Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

ExpectingJoy
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

751 total posts

Name:
Cari

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

I used to leave my older daughter sleeping with the car on for a few minutes if we got back home from somewhere and she had fallen asleep. The heat was on if it was the winter, but my thinking was that she didn't transfer well and I always thought it was a shame to wake her...

Posted 12/9/10 7:40 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Dani77
It's FUN to be ONE

Member since 7/09

4363 total posts

Name:
Danicia

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

I don't like that idea at all! If DS falls alseep in the car, when we get home I still take his coat and hat off, and put him in his crib. He may wake for a few mins and complain, but I rub his back and he's back out like a light. I couldn't imagine leaving him in there alone... never.

Posted 12/9/10 7:43 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

My opinion on this and other posts like it (the child in shorts comes to mind), is that people should mind their own business when it comes to certain things.
You don't know what the details are:
was the car running? was it in the garage? does the child not transition well and she needs to keep him in the car to let him sleep? etc, etc.

If you don't see a child actually being abused or neglected then there is no real reason to get involved. I know a few people who have let their child sleep in the car in the driveway because they can't take the child out of the carseat. I know I have sat in parking lots with the car running cuz DS will wake up as soon as I turn the car off...

Posted 12/9/10 8:06 PM
 

cds58019
The loves of my life :)

Member since 6/08

4276 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by Gertyrae

My opinion on this and other posts like it (the child in shorts comes to mind), is that people should mind their own business when it comes to certain things.
You don't know what the details are:
was the car running? was it in the garage? does the child not transition well and she needs to keep him in the car to let him sleep? etc, etc.

If you don't see a child actually being abused or neglected then there is no real reason to get involved. I know a few people who have let their child sleep in the car in the driveway because they can't take the child out of the carseat. I know I have sat in parking lots with the car running cuz DS will wake up as soon as I turn the car off...




I dont think a possible case of child abuse or neglect is something that you should wait around until you have definite facts. I would say better safe then sorry for things like this.

Posted 12/9/10 8:47 PM
 

SpencersMommy
I'm one lucky girl

Member since 11/07

3494 total posts

Name:
Melanie

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by Meggo613

Omg is all i have to sayChat Icon Chat Icon




ITA! Horrible!

Posted 12/9/10 8:49 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by cds58019

Posted by Gertyrae

My opinion on this and other posts like it (the child in shorts comes to mind), is that people should mind their own business when it comes to certain things.
You don't know what the details are:
was the car running? was it in the garage? does the child not transition well and she needs to keep him in the car to let him sleep? etc, etc.

If you don't see a child actually being abused or neglected then there is no real reason to get involved. I know a few people who have let their child sleep in the car in the driveway because they can't take the child out of the carseat. I know I have sat in parking lots with the car running cuz DS will wake up as soon as I turn the car off...




I dont think a possible case of child abuse or neglect is something that you should wait around until you have definite facts. I would say better safe then sorry for things like this.



And what would you tell CPS or the police? that the child possibly was left sleeping in the car but you don't know any details? and when the police see that the child is healthy then what? do you see my point?
She's going by hearsay from the mother - she didn't even say if she saw the child...
If there is a situation where you see a child that looks dirty, hungry, very thin, very lethargic - those are cases where I would say that you get authorities involved. But, something like this? I don't see that there is anything that could be done in reality.

Posted 12/9/10 8:53 PM
 

doublestroller
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

1179 total posts

Name:

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by Palebride

My mom used to put us out for naps in her basinet in the backyard in the winter. The cold air is good for babies, and as long as they're wrapped, I don't see a problem.

is she german Chat Icon ? i have heard that in germany people put babies outside all the time for naps, cold weather and all, at least once a day! fresh air is good for everyone, even the little ones...

Posted 12/9/10 8:53 PM
 

cds58019
The loves of my life :)

Member since 6/08

4276 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by Gertyrae

Posted by cds58019

Posted by Gertyrae

My opinion on this and other posts like it (the child in shorts comes to mind), is that people should mind their own business when it comes to certain things.
You don't know what the details are:
was the car running? was it in the garage? does the child not transition well and she needs to keep him in the car to let him sleep? etc, etc.

If you don't see a child actually being abused or neglected then there is no real reason to get involved. I know a few people who have let their child sleep in the car in the driveway because they can't take the child out of the carseat. I know I have sat in parking lots with the car running cuz DS will wake up as soon as I turn the car off...




I dont think a possible case of child abuse or neglect is something that you should wait around until you have definite facts. I would say better safe then sorry for things like this.



And what would you tell CPS or the police? that the child possibly was left sleeping in the car but you don't know any details? and when the police see that the child is healthy then what? do you see my point?
She's going by hearsay from the mother - she didn't even say if she saw the child...
If there is a situation where you see a child that looks dirty, hungry, very thin, very lethargic - those are cases where I would say that you get authorities involved. But, something like this? I don't see that there is anything that could be done in reality.




I see your point as far as lack of evidence goes. But this is a situation that you wouldn't see any of the effects until it was too late. I guess you would have to call someone if you are literally watching it go on in front of you. You have to admit, it's a tough call. Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 8:56 PM
 

waiting4ablessing
Love my kids!!

Member since 11/08

4351 total posts

Name:

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

thats disturbing! ive put DS in the car and then realized i forgot something in the house and ran back in for 2 seconds but i literaly run in and run back out! to leave a baby in a car to PAINT is just ridiculous! bring him to a family members house if you're so concerned with painting your rooms!!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 9:03 PM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Well based on the OP, I'm guessing this wasn't an attached/heated garage since the woman herself joked about having to give the baby a warm bath to warm him up Chat Icon

That's terribleChat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 9:04 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by doublestroller

Posted by Palebride

My mom used to put us out for naps in her basinet in the backyard in the winter. The cold air is good for babies, and as long as they're wrapped, I don't see a problem.

is she german Chat Icon ? i have heard that in germany people put babies outside all the time for naps, cold weather and all, at least once a day! fresh air is good for everyone, even the little ones...



My MIL was born in Canada and her mother and grandmother used to put her out on the porch in her pram. Every time I hear the story I Chat Icon but that lady is never sick!

In any case-I could not leave my kid sleeping in the car outside while I was painting.

Posted 12/9/10 9:13 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by CarlieJLD7

Posted by Calla

Maybe the car was pulled into an attached garage?



Thats what I was thinking...

Call me a bad mommy... but the other day Carlie fell asleep in the car, and I just left her in there while I cleaned in the garage... it wasn't that cold in the garage, I had a sweatshirt on no jacket and I was fine... she even still had her jacket on...

I don't see the problem if that was the case... Personally I wouldn't leave the garage and go upstairs... but I don't see it as being that crazy IF she was in the house... but I am sure their are some crazy's out there who do it in their Driveway... and thats crazy...




our garage is like an icebox in the winter. but granted yours sounds like its warmer and you were right there next to her watchiing her, so i cant say its terrible.

and you probably werent in there foras long as you would need to PAINT A ROOM for chrissakes.

this tool left her kid in the car, outside probably, while she's in the house painting. holy sh**Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon someone could break a window, take the kid out of the carseat and kidnap the kid, they can freeze to death..oh my god..

she should not reproduce anymore..she seems too stupid.

Posted 12/9/10 9:16 PM
 

CarlieJLD7
I love my daughter!

Member since 7/07

3061 total posts

Name:
Carlie

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Ya know... One time I was waiting for Carlie to wake up... and it was hot out so I had the car on with the AC ON in the car... and I was sitting in the car.

I was laying down trying to get sun through the sunroof window (I know I am crazy, I love me some sun)

And an older Couple started BANGING ON THE WINDOW... and scared the S h * T out of me b/c I was so nervous she was going to wake Carlie up from her nap... and they started screaming... ARE YOU OK? IS THE BABY OK...

and I was so confused as to why they wouldn't think we were ok... but then I realized maybe they thought I was trying to commit suicide us b/c of the carbon monoxide or something!!!

But I just didn't want to wake Carlie I felt bad b/c she had just fallen asleep...

But this just reminded me of that time hahha

Message edited 2010-12-09 21:18:00.963000.

Posted 12/9/10 9:17 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by doublestroller

Posted by Palebride

My mom used to put us out for naps in her basinet in the backyard in the winter. The cold air is good for babies, and as long as they're wrapped, I don't see a problem.



is she german Chat Icon ? i have heard that in germany people put babies outside all the time for naps, cold weather and all, at least once a day! fresh air is good for everyone, even the little ones...



She is German!!Chat Icon Well, my Grandmother grew up in Germany....maybe she taught that to my mother.

Posted 12/9/10 9:47 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by pickles16

Honestly call me crazy call me anal call me what you like...I don't care if the garage was attached or not...and not so much if the garage was warm or not..the fact of the matter is that she did not have her eye on him/her for a while, while the child was locked in a car...the image of that just makes me want to throw up...being right there is another thing..I've had DD fall asleep in the car park the car in the driveway and walk outside of the car to talk on my cell or something but I'm right there...I don't like the fact that she was NOT there...and now with the OP saying it WAS outside and in the cold, this makes me honestly want to throw up...paint fumes or not, this mom is not thinking



Could not have said it better!

Posted 12/9/10 9:55 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

I wouldn't do it but I definitely wouldn't call CPS. I think that is a crazy overeaction! I have twins and have had to, at times, leave one in the car while I bring the other one, or when we were packing for a trip-put the babies in the car in the driveway(with heat or ac on) and pack our bags. When we were moving we def had them in the car while we put stuff from our old house in the car and moved it over. I admire those of you that never have to do this!

Posted 12/9/10 10:01 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by DRMom

I wouldn't do it but I definitely wouldn't call CPS. I think that is a crazy overeaction! I have twins and have had to, at times, leave one in the car while I bring the other one, or when we were packing for a trip-put the babies in the car in the driveway(with heat or ac on) and pack our bags. When we were moving we def had them in the car while we put stuff from our old house in the car and moved it over. I admire those of you that never have to do this!



this is totally different than leaving your kid in a car for a long period of time to do painting in the house. of course..we've all left kids in the car to unload packages and what not. Gees..especially if you have 2..you would have to do that. But that takes all of what 5 min?? not even. we're talking about leaving a baby in a frigid car to paint a room. thats no 5 min task.

would I call CPS...No. but if she were my friend telling me this,i would be opening a can of whoop a$$ on her.

just stupidity on this person's part.

Posted 12/9/10 10:16 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by Palebride

Posted by doublestroller

Posted by Palebride

My mom used to put us out for naps in her basinet in the backyard in the winter. The cold air is good for babies, and as long as they're wrapped, I don't see a problem.



is she german Chat Icon ? i have heard that in germany people put babies outside all the time for naps, cold weather and all, at least once a day! fresh air is good for everyone, even the little ones...



She is German!!Chat Icon Well, my Grandmother grew up in Germany....maybe she taught that to my mother.



My mom did this to me and my sister too. She is not German Chat Icon Never seemed to hurt us.....

Posted 12/9/10 10:51 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by doublestroller

Posted by Palebride

My mom used to put us out for naps in her basinet in the backyard in the winter. The cold air is good for babies, and as long as they're wrapped, I don't see a problem.

is she german Chat Icon ? i have heard that in germany people put babies outside all the time for naps, cold weather and all, at least once a day! fresh air is good for everyone, even the little ones...



My MIL used to do this with DH. She would put him on the back porch in a snowsuit to sleep. I was like Chat Icon when she told me. My MIL is Irish/Norweigen.

Posted 12/9/10 11:11 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

No I don't believe it's illegal.

While I know plenty of people think it's ok to leave their sleeping baby in the car while they STAY inside the house, I don't think it is.

Posted 12/10/10 4:58 AM
 

BeachMom
Love my 4 kiddos!

Member since 11/08

8346 total posts

Name:
Kristie

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Not that i would ever do it...but i know people who leave their sleeping child in the car in the driveway because the child is sleeping and they dont want to wake them.

Personally I could pick my children up and play catch with them once their asleep and they don't budge, so me moving them from the car, i dont have to worry about them waking upChat Icon

Posted 12/10/10 6:04 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

Posted by Gertyrae

My opinion on this and other posts like it (the child in shorts comes to mind), is that people should mind their own business when it comes to certain things.
You don't know what the details are:
was the car running? was it in the garage? does the child not transition well and she needs to keep him in the car to let him sleep? etc, etc.

If you don't see a child actually being abused or neglected then there is no real reason to get involved. I know a few people who have let their child sleep in the car in the driveway because they can't take the child out of the carseat. I know I have sat in parking lots with the car running cuz DS will wake up as soon as I turn the car off...



I was going to say that last spring (not winter) Ds was being a monster and needed to nap but, wouldn't. I took him for a snooze cruise and picked him up to transfer him and it started all over again. So I put him back in the car and drove for another 30 minutes.. almost in tears myself from the crying. He fell asleep and I drove back to my mom's. I pulled the car all the way up in the driveway, grabbed the monitor and put it in the car and went and sat in the living room where I could see the car until he woke up. Did I love doing it? No. But, I wan't picking him back up again for anything. Call CPS. I don't care. My kid was fine and I checked on him like 20 times.

But, in 20 degree weather.. unless the car war running and the heat was on.... But, then again I don't really like leaving a kid in a running car.. fumes... and you never know if they could get out of the car seat and put the car in gear. Not sure how old this child is. But, you never know with toddlers.

Posted 12/10/10 7:31 AM
 

littlebeanz
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

1667 total posts

Name:

Re: Ummm, isn't this illegal?

why ddint she bring him in...im confused?

Posted 12/10/10 8:26 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]