Union workers and The Rat
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Union workers and The Rat Can someone school me on this? |
|
Posted 10/16/12 5:19 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
DumpsterBaby
Member since 5/11 2210 total posts Name: |
Union workers and The Rat Shoprite in Selden. It's because they didn't use union workers, to my knowledge. |
Posted 10/16/12 5:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat I don't understand |
|
Posted 10/16/12 5:25 PM
|
|
|
DumpsterBaby
Member since 5/11 2210 total posts Name: |
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by Jugglemom I don't understand doesn't everyone have the right to hire who they choose? Or am I missing something? It seems like bullying to me.I agree, but I know nothing about union jobs/politics. |
Posted 10/16/12 5:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflatable_rat Message edited 2012-10-16 17:29:11.497000. |
|
Posted 10/16/12 5:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by Jugglemom I don't understand doesn't everyone have the right to hire who they choose? Or am I missing something? It seems like bullying to me.I don't understand either. That's what I'm trying to find out. Like is it encouraged that they use the union workers for a specific reason? Do they get in trouble at all for NOT picking them? |
|
Posted 10/16/12 5:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Thank you! I didn't even think to Wiki an inflatable rat. |
|
Posted 10/16/12 5:28 PM
|
|
|
Union workers and The Rat Ok, I see the significance of the rat, but some of my questions still are unanswered. Will do more research |
|
Posted 10/16/12 5:31 PM
|
|
|
Union workers and The Rat Non union construction employees are not paid as much and many time they are not trained and safety is severely compromised. |
|
Posted 10/16/12 8:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat This could turn into a big debate! In order to save money by not hiring union labor, most places will have to compromise safety. In some cases, some of the work is being done under the table. There are orgainzations that have signed contracts that obligate them to use union labor and then when they breach they get to protests. There are rules that only union workers can do speific things. Those rules vary from state to state. |
|
Posted 10/16/12 8:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by Kerie-is-so-very This could turn into a big debate! In order to save money by not hiring union labor, most places will have to compromise safety. In some cases, some of the work is being done under the table. There are organizations that have signed contracts that obligate them to use union labor and then when they breach they get to protests. There are rules that only union workers can do speific things. Those rules vary from state to state. I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. |
|
Posted 10/16/12 9:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat I always took it as a protest and as a signal for people who support unions to not do business there. |
|
Posted 10/16/12 9:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. ITA, where I grew up there were no unions, at all. Buildings are not falling down, houses are not crumbling and the ER rooms are not filled with injured workers. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 7:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat yes you may hire non-union workers and yes they may do just as good a job or better. However, unlike a union position there is no one fighting for a living wage, benefits and/or safety for workers. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 9:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by Nifheim yes you may hire non-union workers and yes they may do just as good a job or better. However, unlike a union position there is no one fighting for a living wage, benefits and/or safety for workers. this country needs to decide are we a country for a minimum of a living wage, decent benefits and safety for workers or a country of cheap work/items so that companies pocket more profits instead of the workers. It really boils down to that. I will also add I also feel unions themselves need to be held more accountable for where the dues go and more importantly who is voted in as its leaders. Just like politicians some of the heads of unions are freaking scum. ITA |
|
Posted 10/17/12 10:47 AM
|
|
|
Union workers and The Rat I've been union all my life ( my dad is in the union and now DH and I are also in). Everyone has a right to protest. Non-unions can protest if they wanted to for union jobs but they choose not to. From what I've learned growing up in the union is that it's a brotherhood. We stand for each other and when jobs are taken away from our brothers and sisters, we protest. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 11:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by EatingMyVeggies Can someone school me on this? There's a new supermarket opening near me and I see people standing with the rat. I was trying to explain it to DC, who was asking me why there was a giant rat on the lawn. It's my understanding that the supermarket didn't go with the union workers and hired other people, right? What is the reason for this - is it just $? Are they supposed to hire union people? Is anyone to blame here? or is it blame on both sides? There is no one to blame. The grocery store has a right to hire who they want to perform the work. Workers and Unions have a right to stand oustide of the store and try to appeal to the public for their support. It's well-settled that this kind of conduct is free speech. Most likely, the union standing there with the rat was a construction union protesting the use of non-union labor that pays below the area standards and benefits. Sometimes, the union is trying to draw attention to unsafe working conditions like asbestos removal by unskilled or less skilled workers. When I see an inflatable rat, I stop and ask for the flyer they are handing out in each case because I am curious to know what specifically the issue is! IN the past, I have I have seen issues randing from area standards, safety issues, failure to pay prevailing wages on federal/state contracts and wage theft (not paying overtime, etc). |
|
Posted 10/17/12 11:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by melbalalala I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. First disclaimer: DH is in a union job. I work in HR at a non-union company. Second, I don't think it's silly for grocery workers to be unionized. Unions aren't just for safety issues, although in construction safety issues are ESSENTIAL. Unions are a group of workers that are requesting a minimum payment of wages, benefits & job protection from their employer. Take a look at Walmart, for example. They're able to be successful at delivering very low prices at the expense of the workers they employ. They were brought up on charges for forcing hourly employees to work overtime without pay, not allowing employees to take rest or lunch breaks, employing undocumented workers, LOCKING night time employees in stores where only one manager has the key, discriminating against their female workers. Walmart employs many part-time workers rather than full-time to avoid paying benefits (they're not the only ones guilty of this!). Guess who picks up those worker's healthcare costs? You got it, the State. More examples: Walmart is the devil |
|
Posted 10/17/12 11:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by HeyJude Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. ITA, where I grew up there were no unions, at all. Buildings are not falling down, houses are not crumbling and the ER rooms are not filled with injured workers. I work in construction and have been on both side of the union/non-union and in NY, Boston and DC the non union jobs have a higher rate of accidents. Yes there is data on this but most comapnies will not share this info with you. The safety programs that union companies have in place is insane. THe company I work for now spends MILLIONS in safety programs and training. Do we still have accidents...of course because construction is dangerous but I worked for a non -union comapny in 2008 and they were working at excavation site where the DOB was shutting the sites down weekely due to unsafe conditions. The comapny/owner did nto care cause it was all about get it done and at a low cost. THey had zero safety programs. No chances are the buildings are not goign to fall down because they still have to be inspected by the various cities and towns but yes people are geting hurt on these projects and they are probably in the ER and unless you are hanging out there you wouldn't see them. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 12:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by DumpsterBaby Shoprite in Selden. It's because they didn't use union workers, to my knowledge. Yup they are always out there. Usually sitting in stadium chairs reading the newspaper lol |
|
Posted 10/17/12 12:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat We had an experience with a blow up Rat. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 12:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat I have no problems with unions (I am a teacher). I see their purpose. However, I do have some issues with the Rat. Last year in Long Beach the middle school and elementary school had some work done and the school district apparently did not choose union. Well the union workers had that big ugly Rat up there right next to an elementary school where children had to pass by it when they went to school everyday. That is just disgusting in my honest opinion. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 12:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Just to break up the possible debate / controversial issue with a little humor... |
|
Posted 10/17/12 1:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat if a company chooses to be part of a union then the workers need to be union. Union workers pay fees to get the benefits that they have, they have elections, meetings etc, depending what union, they have to wait on a list, go to school, get certifications. Bringing non union workers undercuts those that pay their dues etc. because now you have cheap (and many times unqualified or uncertified) labor coming in and taking the place of the men who are certified and pay dues etc, it undercuts fair pay for those workers as well and puts union workers out of a job. Message edited 2012-10-17 13:34:52.710000. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 1:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Union workers and The Rat Posted by alli3131 Posted by HeyJude Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages... I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps. There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much. ITA, where I grew up there were no unions, at all. Buildings are not falling down, houses are not crumbling and the ER rooms are not filled with injured workers. I work in construction and have been on both side of the union/non-union and in NY, Boston and DC the non union jobs have a higher rate of accidents. Yes there is data on this but most comapnies will not share this info with you. The safety programs that union companies have in place is insane. THe company I work for now spends MILLIONS in safety programs and training. Do we still have accidents...of course because construction is dangerous but I worked for a non -union comapny in 2008 and they were working at excavation site where the DOB was shutting the sites down weekely due to unsafe conditions. The comapny/owner did nto care cause it was all about get it done and at a low cost. THey had zero safety programs. No chances are the buildings are not goign to fall down because they still have to be inspected by the various cities and towns but yes people are geting hurt on these projects and they are probably in the ER and unless you are hanging out there you wouldn't see them. I agree. Workplace safety is often an issue. I dated a union guy and he told me that if he did the same work non-union, they would not even have to supply him with goggles for eye protection. When I handled Workers' Comp cases I saw a huge difference. |
|
Posted 10/17/12 1:57 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question regarding furlough for union workers | Laura1976 | 1/7/12 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |




doesn't everyone have the right to hire who they choose? Or am I missing something? It seems like bullying to me.







