|
Re: The Gap Accident
Posted 11/21/2006 8:25:47 AM by My2Boys I disagree that the MTA bears any blame in this. It's an absolutely horrible tragedy, but if the LIRR is in compliance with state regulations, then, IMO, they cannot be held responsible. This young lady was drunk and no doubt scared out of her mind when she fell. It's heartbreaking, but it's an accident. I sat on a jury once in a civil suit against the MTA. In that particular case, a bike messenger was exiting the escalator at Chambers Street and his sneaker got caught in the teeth of the escalator. We were shown evidence that proved that the escalators repair and maintenance log was not kept up to date and there were several "teeth" missing at the top of the escalator stairs which enabled this man's foot to get caught. Also, the escalator didn't automatically stop when it should have, thus "chewing up" this man's foot (he lost about 40% of his foot). We found that the MTA was negligent and awarded him 1.33M. Quite frankly, I wanted to give him more, but many of my fellow jurors felt he wasn't "worth" it since he was an immigrant and *only* a bike messenger. |