Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff
Posted 4/20/2010 1:59:30 PM by KateDevine
Posted by MRSBA
Posted by Diana1215
Posted by MRSBA
Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms.
JMO
I'm not trying to scare off new moms. I said that this is what worked for ME! I also said that other people had success when going in to comfort their child. If my children even so much as felt my hand on their back - they got even more worked up.
For me, two nights of crying is worth it to me when I will then have a child that is able to fall asleep on his own. Not only when he is 6 months - but when he is 2 years, 3 years, etc.
I read Ferber. In fact I read every single sleep book out there before trying CIO with my son. I took pieces from every single one of them and made it my own - to fit with my children.
yes, but when you title the post "the truth about CIO" I think it implies to new moms that this is how CIO works...when really it's just your version and not based on actual theories....and IMO that's why some new moms get scared off...cause they think to themselves that they would never let their child cry for an hour and a half so they assume CIO is not for them....just offering up a different "truth" that's all.....not sure that any actual book you read advocated your method.....
I think what Diana means is that CIO was getting bashed in another thread for being all of these things and making it sound like pure torture.
And yes, Ferber is one KIND of CIO. Like Amy (porrruss) said, it isn't the only kind. I did it too, and it didn't work for me until DS was 12 months old (though we did it on and off until from when he was 5 months, on my PEDs recommendation)
I also think that this really, really, really falls into one of these things that newer moms think sounds TERRIBLE because they can't see their little newborn crying, but that is why it isn't recommended til babies are older
|