Re: Teachers and Merit
Posted 3/2/2011 9:23:40 PM by nicrae
Posted by DavaDay
But how do you decide on "merit"? Who gets to decide which teachers are good and which teachers are not?
I taught in NYC and my fifth year there, we got a new principal. Our school was deemed "failing" and he decided to rule with an iron fist: - You had to write your name on the top left corner of the chalkboard and could not erase it, even accidentally, during the 45 minute period - You had to have a "Late Log" out and open on the top left corner of your desk - Your "Aim" - which also could not be erased from the chalkboard - had to contain the words "Why" or "How" and not the word "What" (as in, "What were the causes of WWII?") - Your had to have a Do Now activity every day, for every type of lesson, and it had to take between 3 and 6 minutes to complete and review.
... The list went on. If he did not like a teacher, and the teacher erased the chalkboard to make room for more notes (and erased his "Aim" in the process), the teacher would get an Unsatisfactory observation. When we complained at faculty meetings about this, he defended himself: "Look, I'm a new principal and I need to surround myself with people who will support me. If you don't support me, you'll have to find somewhere else to work."
Teachers were given U's because he did not like them, or because they disagreed with his policies. This is why I just can't get behind a "Merit" system as it's being discussed now - it's too arbitrary. And honestly, I can't think of a way to judge teachers that would be fair. Until I hear a plan that makes sense, I can't agree with this at all.
I think we might have had the same principal. I agree with everything you said because we are going through the same thing right now. In the last 3 years our principal has targeted people for no other reason than they erased the Aim to put more notes on the board. He does "drive by" observations and rips you apart over a 2 minute glimpse of your class; doesn't give you the opportunity to explain why the Aim isn't on the board or why your homework log is a day behind. We lost a lot of GREAT teachers because of this. They transferred before he could destroy their careers.
I think it is easy if you are not in the industry to think that merit and teachers should go hand in hand. It a perfect world it would be a fair way to assess teachers. However when you have a principal that targets a teacher just because he doesn't like their handwriting, fair goes out the window.
|