Teachers and Merit

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Teachers and Merit

Thoughts? Opinions?

NYC Teachers

Posted 3/2/11 10:37 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Teachers and Merit

I like it. a lot actually.

get rid of the bad first, no matter how long they've been mucking up the place.

Posted 3/2/11 10:59 AM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

I agree with it as long as its done properly. I havent found someone who doesnt (although maybe here Chat Icon ). However, its highly unlikely the assembly will pass it and it will be tabled until next year. Again. The unions are powerful supporters of the Democrats.

Posted 3/2/11 11:07 AM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Teachers and Merit

I saw this when they were still thinking of implementing this and thought right away that it is a very good and fair idea.

Our main goal should be to have our kids taught by the best teachers, not the ones who have been on the job the longest!

My son's current teachers is very young and only has 4 years of experience. I would hate to think that he would be let go should anything happen. He is amazing and the school system should be so lucky to have more like him!

Posted 3/2/11 11:08 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Teachers and Merit

I wonder too how the layoffs with affect teaching fellows.

2 friends and a family member are teaching fellows (or rather have just finished the program) and teach in some of the worst elementary schools in Brooklyn.

they are so dedicated to their kids that it blows my mind. I would hate to think that any of them would be axed over someone who has lost the will to teach. Chat Icon

Posted 3/2/11 11:11 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Teachers and Merit

This is a great idea in theory, in reality it will be a way to can teachers who are too expensive and keep newbies.

Some things that might be better are actually firing teachers who have been investigated more than once. They did away w/ rubber rooms and we now have a teacher in my building who has had @ 5 incidents with students and is still teaching.

Teachers who are chronically absent. I have a teacher in my building who melts down once every cple yrs and is absent for weeks at a time.

THESE are things the mayor should look into.

One of the problems is that Bloomberg signed a contract a cple yrs ago that said excessed teachers can sit where they are until they secure a job in a place they LIKE.

PROBLEM! He has teachers sitting subbing, reading papers, and in the same building has hired NEW teachers (bc he opened NEW schools. Each with a Principal, guidance counselor, Asst Princpal for 100 kids..not good budget wise). This was HIS dumbass move Chat Icon It is tricky to explain and since I have only a cple minutes I will leave it at that, I can explain more in detail later.

Posted 3/2/11 11:20 AM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by Ophelia

I wonder too how the layoffs with affect teaching fellows.

2 friends and a family member are teaching fellows (or rather have just finished the program) and teach in some of the worst elementary schools in Brooklyn.

they are so dedicated to their kids that it blows my mind. I would hate to think that any of them would be axed over someone who has lost the will to teach. Chat Icon


i dont think it will affect the fellows ( i read it somewhere) because they are working in high need areas- special ed and math etc.

Posted 3/2/11 11:22 AM
 

TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog
Leah's here!

Member since 9/07

5404 total posts

Name:
Sabrina

Re: Teachers and Merit

I have to say..I do agree that the best teachers should be kept, but my fear (which I'm almost sure will be realized) is that unless we set up FAIR ways of judging teachers, it will make teachers subject to arbitrary layoffs/firings...which is one of the original reasons LIFO was imposed. I think rushing into evaluations where not all parties/situations are taken into consideration is a big mistake...

A side note...newer teachers eventually become older teachers and will thereby cost money as well..we need some foresight as well as financial-mindness when making decision (if that even makes sense).

Posted 3/2/11 12:13 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by cateyemm


i dont think it will affect the fellows ( i read it somewhere) because they are working in high need areas- special ed and math etc.



It depends- my school has had Fellows who are in different subject areas- but no special ed teachers and only 3% of math teachers will be laid off. Elementary schools and Brooklyn schools will be hardest hit.

However, I suspect that Bloomberg will "find" the money somehow and avert layoffs because he has not gotten exactly what he wanted. For whatever reason he is very unhappy with Cuomo's bill though the end result would be the same.

He wanted principals to have carte blanche to fire whoever they wanted, and he also said more than once that laying off veteran teachers would mean laying off fewer overall teachers. Jonathan Bing made similar comments when he introduced a similar bill almost a year ago. So quality certainly is an issue, but so is economics. I also imagine that canning teachers with only a few years to retirement would lessen the pension burden.

A fair system to end LIFO is needed and this bill is being shelved in the Assembly till one can be created. Cuomo's bill is on the fast track and it will also be statewide, but I don't know if it will be in time for this current problem.

If only we weren't spending so much money on testing, and oddly, recruitment, many layoffs could be averted.

Posted 3/2/11 12:35 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

On the surface, I like it. I worked in NYC for quite a few years, not as a teacher, but in another city agency. All employees were part of a union. My job involved working with children, and there were some people I worked with who were horrible. At best ineffective, dead wood types and at worst loose cannons who really should never work with the public. But they had jobs and it was so hard to get rid of them because of the union rules. One guy actually hit a child and continued bouncing around the system for years. So on the surface it sounds good.

But as others have noted, there needs to be a fair rating system in place for this to work, and it should not be a means for good teachers earning high pay to be let go or teachers who disagree with their principals to be let go.

Posted 3/2/11 8:20 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

But how do you decide on "merit"? Who gets to decide which teachers are good and which teachers are not?

I taught in NYC and my fifth year there, we got a new principal. Our school was deemed "failing" and he decided to rule with an iron fist:
- You had to write your name on the top left corner of the chalkboard and could not erase it, even accidentally, during the 45 minute period
- You had to have a "Late Log" out and open on the top left corner of your desk
- Your "Aim" - which also could not be erased from the chalkboard - had to contain the words "Why" or "How" and not the word "What" (as in, "What were the causes of WWII?")
- Your had to have a Do Now activity every day, for every type of lesson, and it had to take between 3 and 6 minutes to complete and review.

... The list went on. If he did not like a teacher, and the teacher erased the chalkboard to make room for more notes (and erased his "Aim" in the process), the teacher would get an Unsatisfactory observation. When we complained at faculty meetings about this, he defended himself: "Look, I'm a new principal and I need to surround myself with people who will support me. If you don't support me, you'll have to find somewhere else to work."

Teachers were given U's because he did not like them, or because they disagreed with his policies. This is why I just can't get behind a "Merit" system as it's being discussed now - it's too arbitrary. And honestly, I can't think of a way to judge teachers that would be fair. Until I hear a plan that makes sense, I can't agree with this at all.

Posted 3/2/11 9:03 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by DiamondGirl

This is a great idea in theory, in reality it will be a way to can teachers who are too expensive and keep newbies.




Exactly. No one's talking about it but THIS is the one and only reason Bloomberg is pushing for "merit" over "seniority." Guaranteed.

Posted 3/2/11 9:05 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

It's very easy, in Bloomberg's eyes: Merit= test scores. Those of us who teach know this has pitfalls, but this current bill will rely on value-added measures, which are flawed.

Currenly math and ELA are the only subjects where teachers are "ranked" via VAM. So as to not lay off a disproportionate number in those areas, ALL teachers will be ranked. So I infer that we are about to see lots and lots more testing, all grades, all subjects. But since we won Race to the Top money, we have lots of money for testing and evaluation. Plus the new teacher eval system will require 40% of the teacher's rating to be based on test scores. Every grade is going to look like high school junior year when there were Regents in nearly all subjects. Chat Icon

Posted 3/2/11 9:18 PM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by DavaDay

But how do you decide on "merit"? Who gets to decide which teachers are good and which teachers are not?

I taught in NYC and my fifth year there, we got a new principal. Our school was deemed "failing" and he decided to rule with an iron fist:
- You had to write your name on the top left corner of the chalkboard and could not erase it, even accidentally, during the 45 minute period
- You had to have a "Late Log" out and open on the top left corner of your desk
- Your "Aim" - which also could not be erased from the chalkboard - had to contain the words "Why" or "How" and not the word "What" (as in, "What were the causes of WWII?")
- Your had to have a Do Now activity every day, for every type of lesson, and it had to take between 3 and 6 minutes to complete and review.

... The list went on. If he did not like a teacher, and the teacher erased the chalkboard to make room for more notes (and erased his "Aim" in the process), the teacher would get an Unsatisfactory observation. When we complained at faculty meetings about this, he defended himself: "Look, I'm a new principal and I need to surround myself with people who will support me. If you don't support me, you'll have to find somewhere else to work."

Teachers were given U's because he did not like them, or because they disagreed with his policies. This is why I just can't get behind a "Merit" system as it's being discussed now - it's too arbitrary. And honestly, I can't think of a way to judge teachers that would be fair. Until I hear a plan that makes sense, I can't agree with this at all.




I think we might have had the same principal. I agree with everything you said because we are going through the same thing right now. In the last 3 years our principal has targeted people for no other reason than they erased the Aim to put more notes on the board. He does "drive by" observations and rips you apart over a 2 minute glimpse of your class; doesn't give you the opportunity to explain why the Aim isn't on the board or why your homework log is a day behind. We lost a lot of GREAT teachers because of this. They transferred before he could destroy their careers.

I think it is easy if you are not in the industry to think that merit and teachers should go hand in hand. It a perfect world it would be a fair way to assess teachers. However when you have a principal that targets a teacher just because he doesn't like their handwriting, fair goes out the window.

Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-03-02 21:27:19.663000.

Posted 3/2/11 9:23 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by nicrae
However when you have a principal that targets a teacher just because he doesn't like their handwriting, fair goes out the window.

Chat Icon



The principal I mentioned targeted a teacher one year because he didn't like his SHIRT. He told him earlier in the day that his clothing was inappropriate (it was June and he was wearing a tee shirt). Popped in to observe him on the last period of the day on June 24. Can you imagine?

Posted 3/2/11 9:29 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by nicrae

I think we might have had the same principal. I agree with everything you said because we are going through the same thing right now. In the last 3 years our principal has targeted people for no other reason than they erased the Aim to put more notes on the board. He does "drive by" observations and rips you apart over a 2 minute glimpse of your class; doesn't give you the opportunity to explain why the Aim isn't on the board or why your homework log is a day behind. We lost a lot of GREAT teachers because of this. They transferred before he could destroy their careers.

I think it is easy if you are not in the industry to think that merit and teachers should go hand in hand. It a perfect world it would be a fair way to assess teachers. However when you have a principal that targets a teacher just because he doesn't like their handwriting, fair goes out the window.

Chat Icon



We had a "co-principal" several years ago who was like this too. She ultimately caused my school to be split and the two newer schools are still struggling six years later. Our school wasn't bad, but she liked nitpicking. After Balanced Literacy became the
"thing" she took all our literature antholgies but told us we could photocopy individual things if we wanted- we were not allowed to have the books. Chat Icon This was also someone who could not run a school by herself, hence the "co" status.

Your friends were lucky to transfer- because of Fair Funding principals are not eager to hire more expensive teachers.

I get the feeling the city is coming after my school and if we are closed I know I will probably not be able to find another position, which is a big factor in why I'm planning to leave next year.

Posted 3/2/11 9:35 PM
 

TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog
Leah's here!

Member since 9/07

5404 total posts

Name:
Sabrina

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by DavaDay


Teachers were given U's because he did not like them, or because they disagreed with his policies. This is why I just can't get behind a "Merit" system as it's being discussed now - it's too arbitrary. And honestly, I can't think of a way to judge teachers that would be fair. Until I hear a plan that makes sense, I can't agree with this at all.



ITA with this..remember when the Union was talking about getting into work with this and now it's gone away and it's all about $$? Sad state of affairs...

How do we account for things we CANNOT control? We cannot control kids who don't eat because their parents can't/won't...we cannot control the work done by the student..we can only work with them but some has to be independent..we can only control so much, but our entire career becomes dependent...

Posted 3/2/11 9:37 PM
 

jenheartsrob
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

1861 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

How do they plan to asses the merit of the gym teacher or the art teacher? Or the Resource Room teacher versus the Gifted and Talented room teacher? The teacher with 10 IEPS in her room versus the "advanced" class? It just doesn't seem like a level playing field to decide "merit" based on test scores when there are so many variables within the teaching profession, let alone when compounded with the variables over which teachers have no control: students who don't go to bed early, eat breakfast, have support at home, have a warm bed to sleep in, etc..

Posted 3/2/11 9:42 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: Teachers and Merit

It is so easy to put all the blame on the teachers who are inside the classroom. You need to look at The students who have been out of school 30 plus times in a school year and have been late just as much. How about the children who get pulled during the reading the math block? If students are missing my lesson once or twice a week, why am I getting all the focus? Not to mention around testing time (now) some children are pulled from the classroom and they have a AIS teacher work with those kids. Some kids are being pulled for 6-12 hours out of that time. Am I going to be evaluated for their tests score also?

There are just too many factors to have merit pay. You really would have to be a teacher and really know how the system works to understand what those factors are. Too bad many who are running the ship do not seem to understand. Educating our students is not a business. Yes, there are a lot of way that money is not being used effectively. However, they are looking in the wrong place.

Message edited 2011-03-02 22:47:54.943000.

Posted 3/2/11 10:08 PM
 

nancygrace
I'm 2!

Member since 9/05

6616 total posts

Name:
Live*Love*Laugh

Re: Teachers and Merit

im a teacher and i like the idea to tell u the truth

Posted 3/3/11 12:13 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Teachers and Merit

i agree with it but i agree with the Cuomo's plan and not Bloombergs. He would have a panel of experienced educators reviewing not just "decide"

Posted 3/3/11 12:18 PM
 

firsttimer

Member since 5/07

1532 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

We all want the best teachers teaching our kids. However this seems like a backend way of getting rid of tenure.

Posted 3/3/11 12:42 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Teachers and Merit

I think major committees would have to design a very detailed system of checks and balances in order for this not to be abused.

Posted 3/3/11 1:38 PM
 

Teach
LIF Infant

Member since 6/10

263 total posts

Name:

Re: Teachers and Merit

I like this idea, but I am special education and my scores will NEVER be up to par. I would never receive merit pay Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/11 4:46 PM
 

mdn13
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/07

408 total posts

Name:
Marcie

Re: Teachers and Merit

Posted by Teach

I like this idea, but I am special education and my scores will NEVER be up to par. I would never receive merit pay Chat Icon



I hope you understand that under a merit pay system you would not get a "bonus." Your base pay would start out significantly lower and if your students did "excellent" your salary would be what it is now.

There is NOTHING good about merit pay. There will NEVER be a fair way to measure all teachers performance objectively. And if anyone disagrees with me, I would love to hear how you forsee a fair and way to do this.

Posted 3/3/11 6:47 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Teachers- anyone know what i need to do if i want to 04bride 5/18/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
Need help writing a cover letter teachers I could use your help TAD 5/17/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Question for teachers MamaNDaddyof3 5/17/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
For the teachers ... Miro127 5/13/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
no offense to any school teachers BUT TAD 5/13/05 28 Families Helping Families ™
City Teachers TAD 5/12/05 5 Families Helping Families ™