Re: Wedding gift question
Posted 3/28/2011 11:54:48 AM by cateyemm


Posted by nferrandi


Posted by CarlieJLD7


Posted by J9-13


Posted by JME78

I give gifts based on my relationships with the couple, not based on the location of the wedding.

If these were good friends I would absolutely give them what they gave to us.



I agree.
I wouldn't be thrilled about the way this friend expressed his feelings though.



I agree 100%... Yes that is stupid that he actually said that out loud to more then just his spouse... But I tend to agree with him, if he went to everyone elses wedding and laid out such and such amount of money, just b/c they chose not to have a huge wedding, I do think the money should be receipted.




I get the sentiment, but the reality is they will be "making" a fortune for their bbq. Even if people gave $100pp they would still be clearing more then $20,000 with the amount of people they are inviting. My DS received a very small fraction of that at his recent 1st birthday party. And I hosted that at a hall and spent $$$. Way more then they will spend on this wedding.



I dont quite agree with the location argument. As a guest of any wedding, including an extravagant wedding, you usually have no idea who's paying for what. What if the parents are paying for the entire thing and the gifts that are going to the married couple are pure "profit"? Does that mean that you would give them less based on that?

I'd more likely go by what they gave me for my wedding than base it on their wedding locale. If they are a dear friend and they were generous at my wedding, i would be generous back regardless of the location.
Print Post      Close Window