Terrorists released from GITMO
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Hostages released from GITMO Not sure how I feel about this. Glad an American soldier is home, but agree that it could be the start of a very slippery slope. But I do not consider the detainees held in GITMO to be hostages - not sure if that's what you meant, but you subject line seems to indicate that you did. |
|
Posted 6/2/14 1:41 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Hostages released from GITMO Posted by ANewDayHasCome I didn't read what you posted but I have been following the story. I think it puts our soldiers in danger bc it sends the message you capture one American soldier and you can negotiate to free 5 Taliban. These men are the highest of the highest power in Taliban and it's very scary they are now free to get us again. I also think the circumstances in which he was taken hostage or mysterious. Days before he emailed his father how he was ashamed to be an American and America is disgusting. He wanted to help the afghan people. I'm also sure a lot of information wasn't released Word for word agree with you I think this sets a very bad precedent for future negotiations |
|
Posted 6/2/14 2:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hostages released from GITMO Posted by Otherme Posted by Aries14 I work for the federal govt and I have learned to never judge certain decisions from being on the outside. Things you think you know - you don't. I am fully confident that the people that made this decision and negotiations know a hell of a lot more about this soldier and the situation than any of us. Thank you this isn't some episode of RHONJ for people to dissect - its real life and there is a hell of a lot of information that the gov has and does NOT release to the general public. It's so easy to pass judgment from the outside, but we don't and probably never will know the full story about any of it. I have no idea if this guy is a traitor or not but can only say i'm glad he is being returned to his family. I'm sure the last 5 years have been hell for all of them I completely agree. We, as civilians, know next to nothing about the decision making process in a case like this, I am willing to bet CNN doesn't know much more than we do. I am withholding judgment because it's not my place to claim I know better. |
|
Posted 6/2/14 2:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO Posted by chilltocam But I do not consider the detainees held in GITMO to be hostages - not sure if that's what you meant, but you subject line seems to indicate that you did. ahh, you are correct. I edited to say "terrorists". I think it's safe to say that's what they are ![]() I don't know how I feel about this......I will say, something KIND OF related to the comment about negotiating with terrorists....I was watching a WW2 documentary over the weekend and it showed how FDR and Churchill "negotiated" with Stalin in order to stop Hitler (all 3 came to an agreement after 3 or 4 days of negotiation). Stalin was a known P.O.S.....but joining forces with one ******** to get rid of another.....maybe something like that is happening here (insofar as something else going on here that we don't know about). I am NOT saying both situations are the same.....but that there have been instances where we had to make deals with "evil" people for the greater good. But how it LOOKS to the rest of the world? I don't know. I think it makes us look weak. I am afraid they will kill more of us now that they are free. |
|
Posted 6/2/14 3:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO I think it is a terrible precedent to set. And while I do agree that we are not privy to all the details the fact is neither is anyone else. As such, a terrorist could see that and think that they can also get the US to do what they want by holding hostages. The reason behind it becomes irrelevant because it creates the perception that we will negotiate with terrorists. Message edited 2014-06-02 16:06:11.240000. |
|
Posted 6/2/14 4:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO Posted by Jugglemom I think it is a terrible precedent to set. And while I do agree that we are not privy to all the details the fact is neither is anyone else. As such, a terrorist could see that and think that they can also get the US to do what they want by holding hostages. The reason behind it becomes irrelevant because it creates the perception that we will negotiate with terrorists. As someone who used to work on the Hill, I do know that there is obv a lot of Intel that isn't shared with us but I also know that sometimes govt officials make poor and/or shady decisions. Edited to add: I think the fact that they circumvented notice to congress in order to release the detainees is also a problem. Edited again: the more I read about this the angrier I get. The US government was "assured" these detainees won't be a threat to the US? Really? They have been given a one year travel ban ...seriously? [ |
|
Posted 6/2/14 4:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO the US wants this man back from some reason and it must be good to release 5 from GITMO. Curious what else comes out on this. |
|
Posted 6/2/14 4:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO Posted by Jugglemom I think it is a terrible precedent to set. And while I do agree that we are not privy to all the details the fact is neither is anyone else. As such, a terrorist could see that and think that they can also get the US to do what they want by holding hostages. The reason behind it becomes irrelevant because it creates the perception that we will negotiate with terrorists. As someone who used to work on the Hill, I do know that there is obv a lot of Intel that isn't shared with us but I also know that sometimes govt officials make poor and/or shady decisions. Edited to add: I think the fact that they circumvented notice to congress in order to release the detainees is also a problem. Edited again: the more I read about this the angrier I get. The US government was "assured" these detainees won't be a threat to the US? Really? They have been given a one year travel ban ...seriously? Sure.. after this year its not this administration's problem anymore. I am SURE these fine gentlemen love our country as much as we do now and would never have ill will or support any repercussions to our country. Plus that one year ban on travel is sooooo serious I mean, its not like you can fly, right? ETA Oh great and he's coming to my town *sigh* Message edited 2014-06-02 19:22:21.513000. |
|
Posted 6/2/14 5:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO Posted by kimmaymb20 Sorry I don't like this for one second. There are many stories from soldiers in his brigade that said he was speaking against America and walked off the base. This doesn't agree well with me AT ALL And we release 5 Gitmo prisoners for one American? Then the father deletes a tweet about releasing more prisoners? We have an American solider right now sitting in Mexico for accidently crossing the border and we are doing nothing about that? Or the Sydanian woman sitting in prison for marrying an American? The priorites in the country are so out of wack. This! There are soldiers who served with him saying he took a water bottle & left the base -didn't even bring his weapon. If he deserted, it's treason and he should be tried accordingly when he returns. Not to mention it's been reported that at least 6 soldiers died on the missions sent out to search for him. And I'm bothered by the fact that the administration broke the law by circumventing congress to get this deal done. I hope we find out more about this shady story! |
|
Posted 6/2/14 9:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO I'm going to for the SYFY hope that there's tracking devices implanted to trace movements....maybe they'll find the Malaysian airliner when they return them. I agree there is more to this than we know (or would ever want to know). |
|
Posted 6/2/14 9:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO The more information that comes out, the more nervous I'm getting. |
|
Posted 6/4/14 6:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO Posted by Ayne11 The more information that comes out, the more nervous I'm getting. The more information that comes out, the angrier I am getting. His fellow soldiers said that he was disillusioned, he abandoned his post, and had a sense of wanderlust. They said he thought that he could try to end the war. If he did the above, he should be court marshaled with a dishonorable discharge. It bothers me greatly that the White House did not follow the law and provide Congress the required 30 days notice. It bothers me very greatly that they traded prisoners of war for this person and that they negotiated with terrorists. It also bothers me that the soldier's father made remarks in Arabic about ending the war and returning all of the captives which he subsequently deleted. I am going to reserve judgement as I am sure we don't have all of the facts, but the facts we do know are not painting a good picture. From all that I have read and seen, the White House appears blind sided about the reaction and that is not a good thing at all. I absolutely hope that a bi-partisan investigation into the matter is conducted by Congress. |
|
Posted 6/4/14 6:41 PM
|
|
|
Terrorists released from GITMO He also mailed home his computer and personal items before walking away from his post. This is all very suspect and I'm sure there is tons of information not released and will never be. |
|
Posted 6/4/14 6:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Terrorists released from GITMO Posted by LSP2005 Posted by Ayne11 The more information that comes out, the more nervous I'm getting. The more information that comes out, the angrier I am getting. His fellow soldiers said that he was disillusioned, he abandoned his post, and had a sense of wanderlust. They said he thought that he could try to end the war. If he did the above, he should be court marshaled with a dishonorable discharge. It bothers me greatly that the White House did not follow the law and provide Congress the required 30 days notice. It bothers me very greatly that they traded prisoners of war for this person and that they negotiated with terrorists. It also bothers me that the soldier's father made remarks in Arabic about ending the war and returning all of the captives which he subsequently deleted. I am going to reserve judgement as I am sure we don't have all of the facts, but the facts we do know are not painting a good picture. From all that I have read and seen, the White House appears blind sided about the reaction and that is not a good thing at all. I absolutely hope that a bi-partisan investigation into the matter is conducted by Congress. It really is infuriating and downright terrifying. |
|
Posted 6/4/14 9:56 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |












