Updated in first post
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 | |
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Sweets13 Your children only get one childhood. Make the best of it for them. Help them laugh and love. Give them awesome memories that they can share with the world.... Good night AMEN!!!!! Goodnight! |
|
Posted 10/7/10 11:57 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by Diana1215 Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by Diana1215 I'll see you at Zumba, with no grudges. WHAT????????????????????? You guys go to Zumba together????? |
|
Posted 10/8/10 12:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Sweets13 Your children only get one childhood. Make the best of it for them. Help them laugh and love. Give them awesome memories that they can share with the world.... They are kids...and they have their moments. No such thing as the most well beahved child. I dont care if you are a behavorial specialist or Super Nanny herself. Good night Good night! this was the best thing written all day!
|
|
Posted 10/8/10 12:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by carolyns4cupcakes Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by Diana1215 Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by Diana1215 I'll see you at Zumba, with no grudges. WHAT????????????????????? You guys go to Zumba together????? Yup - and she totally rocks!!! AND lost a lot of weight doing it - and looks really amazing.... I only get to that class once in a while though....Seriously - this is what I get for posting when working on behavior powerpoints all night and writing up behavior plans. I attempted to take a break from work at home, brought it here, and then I turned into some evil narcissist determined to take down the "awful" moms of LIF. Note to self - just do your work, and step away from the chat boards..... |
|
Posted 10/8/10 12:03 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by lipglossjunky73 I attempted to take a break from work at home, brought it here, and then I turned into some evil narcissist determined to take down the "awful" moms of LIF. Note to self - just do your work, and step away from the chat boards..... wow really??
|
|
Posted 10/8/10 12:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post I read your first post last night and I read through the thread this morning and really needed to respond. First of all, the video you posted is NOT an example of extinction since the behavior was reinforced at the end. If a behavior was on extinction, there would be a removal of reinforcement. This behavior was inadvertantly reinforced. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 4:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by carolyns4cupcakes Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by Diana1215 Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by Diana1215 I'll see you at Zumba, with no grudges. WHAT????????????????????? You guys go to Zumba together????? Yup - and she totally rocks!!! AND lost a lot of weight doing it - and looks really amazing.... I only get to that class once in a while though....Seriously - this is what I get for posting when working on behavior powerpoints all night and writing up behavior plans. I attempted to take a break from work at home, brought it here, and then I turned into some evil narcissist determined to take down the "awful" moms of LIF. Note to self - just do your work, and step away from the chat boards..... Yes Liza, I'm part of the "awful" moms of LIF! Poor poor Liza! And let me guess YOU are part of "the mother of the years" moms??? Shocker! And, you wonder why you have issues with your co-workers, your step mother, and everyone else in your life?? I can only imagine it must be really hard to have to listen to your nonsense in real life! I will stop now because anything I have to say will get me kicked off LIF and you, are most certainly not worth it (besides, I'm sure you'll be doing one of your long, dramatic goodbye posts again...and then come back two hours later...we all had bets BTW on how long you could actually stay away from promoting how great you are. Message edited 2010-10-08 06:29:22.933000. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 6:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Jacksmommy I read your first post last night and I read through the thread this morning and really needed to respond. First of all, the video you posted is NOT an example of extinction since the behavior was reinforced at the end. If a behavior was on extinction, there would be a removal of reinforcement. This behavior was inadvertantly reinforced. Other things I think that needs to be mentioned if you are talking about sticker charts is that 1. a sticker is a conditioned reinforcer and must be paired with a back up reinforcer. Most kids are not going to just work for stickers - or atleast not for very long. There needs to be a carrot dangling at the end. 2. The goal of any behavior management program is for a child to do whatever skill it is WITHOUT the reinforcer and to make it INTERNALLY motivating. You should NOT have to be doing sticker charts over a long term. 3. Sometimes - kids get tired of the reinforcer, especially when it is used incorrectly. I also always tend to ask people to look at the events leading up to the behavior. For example, in Diana's post, she said he napped right after. Maybe he was actually tired and needed to nap. She said he complied after nap - so it is always important to look at the setting events that lead up to a behavior. Also, I always caution the use of time outs on a consistent basis. Sometimes there is a huge overuse of time outs . . . KWIM The key to any type of behavior is consistency and unfortunately MOST people are not consistent - MYSELF included. I personally work a full time teaching job and then do home cases 7 days a week. When I come home from work, I don't always want to be on my game and honestly, my son gets away with things. Unfortunately that is life. We can't always be perfect and consistent 100% of the time. As parents, we try to do what we do to be successful. I am POSITIVE that no 2, 3,4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 (etc) year old child is perfect 100% of the time, just like I am POSITIVE that no parent is going to be "on their game" 100% of the time. Now THIS is great advice!
|
|
Posted 10/8/10 7:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by lipglossjunky73 I am so glad this turned out to be a thread where we all band together to help - thank you for that!!!!!! As for the resource - BF Skinner - I'm a behaviorist through and through. Also Nathan Azrin and Richard Foxx. If you guys want specific articles, resources, etc - I have tons and tons and tons on PDF files - just FM me the issue - I have the journal article for you. I am not talking about opinion - I am talking about behavior science... As for the church service - realistically, an hour is not going to be easy to expect your 3 yr old to sit. Even with promises of rewards. Developmentally they are just not there yet. This is why I asked what you are willing to sacrifice to build up her good church behavior. If you wanta good 5 minutes versus 30-60 minutes of threatening her within an inch of her life I suggest this - again - I will get many responses saying this won't work, who do I think I am, yada yada yada. This should work. If you are willing to try this - please let me know - we can iron out the details offline....Bring her to the last 5 minutes of the service. WITH the reminders ahead of time of how she should behave. And with the promises of rewards and the follow through after. This way - she is sitting through the end of the service successfully, has the opportunity to receive her reward right after the service ends. Then, start bringing her the last 10 minutes. Those extra 5 mins will be easier for her because she now has a history of what she will get if she sits with the behavioral expectations you set out for her. Then up it to 15, etc until you can get her through the whole service. You have to be willing to miss the rest of the service to get her to that point - or take turns with DH - but the end oroduct will be her sitting next to you for an entire service. FM me - I can help you with it if you want to go that route BF Skinner, the rat guy? I don't remember him giving them time-outs..but I could be wrong. Now Azrin is a tim-out expert...doesn't he say that all time out should be explained to the child and that the child needs to think about what they did wrong, and also that a child should alwaysfeel safe during a time-out. IDK but I think according to his theory 10 months is really to young for that. But I am more into methodology and I don't really remember who said what that well, but I do know that I studied behavior and never thought that there is one be all and end all way to raise children. Additionally I do remember learning that the child is and individual and we must teach the child according to their needs. ] MAybe just mention that another parent is not necessarily won but that this is YOUR way. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 7:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Jacksmommy: You make some excellent posts - let me put your words in quotes.... |
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by twicethefun Posted by lipglossjunky73 I am so glad this turned out to be a thread where we all band together to help - thank you for that!!!!!! As for the resource - BF Skinner - I'm a behaviorist through and through. Also Nathan Azrin and Richard Foxx. If you guys want specific articles, resources, etc - I have tons and tons and tons on PDF files - just FM me the issue - I have the journal article for you. I am not talking about opinion - I am talking about behavior science... As for the church service - realistically, an hour is not going to be easy to expect your 3 yr old to sit. Even with promises of rewards. Developmentally they are just not there yet. This is why I asked what you are willing to sacrifice to build up her good church behavior. If you wanta good 5 minutes versus 30-60 minutes of threatening her within an inch of her life I suggest this - again - I will get many responses saying this won't work, who do I think I am, yada yada yada. This should work. If you are willing to try this - please let me know - we can iron out the details offline....Bring her to the last 5 minutes of the service. WITH the reminders ahead of time of how she should behave. And with the promises of rewards and the follow through after. This way - she is sitting through the end of the service successfully, has the opportunity to receive her reward right after the service ends. Then, start bringing her the last 10 minutes. Those extra 5 mins will be easier for her because she now has a history of what she will get if she sits with the behavioral expectations you set out for her. Then up it to 15, etc until you can get her through the whole service. You have to be willing to miss the rest of the service to get her to that point - or take turns with DH - but the end oroduct will be her sitting next to you for an entire service. FM me - I can help you with it if you want to go that route BF Skinner, the rat guy? I don't remember him giving them time-outs..but I could be wrong. Now Azrin is a tim-out expert...doesn't he say that all time out should be explained to the child and that the child needs to think about what they did wrong, and also that a child should alwaysfeel safe during a time-out. IDK but I think according to his theory 10 months is really to young for that. But I am more into methodology and I don't really remember who said what that well, but I do know that I studied behavior and never thought that there is one be all and end all way to raise children. Additionally I do remember learning that the child is and individual and we must teach the child according to their needs. ] MAybe just mention that another parent is not necessarily won but that this is YOUR way. They have written many books - yes - the Skinner box - I think he was known to put his own kid in one - but they have all used the science of behavior in applied ways - Azrin and Foxx write a lot on time out procedures, potty training, etc - and what you have described is obviously used with individuals who are cognitively able to understand all that language. Many kids on the spectrum as well do not get all that language inundated on them because it is simply not going to be understood. That is why the science must be looked at more than the specific method one uses to apply it.
|
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by carolyns4cupcakes Posted by Sweets13 Your children only get one childhood. Make the best of it for them. Help them laugh and love. Give them awesome memories that they can share with the world.... They are kids...and they have their moments. No such thing as the most well beahved child. I dont care if you are a behavorial specialist or Super Nanny herself. Good night Good night! this was the best thing written all day!CLEARLY! Im not even going to read this whole thread because I know Liza is, to the core, a caring and giving individual who would probably bend over backwards for any one of our kids sight unseen. I know she has helped me with my own. That being said, though by trade, I am a special educator, I carry out MANY of Liza's specialties in the form of behavioral techniques in my classroom and yes, I do carry them over to my home for Abby - AND IT WORKS. I have MANY years of professional experience and I'd be an azz if I did not use my professional know-how with my own children even if that included charts of any kind. That would be like a CPA who did not have enough confidence in themselves to do their own taxes or at least have input. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:19 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Goodness...I can't believe this has ballooned to what it is now since I first read this post yesterday... |
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by MikesBride Goodness...I can't believe this has ballooned to what it is now since I first read this post yesterday... FWIW, I thought the OP was good advice...I also don't think that she meant that she was the best mother ever (in fact she acknowledged that she had failed in more than one area) and everyone should take her advice or their kid would end up a heinous jerk...just advising about what worked for her. I found a lot of it to be very helpful and am determined to try some of the techniques for my FC. ITA! I can't believe it got to where it did. WOW. To OP: Thanks again!
|
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Goldi0218 Posted by carolyns4cupcakes Posted by Sweets13 Your children only get one childhood. Make the best of it for them. Help them laugh and love. Give them awesome memories that they can share with the world.... They are kids...and they have their moments. No such thing as the most well beahved child. I dont care if you are a behavorial specialist or Super Nanny herself. Good night Good night! this was the best thing written all day!CLEARLY! Im not even going to read this whole thread because I know Liza is, to the core, a caring and giving individual who would probably bend over backwards for any one of our kids sight unseen. I know she has helped me with my own. That being said, though by trade, I am a special educator, I carry out MANY of Liza's specialties in the form of behavioral techniques in my classroom and yes, I do carry them over to my home for Abby - AND IT WORKS. I have MANY years of professional experience and I'd be an azz if I did not use my professional know-how with my own children even if that included charts of any kind. That would be like a CPA who did not have enough confidence in themselves to do their own taxes or at least have input. ITA on all counts |
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by speakthetruth Speaking of Super Nanny, I always felt like DH wanted me to dress up as that nanny and get freaky. He was oddly attracted to her. BEST.PART.OF.THIS.THREAD! |
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by ourvalentinesday Posted by MikesBride Goodness...I can't believe this has ballooned to what it is now since I first read this post yesterday... FWIW, I thought the OP was good advice...I also don't think that she meant that she was the best mother ever (in fact she acknowledged that she had failed in more than one area) and everyone should take her advice or their kid would end up a heinous jerk...just advising about what worked for her. I found a lot of it to be very helpful and am determined to try some of the techniques for my FC. ITA! I can't believe it got to where it did. WOW. To OP: Thanks again! I agree! I also think tearing her apart for writing this is completely uncalled for. I really think she was just trying to help. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 8:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post I am just so taken aback by the vitriol being spewed here. It's shocking and saddens me. Maybe I'm completely oblivious and unable to read into things that are posted? |
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post at 8:53 PM, posted on Diana's my 3 year old is driving me crazy post. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post I missed the original post and I don't post as often as I used to (when the kids were younger), but geez, I can't get over how dramatic things have gotten on the Parenting board. Things were NOT like this a couple years ago... Message edited 2010-10-08 09:31:44.223000. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Janice at 8:53 PM, posted on Diana's my 3 year old is driving me crazy post. 30 minutes later, this thread surfaces..."How I have perfectly trained my 3 year old" 2 minutes later, back on Diana's post. timing was all wrong and rude. Happy for those who this helped...but what about the person who was hurt by this?? It is like going on relationships...posting on sexless marriages, then within minutes, starting a new thread detailing how to have a marriage full of banging. then going back to sexless 2 minutes later for another comment. I understand that this is why Diana was upset. But my line of thinking was that Diana's post about being frustrated with her DS gave Liza the idea to post about what worked for her with her DS - not to tear Diana down. She also admitted to mis-reading Diana's post about the toy. Diana is, understandably, upset because she felt attacked and like Liza was using her post as an opportunity to demonstrate what a great mom she is. Liza, from what I could see, wanted to take the opportunity to show Diana (and all the other posters who commiserated with her on her frustration thread) what has worked for her in the past and could work for other moms. I really see both sides of it. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Janice at 8:53 PM, posted on Diana's my 3 year old is driving me crazy post. 30 minutes later, this thread surfaces..."How I have perfectly trained my 3 year old" 2 minutes later, back on Diana's post. timing was all wrong and rude. Happy for those who this helped...but what about the person who was hurt by this?? It is like going on relationships...posting on sexless marriages, then within minutes, starting a new thread detailing how to have a marriage full of banging. then going back to sexless 2 minutes later for another comment. Hrmmm.. given that context I guess it could seem really thoughtless but I hate to think it was intentionally hurtful. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Janice at 8:53 PM, posted on Diana's my 3 year old is driving me crazy post. 30 minutes later, this thread surfaces..."How I have perfectly trained my 3 year old" 2 minutes later, back on Diana's post. timing was all wrong and rude. Happy for those who this helped...but what about the person who was hurt by this?? It is like going on relationships...posting on sexless marriages, then within minutes, starting a new thread detailing how to have a marriage full of banging. then going back to sexless 2 minutes later for another comment. THANK YOU Janice! You can all think I'm a monster, it has no bearinig on me. I know the truth, and I have been around these boards long enough to know the true intent behind this post. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by Diana1215 THANK YOU Janice! You can all think I'm a monster, it has no bearinig on me. I know the truth, and I have been around these boards long enough to know the true intent behind this post. I don't think you are a monster. You are frustrated and given the context I really understand why you are hurt. It sucks. I also don't think you are a bad mom in any respect.I just don't want to think Liza's a monster either. |
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Updated in first post Posted by labonnevie ITA! I can't believe it got to where it did. WOW. In true LIF fashion... For the record, spending quality time with your kids is far more productive as far as curving negative behaviors goes,than wasting precious time competing with other mothers on the internet on who has better methods for bringing up their kids. Honestly people, get off the damn internet and go spend some quality time with your kids.
|
|
Posted 10/8/10 9:33 AM
|
|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 | |





You guys go to Zumba together?????
this was the best thing written all day!
AND lost a lot of weight doing it - and looks really amazing.... I only get to that class once in a while though....

I think he was known to put his own kid in one - but they have all used the science of behavior in applied ways - Azrin and Foxx write a lot on time out procedures, potty training, etc - and what you have described is obviously used with individuals who are cognitively able to understand all that language. Many kids on the spectrum as well do not get all that language inundated on them because it is simply not going to be understood. That is why the science must be looked at more than the specific method one uses to apply it.








