Union workers and The Rat
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by Ayne11 Posted by DumpsterBaby Shoprite in Selden. It's because they didn't use union workers, to my knowledge. Yup they are always out there. Usually sitting in stadium chairs reading the newspaper lol Do they get paid to do this? Or are they sitting there on their days off? |
|
Posted 10/17/12 1:59 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by BargainMama Posted by Ayne11 Posted by DumpsterBaby Shoprite in Selden. It's because they didn't use union workers, to my knowledge. Yup they are always out there. Usually sitting in stadium chairs reading the newspaper lol Do they get paid to do this? Or are they sitting there on their days off? no pay |
|
Posted 10/17/12 2:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. I don't question the safety issue because I overhear DH talking about mine collapses, building collapses, etc & the first thing he & his friends ask is if it was a union job, which it almost never is. As for the time & place for unions 120 years ago, I disagree too. Today workers are asked to work more hours for less wages. Workers are laid off & other workers are told to pick up the slack. Wages are cut, more work is piled on. Benefits get eroded. It happens every day. I'm in HR so I see it all of the time. If anything, I think workers need more protection from employers because just like in real estate, it's a buyer's market - in business, it's an employer's market. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 2:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by MrsMeloyellow Posted by BargainMama Posted by Ayne11 Posted by DumpsterBaby Shoprite in Selden. It's because they didn't use union workers, to my knowledge. Yup they are always out there. Usually sitting in stadium chairs reading the newspaper lol Do they get paid to do this? Or are they sitting there on their days off? no pay They are there on their days off and they do not get paid for it. During vacation or furlough or even while they are laid off, it's on their own time. Sometimes during their lunch break or even after work. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 3:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. I don't question the safety issue because I overhear DH talking about mine collapses, building collapses, etc & the first thing he & his friends ask is if it was a union job, which it almost never is. As for the time & place for unions 120 years ago, I disagree too. Today workers are asked to work more hours for less wages. Workers are laid off & other workers are told to pick up the slack. Wages are cut, more work is piled on. Benefits get eroded. It happens every day. I'm in HR so I see it all of the time. If anything, I think workers need more protection from employers because just like in real estate, it's a buyer's market - in business, it's an employer's market. Contractors don't often choose to bid on non union jobs because if they do, they will never get union jobs again. Union jobs are always larger in nature meaning they buy more and spend more on supplies...keeps the economy going...which is why suppliers will bend over backwards for union shops as opposed to non. I think the problem is really more that you think their wages are overinflated. Have you seen how dangerous the job sites can be? These men work over 1,000 feet in the air with no walls, no floors etc...they walk along beams while the wind blows. They bust their azzes and come home beat up and filthy. Why should companies be able to pay people the same as the guy who works at mcdonalds for this type of job? It's not like we live in a mansion and drive fancy cars! We live in a modest home in baldwin and we still struggle ALOT...so how overinflated do you think those paychecks can really be? Unions are about fair pay and fair treatment of employees...I can't wrap my head around why someone would be against that. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 5:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by HeyJude Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. ITA, where I grew up there were no unions, at all. Buildings are not falling down, houses are not crumbling and the ER rooms are not filled with injured workers. Around here, the non-union workers are not trained and don't receive benifits and low pay. I know because my brother is non-union..
|
|
Posted 10/17/12 6:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by HeyJude Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. ITA, where I grew up there were no unions, at all. Buildings are not falling down, houses are not crumbling and the ER rooms are not filled with injured workers. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 6:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. I don't question the safety issue because I overhear DH talking about mine collapses, building collapses, etc & the first thing he & his friends ask is if it was a union job, which it almost never is. As for the time & place for unions 120 years ago, I disagree too. Today workers are asked to work more hours for less wages. Workers are laid off & other workers are told to pick up the slack. Wages are cut, more work is piled on. Benefits get eroded. It happens every day. I'm in HR so I see it all of the time. If anything, I think workers need more protection from employers because just like in real estate, it's a buyer's market - in business, it's an employer's market. thank you. I am a Local 3 kid and let me tell you... my father was on furlough many so that other union members could work... instead of people being let go... it's a brotherhood. I don't expect any "non-union" person to understand but there is a sense of security and family within a union. You will never convince me otherwise that we don't need unions in this country. Message edited 2012-10-17 18:24:08.973000. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 6:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat In order to get into his union my husband had to apply. He had to show proof of academic competency through traditional transcripts. He had to take a test, interview a few times and then - once he was accepted - he had to go to school and act as a working apprentice for 5 years before he was turned out and told he was good enough to be given the union stamp of approval as a certified journeyman. It wasn't a cakewalk. Even now he takes the classes that they offer to keep his knowledge about the changing field current. Message edited 2012-10-17 19:41:33.833000. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 7:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by rojerono In order to get into his union my husband had to apply. He had to show proof of academic competency through traditional transcripts. He had to take a test, interview a few times and then - once he was accepted - he had to go to school and act as a working apprentice for 5 years before he was turned out and told he was good enough to be given the union stamp of approval as a certified journeyman. It wasn't a cakewalk. Even now he takes the classes that they offer to keep his knowledge about the changing field current. So with all of this training and experience he DOES command a decent compensation - a liveable wage and good benefits. And he deserves it. He recently got called by a non-union shop because a friend of his knew he needed work. The shop offered him 15/hour, no benefits, PTO accrual at 3.8 hours for every 40 hours worked AFTER 6 months (that's FIVE days a year for sick, vacation, personal) and no medical, vision, life or dental. That's not unusual. That's not uncommon. 20 years of experience plus hands on training and formal education .. and that's what they think he's worth. That's the reason they can outbid union shops. And while some non-union shops have damn fine workers.. a lot of them just have guys who don't have the right training or experience. And because of the crap compensation they have a pretty high turnover.. the the degree that some actually have been known to hire day laborers to do simple wiring rather than trained, certified electrical mechanics. He didn't take the job. Not only because the wage was laughable (actually less than UEI when you factor in taxes and the childcare and gas expense we'd have to tack on) but because when you are union and you take that brotherhood seriously - you don't screw your brothers by undermining them and working for an outfit that doesn't see the value in well trained professionals. I don't know.. I'm a union daughter and a union wife. I guess I just see things differently.
|
|
Posted 10/17/12 7:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by MrsMeloyellow Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. I don't question the safety issue because I overhear DH talking about mine collapses, building collapses, etc & the first thing he & his friends ask is if it was a union job, which it almost never is. As for the time & place for unions 120 years ago, I disagree too. Today workers are asked to work more hours for less wages. Workers are laid off & other workers are told to pick up the slack. Wages are cut, more work is piled on. Benefits get eroded. It happens every day. I'm in HR so I see it all of the time. If anything, I think workers need more protection from employers because just like in real estate, it's a buyer's market - in business, it's an employer's market. Contractors don't often choose to bid on non union jobs because if they do, they will never get union jobs again. Union jobs are always larger in nature meaning they buy more and spend more on supplies...keeps the economy going...which is why suppliers will bend over backwards for union shops as opposed to non. I think the problem is really more that you think their wages are overinflated. Have you seen how dangerous the job sites can be? These men work over 1,000 feet in the air with no walls, no floors etc...they walk along beams while the wind blows. They bust their azzes and come home beat up and filthy. Why should companies be able to pay people the same as the guy who works at mcdonalds for this type of job? It's not like we live in a mansion and drive fancy cars! We live in a modest home in baldwin and we still struggle ALOT...so how overinflated do you think those paychecks can really be? Unions are about fair pay and fair treatment of employees...I can't wrap my head around why someone would be against that. Thank you! My DH is Local 3 electrician. He can literally blow up on any given day. How much do you (melbalalala) think he should be paid? FTR bc his union is so saturated, they are required to take 14 weeks of furlough every year with no pay. That's more than 25% of the year and we've been lucky, other guys have been laid off for up to a year. My DH EARNS every cent of his "overinflated" pay check. Message edited 2012-10-17 20:59:56.313000. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 8:38 PM
|
|
|
Union workers and The Rat Thank you for these very informative responses! |
|
Posted 10/17/12 8:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat i think unions do a great job of protecting their workers and in some industries it is essential....however i also think the costs of unionized labor for companies is unsustainable in this economy...the benefits (from my experience) are very rich and the defined pension plans are a big problem for companies. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 10:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by DaniRella Just to break up the possible debate / controversial issue with a little humor... Someone I know who I am NOT related to, I won't say who, but they MAY be somewhere in DH's family tree lol thought that the blow-up rat was a bouncy-house for kids to play and jump in - like one you'd find at a child's birthday party. We actually had to explain to him/her that the rat has to do with businesses not using union workers. To this day, DH goes, EVEN IF you didn't know about the union thing - common sense would say, why would anyone want a HUGE rat with green eyes and fangs as a bouncy house?! It is so scary looking! gives me an idea for a new design....bring your kids to the protest and the back of the rat can be a bouncer. |
|
Posted 10/18/12 1:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by blue11 i think unions do a great job of protecting their workers and in some industries it is essential....however i also think the costs of unionized labor for companies is unsustainable in this economy...the benefits (from my experience) are very rich and the defined pension plans are a big problem for companies. What is unsustainable? Union members aren't raking in the dough in this country. Corporations are. Union members are making a living wage. Also what union benefits are "too rich"? Paid health insurance? A retirement fund you can draw from when you are out 14 weeks a year or 53 weeks if you are laid off? Maybe DH is in the wrong union. Historically, Local 3 is known for having great benefits of all of the trade unions. |
|
Posted 10/18/12 5:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by blue11 i think unions do a great job of protecting their workers and in some industries it is essential....however i also think the costs of unionized labor for companies is unsustainable in this economy...the benefits (from my experience) are very rich and the defined pension plans are a big problem for companies. What is unsustainable? Union members aren't raking in the dough in this country. Corporations are. Union members are making a living wage. Also what union benefits are "too rich"? Paid health insurance? A retirement fund you can draw from when you are out 14 weeks a year or 53 weeks if you are laid off? Maybe DH is in the wrong union. Historically, Local 3 is known for having great benefits of all of the trade unions. too rich wasn't the right way to describe it...it boils down to pension costs. Not in terms of offering pension to employees but how they are offered as in a defined pension plan which puts very large pension obligations on organizations - and the funding requirements that come with it. When the market took a downturn, the pension obligations became HUGE and with a pension all of the risk is on the employer, unlike defined contribution plans. Its part of the reason why some companies are claiming bankruptcy (hostess comes to mind) |
|
Posted 10/18/12 7:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by ourlivesstartnow2012 Posted by MrsMeloyellow Posted by BargainMama Posted by Ayne11 Posted by DumpsterBaby Shoprite in Selden. It's because they didn't use union workers, to my knowledge. Yup they are always out there. Usually sitting in stadium chairs reading the newspaper lol Do they get paid to do this? Or are they sitting there on their days off? no pay They are there on their days off and they do not get paid for it. During vacation or furlough or even while they are laid off, it's on their own time. Sometimes during their lunch break or even after work. if they dont go to one a year they also get fined from the union |
|
Posted 10/18/12 10:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by danielle3203 if they dont go to one a year they also get fined from the union Is this true? I don't think my DH has ever gotten fined.
|
|
Posted 10/18/12 10:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by danielle3203 if they dont go to one a year they also get fined from the union Is this true? I don't think my DH has ever gotten fined. This can not be true. I'm a union member and the daughter of a union member as well and no one I know has ever been forced to go to a protest or fined if they didn't. |
|
Posted 10/18/12 10:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by BunnyWife Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by danielle3203 if they dont go to one a year they also get fined from the union Is this true? I don't think my DH has ever gotten fined. This can not be true. I'm a union member and the daughter of a union member as well and no one I know has ever been forced to go to a protest or fined if they didn't. Maybe it depends on the union? My husband gets calls to attend rallies and protests, but it's never been a demand. He takes care of our kids and he's never gone and he's never been fined. |
|
Posted 10/18/12 11:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by danielle3203 Posted by ourlivesstartnow2012 Posted by MrsMeloyellow Posted by BargainMama Posted by Ayne11 Posted by DumpsterBaby Shoprite in Selden. It's because they didn't use union workers, to my knowledge. Yup they are always out there. Usually sitting in stadium chairs reading the newspaper lol Do they get paid to do this? Or are they sitting there on their days off? no pay They are there on their days off and they do not get paid for it. During vacation or furlough or even while they are laid off, it's on their own time. Sometimes during their lunch break or even after work. if they dont go to one a year they also get fined from the union not true at all. union daughter & union rep here. |
|
Posted 10/18/12 11:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by danielle3203 if they dont go to one a year they also get fined from the union Is this true? I don't think my DH has ever gotten fined. I have never heard that before... 2 sisters, cousins, uncles, brother & BIL are union workers and none of them have ever been fired for not going to a rally. |
|
Posted 10/18/12 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by AngnShaun Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by danielle3203 if they dont go to one a year they also get fined from the union Is this true? I don't think my DH has ever gotten fined. I have never heard that before... 2 sisters, cousins, uncles, brother & BIL are union workers and none of them have ever been fired for not going to a rally. Yes, unions are permitted to fine members for not engaging in collective action that benefits their trade. The Carpenters charge members $500 per year if the member does not do at least one 4 hour picket shift per year. No one is fired over this! They give you four options per year. You have to make just one. If someone doesn't want to do their picket duty, they can become an objecting member and not do it but it you want to be a full member (which is your choice!) then its once a year or pay the fine. Message edited 2012-10-18 13:16:05.050000. |
|
Posted 10/18/12 1:15 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question regarding furlough for union workers | Laura1976 | 1/7/12 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |












