Re: Updated in first post
Posted 10/8/2010 8:04:23 AM by lipglossjunky73

Jacksmommy: You make some excellent posts - let me put your words in quotes....

"I read your first post last night and I read through the thread this morning and really needed to respond. First of all, the video you posted is NOT an example of extinction since the behavior was reinforced at the end. If a behavior was on extinction, there would be a removal of reinforcement. This behavior was inadvertantly reinforced:"

Good point - I can see why you would think that. What she did was reinforce him in the middle of an extinction burst. The increase in the amount of times he said her name - plus the fact that he used other forms of the same behavior is all a part of the extinction burst. The fact that she reinforced him in the middle of the burst means that next time he engages in that behavior - he is going to have to go through an even bigger burst before he sees that his behavior is no longer going to be reinforced at all (if she chooses to not respond). I like to use this example as how easy it is to finally give in in the middle of an extinction burst (you know the adage - it gets better before it gets worse) because some behaviors drive us insane!!!

"Other things I think that needs to be mentioned if you are talking about sticker charts is that 1. a sticker is a conditioned reinforcer and must be paired with a back up reinforcer. Most kids are not going to just work for stickers - or atleast not for very long. There needs to be a carrot dangling at the end. "

Yep - I said that several times - I didn't get as technical as you did because I wanted it to be more user-friendly, but you definitely are on target!


"The goal of any behavior management program is for a child to do whatever skill it is WITHOUT the reinforcer and to make it INTERNALLY motivating. You should NOT have to be doing sticker charts over a long term. "

Yes - you are right. That is why I said I forget to give Cai stickers - he is on automatic pilot. He asks for the stickers because he likes that we use superhero stickers, and he likes getting toys. He gets small little things, and it is a nice schedule for him to receive them so we don't keep buying stuff. It works for us and it works for him - which is the most important part of any system. We get a paycheck for our job. I t sould be nice to be intrinsically motivated to get up and go to a job, but in the end - we work for our backup reinforcers.

No one gets tired of reinforcers - just a specific reinforcer. We never get tired of money because it gets us other reinforcers. We get tired of eating the same thing, doing the same thing, etc - that is why novelty is reinforcing in and of itself. Stickers when used right take on the same property as money - sometimes they can get ice cream, a toy, a surprise, go to the store pick somehting out, etc.

"I also always tend to ask people to look at the events leading up to the behavior. For example, in Diana's post, she said he napped right after. Maybe he was actually tired and needed to nap. She said he complied after nap - so it is always important to look at the setting events that lead up to a behavior. "

What you are describing is the antecedenet and the consequence. (your basic, 3 columned A-B-C chart) When I am working officially this is what I suggest people to do - but this is a chat board and I wanted to give a watered down version. This is a very basic piece of a functional behavior assessment. Sometimes to get more intensive I conduct a functional behavior analysis - which is much more involved.... You are exactly right!

"Also, I always caution the use of time outs on a consistent basis. Sometimes there is a huge overuse of time outs . . . KWIM"

Abso-friggen-loutely. Time outs MUST be implemented in a very specific way. This is a punishment procedure and actually forbidden to use in schools without parental permission and an ethical commitee. If this is overused in the school system that is an ethical issue. That is why I only have parents do it in a very specific systematic way with it being phased out... which I have outlined here on the past when people FM me. Again - I agree with you!

"The key to any type of behavior is consistency and unfortunately MOST people are not consistent - MYSELF included. "

This is called reinforcing on an intermittent schedule - the hardest to break!

"I personally work a full time teaching job and then do home cases 7 days a week. "

Yeesh - that is a heavy case load - I can see why you are so knowledgeable - that is awesome!!!

" When I come home from work, I don't always want to be on my game and honestly, my son gets away with things. "

That is usually the case - I have done this for so long that most of the time I'm on my game just because it's the only way I know how to be. Not everyone is this way and there are areas I really have not even stepped up in - as I mentioned in my original post. I do what I can do given the contextual fit of my home culture. You have to do the same!

" Unfortunately that is life. We can't always be perfect and consistent 100% of the time.

As parents, we try to do what we do to be successful. I am POSITIVE that no 2, 3,4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 (etc) year old child is perfect 100% of the time, just like I am POSITIVE that no parent is going to be "on their game" 100% of the time. "

Very well said - thank you for sharing! I am glad we are on the same page!

Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window