Re: Union workers and The Rat
Posted 10/17/2012 5:54:54 PM by hotsauce345
Posted by nrthshgrl
Posted by melbalalala I question the safety issue as there are many states that have construction done by non-union members without any safety problems. It seems that many NY union members use this argument and I would think in this economy, with so many unemployed people willing to work hard to make a buck and so many contracting company desperate for contracts that the argument is outdated. I would guess there are many companies willing to bid on a project, with non-union members, willing to follow the highest safety standards for a job and can win the contract with a much lower price because they don't have to pay union workers overinflated wages...
I have issues with unions from an economic perspective (biggest issue is overinflating wages and in turn, prices to the consumer) and think it's silly that grocery workers, in particular, would ever need to be unionized. I, too, am in a position that is unionized unnecessarily (Federal worker - I don't pay union dues but I am somewhat protected by the union) and think that it hurts more people (tax payers) than it helps.
There was a time and place for unions 120 years ago when people were losing limbs in sweatshop- like conditions manufacturing sausages but now.. not so much.
I don't question the safety issue because I overhear DH talking about mine collapses, building collapses, etc & the first thing he & his friends ask is if it was a union job, which it almost never is.
As for the time & place for unions 120 years ago, I disagree too.
Today workers are asked to work more hours for less wages. Workers are laid off & other workers are told to pick up the slack. Wages are cut, more work is piled on. Benefits get eroded. It happens every day. I'm in HR so I see it all of the time. If anything, I think workers need more protection from employers because just like in real estate, it's a buyer's market - in business, it's an employer's market.
Contractors don't often choose to bid on non union jobs because if they do, they will never get union jobs again. Union jobs are always larger in nature meaning they buy more and spend more on supplies...keeps the economy going...which is why suppliers will bend over backwards for union shops as opposed to non.
I think the problem is really more that you think their wages are overinflated. Have you seen how dangerous the job sites can be? These men work over 1,000 feet in the air with no walls, no floors etc...they walk along beams while the wind blows. They bust their azzes and come home beat up and filthy. Why should companies be able to pay people the same as the guy who works at mcdonalds for this type of job? It's not like we live in a mansion and drive fancy cars! We live in a modest home in baldwin and we still struggle ALOT...so how overinflated do you think those paychecks can really be? Unions are about fair pay and fair treatment of employees...I can't wrap my head around why someone would be against that.
|