In theory it sounds like a good idea, but in reality I think it's crap. There's just no way to implement it fairly. How do you objectively decide that someone is a "bad" teacher? They could be working their butts off but the kids don't care, don't study, are only interested in texting, etc. so they fail anyway. So you can't look at student achievement as a reflection of the teacher. So what can you look at to make it fair? Observations are too subjective & principals will totally abuse this to get rid of the teachers that are most expensive or who they don't get along with. Teachers are under enough pressure as it is. I am so glad I got out of that job.