spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by KateDevine

ITA with you....I always thought it was a positive thing, a COMMUNITY thing...

ETA-Similarily, my friend lives ona military base on Sicily, she said the BEST thing about it is the feeling of community and that they are all in it together. The kids all play together, go to everyone's houses and all of the parents pitch in...




Sig????? if so, I've been there. my cousin was stationed there.

besides the fact that the PX sold Hormel pepperoni (I died a little inside...I mean, it's friggin SICILY! Chat Icon ) I thought the sense of community there was awesome.

though honestly, (and yes, I know people think I am just sooooo unamerican Chat Icon ) most places I've been to in the world are like this. people smile at each other, even strangers...there isn't the eff you attitude you find here too often.

Message edited 2010-05-20 13:21:22.360000.

Posted 5/20/10 1:21 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by KateDevine

ITA with you....I always thought it was a positive thing, a COMMUNITY thing...

ETA-Similarily, my friend lives ona military base on Sicily, she said the BEST thing about it is the feeling of community and that they are all in it together. The kids all play together, go to everyone's houses and all of the parents pitch in...




Sig????? if so, I've been there. my cousin was stationed there.

besides the fact that the PX sold Hormel pepperoni (I died a little inside...I mean, it's friggin SICILY! Chat Icon ) I thought the sense of community there was awesome.

though honestly, (and yes, I know people think I am just sooooo unamerican Chat Icon ) most places I've been to in the world are like this. people smile at each other, even strangers...there isn't the eff you attitude you find here too often.



Yup!! Sig!! They've been there since July 07. Hers were 2 and 4 when she moved there...and she said that was the best part about it.

Chat Icon about the pepperoniChat Icon

I sorta feel there is so much fear now (rightfully so in a lot of cases) that this feeling is really gone for the most partChat Icon

ETA-I used this example b/c they are Americans, just living abroad

Message edited 2010-05-20 13:38:44.893000.

Posted 5/20/10 1:24 PM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Do I believe in the phrase? Yes.
Do I feel we live in a society that supports it? No.

I was walking through Penn Station one day and saw a small boy who couldn't have been older than 3 walking around by himself. I followed him until I saw he found a parent or the person he was with. I noticed there was one other woman who did the same thing. I can't even count how many people walked by this child without giving him a second glance.

I do have my family and friends who I believe are my own village (beyond DH of course) who I know will help out if needed.

But I don't trust that anyone else out there, any strangers, are going to watch out for me or my family. I feel as a society we have taken the MYOB philosophy too far. Obviously there are exceptions to this, but overall that is how I feel.

Posted 5/20/10 1:27 PM
 

chikita315
Love

Member since 8/06

7945 total posts

Name:
M-lo

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I believe it takes a village. When I hear village I think community of people who are involved in my child's life (other than DH and myself), grandparents, aunts/uncles, daycare providers, neighbors, teachers, friends . . .

All of these individuals are going to have some level of impact on my child's personality, morals, ethics and just who he's going to become good or bad.
I pay close attention to who/what he spends the most time with, as they will have the greatest impact.

I do to a certain extent expect them to "protect" my child, or at least let me know when something is amiss. That's why I trust these people.

Posted 5/20/10 1:28 PM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by MarisaK

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



You know what, we all do what we think is best at that time. I went inside the daycare and notified a teacher who immediately went outside to see what was going on. She continued to watch the car until the mother returned, ensuring that the child was safe. I called and spoke with the assistant director and they assured me they will speak with the mother. Bottom line, maybe I didn't have "the nerve" to tell the mother to her face (because I didn't actually see her), but at least I am comfortable knowing that I did something.

Today I was a part of the village.. I don't know what tomorrow will bring, but I will cross that bridge when I get to it.

Posted 5/20/10 1:33 PM
 

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

In my interpretation of "it takes a village"...it has nothing to do with Responsibility for the child, but rather the environment in which that child grows up and the experiences that child has. I'm not talking about inside your four walls, but every time you step outside your house.

To me, we need to choose our "villages" carefully, because these experiences shape our child just as much as what we do inside our families and homes. As well they should...there are experiences and things I can't possibly give my children, because I don't know enough about them and/or haven't experienced them myselves...From the people on Career Day who have different professions to talk about, to the person who is just back from an amazing Safari, to the person who is from another country with a vastly different culture and background, who can share those with my children, to the person who doesn't have a home to live in....all of those people give my children experiences I CAN'T...so if it weren't for my "village"...how sheltered / limited a life would she lead?

Of course our children are OUR responsiblity, and it is OUR job to expose them to these things and talk about them with them, but if we don't have a "village" where do we get the experiences?

Posted 5/20/10 1:38 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by DRMom

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Bxgell2

I think it all depends on where you live. I live in a very community-oriented area, where everyone basically knows everyone. We all watch out for each other's children at daycare, and there have been many an occasion where I have intervened on behalf of another child, brought a child home with me if mom or dad was going to be late, or alerted another parent to something I observed that would be concerning to them.

BUT, with that said, at the end of the day, my children are just that - MINE. I would never just assume that others are watching out for them, though I would hope that if Alex or Yael were ever in trouble, someone would help them if DH or I were not available for some reason.

I always tell Alex that, if she gets lost from me, to find a police officer, someone who works at the store, or, a mommy who has children with her, because, yes, to some degree, I assume that a mother will have the same instinct that I have when I see a child in danger or in need.



I agree most with this. I am using the village phrase lightly, b/c let's face it, nowadays we sometimes don't even know our next door neighbors that well.

but me, I ALWAYS look out for children that I pass in the street, if they are not near an adult, I ALWAYS stop and ask "where is your mommy/daddy" or I stand near small children at the train station as their mom struggles with another down the stairs so they don't run into the platform tracks etc.

what I am saying is, I keep an eye out. I know anything can happen in a split second, and I pray EVERY day that if Luce is ever in a situation that doesn't look kosher, someone will be doing the same.



I do the same. I have waited with lost children to find their Moms.



I agree with this. I do believe in a village mentality, but that doesn't mean I leave my child to the will of the neighborhood, I just feel comfortable knowing they are keeping an eye out also. I am lucky to live in a great community where everyone knows each other. If my 14 y/o SS is down by the pond and is misbehaving, it is going to get back to me - and HE KNOWS IT!

I don't believe in following a 14 y/o around, he needs to learn independence, but I also don't think he is going to always make the best choices and I am glad I have neighbors who will let me know when he is misbehaving. I don't take it as judgment about how I parent, just that he is a kid and WILL do things he shouldn't. Just yesterday I spoke to some 12 year old boys because they were throwing rocks at some girls, they know if I see them doing it again, I go to their moms - should I have just let them taunt the girls and hit them with rocks??

I grew up this way also, if I did something wrong and one of the other Moms in the neighborhood saw it, I was in deep sh*t, because I knew it would get back to my mom. We had RESPECT for the adults in our community, we didn't say " F you, you aren't my mom" like many kids today do.

My "village" is my neighborhood, my family, the local police etc. we all look out for each other. There are times when someone comes to me with something that I don't agree with and just let them know that we allow DSS to do such and such - just because we are a "village" doesn't mean I have to agree or go along with everything, but I am 100% happy to know my neighbors are also looking out for my children.

Posted 5/20/10 1:48 PM
 

bonitachyc
big sister status may 2012!!

Member since 5/08

3242 total posts

Name:
Lupe

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

def believe it takes a village to raise MY child. yours? i dunno, but mine, def. Chat Icon

Posted 5/20/10 1:50 PM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by MarisaK

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



Honestly now what will this do? Obviously the person endangering their child doesn't believe they are so what's the point? This would only start a confrontation. That OP did the right thing by telling school officials. That mother should know better and invest in a double stroller already. You pretty much called that OP out saying she was a coward by not talking to the mother directly. That's just ridiculous. What's horrible is seeing a baby left in a car all alone and you going on your merry way (minding your own business) because at that particular moment you saw no danger. You agree yourself this woman used poor judgement.

Posted 5/20/10 3:32 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Message edited 2010-05-22 10:27:30.200000.

Posted 5/20/10 3:44 PM
 

NS1976
My princess!

Member since 5/05

6548 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

My village is my Mom and my sister. I even gave them matching necklaces (for the 3 of us) for Mothers day symbolizing how we all have a hand in raising Megan. They are there every day teaching her about just regular life. They dont have her by themselves often, thats all me..but we are a very close family..see each other on a daily basis usually. I feel like they are my village...she learns different things from different family members. She takes a little from here and there and is just well rounded because of it. As far as community, OH HELL NO! She is MY child and my responsibility. I am not even too keen on teachers having a hand in her education to be honest..I cant explain it..I just feel like besides family, she is my daughter, my life and its all about how I raise and take care of her.

Posted 5/20/10 3:55 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Message edited 2011-11-27 18:43:34.540000.

Posted 5/20/10 4:18 PM
 

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by Hofstra26

I don't think "it takes a village". My DD is my responsibility and DH and I do EVERYTHING for her and have since she was born. That being said, it's nice to have family around to help you out when you need a break or have to run out but ultimately DH and I are on our own in raising our children which is as it should be I believe. Chat Icon



I agree

Posted 5/20/10 8:23 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

my children are MY responsibility. my village is my family and friends. i don't want or need strangers telling me their opinions or giving me their judgement. if they truly want to help me and my child, great.

Posted 5/20/10 10:22 PM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by FrankiesGirl107

In my interpretation of "it takes a village"...it has nothing to do with Responsibility for the child, but rather the environment in which that child grows up and the experiences that child has. I'm not talking about inside your four walls, but every time you step outside your house.

To me, we need to choose our "villages" carefully, because these experiences shape our child just as much as what we do inside our families and homes. As well they should...there are experiences and things I can't possibly give my children, because I don't know enough about them and/or haven't experienced them myselves...From the people on Career Day who have different professions to talk about, to the person who is just back from an amazing Safari, to the person who is from another country with a vastly different culture and background, who can share those with my children, to the person who doesn't have a home to live in....all of those people give my children experiences I CAN'T...so if it weren't for my "village"...how sheltered / limited a life would she lead?

Of course our children are OUR responsiblity, and it is OUR job to expose them to these things and talk about them with them, but if we don't have a "village" where do we get the experiences?



Exactly how I see/interpret "It takes a village". When I drop my kids off at school for the day the teachers and counselors are there to make sure he is doing the right thing. I obviously can't be there so I'm relying on them to educate and watch over him. We all have our own way of interpreting this saying...I feel we all use it though from looking at it from a school, daycare, babysitting, summer camp, day at grandmas/aunts etc.type enviorment.

I also believe it is great to have a village to speak out for the so many children out there that are misguided and abused by parents. If there was no village for them what kind of future would those kids have?

Posted 5/21/10 7:46 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by adeline27

Posted by MarisaK

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



Honestly now what will this do? Obviously the person endangering their child doesn't believe they are so what's the point? This would only start a confrontation. That OP did the right thing by telling school officials. That mother should know better and invest in a double stroller already. You pretty much called that OP out saying she was a coward by not talking to the mother directly. That's just ridiculous. What's horrible is seeing a baby left in a car all alone and you going on your merry way (minding your own business) because at that particular moment you saw no danger. You agree yourself this woman used poor judgement.



my post had nothing to do with that poster going into the school to tell the director - it was about people saying they will 'call the cops' or 'call CPS' ........

there's a big difference between walking into the daycare and telling the director - "there's a child sitting alone in the car outside' and calling the police or CPS to report a mother for neglect/abuse IMO

Posted 5/21/10 10:15 AM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by MrsGmomof3

No. Personally, my children are MY responsibilty (and DHs). I have people I can rely on if I need them, but ultimately, I do NOT subscribe to the "village" mentality.



ITA. Nobody cares about my child's well being as much as I do, except for DH.

Posted 5/21/10 10:20 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by adeline27

Posted by MarisaK

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



Honestly now what will this do? Obviously the person endangering their child doesn't believe they are so what's the point? This would only start a confrontation. That OP did the right thing by telling school officials. That mother should know better and invest in a double stroller already. You pretty much called that OP out saying she was a coward by not talking to the mother directly. That's just ridiculous. What's horrible is seeing a baby left in a car all alone and you going on your merry way (minding your own business) because at that particular moment you saw no danger. You agree yourself this woman used poor judgement.



my post had nothing to do with that poster going into the school to tell the director - it was about people saying they will 'call the cops' or 'call CPS' ........




For the record, what I said was that if I continued to see this same child left in the car alone AFTER I spoke with the director and they talked to the mother about it, THEN I would call the cops. I would not call the police as a first option the circumstances warranted it... and I understand that this situation would not warrant that.

Posted 5/21/10 10:28 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by JennyPenny

Posted by MrsGmomof3

No. Personally, my children are MY responsibilty (and DHs). I have people I can rely on if I need them, but ultimately, I do NOT subscribe to the "village" mentality.



ITA. Nobody cares about my child's well being as much as I do, except for DH.



my thing is, I realize that no one cares for or loves my son as much as his parents family, but I DO care for anyone else's child that I see. I have a general care for my fellow man, but especially children, and I feel it is my responsibility as an adult and a person in the very least keep an eye out for danger.

again, I think people are not interpreting the saying as it is truly meant, b/c some of the comments on this thread are down right defensive (qp, not talking about yours).

honestly, reading this kind of makes me sad...that people wouldn't say anything or keep an eye out for my child simply b/c he is a stranger to them.

Posted 5/21/10 10:40 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by adeline27

Posted by MarisaK

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



Honestly now what will this do? Obviously the person endangering their child doesn't believe they are so what's the point? This would only start a confrontation. That OP did the right thing by telling school officials. That mother should know better and invest in a double stroller already. You pretty much called that OP out saying she was a coward by not talking to the mother directly. That's just ridiculous. What's horrible is seeing a baby left in a car all alone and you going on your merry way (minding your own business) because at that particular moment you saw no danger. You agree yourself this woman used poor judgement.



I don't want to speak for Marisa, but I think this comment was based on the OP of the other post saying that she would be calling the police instead of talking to the Mother.

Posted 5/21/10 10:50 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I'm surprised so many take this phrase to be a negative thing. I see it less as people poking their nose in my business and more as a support network in the community, which is a wonderful thing to have. Years ago, I think families often filled this roll, but not everyone lives near family at all today.

We have no family close to us, and it has been very important to me to make connections with other parents in our town. Some have been incredibly helpful and supportive--when my husband was diagnosed with cancer, I can't tell you how many women offered to watch our son if needed for doctor visits or an emergency. It was heart-warming to have so many people offer to help with childcare, shopping, and just plain reaching out and asking how DH was doing. I met most of these mothers through the library and Mommy & Me programs, and we have had playdates with our kids for a long time.

So it takes a village to me is a positivie idea, it means you have people besides DH who are there to offer help and support to the parents (as well as the children) when needed.


Posted 5/21/10 11:00 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by DRMom

Posted by adeline27

Posted by MarisaK

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



Honestly now what will this do? Obviously the person endangering their child doesn't believe they are so what's the point? This would only start a confrontation. That OP did the right thing by telling school officials. That mother should know better and invest in a double stroller already. You pretty much called that OP out saying she was a coward by not talking to the mother directly. That's just ridiculous. What's horrible is seeing a baby left in a car all alone and you going on your merry way (minding your own business) because at that particular moment you saw no danger. You agree yourself this woman used poor judgement.



I don't want to speak for Marisa, but I think this comment was based on the OP of the other post saying that she would be calling the police instead of talking to the Mother.



OK, as the OP, I feel as though what I said was taken the wrong way. From these comments, it is as though I said I was going to immediately call the cops. Not my point at all. I clarified this above, but will try one more time. I said that if AFTER speaking to the director (which I did) and the director speaks with the mother (which they did)... if I continue to see the same child being left alone in the car, I would call the cops. I don't feel at all bad about saying that. I believe that would be my way of being a "villager" and watching out for a child's welfare.

I belive that if a parent has fair warning that the daycare does not agree with her leaving her son unattended in the car and she is told that there were other concerned parents as well... it would not be a smart move to continue to leave your child unattended in a public parking lot after that.

Posted 5/21/10 11:04 AM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by KateDevine

Can I ask why people keep using the word "responsibility"??

I never thought of this expression or the idea behind it having to do with responsibilities....

I'm confusedChat Icon Chat Icon



I used the word responsibility.

The OP stated somewhere that she "looks out" for children who seem to have no adult around, and stands close to moms who are struggling and things of that nature.

If I were a "struggling" mom, I would be seriously offended if some stranger lurked about "in case" I screwed up and my kid fell, MY child, my responsibilty to make sure that he/she is safe, NO one elses job. I am a MYOB type.

Unless there is a clear and present DANGER, I do not appreciate strangers comments, offers of "help" (because lets be real, in this day and age, how can you know if someone REALLY has good intentions), etc.

Message edited 2010-05-21 12:24:32.877000.

Posted 5/21/10 12:22 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by jerseypanda

Posted by DRMom

Posted by adeline27

Posted by MarisaK

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



Honestly now what will this do? Obviously the person endangering their child doesn't believe they are so what's the point? This would only start a confrontation. That OP did the right thing by telling school officials. That mother should know better and invest in a double stroller already. You pretty much called that OP out saying she was a coward by not talking to the mother directly. That's just ridiculous. What's horrible is seeing a baby left in a car all alone and you going on your merry way (minding your own business) because at that particular moment you saw no danger. You agree yourself this woman used poor judgement.



I don't want to speak for Marisa, but I think this comment was based on the OP of the other post saying that she would be calling the police instead of talking to the Mother.



OK, as the OP, I feel as though what I said was taken the wrong way. From these comments, it is as though I said I was going to immediately call the cops. Not my point at all. I clarified this above, but will try one more time. I said that if AFTER speaking to the director (which I did) and the director speaks with the mother (which they did)... if I continue to see the same child being left alone in the car, I would call the cops. I don't feel at all bad about saying that. I believe that would be my way of being a "villager" and watching out for a child's welfare.

I belive that if a parent has fair warning that the daycare does not agree with her leaving her son unattended in the car and she is told that there were other concerned parents as well... it would not be a smart move to continue to leave your child unattended in a public parking lot after that.



I agree with you-her behavior should change after they talk to her. I guess when you first posted it it sounded like if you saw her do it the next day then you would call the police...I mean what if daycare did not speak to her yet KWIM? Chat Icon

Posted 5/21/10 12:34 PM
 

jprimrose
I love my little munchkins!

Member since 10/05

3939 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by jerseypanda

Do I believe in the phrase? Yes.
Do I feel we live in a society that supports it? No.

I was walking through Penn Station one day and saw a small boy who couldn't have been older than 3 walking around by himself. I followed him until I saw he found a parent or the person he was with. I noticed there was one other woman who did the same thing. I can't even count how many people walked by this child without giving him a second glance.

I do have my family and friends who I believe are my own village (beyond DH of course) who I know will help out if needed.

But I don't trust that anyone else out there, any strangers, are going to watch out for me or my family. I feel as a society we have taken the MYOB philosophy too far. Obviously there are exceptions to this, but overall that is how I feel.



ITA with everything you wrote.

Posted 5/21/10 12:39 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Bridget Moynahan takes a walk in the West Village with a friend, 12/16 MrsQ 12/19/06 3 Celebrities & Entertainment
bush takes responsibility june262004 9/13/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Which place takes the best pics???? Dani00518 9/10/05 0 Parenting
Ryan Seacrest takes over New Years Rockin Eve from Di*k Clark Elbee 8/16/05 24 Families Helping Families ™
Calling all Lindenhurst Experts - Village/apt question laborday06 8/8/05 0 Home
Pedro was supposedley in Huntington Village yesterday... deedee 6/12/05 4 Sports