Terrorists released from GITMO

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Terrorists released from GITMO

Forgive me if this subject was posted about already -- but what are your thoughts on the negotiation to have the soldier released?

(CNN) -- President Barack Obama, flanked by the parents of Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl at the White House on Saturday, praised the diplomatic officials and troops who helped secure the release of the American soldier held captive for nearly five years by militants during the Afghanistan war.

Bergdahl was released in exchange for five Guantanamo detainees, officials said.

The government of Qatar, which helped broker the release, pledged to "put in place measures to protect our national security," Obama said at the White House Rose Garden.

"While Bowe was gone, he was never forgotten," the President said.

Bergdahl's mother, Jani, said, "We will continue to stay strong for Bowe while he recovers."

Bob Bergdahl said he was not sure whether his son still speaks English and spoke at one point in what appeared to be Pashtun.

"I'm your father, Bowe," the father said.

Members of the White House national security team -- including Chief of Staff Denis McDonough, National Security Adviser Susan Rice and counterterrorism adviser Lisa Monaco -- grew emotional when the parents thanked those who helped secure their son's release.

Bergdahl, the only remaining U.S. soldier captured during the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan, was recovered by U.S. special operations forces without incident about 10:30 a.m. ET at a "pick-up" point in eastern Afghanistan, near the border with Pakistan, a senior Department of Defense official told CNN. There were 18 armed Taliban members present.

Once he was on an American helicopter, Bergdahl, 28, used a paper plate to communicate because of the noise. He wrote, "SF?" meaning, "special forces?"

One of the operators sitting with Bergdahl responded loudly: "Yes, we've been looking for you for a long time," according to the official.

Bergdahl broke down crying.

'Cannot wait to wrap our arms around our only son'

Earlier, the White House said in a statement, "Today the American people are pleased that we will be able to welcome home Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl."

Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel said that he had informed Congress of the decision to transfer five detainees from Guantanamo Bay to Qatar in exchange for Bergdahl, who was the only remaining American soldier captured from conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan.

After Bergdahl was handed over, a series of secret procedures were set in motion so each side knew the other was living up to the bargain, according to U.S. Defense officials. Qatari officials were already at Guantanamo and took custody of the detainees. They assured the Taliban that the detainees would be flown to Qatar.

The Afghan Taliban issued a statement on its website in Arabic and Pashto announcing with "great happiness and joy" the exchange of Bergdahl for five of its imprisoned senior leaders.

It said, "The Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan was and has been for a long time attempting to free all the imprisoned Afghan prisoners inside and outside the country."

This undated image provided by the U.S. Army shows Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, who has been held by insurgents in Afghanistan since 2009. The White House announced Bergdahl's release on Saturday, May 31.

An Iranian court threw out a 2011 death sentence for Amir Hekmati, a former U.S. Marine charged with spying. But he was secretly retried in Iran and convicted of "practical collaboration with the U.S. government," his sister told CNN on Friday, April 11. He has been sentenced to 10 years in prison, she said. Hekmati was detained in August 2011 during a visit to see his grandmother. His family and the Obama administration deny accusations he was spying for the CIA.


A North Korean court sentenced Kenneth Bae, a U.S. citizen, to 15 years of hard labor for committing "hostile acts" against the state. Those alleged acts were not detailed by the country's state-run news agency when it announced the sentence in May. Bae, here in a photo from a Facebook page titled Remember Ken Bae, was arrested in November 2012. "This was somebody who was a tour operator, who has been there in the past and has a visa to go to the North," a senior U.S. official told CNN.


Retired FBI agent Robert Levinson has been missing since 2007. His family says he was working as a private investigator in Iran when he disappeared, and multiple reports suggest Levinson may have been working for the CIA. His family told CNN in January that they have long known that Levinson worked for the CIA, and they said it's time for the government to lay out the facts about Levinson's case. U.S. officials have consistently denied publicly that Levinson was working for the government, but they have repeatedly insisted that finding him and bringing him home is a "top" priority.


Warren Weinstein, a contractor held by al Qaeda militants, is a U.S. citizen who has been held hostage in Pakistan since August 2011.


U.S. tourist and Korean War veteran Merrill Newman arrives at the Beijing airport Saturday, December 7, after being released by North Korea. Newman was detained October 26 by North Korean authorities just minutes before he was to depart the country after visiting through an organized tour. His son Jeff Newman says the Palo Alto, California, man had all the proper paperwork and set up his trip through a North Korean-approved travel agency.


Mexican authorities arrested Yanira Maldonado, a U.S. citizen, right, on May 22, for alleged drug possession. She and her husband, Gary, were traveling from Mexico back to the United States when their bus was stopped and searched. She was released on Friday, May 31, and is back in the United States.


Saeed Abedini, a 33-year-old U.S. citizen of Iranian birth, was sentenced to eight years in prison in January 2013, accused of attempting to undermine the Iranian government and endangering national security by establishing home churches.


North Korea has arrested Americans before, only to release them after a visit by a prominent dignitary. Journalists Laura Ling, center, and Euna Lee, to her right, spent 140 days in captivity after being charged with illegal entry to conduct a smear campaign. They were freed in 2009 after a trip by former President Bill Clinton.


Former President Jimmy Carter negotiated the release of Aijalon Gomes, who was detained in 2010 after crossing into North Korea illegally from China. Analysts say high-level visits give Pyongyang a propaganda boost and a way to save face when it releases a prisoner.


Eddie Yong Su Jun was released by North Korea a month after he was detained in April 2011. His alleged crime was not provided to the media. The American delegation that secured his freedom included Robert King, the U.S. special envoy for North Korean human rights issues.


Robert Park was released by North Korea in 2010 without any apparent U.S. intervention. The Christian missionary crossed into North Korea from China, carrying a letter asking Kim Jong Il to free political prisoners and resign. North Korea's state-run news agency said Park was released after an "admission and sincere repentance of his wrongdoings." Here, Park holds a photo of Kim and a malnourished child during a protest in Seoul.


Josh Fattal, center, Sarah Shourd, left, and Shane Bauer were detained by Iran while hiking near the Iraq-Iran border in July 2009. Iran charged them with illegal entry and espionage. Shourd was released on bail for medical reasons in September 2010; she never returned to face her charges. Bauer and Fattal were convicted in August 2011, but the next month they were released on bail and had their sentences commuted.


Haleh Esfandiari, an Iranian-American scholar, was also detained at Evin Prison, spending months in solitary confinement before Iran released her on bail in August 2007. Esfandiari was visiting her ailing mother in Tehran when she was arrested and charged with harming Iran's national security.


Alan Gross, at right with Rabbi Arthur Schneier, has been in Cuban custody since December 2009, when he was jailed while working as a subcontractor. Cuban authorities say Gross tried to set up illegal Internet connections on the island. Gross says he was just trying to help connect the Jewish community to the Internet. Former President Jimmy Carter and New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson have both traveled to Cuba on Gross' behalf, but they were unable to secure his release.


Sixteen Americans were among the dozens arrested in December 2011 when Egypt raided the offices of 10 nongovernmental organizations that it said received illegal foreign financing and were operating without a public license. Many of the employees posted bail and left the country after a travel ban was lifted a few months later. Robert Becker, right, chose to stay and stand trial.


Freelance reporter James Foley went missing in November 2012 after his car was stopped by gunmen in Syria. He is likely being held by the Syrian government, according to the GlobalPost, an online international news outlet to which he contributed, and Foley's brother.


Filmmaker Timothy Tracy was arrested in Venezuela in April on allegations of funding opponents of newly elected President Nicolas Maduro, successor to the late Hugo Chavez. Tracy went to Venezuela to make a documentary about the political division gripping the country. He was released in June.

U.S. Army Sergeant released by Taliban

"Sgt. Bergdahl is now under the care of the U.S. military after being handed over by his captors in Afghanistan," Hagel said. "We will give him all the support he needs to help him recover from this ordeal, and we are grateful that he will soon be reunited with his family."

Bergdahl's parents happened to still be in Washington, having visited for Memorial Day.

They said in an earlier statement: "We were so joyful and relieved when President (Barack) Obama called us today to give us the news that Bowe is finally coming home! We cannot wait to wrap our arms around our only son. We want to thank Bowe's many supporters in Idaho, around the nation and around the world. We thank the Amir of Qatar for his efforts. And of course, we want to take this opportunity to thank all those in the many U.S. Government agencies who never gave up. Today, we are ecstatic!"

Secretary of State John Kerry said the "cost of years of captivity to Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl and his family is immeasurable."

'Appropriate assurances' over five detainees

In exchange for Bergdahl's release, five detainees at Guantanamo Bay will be released to Qatar, authorities said. The United States has "appropriate assurances" that Qatar will be able to secure the detainees there, where they are under a travel ban for a year.

A U.S. Air Force aircraft carrying the detainees left the U.S. Navy base in Cuba on Saturday afternoon, a senior Defense official told CNN.

Bergdahl was first transferred to Bagram Airfield, the main U.S. base in Afghanistan, for medical evaluation.

"His health is our number one priority at this time," a senior U.S. defense official said.

Saturday night, Bergdahl was en route from Bagram to Landstuhl Regional Medical Center in Germany, a senior defense official told reporters traveling with Hagel.

His "reintegration process" will include "time for him to tell his story, decompress, and to reconnect with his family through telephone calls and video conferences. At this time we believe that he will physically reunite with his family in Texas," the official said.

Hagel said the United States "coordinated closely with Qatar to ensure that security measures are in place and the national security of the United States will not be compromised."

The United States believes Bergdahl had been held for the bulk of his captivity in Pakistan, the official said. It was unclear when he was moved to Afghanistan.

The U.S. government acknowledged in May 2012 that it was engaged in talks with the Taliban to free Bergdahl.

Saturday's transfer was brokered through the local Qatari government, the official said, after talks that began about a week ago.

U.S. officials had said this year that one route to getting Bergdahl back was through Qatari officials, who had been talking to the Taliban. But Bergdahl was believed to be held by operatives from the Haqqani network, an insurgent force affiliated with the Taliban and al Qaeda, and it was not clear whether Haqqani operatives would abide by any agreement among the United States, Qatar and the Taliban.

An Afghan Taliban commander, not authorized to speak to the media, confirmed to CNN that Bergdahl was captured by the Afghan Taliban with links to the Haqqani network in Pakistan. Over the years, the captive was transferred back and forth between Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Bergdahl was deployed to Afghanistan in May 2009. He was 23 when he was captured by the Taliban after finishing a guard shift at a combat outpost on June 30, 2009, in Paktika province.

Fast Facts: Bowe Bergdahl

In July of that year, a U.S. military official said the soldier was being held by the clan of warlord Siraj Haqqani.

Critics question the negotiations

The United States has long declared that it won't negotiate with groups linked to terrorists, but analysts have said the United States has effectively maneuvered around the edges of that declaration over the years.

"As the administration has repeatedly affirmed, we will not transfer any detainee from Guantanamo unless the threat the detainee may pose to the United States can be sufficiently mitigated and only when consistent with our humane treatment policy," a senior administration official told CNN, adding that the detainees will be "subject to restrictions on their movement and activities."

Arizona Sen. John McCain, a former POW, in a statement called the released detainees "hardened terrorists who have the blood of Americans and countless Afghans on their hands."

"I am eager to learn what precise steps are being taken to ensure that these vicious and violent Taliban extremists never return to the fight against the United States and our partners or engage in any activities that can threaten the prospects for peace and security in Afghanistan," he said. "The American people, and our Afghan partners, deserve nothing less."

A senior administration official told CNN, "With regard to whether or not we're negotiating with terrorists: Sergeant Bergdahl is a member of the military who was detained during the course of an armed conflict. The transfer of these individuals is not a concession -- it is fully in line with the President's goal of closing the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay."

The Taliban had long demanded the release of five detainees at the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. But U.S. officials said that releasing them would be difficult because Congress would have to be notified in advance, and lawmakers have previously resisted releasing them.

NATO leaders signed off last week on Obama's exit strategy from Afghanistan that calls for an end to combat operations next year and the withdrawal of the U.S.-led international military force by the end of 2014.

Bergdahl, of Wood River Valley, Idaho, appeared in diminished health in a video that the U.S. military obtained in January. His family also received a letter from him last year via the Red Cross.


Message edited 2014-06-02 15:11:42.857000.

Posted 6/2/14 10:35 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Hostages released from GITMO

I have to read more, but it just feels a little too Homeland for me.

Posted 6/2/14 10:42 AM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Hostages released from GITMO

I didn't read what you posted but I have been following the story. I think it puts our soldiers in danger bc it sends the message you capture one American soldier and you can negotiate to free 5 Taliban.

These men are the highest of the highest power in Taliban and it's very scary they are now free to get us again.

I also think the circumstances in which he was taken hostage or mysterious. Days before he emailed his father how he was ashamed to be an American and America is disgusting. He wanted to help the afghan people.

I'm also sure a lot of information wasn't released

Posted 6/2/14 10:45 AM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

I didn't read what you posted but I have been following the story. I think it puts our soldiers in danger bc it sends the message you capture one American soldier and you can negotiate to free 5 Taliban.

These men are the highest of the highest power in Taliban and it's very scary they are now free to get us again.

I also think the circumstances in which he was taken hostage or mysterious. Days before he emailed his father how he was ashamed to be an American and America is disgusting. He wanted to help the afghan people.

I'm also sure a lot of information wasn't released



Completely agree with everything you said! I don't understand at what point "We do NOT negotiate with terrorists." was changed to "we'll negotiate and free FIVE terrorists for ONE soldier". I know a number of people that have served in our country's armed forces and I don't know one that would agree with what happened.

Posted 6/2/14 10:51 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

So they get a five to one advantage?
And um, since when did we start negotiating with terrorists?

Posted 6/2/14 10:53 AM
 

lilqtny
-Crossfit & pitbull addict

Member since 7/06

2830 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Hostages released from GITMO

It may only be ONE soldier to you, but to his family it's their ONE and only child. It's the ONE that's important to them. He is OnE of our own and I'm glad he is free.

Posted 6/2/14 11:04 AM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by lilqtny

It may only be ONE soldier to you, but to his family it's their ONE and only child. It's the ONE that's important to them. He is OnE of our own and I'm glad he is free.



I understand that as a family member of the soldier, but this is a VERY DANGEROUS precedent to set. How can we, as a nation, now move forward and tell others "We do not negotiate with terrorist.", because now, we have proven that we do.

Posted 6/2/14 11:08 AM
 

mrsboss
my little love

Member since 12/09

5054 total posts

Name:
Me

Hostages released from GITMO

There's so much wrong on so many levels. It appears he abandoned post, siding with the afghani's in the months leading up to his capture. He was anti-American.. Selfish. deserting post cost other soldiers their lives. He should be tried in military court. And let's not forget about the tweet that's since been deleted by bergdahl's father, his abilities to speak Arabic, praising Allah.. And he suddenly forgot how to speak English? This whole thing is fishy. Don't even get me started on releasing the 5 from Gitmo. That's a whole other story. They'll do the Benghazi Shuffle, and the truth will come out in time. Remember the Pat Tillman fiasco?

Posted 6/2/14 11:11 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by mrsboss
And let's not forget about the tweet that's since been deleted by bergdahl's father, his abilities to speak Arabic, praising Allah.. And he suddenly forgot how to speak English? This whole thing is fishy.



This had meChat Icon
I remember seeing the father during his news conference with the president saying he had something to tell his son. And spoke in Arabic because he was having trouble understanding English.
How??

CNN Link

ETS: After reading some things about how he felt about America, I agree with this being fishy.

Message edited 2014-06-02 11:18:42.493000.

Posted 6/2/14 11:17 AM
 

mrsboss
my little love

Member since 12/09

5054 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by mrsboss
And let's not forget about the tweet that's since been deleted by bergdahl's father, his abilities to speak Arabic, praising Allah.. And he suddenly forgot how to speak English? This whole thing is fishy.



This had meChat Icon
I remember seeing the father during his news conference with the president saying he had something to tell his son. And spoke in Arabic because he was having trouble understanding English.
How??

CNN Link



The truth will be revealed in time. He is a traitor.

Posted 6/2/14 11:18 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Hostages released from GITMO

I work for the federal govt and I have learned to never judge certain decisions from being on the outside. Things you think you know - you don't. I am fully confident that the people that made this decision and negotiations know a hell of a lot more about this soldier and the situation than any of us.

Posted 6/2/14 11:19 AM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by lilqtny

It may only be ONE soldier to you, but to his family it's their ONE and only child. It's the ONE that's important to them. He is OnE of our own and I'm glad he is free.



Exactly. I'm torn as an American I feel like yikes we released five demons who hate us for one soldier BUT as the sister of a soldier, I know my little brothers life to me is worth more. I'm happy for his family.

ETA: Just realized there is more to the story...if this is true it's crazy then I definitely change my mind. One thing to release a soldier who was captured vs. one who voluntarily left.

CNN

Message edited 2014-06-02 11:29:36.590000.

Posted 6/2/14 11:19 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by mrsboss
And let's not forget about the tweet that's since been deleted by bergdahl's father, his abilities to speak Arabic, praising Allah.. And he suddenly forgot how to speak English? This whole thing is fishy.



This had meChat Icon
I remember seeing the father during his news conference with the president saying he had something to tell his son. And spoke in Arabic because he was having trouble understanding English.
How??


He was held captive for 5 years where no one spoke english and everyone spoke in Arabic - thats how.

Posted 6/2/14 11:23 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by Aries14

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by mrsboss
And let's not forget about the tweet that's since been deleted by bergdahl's father, his abilities to speak Arabic, praising Allah.. And he suddenly forgot how to speak English? This whole thing is fishy.



This had meChat Icon
I remember seeing the father during his news conference with the president saying he had something to tell his son. And spoke in Arabic because he was having trouble understanding English.
How??




He was held captive for 5 years where no one spoke english and everyone spoke in Arabic - thats how.




I get that. Thanks.
Still doesn't make sense to me.


And I just want to clear up, I am happy for his family.

Message edited 2014-06-02 11:28:27.843000.

Posted 6/2/14 11:25 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

double post

Message edited 2014-06-02 11:26:16.370000.

Posted 6/2/14 11:25 AM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by Aries14

I work for the federal govt and I have learned to never judge certain decisions from being on the outside. Things you think you know - you don't. I am fully confident that the people that made this decision and negotiations know a hell of a lot more about this soldier and the situation than any of us.



That's very true - and there's no way that the US would have done something like this without it being in agreement with the UN and other major world powers. That said, I still worry about the precedent that has been set.

Posted 6/2/14 11:27 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by Aries14

I work for the federal govt and I have learned to never judge certain decisions from being on the outside. Things you think you know - you don't. I am fully confident that the people that made this decision and negotiations know a hell of a lot more about this soldier and the situation than any of us.



Very true.

But people will react to the information given to them. Not saying we should be privy to all the details.

Posted 6/2/14 11:32 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by mrsboss

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by mrsboss
And let's not forget about the tweet that's since been deleted by bergdahl's father, his abilities to speak Arabic, praising Allah.. And he suddenly forgot how to speak English? This whole thing is fishy.



This had meChat Icon
I remember seeing the father during his news conference with the president saying he had something to tell his son. And spoke in Arabic because he was having trouble understanding English.
How??

CNN Link



The truth will be revealed in time. He is a traitor.



That's quite an inflammatory statement. This guy has been held for 5 years in a country where very few people speak english. God only knows the kind of torture, physical and psychological he was put through. Our country abandoned a US soldier for 5 years. I'm glad he is coming home.
Gitmo need to be closed. People have been held there for years without any charges leveled against them. It's sick.

Posted 6/2/14 11:42 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by Aries14

I work for the federal govt and I have learned to never judge certain decisions from being on the outside. Things you think you know - you don't. I am fully confident that the people that made this decision and negotiations know a hell of a lot more about this soldier and the situation than any of us.



Very true.

But people will react to the information given to them. Not saying we should be privy to all the details.



Yeah, I understand that. And that is human nature. I have just personally seen so many times that either the media gets things wrong or even just the wording they use - totally misinterpurts the story/facts.

for a small scale example: I worked on a case that the guy recently got sentenced for a crime he plead guilty to. The news half ass reported the story. Only really told the crime he was charged with and what he was sentenced too - and people freaked all over news facebook page and had so much to say about the judge and our justice system... etc. No one had the real facts!! They read a 3 paragraph article and decided that they knew the case enough to judge. The writers know what they are doing... They only report the stuff that will make people be "outraged"

Posted 6/2/14 11:43 AM
 

kimmaymb20
a year of surprise

Member since 7/09

1119 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Hostages released from GITMO

Sorry I don't like this for one second. There are many stories from soldiers in his brigade that said he was speaking against America and walked off the base. This doesn't agree well with me AT ALL And we release 5 Gitmo prisoners for one American? Then the father deletes a tweet about releasing more prisoners? We have an American solider right now sitting in Mexico for accidently crossing the border and we are doing nothing about that? Or the Sydanian woman sitting in prison for marrying an American? The priorites in the country are so out of wack.

Posted 6/2/14 11:45 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

I am truly happy for the release of any US solider who was being held, however, this is a VERY slippery slope.

Posted 6/2/14 12:46 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by Aries14

I work for the federal govt and I have learned to never judge certain decisions from being on the outside. Things you think you know - you don't. I am fully confident that the people that made this decision and negotiations know a hell of a lot more about this soldier and the situation than any of us.



Thank you

this isn't some episode of RHONJ for people to dissect - its real life and there is a hell of a lot of information that the gov has and does NOT release to the general public.
It's so easy to pass judgment from the outside, but we don't and probably never will know the full story about any of it.
I have no idea if this guy is a traitor or not but can only say i'm glad he is being returned to his family.
I'm sure the last 5 years have been hell for all of them

Posted 6/2/14 1:19 PM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by Otherme

Posted by Aries14

I work for the federal govt and I have learned to never judge certain decisions from being on the outside. Things you think you know - you don't. I am fully confident that the people that made this decision and negotiations know a hell of a lot more about this soldier and the situation than any of us.



Thank you

this isn't some episode of RHONJ for people to dissect - its real life and there is a hell of a lot of information that the gov has and does NOT release to the general public.
It's so easy to pass judgment from the outside, but we don't and probably never will know the full story about any of it.
I have no idea if this guy is a traitor or not but can only say i'm glad he is being returned to his family.
I'm sure the last 5 years have been hell for all of them




For me, it's not the issue of him possibly being a traitor, it's the complete change in our stance of negotiating with terrorists. It scares me to think that this has happened, traitor or not.

Posted 6/2/14 1:24 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Hostages released from GITMO

Posted by NervousNell

So they get a five to one advantage?
And um, since when did we start negotiating with terrorists?



Exactly

So 5 men free to kill HUNDREDS more Americans in the LEAST. If not them personally, their release signals our weakness and more will rally to their cause. You think this won't spur more death?

Not that I want any American held hostage, but I would not want my freedom at the cost of more death. I would hope that my family would understand that if held hostage that we would not negotiate the freedom of terrorist for their lives. They signed up to DIE for our freedom, die for our way of life not to allow others freedom to threaten us again.

I am honestly disgusted by this but right now its all PC for this to happen so it did and its also an election year for many so this makes them 'look good'. I find myself in the minority.

But I'm old enough to recall the words, "We do NOT negotiate with Terrorists"

Posted 6/2/14 1:27 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Hostages released from GITMO

There is more than meets the eye here, as we all agree


My thought was if he did get tied into the terrorist groups , maybe they wanted him back here to gather intel.

We normally don't negotiate so I'm thinking there's more at stake here

Posted 6/2/14 1:38 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2