Switch witch???

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Switch witch???

Dd keeps asking me when the Switch Witch is coming. Is this something new? I've never heard of this before and now it seems this witch is supposed to swap out candy for a toy. Looks like we're running to the store today! Anyone else's kids talking about this?

Posted 10/31/15 12:28 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Lara&Aidansmommy
For mom i miss u ETC ILOVEU

Member since 3/07

13921 total posts

Name:
ETC I LOVE YOU

Re: Switch witch???

Just saw this on Shark Tank. The swith witch swaps out their candy for a toy. Never ever in all of my 40 years heard of this until last week. Ill tell you this much my kids wont give up their candy for any toy LOL

Posted 10/31/15 12:37 PM
 

Naturalmama
Love my boys!!

Member since 1/12

3548 total posts

Name:
Christine

Switch witch???

Never heard of this. We will keep it around for a week or so, allow them to have a piece or two a day, and then throw away the rest- or DH will eat it after they are in bed LOL. No toy needed, my kids lose interest in those kinds of things quickly. By Monday they will forget the candy even exists.

Posted 10/31/15 2:01 PM
 

iluvmynutty
Mom to E&M

Member since 12/08

1762 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Switch witch???

We are doing the switch witch for our 5 and 2 yr olds. I just printed up the poem on orange paper in a fancy font and rolled it up like a scroll with their names on it in "fancy" handwriting. I left it in the mailbox for them one day and read it it to them. I acted really excited about it and said it was an invitation to participate with the switch witch. My 5 yr old has been so into it! Here's the poem:

I Am the switch witch from the land of moonlight
I come to trade candy on Halloween night
With my black cat, Zoom we ride in on my broom
Searching from here to there for a child who likes to share
My cat loves candy that's what he most enjoys
So leave him your stash and I'll switch it for some toys
Place all your treats in a basket right here
And on Hallooween night you new toy will appear!

Posted 10/31/15 2:53 PM
 

nycbuslady
LIF Adult

Member since 9/15

1073 total posts

Name:

Switch witch???

My daughter never mentioned this. And, I think it's ridiculous. Frankly, I'd rather have her eat some candy instead of having another toy in the house!

Posted 10/31/15 5:11 PM
 

Maybe-Baybe
My Sunshine

Member since 7/12

3415 total posts

Name:
My only Sunshine

Re: Switch witch???

Saw this on shark tank too. Basically you buy the switch witch doll and the kids give you the candy at night and then then they get a toy from the switch witch instead of their candy.

I thought it sounded really cute at first, but it's not something I would buy into. Kids should learn how to ration the candy. Or just eat it as they please like I did when I was a kid. Chat Icon

Posted 10/31/15 6:33 PM
 

iluvmynutty
Mom to E&M

Member since 12/08

1762 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by nycbuslady

My daughter never mentioned this. And, I think it's ridiculous. Frankly, I'd rather have her eat some candy instead of having another toy in the house!



My 2 yr old is highly allergic to peanuts/tree nuts so I saw this as a great opportunity to keep him safe. I didn't find it ridiculous, I actually felt relieved when I heard if it and was happy that my kids are into it. I see what your saying in that it's basically adding a whole extra component to the holiday that for most families is completely unnecessary. However, for our family, it works. I also kept it very simple and am not doing it like the elf in the shelf (we don't do the elf on the shelf).

Posted 10/31/15 7:48 PM
 

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: Switch witch???

I don't think it's ridiculous but I don't think it's necessary either. We don't really get all that much candy to begin with and we usually just ration it, then after a while DH takes it to work or we toss it. I more see it as a fun tradition. We won't make her give away all of her candy, just some of it. I ran out and got DD and DS each a small toy ($10 max) that the witch will leave tonight. This is all new to me!

Posted 10/31/15 8:10 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Switch witch???

Efffff that. Dd has enough toys and Christmas is coming too.
Plus we love candy in this house. I consume it daily. And I don’t believe in throwing things out for no good reason. ..how wasteful
There are some things you never should waste...booze is one, junk food is another.
Chat Icon

Message edited 2015-10-31 21:01:48.757000.

Posted 10/31/15 8:55 PM
 

ChristinaM128
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

4043 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by NervousNell

Efffff that. Dd has enough toys and Christmas is coming too.
Plus we love candy in this house. I consume it daily. And I don’t believe in throwing things out for no good reason. ..how wasteful
There are some things you never should waste...booze is one, junk food is another.
Chat Icon



Couldn't have worded this better!

Posted 10/31/15 11:45 PM
 

xosweetiexo
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/09

856 total posts

Name:

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by NervousNell

Efffff that. Dd has enough toys and Christmas is coming too.
Plus we love candy in this house. I consume it daily. And I don’t believe in throwing things out for no good reason. ..how wasteful
There are some things you never should waste...booze is one, junk food is another.
Chat Icon




Chat Icon Chat Icon so true!!

Posted 11/1/15 12:06 AM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Switch witch???

I think it's a bit ridiculous also. I saw the doll in Target recently. The point of trick or treating is to get candy. If you have to give up the candy, why bother? I save a lot of it for gingerbread house decorating (twizzlers, etc. are great for this!)

Posted 11/1/15 9:00 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Switch witch???

So you gotta buy a witch then buy ANOTHER toy as the "switch?"

Posted 11/1/15 9:54 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by BargainMama

I think it's a bit ridiculous also. I saw the doll in Target recently. The point of trick or treating is to get candy. If you have to give up the candy, why bother? I save a lot of it for gingerbread house decorating (twizzlers, etc. are great for this!)



Good idea!! (Too bad our candy won't make it past tomorrow lol)

Posted 11/1/15 9:54 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Switch witch???

I don't understand this!

Maybe it is bc I grew up in a "because I said so" household but with my son it was run and go to as many houses as you can, have a ball, etc. Then, choose some treats to keep, a small but reasonable amount. Then donate the rest to the troops. My sister's job is taking up a collection of leftover or unwanted candy and shipping it out to the troops. And I explained the importance of giving back to our servicemen and women. And it was simply "bc it is the right thing to do and bc I said so" with a ooh-rah lol Chat Icon

Sure he, at first, wanted to throw a little fit but he knows that gets him nowhere fast and he was fine. I put hissy and tantrum like behavior on full-on ignore Chat Icon always have! Just kept reiterating that this is going to the troops and how it's the right thing to do. Did a fun project with him where we made a big thank you card to send with the candy. He loved that and ended up really enjoying "sending it off". And how he was able to choose a reasonable and healthy amount for himself. Liked that too.

I don't need a distraction, like a swap out for a toy, to turn to over effective parenting and important life lessons like self control with treats and giving back what we don't need to those who deserve everything.

I mean, there's an amazing set of lessons in there he would have never learned bc it would have been a POOF!!! Candy gone and LOOK new toy!!! Yeah there's so much wrong with that Chat Icon better off letting him eat himself into a candy-coma before I do that! Chat Icon

Posted 11/2/15 4:26 AM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by DaniJude
I don't need a distraction, like a swap out for a toy, to turn to over effective parenting and important life lessons like self control with treats and giving back what we don't need to those who deserve everything.



We don't always agree, but this is exactly it!!! Sorry, you're not eating 7 lbs of candy bc I'm your mom and that's the rule. I don't need to make up some character. I swear, kids these days are going to expect to be patted on the back and given a gift for waking up in the morning!!!!

I will say, I would do something special if my child had an allergy and couldn't eat any treats. I'm sure it sucks to see everyone enjoying themselves and you're stuck waving around a glow stick.

Posted 11/2/15 6:22 AM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by Katareen

Posted by DaniJude
I don't need a distraction, like a swap out for a toy, to turn to over effective parenting and important life lessons like self control with treats and giving back what we don't need to those who deserve everything.



We don't always agree, but this is exactly it!!! Sorry, you're not eating 7 lbs of candy bc I'm your mom and that's the rule. I don't need to make up some character. I swear, kids these days are going to expect to be patted on the back and given a gift for waking up in the morning!!!!

.



Don't forget trophies for participating! LOL!

This new way of parenting feels to me more like a game of avoid avoid avoid!!! Or, look over here... At THIS because I don't want you to have THAT! Chat Icon

Message edited 2015-11-02 07:10:32.310000.

Posted 11/2/15 7:08 AM
 

Momma2015
Mommax2

Member since 12/12

6656 total posts

Name:

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by Lara&Aidansmommy

Just saw this on Shark Tank. The swith witch swaps out their candy for a toy. Never ever in all of my 40 years heard of this until last week. Ill tell you this much my kids wont give up their candy for any toy LOL



I saw it on Shark Tank, too. They were NOT impressed. Neither was I. Those kids don't want candy? Pass it over here!

Posted 11/2/15 8:54 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Switch witch???

Posted by Momma2015

Posted by Lara&Aidansmommy

Just saw this on Shark Tank. The swith witch swaps out their candy for a toy. Never ever in all of my 40 years heard of this until last week. Ill tell you this much my kids wont give up their candy for any toy LOL



I saw it on Shark Tank, too. They were NOT impressed. Neither was I. Those kids don't want candy? Pass it over here!



I was going to say, I am surprised the judges on Shark Tank would like this idea.
I guess they didn't!
Seems like a stupid idea

Posted 11/2/15 9:01 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Switch witch???

My kids asked about it. I have a few friends who have peanut allergy kids who do this for their children. We use the Halloween candy to decorate our gingerbread house. We also donate some of the candy to the troops and my husbands office. They also get one piece at lunch this week. They usually make the candy last until about April, though last year we had it well into August when I threw the rest out. I would rather they learn how to ration it out. For every piece we do sit-ups, push ups, and jumping jacks before getting it. And they only got one. I would rather they develop a healthier attitude towards it than I had growing up.

Posted 11/2/15 10:21 AM
 

Funkybutt
LIF Adult

Member since 4/15

3049 total posts

Name:

Switch witch???

I'm another one that thinks it's ridiculous - and my DS has a severe nut allergy. We taught him that he can't have everything in his basket (that's for mommy later!) and that he can keep the stuff that's safe. No need to be cutsie and switch it for a toy. It's a life lesson - sucks that we have to deal with it, but he's learned that there are many things he can't have and he has to accept it.

Posted 11/2/15 10:35 AM
 

M514
Hi

Member since 8/10

6011 total posts

Name:

Switch witch???

I'm sorry I think this is ridiculous too. Halloween is all about trick or treating and getting candy! We have to teach our kids self control. We don't eat a lot of candy in this house. I just threw out some candy from Easter to make room for the new halloween candy we got.

Posted 11/2/15 10:53 AM
 

LotsaLuv
Us

Member since 6/10

4094 total posts

Name:
F

Switch witch???

I need the candy where I can see it so I can eat it. I am not sneaking candy because some switch witch is coming to take it away. My DD is a child who gets to eat candy, just like I was. I am a horrible mom, I know. I am messed up in the head because I ate candy too.

Switch witch will not be coming to this house.

Posted 11/2/15 11:57 AM
 

ohbaby08
Winter is Coming

Member since 10/07

1718 total posts

Name:

Switch witch???

My son has a peanut/nut allergy and even I find this concept ridiculous. What happened to simply telling your child "no more candy"? Now we have to pacify them with a toy instead? No, sorry.

There are plenty of candies that my son can have, he is not left out in the least from the candy gorging. I've already had to bring two bags of it to work because we ended up with so much. He got to fill up a gallon ziplock with what he wanted and the rest came to work with me. Was he happy about it? Nope. But, that's the way it is.

Posted 11/2/15 12:57 PM
 

BriBri2u
L'amore vince sempre

Member since 5/05

9320 total posts

Name:
Mrs. B

Switch witch???

Add me to the this is ridiculous list. If you are going to do this why bother with even taking your kids out?

We allowed our 5 year old to have 5-7 pieces of candy after he came home Saturday. On Sunday he was given a choice of 2 from his bucket. He will be allowed 2 more pieces going forward until its gone. Moderation is the key.

As for nut allergies, there was a lot on non nut items that were given out this year - my son's school is peanut free, so I am familiar with treats that we can bring in. I still don't think this is worth the money

Posted 11/2/15 1:55 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Biggest Loser Fans- Good Article about the witch Vicky! anonttcer 12/2/08 19 Celebrities & Entertainment
EJ met a REAL WITCH today while trick or treating! smdl 10/31/08 6 Parenting
Finger foods question- picky little witch editted w/new ? Porrruss 4/27/08 8 Parenting
Spice Girl Mel B Hires Witch Doctor to Get Eddie Murphy Back? MrsQ 12/28/06 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Watch your Back!!! There is a Witch on the prowl!! Mrs-Boop 10/8/05 18 Families Helping Families ™
At what age did you switch iffer042373 9/7/05 9 Parenting