The age old Salary question

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

afternoondelight828
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

3363 total posts

Name:
Afternoon

The age old Salary question

My girlfriend has been working at her job for 20 years. She only went to a community college for 2 years, getting a secretary certificate. She started at her job at $8/hour and her job has changed over the years to the point that she could not walk in today with what she went to school with. It is basically all experience from what she has learned there. She is currently making almost $50,000 and gets annoyed when she hears what others make working much less years than herself (but in different positions so I think it is hard for her to try and compare herself to them). She works on LI so I tell her that LI pays less so that is why she is not making what others might be making in the city.
Is this normal for someone working that long at the same company. I don't know what to tell her but try and just tell her not to compare salaries as everyone's jobs are different.

Posted 1/14/14 4:12 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

The age old Salary question

It's not uncommon... Say she was making $8/hr for 40hrs/week, that's $16,640, so her salary has increased $35K over the last 20 years (which is A LOT). While she might not like it, most people without a 4 year degree are never going to make what she's making, if she were to go to another company, her years of experience are not going to make that much of a difference because most jobs have a minimum requirement of a 4 year degree. Unfortunately, it's what it is now... and honestly, there are PLENTY of people with 4 year degrees working for 5-10 years who are still making much less than $50K, it's just what the job market is these days.

you'd be surprised, most secretarial positions these days (also referred to as administrative assistants) have a MINIMUM educational requirement of a Bachelors. SOME companies will substitute experience for degree. So long as she can keep it secret, I don't see any harm in her looking elsewhere, I just would not expect much more, even in the city.

Posted 1/14/14 4:17 PM
 

afternoondelight828
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

3363 total posts

Name:
Afternoon

Re: The age old Salary question

Thanks Chat Icon

Posted 1/14/14 4:18 PM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

The age old Salary question

Welcome! I know the info kinda sucks, but it is what it is... if she wants to increase her pay range, she REALLY needs to get her bachelors... which I'm sure she could do in 2 years, since she already has college credits, AND a lot of schools (especially SUNY) will work with you to substitute work experience and real life experience for course credits.

Posted 1/14/14 4:22 PM
 

babyfever24
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

3340 total posts

Name:

Re: The age old Salary question

ITA that's a good salary for someone with no college. Although idk her daily responsibilities I feel like she shouldn't complain and appreciate what she's got!

Posted 1/14/14 4:25 PM
 

afternoondelight828
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

3363 total posts

Name:
Afternoon

Re: The age old Salary question

Yeah I have told her that she might have to go back to school if she really wants to make more. Maybe even try a different career. Don't know. It is not easy out there and I personally think she is lucky she has a job.

Posted 1/14/14 4:25 PM
 

afternoondelight828
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

3363 total posts

Name:
Afternoon

Re: The age old Salary question

Posted by babyfever24

ITA that's a good salary for someone with no college. Although idk her daily responsibilities I feel like she shouldn't complain and appreciate what she's got!



I agree. No job is perfect and even if someone IS making a lot more than she is, you really don't know what they go through to make it and how long of a commute they have, or stress, etc.

Posted 1/14/14 4:27 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: The age old Salary question

It sounds about right for her position/years, and actually, on the high end at that.

You can't compare people in different positions, it's not relative at all. Apples to oranges, no matter how long they've been there.

Even in the same position - education, experience, skills sets and your negotiating skills upon accepting a job position all play into someone's salary.

Message edited 2014-01-14 16:29:01.857000.

Posted 1/14/14 4:27 PM
 

afternoondelight828
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

3363 total posts

Name:
Afternoon

Re: The age old Salary question

Posted by 2BadSoSad

It sounds about right for her position/years, and on the high end at that.

You cant compare to people in different positions, its not relative at all. Apples to oranges, no matter how long they've been there.

Even in the same position - education, experience, skills sets and your negotiating skills upon accepting a job position all play into someones salary.



Very true. The problem is the younger crowd is making just a little bit less than her but they walk in with 4 year degrees so she has had to work her way up when they start off like that. She will always be ahead in her department but because she started off as a different position, it has pushed her back salary-wise.

Posted 1/14/14 4:29 PM
 

Eunyboo
<3

Member since 7/12

4376 total posts

Name:
E

Re: The age old Salary question

I actually work with someone with the exact similar situation. She's been here for 20 years and makes about that... She hit the raise cap for her pay grade and has been extremely frustrated, but she makes more than some managers here so the company is not really willing to budge, especially with the fact that she has some overtime which ends her up at much more than most managers here. Unfortunately, doing what she's doing, she will def not find another job without a degree (Accounting). It is what it is I guess.. Chat Icon

Posted 1/14/14 4:56 PM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: The age old Salary question

She can be making so much more being an admin assistant or an executive assistant in the city. I find that most people that stay with a company for a long time just hit a wall and never make what they should/ could be. Working on LI is another way to be underpaid. A 25 yo will be expected to have a degree. A 50 yo with good experience, maybe not so much.

Posted 1/14/14 5:01 PM
 

Jenhos
Maeve

Member since 6/05

3273 total posts

Name:

Re: The age old Salary question

She would make more in the city. And if she has worked at the same company for 20 years she is more than likely underpaid. Companies pay you to come in they don't pay you to stay. You will get cost of living increases and maybe small bumps along the way but unles you are getting promoted and getting a 10-15% bump in one shot you start to fall behind.

I think he could make more money at another company and in the city.

Posted 1/14/14 5:07 PM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: The age old Salary question

Wow. I have no college degree (3 years and a certificate in my specialty) and 13 years experience in my field and make about $60k.

I sort of disagree that $50k is good for her experience. My office manager has no degree but has worked for my boss for 31 years and makes a six figure salary.

I think that it does depend on the job, and I think her employer is cheap.

ETA: I work in the city

Message edited 2014-01-14 17:16:57.930000.

Posted 1/14/14 5:16 PM
 

babyface10
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/11

804 total posts

Name:

The age old Salary question

I believe she would make more in the city too. But she would have to decide wether it would be worth the long comute and the long days and the cost of travel. Even if she made another $10K would she want to pay possibly $5K a month in travel expenses.

Posted 1/14/14 5:20 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: The age old Salary question

Honestly, there are people with Master's degrees who don't make that much so she should shut her mouth IMHO.

Posted 1/14/14 6:30 PM
 

olive98
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/12

791 total posts

Name:

The age old Salary question

What industry is she in and what is her title? I don't think you can judge her salary without knowing these things. I have friends in sales with no degrees making 6 figures and a social worker friend makes under $40 with a masters.

Message edited 2014-01-14 18:42:19.947000.

Posted 1/14/14 6:41 PM
 

afternoondelight828
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

3363 total posts

Name:
Afternoon

Re: The age old Salary question

Thanks everyone.

Yes, there a a lot of pros to her job. Being close to home and her children's daycare and schools, having a ton of vacation time, benefits from work, etc. I think that is why she has stayed as long as she has.

Posted 1/14/14 6:43 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: The age old Salary question

Posted by olive98

What industry is she in and what is her title? I don't think you can judge her salary without knowing these things. I have friends in sales with no degrees making 6 figures and a social worker friend makes under $40 with a masters.



I agree with this too, especially for the social workers making on the lower end of the spectrum (although that is not always the case depending on type of position, level of experience, hours/duties worked, etc.).

I also think this is another reason that one needs to be very careful who they discuss salary with.

Some people are extremely sensitive to numbers and don't always see all the different variables that go into it.

I've even seen the pissing match between colleagues in my own field, or the best the "Master's social workers vs. nurses who only have a BA debate (do a google search, there's multiple blogs about this).

Sometimes there's no rhyme nor reason to who gets paid what anymore. It really is that simple and you shouldn't compare yourself.


There's very few people who know what my actual salary is. Sometimes DH doesn't even know.

Chat Icon

ETA: I also think benefits packages too need to be accounted for.

Message edited 2014-01-14 19:11:22.153000.

Posted 1/14/14 7:07 PM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

The age old Salary question

well im with morningcuppacoffee, bc i am a social worker too with a masters degree and i dont make much more than her with her no degree.
and i have 13 years of experience.
so....yeah.

Posted 1/14/14 7:33 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: The age old Salary question

Posted by luvmotherhood

well im with morningcuppacoffee, bc i am a social worker too with a masters degree and i dont make much more than her with her no degree.
and i have 13 years of experience.
so....yeah.



Ha, while I do get the differences in industries, I'd probably be seething inside if this was my friend "complaining" to me about her situation.

I used to work with someone like this who only had a HS degree and I wanted to ask her if she wanted to take over my student loan payments, and my work (which I know she could never do!) since according to her she was the only one qualified to do anything.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/15/14 5:25 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: The age old Salary question

I can see where somewhere without a college degree feels that even though they can DO the same things someone with a degree can they won't make the same money, it is true and I can see how it is annoying.

As far as her salary, as others said it depends on industry but based on what she started making she is making a good salary.

Posted 1/15/14 6:32 AM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: The age old Salary question

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by luvmotherhood

well im with morningcuppacoffee, bc i am a social worker too with a masters degree and i dont make much more than her with her no degree.
and i have 13 years of experience.
so....yeah.



Ha, while I do get the differences in industries, I'd probably be seething inside if this was my friend "complaining" to me about her situation.

I used to work with someone like this who only had a HS degree and I wanted to ask her if she wanted to take over my student loan payments, and my work (which I know she could never do!) since according to her she was the only one qualified to do anything.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Social workers are some of the most underpaid and under appreciated people (IMHO). I'd go crazy if I had to listen to that all the time.

Posted 1/15/14 7:26 AM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

The age old Salary question

Ugh. It is the worst.
Honestly if I could do it all over again I would have chosen a different field.
The fact that I have to pay astronomical student loans for the next 27 years on this salary makes me want to vomit.

Posted 1/15/14 8:56 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: The age old Salary question

Posted by Straightarrow

Wow. I have no college degree (3 years and a certificate in my specialty) and 13 years experience in my field and make about $60k.

I sort of disagree that $50k is good for her experience. My office manager has no degree but has worked for my boss for 31 years and makes a six figure salary.

I think that it does depend on the job, and I think her employer is cheap.

ETA: I work in the city



I agree.

I don't have a degree, I work on Long Island and I make WELL over her salary AND I work in nonprofit. When I worked in the private sector I made even more than I'm making now.

I agree with the poster who said she's most likely being underpaid. It's totally true, companies pay you to come in and don't pay you to stay.

Every time I've moved onto a new job it was for a pay increase, better benefits, etc.

If your friend wants to make more money she needs to move on but I'm willing to bet based on the fact that she's been with this company for 20 years that she's become comfortable and not really looking to start over.

Posted 1/15/14 9:04 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: The age old Salary question

Posted by afternoondelight828

Thanks everyone.

Yes, there a a lot of pros to her job. Being close to home and her children's daycare and schools, having a ton of vacation time, benefits from work, etc. I think that is why she has stayed as long as she has.



Those are nice perks and definitely add value to her current position. If she were to go to the City, she'd most likely have 2 weeks vacation.

Posted 1/15/14 9:09 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
The age old stockings w/open toes question nbc188 10/29/07 5 Fashion & Beauty!
It's Time for that age old question Blu-ize 10/16/07 43 Families Helping Families ™
Help me answer that age old question KPtoys 9/19/06 4 Pregnancy
The Age Old Question::: Jesaroo 7/2/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
age appropriate toy question (safety question) mommyIam 6/8/11 9 Parenting
Question about age.. (prob stupid question) jgl 6/25/10 9 Parenting