spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

spinoff..."IT takes a village"

do you believe in this phrase?

do you feel you have a "village" in your corner?

do you feel you can rely on eyes other than yours to look to the protection of your children?

or

do you feel like people are too isolated into their own lives?

or other....what is your take? both on a personal level and then on our society at large...are we an "it takes a village" society?

Posted 5/20/10 11:39 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

No. Personally, my children are MY responsibilty (and DHs). I have people I can rely on if I need them, but ultimately, I do NOT subscribe to the "village" mentality.

Posted 5/20/10 11:43 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I think people take this to the extreme and are WAY too quick to jump in and tell a parent what they;re doing 'wrong' - I also think, as you said yourself in the other thread, that it's my responsibility to speak to my fellow villager directly, and not call the constable on her Chat Icon

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.

Posted 5/20/10 11:44 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I think it all depends on where you live. I live in a very community-oriented area, where everyone basically knows everyone. We all watch out for each other's children at daycare, and there have been many an occasion where I have intervened on behalf of another child, brought a child home with me if mom or dad was going to be late, or alerted another parent to something I observed that would be concerning to them.

BUT, with that said, at the end of the day, my children are just that - MINE. I would never just assume that others are watching out for them, though I would hope that if Alex or Yael were ever in trouble, someone would help them if DH or I were not available for some reason.

I always tell Alex that, if she gets lost from me, to find a police officer, someone who works at the store, or, a mommy who has children with her, because, yes, to some degree, I assume that a mother will have the same instinct that I have when I see a child in danger or in need.

Posted 5/20/10 11:47 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by MrsGmomof3

No. Personally, my children are MY responsibilty (and DHs). I have people I can rely on if I need them, but ultimately, I do NOT subscribe to the "village" mentality.



This is me too. Strangers can stay out of my familys business and I stay out of theirs. I will ONLY get involved if there is a CLEAR case of abuse or neglect. Not bc of different parenting styles or bad judgment calls. This doesnt mean I dont care, or agree with certain things, just that its not my place to get involved.

My parents, siblings, ILs, as are DS teachers, are more than welcome to get involved in his life or what I do with him, everyone else can mind their own business and then to their children.

Posted 5/20/10 11:49 AM
 

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Since DD#1 started school and I have become very involved at school and the community, I will YES! If asked this question 5 years ago, I would have said no.

ETA: I went back and read the responses and I think that I view the whole It takes a Village differently than the Previous Posters. I do not look at it as being in people business or them in mine. I just mean that I can count of them to watch out for the best interest of my kids when I am not around and count on them to help me out reguarding my kids(ie. rides home, watching them at a school event, helping them if they were hurt) things like that. I have neighbors that pick up scripts for my kids at CVS, drop off homework, offer to take the baby while I am at school confrences. That is my kind of villageChat Icon

Message edited 2010-05-20 11:56:25.247000.

Posted 5/20/10 11:49 AM
 

RandiG
Love my Boys!

Member since 7/09

4440 total posts

Name:
Randi

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

It depends how literal we take the statement. I mean we all rely on each other, on this very site, to ask questions and get information. So in a way this is one of our many mini-villages. Family members, friends and doctors could also be considered.

I don't really count on others to watch and protect my child, but I know that there are many people out there (some that I may not even know) that would. Don't get me wrong I don't consider myself naive and I know that not everyone in the world means well.

Posted 5/20/10 11:50 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by Bxgell2

I think it all depends on where you live. I live in a very community-oriented area, where everyone basically knows everyone. We all watch out for each other's children at daycare, and there have been many an occasion where I have intervened on behalf of another child, brought a child home with me if mom or dad was going to be late, or alerted another parent to something I observed that would be concerning to them.

BUT, with that said, at the end of the day, my children are just that - MINE. I would never just assume that others are watching out for them, though I would hope that if Alex or Yael were ever in trouble, someone would help them if DH or I were not available for some reason.

I always tell Alex that, if she gets lost from me, to find a police officer, someone who works at the store, or, a mommy who has children with her, because, yes, to some degree, I assume that a mother will have the same instinct that I have when I see a child in danger or in need.



I agree most with this. I am using the village phrase lightly, b/c let's face it, nowadays we sometimes don't even know our next door neighbors that well.

but me, I ALWAYS look out for children that I pass in the street, if they are not near an adult, I ALWAYS stop and ask "where is your mommy/daddy" or I stand near small children at the train station as their mom struggles with another down the stairs so they don't run into the platform tracks etc.

what I am saying is, I keep an eye out. I know anything can happen in a split second, and I pray EVERY day that if Luce is ever in a situation that doesn't look kosher, someone will be doing the same.

Posted 5/20/10 11:51 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I don't think "it takes a village". My DD is my responsibility and DH and I do EVERYTHING for her and have since she was born. That being said, it's nice to have family around to help you out when you need a break or have to run out but ultimately DH and I are on our own in raising our children which is as it should be I believe. Chat Icon

Posted 5/20/10 11:52 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by MarisaK

I think people take this to the extreme and are WAY too quick to jump in and tell a parent what they;re doing 'wrong' - I also think, as you said yourself in the other thread, that it's my responsibility to speak to my fellow villager directly, and not call the constable on her Chat Icon

If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.



I agree 100%.

People are also WAY to quick to tell parents what they are doing just b/c in their mind *they* would never parent that way, but who are we to say so. If they are abusing their child in front of me then of course my a* * would speak up but for example I got berated at brunch the other day by THREE waitresses on where my son was sitting (obviously the first woman told the other women to confront me about it) it was embarassing, uncalled for and I was SO ANNOYED. I would never put my son in harms way but for someone to judge me like that I wanted to explode (which I did by the time the 3rd person came over to me)

ETA- It's one thing to have a village of supportive/helpful people but it's another thing to have a village of people telling me how *I* should be caring for my son, KWIM?

Message edited 2010-05-20 12:07:48.377000.

Posted 5/20/10 11:53 AM
 

doublestroller
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

1179 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by MarisaK
If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.

okay, while you and i are on the same page re:calling cops and CPS, i have a question to pose...

if there was legitimate concerns, if there was an issue...with all the wackos out there, wouldn't you be concerned for your safety and the safety of your child?

an example...

back when i was young and we were living in an apartment, my mother felt as though there was a bad situation in one of the homes. she had no concrete evidence, but if one had to take a bet, she'd probably unfortunately win...

it was a real on the fence kind of thing and she never did anything about it. why? because she was concerned for MY safety and retaliation from a crazy person.

where does one draw the line? it's a tough question to answer...

Posted 5/20/10 11:53 AM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by Hofstra26

I don't think "it takes a village". My DD is my responsibility and DH and I do EVERYTHING for her and have since she was born. That being said, it's nice to have family around to help you out when you need a break or have to run out but ultimately DH and I are on our own in raising our children which is as it should be I believe. Chat Icon



Totally agree.

Posted 5/20/10 11:56 AM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I absolutely believe that it takes a village to raise a child. My son is constantly learning about life through each experience we have outside the home. These lessons will make significant contributions to his demeanor, choices and affect later on. Natural supports are everywhere..and this, to me, is the concept of 'it takes a village'....not that I'll leave him with just anyone to be raised. But in essense, we are all influencing and thus helping to raise the children of our community...whether by a smile at the grocery store, a vote for yes or no on the school budget, keeping your front yard clean or unkempt, holding the door for the next person or not, driver ettiquette, clothing and grooming norms....etc. These things all make an impact on a child's concept of the world and therefore his/her interaction with the world. Choose your village wisely and be observant to the things your babies are taking in...then you can bring those lessons home and fine tune it with your values.

Posted 5/20/10 11:56 AM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

There is no way for me to know everything, so in that aspect it does take a village. I am lucky to have a lot of family and close friends. We each help and support each other. Each of them have an influence on my child's upbringing. However in the end it is really DH and I that do the raising of our children. Our village just helps us along the way.

Posted 5/20/10 11:58 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I am on this strong effort to make a change in my county, but I know it is falling on deaf ears.

I maybe wrong in my thought process, so I have to leave it at to each their own.

I live in a county where there is a drastic difference in income levels. Some are in million dollar homes on golf courses, while others , closer to the SC border are in trailers.

My sister is a sub teacher for the county. She did her student teaching in Harlem, so you can imagine her surprise when a cart holding mac books came through the 4th grade class and each child grabbed theirs.
Then she goes to a different school...where this would never go on. Pencils had to be handed out. In the same county, 40 mins away from each other.

I am friendly with a guidance counselor in the top school from our county. I told her this. She said yeah, it is a big problem. Parents in these schools help with fundraisers.
At our grocery store, you can link up your savings card to have a percentage donated to "your" school. This goes to your school's funds.

So I found out about this, changed it from our school...which is a really good school...and made the switch to a lesser school. I explained to my mom friends that they should do the same. They did not get it.

They don't want money taken from their child's schools.
There is no big picture view at all.
I am just trying to make my kids' village better.

Posted 5/20/10 12:01 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by ChrisDee

Since DD#1 started school and I have become very involved at school and the community, I will YES! If asked this question 5 years ago, I would have said no.

ETA: I went back and read the responses and I think that I view the whole It takes a Village differently than the Previous Posters. I do not look at it as being in people business or them in mine. I just mean that I can count of them to watch out for the best interest of my kids when I am not around and count on them to help me out reguarding my kids(ie. rides home, watching them at a school event, helping them if they were hurt) things like that. I have neighbors that pick up scripts for my kids at CVS, drop off homework, offer to take the baby while I am at school confrences. That is my kind of villageChat Icon



ITA with this....

I think of "it taking a village" as a positive thing, not a negative thing

Posted 5/20/10 12:06 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Can I ask why people keep using the word "responsibility"??

I never thought of this expression or the idea behind it having to do with responsibilities....

I'm confusedChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/20/10 12:08 PM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by ChrisDee


ETA: I went back and read the responses and I think that I view the whole It takes a Village differently than the Previous Posters. I do not look at it as being in people business or them in mine. I just mean that I can count of them to watch out for the best interest of my kids when I am not around and count on them to help me out reguarding my kids(ie. rides home, watching them at a school event, helping them if they were hurt) things like that. I have neighbors that pick up scripts for my kids at CVS, drop off homework, offer to take the baby while I am at school confrences. That is my kind of villageChat Icon



I just went back and did the same and realized I read it differently too and just updated my post Chat Icon but I agree with what you added here

Posted 5/20/10 12:09 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by ChrisDee

Since DD#1 started school and I have become very involved at school and the community, I will YES! If asked this question 5 years ago, I would have said no.

ETA: I went back and read the responses and I think that I view the whole It takes a Village differently than the Previous Posters. I do not look at it as being in people business or them in mine. I just mean that I can count of them to watch out for the best interest of my kids when I am not around and count on them to help me out reguarding my kids(ie. rides home, watching them at a school event, helping them if they were hurt) things like that. I have neighbors that pick up scripts for my kids at CVS, drop off homework, offer to take the baby while I am at school confrences. That is my kind of villageChat Icon



THIS I agree with - If your view of 'village' means you can count on people to HELP you, and be willing to offer that same HELP to others, rather than go behind your back to alert the authorities when they think you're wrong - I'm all for the village - that's not the 'village' idea I was getting from the other thread

Posted 5/20/10 12:20 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by doublestroller

Posted by MarisaK
If you really truly have an issue w/ someone ;endangering their child' - have the nerve to tell them TO THEIR FACE.

okay, while you and i are on the same page re:calling cops and CPS, i have a question to pose...

if there was legitimate concerns, if there was an issue...with all the wackos out there, wouldn't you be concerned for your safety and the safety of your child?

an example...

back when i was young and we were living in an apartment, my mother felt as though there was a bad situation in one of the homes. she had no concrete evidence, but if one had to take a bet, she'd probably unfortunately win...

it was a real on the fence kind of thing and she never did anything about it. why? because she was concerned for MY safety and retaliation from a crazy person.

where does one draw the line? it's a tough question to answer...



Agreed, which is why I MYOB. It's my responsibility to protect MY kids - at any cost. If someone is arrogant or crazy enough to beat their kid in plain sight of me, well, THAT parent shouldn't be shocked to find CPS knocking on her door - but the woman who made the poor judgement call to leave her kid in the car ????? - Not exactly a lunatic IMO - KWIM?

Posted 5/20/10 12:23 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Bxgell2

I think it all depends on where you live. I live in a very community-oriented area, where everyone basically knows everyone. We all watch out for each other's children at daycare, and there have been many an occasion where I have intervened on behalf of another child, brought a child home with me if mom or dad was going to be late, or alerted another parent to something I observed that would be concerning to them.

BUT, with that said, at the end of the day, my children are just that - MINE. I would never just assume that others are watching out for them, though I would hope that if Alex or Yael were ever in trouble, someone would help them if DH or I were not available for some reason.

I always tell Alex that, if she gets lost from me, to find a police officer, someone who works at the store, or, a mommy who has children with her, because, yes, to some degree, I assume that a mother will have the same instinct that I have when I see a child in danger or in need.



I agree most with this. I am using the village phrase lightly, b/c let's face it, nowadays we sometimes don't even know our next door neighbors that well.

but me, I ALWAYS look out for children that I pass in the street, if they are not near an adult, I ALWAYS stop and ask "where is your mommy/daddy" or I stand near small children at the train station as their mom struggles with another down the stairs so they don't run into the platform tracks etc.

what I am saying is, I keep an eye out. I know anything can happen in a split second, and I pray EVERY day that if Luce is ever in a situation that doesn't look kosher, someone will be doing the same.



I do the same. I have waited with lost children to find their Moms.

Posted 5/20/10 12:25 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I believe it to some extent. I don't believe that other people are responsible for my child but I certainly have a village (my mom, my sister) available to help me out.

On the flip side, I'm willing to help other people out with their kids too.

If I see a child in imminent danger, I'd stop it. (not talking about in a car, in a car seat).

Examples - I saw a 2.5 year old scale a playground fence in less than a minute & run toward the docks. The parent was watching her other child. The kid was already over the fence before I could even get up so I called to the child's mom, watched the other child while she jumped the fence to get her kid.

If I see a child walking around without a parent, I stop & keep an eye on them until I see a parent is with them.

Posted 5/20/10 12:32 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by KateDevine

Can I ask why people keep using the word "responsibility"??

I never thought of this expression or the idea behind it having to do with responsibilities....

I'm confusedChat Icon Chat Icon



yeah, me too.

I think there is a huge difference between being a nosy neighbor and the idea of people looking out for each other.

I've never come across anyone that was angry that I tried to shield their child from potential danger...and even if I did, I wouldn't care. my concern is for the defenseless child, not the defensive parent.

I am not talking about "you should be breastfeeding" or "you shouldn't let him walk in the grass" I am talking about "hey little girl, have a piece of candy" says the pervy man or "omg, that little boy is playing in the street" and running to get him instead of telling the parent they "should have" been more "responsible" for their child.

I don't wait for a disaster to say what someone should have done or to comment on the short comings of others. I see what I can do to avert it, since disaster could strike even the most vigilant parent and worse, any child.

it IS an EXTREMELY positive thing in my view.

Posted 5/20/10 1:07 PM
 

sleepie76
enjoying every minute

Member since 12/07

3881 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

I hope it doesnt take a village, cause I dont have one. Sometimes I wish I did.
It's DH and myself for the most part.
I dont have people that are readily available to watch my child.


I do watch out for other children when out. I've stopped little kids from booking out of stores, stood by a child that looked lost in the supermarket waiting for mommy to show up, things like that.

Posted 5/20/10 1:10 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: spinoff..."IT takes a village"

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by KateDevine

Can I ask why people keep using the word "responsibility"??

I never thought of this expression or the idea behind it having to do with responsibilities....

I'm confusedChat Icon Chat Icon



yeah, me too.

I think there is a huge difference between being a nosy neighbor and the idea of people looking out for each other.

I've never come across anyone that was angry that I tried to shield their child from potential danger...and even if I did, I wouldn't care. my concern is for the defenseless child, not the defensive parent.

I am not talking about "you should be breastfeeding" or "you shouldn't let him walk in the grass" I am talking about "hey little girl, have a piece of candy" says the pervy man or "omg, that little boy is playing in the street" and running to get him instead of telling the parent they "should have" been more "responsible" for their child.

I don't wait for a disaster to say what someone should have done or to comment on the short comings of others. I see what I can do to avert it, since disaster could strike even the most vigilant parent and worse, any child.

it IS an EXTREMELY positive thing in my view.



ITA with you....I always thought it was a positive thing, a COMMUNITY thing...

ETA-Similarily, my friend lives ona military base on Sicily, she said the BEST thing about it is the feeling of community and that they are all in it together. The kids all play together, go to everyone's houses and all of the parents pitch in...

Message edited 2010-05-20 13:18:01.183000.

Posted 5/20/10 1:16 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Bridget Moynahan takes a walk in the West Village with a friend, 12/16 MrsQ 12/19/06 3 Celebrities & Entertainment
bush takes responsibility june262004 9/13/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Which place takes the best pics???? Dani00518 9/10/05 0 Parenting
Ryan Seacrest takes over New Years Rockin Eve from Di*k Clark Elbee 8/16/05 24 Families Helping Families ™
Calling all Lindenhurst Experts - Village/apt question laborday06 8/8/05 0 Home
Pedro was supposedley in Huntington Village yesterday... deedee 6/12/05 4 Sports