I agree 100%... Yes that is stupid that he actually said that out loud to more then just his spouse... But I tend to agree with him, if he went to everyone elses wedding and laid out such and such amount of money, just b/c they chose not to have a huge wedding, I do think the money should be receipted.




I get the sentiment, but the reality is they will be "making" a fortune for their bbq. Even if people gave $100pp they would still be clearing more then $20,000 with the amount of people they are inviting. My DS received a very small fraction of that at his recent 1st birthday party. And I hosted that at a hall and spent $$$. Way more then they will spend on this wedding.



I don't see why thats comparable. You spent money on the party, yes, but I'm sure the people who are close to you would've given you the same if that party was at a hall or at your home.

I also, give gifts based on my relationship with the couple and not the location. I also give back what most people gave me. I wouldn't give someone more because the got married at Oheka vs the Knights of Columbus if I was equally close with them.

Just my 2 pennies.

Posted 3/27/11 9:06 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

If you plan on going to the destination wedding , then yes I would give less.

If you are going to the BBQ then I would give what I would give normally.

I think it is irrelevant how much they spend and how much they clear. Someone could have a $50k wedding at a hall and it could be paid bh the parents. You wouldn't know and the couple would clear whatever is received. So there really is no difference to me.

As far as your sons birthday. I would never expect guests to cover there plate for a birthday or christening. What money the child gets I feel should be banked.

Posted 3/27/11 9:09 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by headoverheels

1. I think it's tacky for someone to SAY that they expect the same amount despite the fact that it's a BBQ.

2. I think it's tacky for someone to consider giving less BECAUSE it's a BBQ. You're celebrating the wedding and marriage, not covering your plate.

So in the end, IMO, discussing gift amounts at all is tacky. Chat Icon



Ditto


It seems there is a lack of tact on both sides of the fence here.

Why is it any of your concern the amount he makes on the bbq compared to what you received for your son's birthday? You make a choice to have the more $$ party, just as he is making a choice to not have an expensive wedding.

While I do think it's very rude for him to come out and say "I expect this amount....", I think saying "Well he didn't spend nearly as much for his party, so I shouldn't give as much as usual" is equally rude.

Posted 3/27/11 9:13 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Wedding gift question

Posted by JerseyMamaOf2



As far as your sons birthday. I would never expect guests to cover there plate for a birthday or christening. What money the child gets I feel should be banked.



That wasnt what I meant to imply, every cent my DS got went directly into his bank account. I wasn't trying to recoup anything I had spent on the party.

Posted 3/27/11 9:31 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

I would give the same gift. It's just like if the parent's pay for the wedding, the couple still walks away with the gifts.

We planned a big wedding and then I found out I was pregnant, and we eloped instead. We had a small dinner with just our families afterwards. His parents gave us $500, they gave his brother who had an actual "wedding" $5500. I've always thought that was kind of mean. So, I agree with your friend.

Sorry.

Posted 3/27/11 10:45 PM
 

DramaQueen10
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

256 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

I think you should give them the same amount they gave you regardless of where they choose to have their wedding. If that means they get to walk away with more money in their pocket because they chose to have a less extravagant wedding, then good for them.

ETA: Under different circumstances, i think you would give less.... DH and I always make sure to cover our plate (to think this is tacky is just not living in the real world. We'd all like to think it's about the gift, not about covering the plate, but that's just not reality) We have given less money when we've gone to lower budget weddings than we have when we go to more expensive weddings, BUT in the event that we are attending a wedding of someone who came to ours, we always give the same gift, regardless of location

Message edited 2011-03-28 09:10:43.150000.

Posted 3/28/11 9:05 AM
 

caps612
In love with my little guys!!

Member since 8/10

5108 total posts

Name:

Re: Wedding gift question

I think gifts should be given based on the relationship and the location of the wedding and cost per plate are irrelevant.

Posted 3/28/11 9:28 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Wedding Gift question.... Gertyrae 7/6/07 10 Families Helping Families ™
Question re: Wedding Gift... Lucky09 3/19/07 11 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding gift question? teacherwheart 7/14/06 16 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding gift question LuckySV 7/7/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding Gift Question jenny 6/7/06 21 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding Gift Question beena 6/7/06 11 Families Helping Families ™