Talking about 9/11 with students...

Posted By Message

VirginiaDeb
Don't eat me, hippo!

Member since 5/05

9252 total posts

Name:
Deb

Talking about 9/11 with students...

So, this has to do w/ teaching, but I wanted the opinions of others as well...

A 6th grade student at my school lost his father when the plane hit the pentagon 7 years ago. The other students are aware of this, but most don't seem to say much.

He attends the memorial every year, and today a few of the kids wanted to discuss this, and just discuss what went on for a bit. The teacher did not start the discussion, but didn't feel that it was in the students' best interest to ignore their feelings/need to talk about what happened.

Another student in the class who had lost his mother (to cancer, not on 9/11) got upset and started crying that he missed his mother, so he went to the councilor.

Later, our principal basically yelled at the teacher for discussing 9/11 with the students.

What would you have done? Ignore their need to discuss what happened? Or do you think it was better to allow them to talk about their feelings about what happened?

Posted 9/11/08 5:02 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

This year i am teaching 2nd grade so i kept in simple!

1st the entire school all wore red, white and blue today. we all met in the hallways 1st thing this morning, said the pledge, sang songs and had a moment of silence.

In my class I read "The man Who Walked Between the Towers" and then we watched the video.

Posted 9/11/08 5:16 PM
 

VirginiaDeb
Don't eat me, hippo!

Member since 5/05

9252 total posts

Name:
Deb

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

Posted by mpetretti

This year i am teaching 2nd grade so i kept in simple!

1st the entire school all wore red, white and blue today. we all met in the hallways 1st thing this morning, said the pledge, sang songs and had a moment of silence.

In my class I read "The man Who Walked Between the Towers" and then we watched the video.



so different from us. We were told not to mention it at all. Besides the morning news where they gave a moment of silence, we weren't supposed to say anything about 9/11.

And my school is only about a 20 minute drive from the pentagon.

I teach 5th.

Posted 9/11/08 5:19 PM
 

july06bride
I'm a mom!

Member since 5/05

3966 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I teach 6,7,and 8 and every class in every subject had some sort of 9/11 activity/lesson/poem/video/project---we had some tears from the 6th graders because they viewed a video that was emotional but overall I think the experience was a good one for them. We have NEVER had any complaints and actually the principal urges us to honor the day in some way.

In the situation you mentioned, I would have done the same thing- if the students have something important they want to discuss and it is appropriate, you use it as a teaching moment and you go with it- the teacher did nothing wrong

Message edited 2008-09-11 17:22:28.047000.

Posted 9/11/08 5:21 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I would've let them talk about it. And I have done things like that, when I was teaching and the students brought up topics that they were curious about or bothered by.

9/11 even has its own designation on the calendar as "Pray for the Nation Day" - your principal telling him not to discuss it is like telling someone not to explain what Memorial Day is, or never to talk about the bombing of Pearl Harbor. Teachers are trained to speak to children at their level and guide discussions appropriately. It's a difficult topic, yes, especially when it's still so recent, but I don't think the teacher did anything wrong.

Posted 9/11/08 5:21 PM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

Posted by VirginiaDeb

Posted by mpetretti

This year i am teaching 2nd grade so i kept in simple!

1st the entire school all wore red, white and blue today. we all met in the hallways 1st thing this morning, said the pledge, sang songs and had a moment of silence.

In my class I read "The man Who Walked Between the Towers" and then we watched the video.



so different from us. We were told not to mention it at all. Besides the morning news where they gave a moment of silence, we weren't supposed to say anything about 9/11.

And my school is only about a 20 minute drive from the pentagon.

I teach 5th.



WOW- thats really sad that it couldn't be mentioned at all, especially to 5th graders! And its a shame that your principal yelled at your colleague for discussing it. I do understand not wanting to go into detail BUT these children do know something about it and they have questions.

I had second graders come in today who heard on the radio about the towers being hit by planes- they had questions and I answered them in as kid friendly terms as possible!

Posted 9/11/08 5:23 PM
 

luckyinlove
I love my baby girls!

Member since 12/06

2441 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

We just had the principal talk about it at 8:40 when the 1st tower was hit. We all stood and faced the flag and had a moment of silence. Then, we talked about it for a few moments. didn't want to spend too much time talking about it b/c it still makes me sad, and my emotions are in overdrive now that i am pg.

Posted 9/11/08 5:24 PM
 

Kate
*****

Member since 5/05

7557 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I think it's outrageous that the teacher was reprimanded. A discussion about the events of 9/11 is completely appropriate in a classroom.

Posted 9/11/08 5:26 PM
 

wannabemom
look who's freshly baked!

Member since 12/07

7364 total posts

Name:
aka marriedinportjeff

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

Posted by VirginiaDeb

Posted by mpetretti

This year i am teaching 2nd grade so i kept in simple!

1st the entire school all wore red, white and blue today. we all met in the hallways 1st thing this morning, said the pledge, sang songs and had a moment of silence.

In my class I read "The man Who Walked Between the Towers" and then we watched the video.



so different from us. We were told not to mention it at all. Besides the morning news where they gave a moment of silence, we weren't supposed to say anything about 9/11.

And my school is only about a 20 minute drive from the pentagon.

I teach 5th.



that's unfortunate...


As for the principal... simply put: you can't shelter kids from their own life experiences! It's their lives, and they must greive in order to move on.....

Posted 9/11/08 5:26 PM
 

VirginiaDeb
Don't eat me, hippo!

Member since 5/05

9252 total posts

Name:
Deb

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

Posted by mpetretti

Posted by VirginiaDeb

Posted by mpetretti

This year i am teaching 2nd grade so i kept in simple!

1st the entire school all wore red, white and blue today. we all met in the hallways 1st thing this morning, said the pledge, sang songs and had a moment of silence.

In my class I read "The man Who Walked Between the Towers" and then we watched the video.



so different from us. We were told not to mention it at all. Besides the morning news where they gave a moment of silence, we weren't supposed to say anything about 9/11.

And my school is only about a 20 minute drive from the pentagon.

I teach 5th.



WOW- thats really sad that it couldn't be mentioned at all, especially to 5th graders! And its a shame that your principal yelled at your colleague for discussing it. I do understand not wanting to go into detail BUT these children do know something about it and they have questions.

I had second graders come in today who heard on the radio about the towers being hit by planes- they had questions and I answered them in as kid friendly terms as possible!



Yeah, it just didn't seem right. We were told that we could listen to a student one on one, but otherwise to send them to the counselor. I was just shocked that the principal yelled at her about it.

Posted 9/11/08 5:27 PM
 

ggt08
;)

Member since 5/05

5208 total posts

Name:

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I teach 3rd grade- they were 1 when it happened. We had a brief moment of silence during morning announcements but the day was business as usual. None of my students brought it up so I chose not to address it.
That doesnt mean I was not thinking about it all day today.... :(

Message edited 2008-09-11 18:45:42.647000.

Posted 9/11/08 5:28 PM
 

zia
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

228 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

i did very little talking about 9/11 with my students today...i do teach high school social studies so felt it was the right forum to discuss it but after getting "we should be off today" comments last year...i limit the comments...but asked if kids wanted to discuss soemthing besides having a day off we could...school should be a safe environment for children to ask questions and speak their mind...that principal was out of line

Posted 9/11/08 5:31 PM
 

beautyq115
New Year!

Member since 5/05

13729 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

We had a moment of silence. We were encouraged to discuss it with them but I get too upset talking about it. My kids were 2 when it happened. I try not to get into it with them. If they ask questions I will answer them but that it about it.

Posted 9/11/08 5:34 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

My adminstrator was encouraging as well. He asked me to do an announcement and memorial this morning. we had a moment of silence, a recap of the events and a beautiful poem reading. We just found out yesterday that one of our freshman lost his dad in the WTC and he was at school today. It is special ed so some of our lower students, his classmate brought it up and they didin't really get into it at all. But the kids kept saying stuff.. not nasty at all... more curious because they just didn't understand. Death is very hard for them to grasp.

Posted 9/11/08 5:38 PM
 

nel
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

1173 total posts

Name:

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

It depends so much on the administration, unfortunately. I was in my second year teaching in 2001, and we were given no instruction about how to handle the situation, so I just decided to open my classroom up to discuss that Friday following the attacks. I was never told either way if that were ok (but I was thanked by some of my 9th graders' parents).

When our admin. changed, we began having a moment of silence every year (with more done in 2002, of course). But I do find it to be outrageous that this teacher in your school was reprimanded -- she was responding to the needs of her class in a teaching moment, which is what a good teacher DOES.

Posted 9/11/08 5:52 PM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

i am in the same district as nel, but on the elementary level. we had a moment of silence and and a co-worker & I sang a verse of Amazing Grace over the PA system. (one of the traditions we started). That's it. I dont' addrses with my kids. Some mention it, but they were only toddlers when it happened and it's over their head. our moment of silence was more for the staff as we have staff that lost loved ones.

Posted 9/11/08 6:16 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I teach HS and choose not to discuss 9/11. It gets me very upset when 9/11 is approaching and the students whine about how they should be off from school. We had a moment of silence this morning and there were kids laughing and talking in the hallways waiting for class. I am beginning to feel that unless these students suffered a direct loss from 9/11, they just don't get it. The Freshmen were only 6 or 7 when it happened.Chat Icon

Posted 9/11/08 6:32 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I teach 1st. We did a school wide ribbon tying.

I told them what today was, that NY experienced a tragedy and that yellow ribbons are a way of remembering people and that it wasn't my job to tell them exactly what happened because maybe their parents don't want them to know yet.

Posted 9/11/08 6:40 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I teach 8th grade in a community that lost a lot of people on that day. I didn't get the official list, but I have 5 students who were directly effected by 9/11.
The parents each year ask that we don't make a big deal about it. We have a moment of silence, but there are no special activities because it's simply still too painful. Pretty much every student in the school knows someone who died on that day.
If any of the students ask, we can speak about it, but we're asked not to bring it up/make a big deal.

No one asked me anything this year....thankfully....I don't deal well with emotional issues.

Posted 9/11/08 8:31 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

we are not permitted to talk about it, and i understand why. there are kids in my school who lost parents. there are other kids (this is elementary school) whose parents don't talk about it with them, and they get upset when they hear about it. there is a moment of silence and i think it was called patriots day or something like that.

it's best to be discussed in the home since some kids were DIRECTLY affected by it. it's not like we're discussing the vietnam war which didn't touch any of them personally.

Posted 9/11/08 8:34 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

I was actually really, really upset because it's the first year since the attacks that my school did not convene around the flag pole for a moment of silence and some words. I was really sad all day about it. Especially when I heard a sixth grader say to her friend, "Oh, wow, I just realized it's September 11th," and her friend sarcastically responded, "Ugg, that was over, like hours agoChat Icon " I was so upset. Chat Icon

Posted 9/11/08 8:49 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...

Posted by browneyedgirl

we are not permitted to talk about it, and i understand why. there are kids in my school who lost parents. there are other kids (this is elementary school) whose parents don't talk about it with them, and they get upset when they hear about it. there is a moment of silence and i think it was called patriots day or something like that.

it's best to be discussed in the home since some kids were DIRECTLY affected by it. it's not like we're discussing the vietnam war which didn't touch any of them personally.



I'm not a teacher but I agree with this. The school doesn't always know who was directly affected by it and to discuss something so personal is not the place of the school if the parents aren't doing it or don't want their kids to get upset. I feel so bad for that child who started crying about missing his Mom. That was just as important - more important - to that child but it's not "on topic" and then it becomes a convoluted subject. But I understand it being a tough call. Kids don't just take in info and not ask questions so I can see how questions can arise and a teacher can't just ignore the student. I just don't think the school should be discussing it without the parent's knowledge. It's so personal. My DS is in 1st grade and this is the age of the children who were not alive for 9-11. Some were already conceived but none were born yet. My DH made the comment that none of them could have lost a parent but it's not true. Obviously none lost a mother but someone could have lost a father that they never knew. So sad. Whatever the case, it sounds like the teacher was just trying to help the kids, it seems wrong that she should be reamed by the Principal over it esp if there wasn't a policy on how they would handle it.

Posted 9/11/08 9:18 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
my students are soo sweet.. listen to what they did... 04bride 3/17/06 11 Pregnancy
Just found out that one of my students... MrsProfessor 3/17/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
people that just start talking saraH 3/15/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
Where are all my college students?? Mushpot 3/12/06 23 Families Helping Families ™
? about talking @14 mos. Scotty-CassidysMom 3/5/06 7 Parenting
Stony Brook Students... I need help! julz33 2/13/06 7 Families Helping Families ™