Re: Updated in first post
Posted 10/8/2010 7:56:28 AM by twicethefun
Posted by lipglossjunky73
I am so glad this turned out to be a thread where we all band together to help - thank you for that!!!!!!
As for the resource - BF Skinner - I'm a behaviorist through and through. Also Nathan Azrin and Richard Foxx. If you guys want specific articles, resources, etc - I have tons and tons and tons on PDF files - just FM me the issue - I have the journal article for you.
I am not talking about opinion - I am talking about behavior science...
As for the church service - realistically, an hour is not going to be easy to expect your 3 yr old to sit. Even with promises of rewards. Developmentally they are just not there yet. This is why I asked what you are willing to sacrifice to build up her good church behavior. If you wanta good 5 minutes versus 30-60 minutes of threatening her within an inch of her life I suggest this - again - I will get many responses saying this won't work, who do I think I am, yada yada yada. This should work. If you are willing to try this - please let me know - we can iron out the details offline....
Bring her to the last 5 minutes of the service. WITH the reminders ahead of time of how she should behave. And with the promises of rewards and the follow through after. This way - she is sitting through the end of the service successfully, has the opportunity to receive her reward right after the service ends. Then, start bringing her the last 10 minutes. Those extra 5 mins will be easier for her because she now has a history of what she will get if she sits with the behavioral expectations you set out for her. Then up it to 15, etc until you can get her through the whole service. You have to be willing to miss the rest of the service to get her to that point - or take turns with DH - but the end oroduct will be her sitting next to you for an entire service. FM me - I can help you with it if you want to go that route
BF Skinner, the rat guy? I don't remember him giving them time-outs..but I could be wrong. Now Azrin is a tim-out expert...doesn't he say that all time out should be explained to the child and that the child needs to think about what they did wrong, and also that a child should alwaysfeel safe during a time-out. IDK but I think according to his theory 10 months is really to young for that.
But I am more into methodology and I don't really remember who said what that well, but I do know that I studied behavior and never thought that there is one be all and end all way to raise children. Additionally I do remember learning that the child is and individual and we must teach the child according to their needs. ]
MAybe just mention that another parent is not necessarily won but that this is YOUR way.
|