Vent (about Religion)
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Vent (about Religion) I am a little upset with people right now. I was on vacation and was flying with many orthodox jewish people. I am jewish. My grandmother was strict conservative-almost orthodox and my great grandfather was a rabbi! I was raised conservative and since marrying non-jewish DH I am reform. Anyway, on this trip, lots of things bothered me but this one thing in particular I need to complain about. I am constantly mistaken for an orthodox jew. I don't really know why. Well, I was holding my almost 1.5 year old baby and was waiting for my luggage on the return flight. An orthodox woman by herself, holding her infant son was also there. I was smiling at her mostly because I smile at everyone and also because we both have young kids and my DD is into waving at strangers now and I noticed she was looking at us so I smiled. So she comes over to me and starts up a friendly conversation. Things like "How was your baby on the flight? I'm glad our plane wasn't too delayed due to the weather". We went back and forth for awhile. There was a large orthodox family standing next to me and she points to all of the kids (i think there were 4) and says are they all yours too? And I no. And she said... no? all confused. And I said yes, I have just the one for now. And she saw my husband come over with the luggage and she looked him up and down judgmentally and then looked me up and down... and then looked over at that family and said oh, so who is with them? wanting to know who those kids belonged to. She then made a face and stopped talking to me. Once i got my bags together, I said "nice talking with you. have a nice night" and she said "yeahhhh" in a strange tone. It was so annoying. It's like once she realized I wasn't orthodox she shut down completely. I don't understand it. I just don't. Just because we don't share the same religious beliefs or live our lives under the same stringent rules it shouldn't mean that you can't have a conversation with me or that you can't be friendly. She started the conversation with me too originally so it wasn't like I was bothering her or tricking her in any which way. I was truly upset after this encounter and I can't seem to get it all out of my head. Just needed to vent. Thanks. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:07 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Vent (about Religion) I'm not well educated in the orthodox religion so can you explain to me how one would assume someone is another orthodox? Well a woman...I guess I would know how you know a man is. Also, is having many kids something part of the religion? Sorry, I'm just confused how this would al be based upon. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:14 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Vent (about Religion) Wow that is pretty bigoted if you ask me. |
Posted 1/24/14 12:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Sorry you experienced that. I am not Jewish but I do know (as I'm sure you do) that the orthodox Jewish communities are very tight knit groups and don't often talk to 'outsiders' or at least they're not supposed to so I'm guessing that is why she shut down and just stopped talking to you. I've seen it firsthand and it is kind of sad but I think for many of them it's just a way of life. I wouldn't let it get to you though, as annoying as it is Message edited 2014-01-24 12:16:16.107000. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) I'm Jewish (reform), my father was raised in a conservative house (his parents were holocaust survivors), they all went to Yeshiva except my father...he went to public school. my uncle is orthodox. we don't speak to him anymore. he sees us as not Jewish. one year for hanukkah he bought me and my sister the book "The Idiots Guide to Judaism". my mother was furious and made us leave the books there and we left. all because we wear pants and don't go to temple. Message edited 2014-01-24 12:18:46.640000. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by 2boys1girl I'm not well educated in the orthodox religion so can you explain to me how one would assume someone is another orthodox? Well a woman...I guess I would know how you know a man is. Also, is having many kids something part of the religion? Sorry, I'm just confused how this would al be based upon. It's known in the orthodox community that (one of) the main purpose of a woman is to breed more Jews. So for her to have one child is unheard of. She could have thick, dark hair that may be thought to be a wig...or she could have been wearing a hat or head scarf. Jewish women are supposed to cover their head. Or should could have been wearing a skirt past her knees. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by MrsA714 Sorry you experienced that. I am not Jewish but I do know (as I'm sure you do) that the orthodox Jewish communities are very tight knit groups and don't often talk to 'outsiders' or at least they're not supposed to so I'm guessing that is why she shut down and just stopped talking to you. I've seen it firsthand and it is kind of sad but I think for many of them it's just a way of life. I wouldn't let it get to you though, as annoying as it is They're not supposed to talk to outsiders? I really didn't know that. I am good friends with an Orthodox man, who I used to work with and I still keep in contact with him. He is so friendly to everyone. So I am surprised to hear that I guess. Message edited 2014-01-24 12:20:30.000000. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by forevermylilgirls Posted by MrsA714 Sorry you experienced that. I am not Jewish but I do know (as I'm sure you do) that the orthodox Jewish communities are very tight knit groups and don't often talk to 'outsiders' or at least they're not supposed to so I'm guessing that is why she shut down and just stopped talking to you. I've seen it firsthand and it is kind of sad but I think for many of them it's just a way of life. I wouldn't let it get to you though, as annoying as it is There not supposed to talk to outsiders? I really didn't know that. I am good friends with an Orthodox man, who I used to work with and I still keep in contact with him. He is so friendly to everyone. So I am surprised to hear that I guess. they are allowed to talk to outsiders...some just don't choose too because they don't approve of their lifestyle. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by IansMommy23 Posted by forevermylilgirls Posted by MrsA714 Sorry you experienced that. I am not Jewish but I do know (as I'm sure you do) that the orthodox Jewish communities are very tight knit groups and don't often talk to 'outsiders' or at least they're not supposed to so I'm guessing that is why she shut down and just stopped talking to you. I've seen it firsthand and it is kind of sad but I think for many of them it's just a way of life. I wouldn't let it get to you though, as annoying as it is There not supposed to talk to outsiders? I really didn't know that. I am good friends with an Orthodox man, who I used to work with and I still keep in contact with him. He is so friendly to everyone. So I am surprised to hear that I guess. they are allowed to talk to outsiders...some just don't choose too because they don't approve of their lifestyle. Ah ok. Just curious bc this man is the nicest man I have ever met and so friendly to everyone. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by IansMommy23 Posted by 2boys1girl I'm not well educated in the orthodox religion so can you explain to me how one would assume someone is another orthodox? Well a woman...I guess I would know how you know a man is. Also, is having many kids something part of the religion? Sorry, I'm just confused how this would al be based upon. It's known in the orthodox community that (one of) the main purpose of a woman is to breed more Jews. So for her to have one child is unheard of. She could have thick, dark hair that may be thought to be a wig...or she could have been wearing a hat or head scarf. Jewish women are supposed to cover their head. Or should could have been wearing a skirt past her knees. Ahh thank you for explaining. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by forevermylilgirls Posted by MrsA714 Sorry you experienced that. I am not Jewish but I do know (as I'm sure you do) that the orthodox Jewish communities are very tight knit groups and don't often talk to 'outsiders' or at least they're not supposed to so I'm guessing that is why she shut down and just stopped talking to you. I've seen it firsthand and it is kind of sad but I think for many of them it's just a way of life. I wouldn't let it get to you though, as annoying as it is There not supposed to talk to outsiders? I really didn't know that. I am good friends with an Orthodox man, who I used to work with and I still keep in contact with him. He is so friendly to everyone. So I am surprised to hear that I guess. Please don't take my statement as a broad generalization. If I worded it wrong, forgive me. They are so many different sects/groups and I believe some are more 'strict' when it comes to their dealings with people outside of their communities/group. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:25 PM
|
|
|
Vent (about Religion) weird. This is something I noticed in America, I am Israeli and back home we mix with all. I am secular and lived there in a fairly secular neighborhood which was surrounded by 3 extremely orthodox neighborhoods. I even went several summers to orthodox camps and my mom moonlighted at an orthodox home for a while. All with no issues, they did try to bring us closer to religion and practices/praying but not to the point where if we didn't they didn't speak to us. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by 2boys1girl Posted by IansMommy23 Posted by 2boys1girl I'm not well educated in the orthodox religion so can you explain to me how one would assume someone is another orthodox? Well a woman...I guess I would know how you know a man is. Also, is having many kids something part of the religion? Sorry, I'm just confused how this would al be based upon. It's known in the orthodox community that (one of) the main purpose of a woman is to breed more Jews. So for her to have one child is unheard of. She could have thick, dark hair that may be thought to be a wig...or she could have been wearing a hat or head scarf. Jewish women are supposed to cover their head. Or should could have been wearing a skirt past her knees. Ahh thank you for explaining. no prob. i like when people want to be educated and don't just assume.
|
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by MrsA714 Posted by forevermylilgirls Posted by MrsA714 Sorry you experienced that. I am not Jewish but I do know (as I'm sure you do) that the orthodox Jewish communities are very tight knit groups and don't often talk to 'outsiders' or at least they're not supposed to so I'm guessing that is why she shut down and just stopped talking to you. I've seen it firsthand and it is kind of sad but I think for many of them it's just a way of life. I wouldn't let it get to you though, as annoying as it is There not supposed to talk to outsiders? I really didn't know that. I am good friends with an Orthodox man, who I used to work with and I still keep in contact with him. He is so friendly to everyone. So I am surprised to hear that I guess. Please don't take my statement as a broad generalization. If I worded it wrong, forgive me. They are so many different sects/groups and I believe some are more 'strict' when it comes to their dealings with people outside of their communities/group. I see what you are saying. I was really curious that's all!! Thanks for explaining! |
|
Posted 1/24/14 12:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Ugh that is so maddening. Message edited 2014-01-24 13:18:07.403000. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 1:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) It's so funny you posted this. Just this past weekend I was at my friend's home. She is reform and her DH is not Jewish. They recently moved to a neighborhood that is known to be predominately Jewish but apparently it is predominately Orthodox. She was complaining how she feels so excluded from her community. She said that several times she has been outside on Saturday morning and she has greeted her neighbors as they are walking to temple and they totally ignore her. I almost couldn't believe her because I thought to myself why wouldn't someone just say "good morning" back? But now that you are posting a similar sentiment I guess she wasn't exaggerating. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 1:40 PM
|
|
|
Vent (about Religion) i lived in a brooklyn apartment where we had one part of the floor designated as "non jewish" that I lived on. It was rather entertaining. The men would say hello to me and make conversation if alone but as soon as a wife was there or if it was just women/children, no one would even look up at me. LoL Oddly enough I have a few ortho clients that actually avoid working with people from their community. Such a contradiction now for me but they find i'm easier to deal with LoL |
|
Posted 1/24/14 1:51 PM
|
|
|
Message edited 2014-02-19 05:05:18.980000. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 1:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) I have quite a few modern orthodox friends, but I have also had experiences similar to the OP's, which is very disheartening as a fellow Jew. There are a few Orthodox families near my mother's house, and on the High Holy Days, or if I'm there on a Saturday, I will see them walking to shul (sometimes we are getting in the car to do the same thing). I always greet them with a traditional greeting, and it's a crapshoot whether I'll get a response. When I do, they always look so surprised, and I wonder if it's because they don't expect me to either 1) be Jewish, or 2) know any Hebrew. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 2:12 PM
|
|
|
Vent (about Religion) It is so funny you post this. I'm not Jewish, but I went to a kiddie gym place for a free trial in a predominately Jewish neighborhood. I was the only non Jewish mom there (just assuming because the other ladies wore long sleeves and skirts, and some wore wigs). I was gawked at pretty much the whole time. I was pretty offended. Like they were shunning me because I came to "their" class. Disturbing! |
|
Posted 1/24/14 2:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Posted by Jax430 In general, one of my biggest pet peeves are "religious" people who are not nice to their fellow man. Really, what's the point? This! To me that is the greatest irony of all! I've seen it in every religion too! |
|
Posted 1/24/14 3:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) Sorry you experienced this, but completely not surprised. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 5:29 PM
|
|
|
Vent (about Religion) I truly do not like hypocrites of any faith. They deliberately ignore their faith's teaching in favor of their own petty self-aggrandizing ideas. I do love the saying that those who push themselves closest to the altar are in most need of Godliness. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 5:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Vent (about Religion) I had a similar experience at the airport amongst other places. |
|
Posted 1/24/14 6:46 PM
|
|
|
Vent (about Religion) LOL welcome to my world |
|
Posted 1/24/14 7:06 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I need to vent alittle | Tany | 5/24/05 | 16 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| vent! | janet | 5/23/05 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| MIni-Vent----Nobody ever comes out here!!!!!!! | Holly | 5/20/05 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| peasant skirts - mini vent! | Jax430 | 5/15/05 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| I have to vent...... | MsMBV | 5/13/05 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| OK, I really need to vent (long) | Scotty-CassidysMom | 5/12/05 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |








i like when people want to be educated and don't just assume.






