Re: Talking about 9/11 with students...
Posted 9/11/2008 9:18:48 PM by Elizabeth


Posted by browneyedgirl

we are not permitted to talk about it, and i understand why. there are kids in my school who lost parents. there are other kids (this is elementary school) whose parents don't talk about it with them, and they get upset when they hear about it. there is a moment of silence and i think it was called patriots day or something like that.

it's best to be discussed in the home since some kids were DIRECTLY affected by it. it's not like we're discussing the vietnam war which didn't touch any of them personally.



I'm not a teacher but I agree with this. The school doesn't always know who was directly affected by it and to discuss something so personal is not the place of the school if the parents aren't doing it or don't want their kids to get upset. I feel so bad for that child who started crying about missing his Mom. That was just as important - more important - to that child but it's not "on topic" and then it becomes a convoluted subject. But I understand it being a tough call. Kids don't just take in info and not ask questions so I can see how questions can arise and a teacher can't just ignore the student. I just don't think the school should be discussing it without the parent's knowledge. It's so personal. My DS is in 1st grade and this is the age of the children who were not alive for 9-11. Some were already conceived but none were born yet. My DH made the comment that none of them could have lost a parent but it's not true. Obviously none lost a mother but someone could have lost a father that they never knew. So sad. Whatever the case, it sounds like the teacher was just trying to help the kids, it seems wrong that she should be reamed by the Principal over it esp if there wasn't a policy on how they would handle it.
Print Post      Close Window