The Gap Accident

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

The Gap Accident

We've all heard about the 18 year old tourist that fell through the LIRR gap. No doubt it was a horrible tragedy. According to the report, the gap where she fell on Woodside's track 3 was between 7 7/8 inches and 8 1/2 inches -- which complies with state and industry standards requiring a minimum gap of 7 inches. She fell through the gap, crawled under the concrete platform and was struck by a train on the other side. She had a blood alcohol level of .23 percent. The blood-alcohol test was performed 90 minutes after Smead was struck by the train. Her cousin said jokingly as she was getting out of the train, "Watch the Gap!" Her cousin, friends & LIRR employees told her not to move & that they would get her out.


Who do you feel is at fault in this specific case?

If you were assigning blame in this case, what percentage would you give to the girl? What percentage would you assign to the LIRR?

Message edited 2006-11-21 00:21:17.293000.

Posted 11/21/06 12:02 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: The Gap Accident

Honestly, I agree that it was a tragic accident, but all of the evidence points to either the girl's naivite, her blood alcohol lever, or her lack of knowledge of her surroundings.

Where were the friends that claim to be with her? How come none of her friends helped her out?

IMO, the LIRR did nothing wrong. There are "Watch the Gap" signs everywhere, and the platform and train entrance are painted BRIGHT YELLOW. Sometimes people just slip.

I would not give the LIRR any percentage. (I know when there's a car accident, sometimes even innocent parties involved in the accident get a % of guilt just because they were on the road. I don't think that applies here.)

eta: and I can't believe they want so much money. How long has her Dad known that she was DRUNK?!

Message edited 2006-11-21 00:10:32.170000.

Posted 11/21/06 12:09 AM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

I've been pondering these thoughts all day after reading the article in Newsday today. 17 year old drinking Red Bull with vodka. Chat Icon Chat Icon It really changes how I feel about this horrible tragic accident. But I can't help wondering that if the girl was sober, she may have had the where-with-all to sense her predicament and may have made better judgements.

While I do think the LIRR needs to take some action, I hate to say that I, IMO, place a large majority of the blame on her. I am sure I am in the minority here, everyone I talk to tells me that IF she hadn't fallen through the gap whe wouldn't have been killed, but maybe, just maybe, not drinking would have not lead to such rough housing on the train while exiting (as I read on Newsday).

It'll be interesting to read everyone's thoughts.

Posted 11/21/06 12:12 AM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

Chmlengr I believe the same as you. If she had just stayed where she fell she would probably be fine. While I was reading the article I can't believe the family let the cousin speak to Newsday. I think it looks really bad that the cousin said she told her to watch the gap and that they were drinking all day. It seems to place a lot of blame on the victim.

Posted 11/21/06 8:00 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

drunk or not, NO ONE should be able to fall through that gap!

SHAME on the MTA Chat Icon

Posted 11/21/06 8:09 AM
 

baghag
:P

Member since 5/05

10278 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

Probably a dumb question...

Those gaps have been there as long as the LIRR has been around, right? And the LIRR isn't exactly brand new. So why are people falling in between the gap now and never in such huge numbers before? Or was it just never deemed newsworthy? Chat Icon

As for laying blame for that girl falling through the gap, I don't know if I could assign a percentage to each side. I do think it is absurd for the parents to sue. Chat Icon

Posted 11/21/06 8:15 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by baghag

Probably a dumb question...

Those gaps have been there as long as the LIRR has been around, right? And the LIRR isn't exactly brand new. So why are people falling in between the gap now and never in such huge numbers before? Or was it just never deemed newsworthy? Chat Icon


good point! I have been wondering the same thing Chat Icon

Posted 11/21/06 8:16 AM
 

My2Boys
Love.

Member since 10/05

4796 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

I disagree that the MTA bears any blame in this. It's an absolutely horrible tragedy, but if the LIRR is in compliance with state regulations, then, IMO, they cannot be held responsible. This young lady was drunk and no doubt scared out of her mind when she fell. It's heartbreaking, but it's an accident.

I sat on a jury once in a civil suit against the MTA. In that particular case, a bike messenger was exiting the escalator at Chambers Street and his sneaker got caught in the teeth of the escalator.

We were shown evidence that proved that the escalators repair and maintenance log was not kept up to date and there were several "teeth" missing at the top of the escalator stairs which enabled this man's foot to get caught. Also, the escalator didn't automatically stop when it should have, thus "chewing up" this man's foot (he lost about 40% of his foot). Chat Icon We found that the MTA was negligent and awarded him 1.33M. Quite frankly, I wanted to give him more, but many of my fellow jurors felt he wasn't "worth" it since he was an immigrant and *only* a bike messenger. Chat Icon

Posted 11/21/06 8:25 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by baghag

Probably a dumb question...

Those gaps have been there as long as the LIRR has been around, right? And the LIRR isn't exactly brand new. So why are people falling in between the gap now and never in such huge numbers before? Or was it just never deemed newsworthy? Chat Icon


good point! I have been wondering the same thing Chat Icon



are the gaps worse for the new trains? Maybe that has something to do with it?

I think they are both at fault. They shouldnt have such large gaps, but a 17 year old with a BAC of .23 - she was probably stumbling. Its a tragic accident - and the gaps should be fixed.

Posted 11/21/06 8:26 AM
 

pugmama
April already?

Member since 3/06

5297 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: The Gap Accident

Today's Newsday cover is saying that she is at fault. I agree that she is at fault but that the MTA should take some responsibility because even if the gaps have been there for years, if they now there is potential for someone to get hurt, why would they not do something earlier. Yes they put the watch the gap signs but why not be proactive instead of reactive?

Posted 11/21/06 10:54 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

the bottom line is that this happening a lot lately and NO ONE, not even a child should be able to fall through that gap. they need to move the tracks closer to the platform like they have done at a few stations already. how many more people have to die?

Posted 11/21/06 10:57 AM
 

Sweetpea130000
My Love!

Member since 5/05

2375 total posts

Name:
Shandra

Re: The Gap Accident

If she was drunk, I definitely put some blame on her, on the other hand, I think that how we are nowadays (on the cell, rushing, not really paying attention) that could lead to people being less than careful

Posted 11/21/06 10:59 AM
 

Ltdentway99
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1752 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

This is why I hate Newsday. Last week they bashed the LIRR and today they bashed the girl who died. Come on, how many drunk people get on that LIRR every weekend. Also, those watch the gap signs have been around forever. I remember as a child being afraid of the gap. The girl was not from LI, so she obviously was drunk and didn't know about the gaps. The LIRR could counteract and create a new policy saying if you are intoxicated, we are not responsible for your actions. Ride at your own risk... I believe it was a horrible tragedy, like every other accident.

Posted 11/21/06 10:59 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by baghag

Probably a dumb question...

Those gaps have been there as long as the LIRR has been around, right? And the LIRR isn't exactly brand new. So why are people falling in between the gap now and never in such huge numbers before? Or was it just never deemed newsworthy? Chat Icon


good point! I have been wondering the same thing Chat Icon




the new trains don't line up to the platform as the old trains did. They are narrower inside and out.

Posted 11/21/06 11:01 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: The Gap Accident

The gaps still need to be fixed. The gaps are too wide.

Posted 11/21/06 11:02 AM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by Ellebelle1

This is why I hate Newsday. Last week they bashed the LIRR and today they bashed the girl who died. Come on, how many drunk people get on that LIRR every weekend. Also, those watch the gap signs have been around forever. I remember as a child being afraid of the gap. The girl was not from LI, so she obviously was drunk and didn't know about the gaps. The LIRR could counteract and create a new policy saying if you are intoxicated, we are not responsible for your actions. Ride at your own risk... I believe it was a horrible tragedy, like every other accident.



I agree. Plus, the gap wasn't even 8 1/2 inches. That is not even the size of a ruler. I am dumbfounded as to how a 17 year old can FALL THROUGH! And then have the mindset to crawl under the train!! I believe in this case it was definitely a tragedy.

Posted 11/21/06 11:03 AM
 

jerrysgirl
I love my hot dog!!

Member since 6/06

5357 total posts

Name:
E & J

Re: The Gap Accident

the outer tracks are moving. like track 1 and track 8 at jamaica are moving so the gaps are getting bigger i heard. that is what it is like at other stations like that.

Posted 11/21/06 11:25 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: The Gap Accident

It was a horrible accident, and I don't think you can assign a percentage of blame, really. The gap was within the standards for gap width and the girl was told by her friends, bystanders AND MTA employees to stay where she was and wait for help. If she decided to crawl underneath the platform, then I don't see how the MTA was sued.

I also don't understand how a 17 year old could fall in 7-8 inch gap.

Posted 11/21/06 11:30 AM
 

Kate07
Feel better my little guy!

Member since 5/05

4476 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by nrthshgrl
Her cousin said jokingly as she was getting out of the train, "Watch the Gap!"



I was talking about this and someone was saying since the cousin said this - like they were making a mockery of it - and so they didn't feel as bad.

I think it is awful. I think it was an accident and no one is to blame - LIRR OR the deceased.

Posted 11/21/06 11:30 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: The Gap Accident

how do you fall all the way thru a 8 inch gap? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/21/06 12:05 PM
 

anonttcer
BOOOO for fall!

Member since 7/06

10082 total posts

Name:
Meaning a NON ttcer!

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by architectnycity

Chmlengr I believe the same as you. If she had just stayed where she fell she would probably be fine. While I was reading the article I can't believe the family let the cousin speak to Newsday. I think it looks really bad that the cousin said she told her to watch the gap and that they were drinking all day. It seems to place a lot of blame on the victim.



I agree- If she had stayed where she was and waited for help, she probably would have lived. The train wasn't going anywhere at that point.
I oftened wondered what possessed her to crawl UNDER the train and cross the tracks. Now that I hear she was drunk, I guess I can see why. Her judgment was definitely impaired.

Posted 11/21/06 12:10 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by Beth1210

how do you fall all the way thru a 8 inch gap? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

exactly! you would have to be deathly thin or a very small child. that's why I think it's BS and has to be a bigger gap than that.

Posted 11/21/06 12:11 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Beth1210

how do you fall all the way thru a 8 inch gap? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

exactly! you would have to be deathly thin or a very small child. that's why I think it's BS and has to be a bigger gap than that.



I thought at first they said the gap was 18 inches or something like that

I just don't buy it

Posted 11/21/06 12:12 PM
 

jennifaaaa
Live..Love..Laugh!

Member since 5/05

1207 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by baghag

Probably a dumb question...

Those gaps have been there as long as the LIRR has been around, right? And the LIRR isn't exactly brand new. So why are people falling in between the gap now and never in such huge numbers before? Or was it just never deemed newsworthy? Chat Icon


good point! I have been wondering the same thing Chat Icon



I agreeChat Icon

Posted 11/21/06 12:14 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap Accident

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Beth1210

how do you fall all the way thru a 8 inch gap? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

exactly! you would have to be deathly thin or a very small child. that's why I think it's BS and has to be a bigger gap than that.



I thought the gap was more like 11 inches?

I think being drunk and repeatedly being warned by EVERYONE takes liability off of the LIRR but they should fix the gap. It's ridiulous that there are portions wide enough for people to fall clear through.

I wonder if the parents are going to sue whoever overserved their underage daughter as well?

Posted 11/21/06 12:14 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Baby Gap Coupon Smileyd17 3/16/06 3 Parenting
Baby gap coupon Smileyd17 3/16/06 5 Pregnancy
Huge accident on the LIE! dandr10199 3/15/06 11 Families Helping Families ™
Gap Maternity? Ali1 3/6/06 10 Pregnancy
Another train accident tourist 2/17/06 10 Families Helping Families ™
LIRR Fire/Accident Wendy 2/15/06 19 Families Helping Families ™