Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

Posted By Message

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

Discuss.

I love her, I don't get why everyone hates her so much.

And I kinda agreed with her talking back the other night--they berate her and they don't do it to anyone else, regardless of some of the poor song choices i've seen..

Posted 5/13/11 11:22 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bea559
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/10

457 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I never cared for her sound or style since the audtions. I'll admit, she has had some good moments but overall, I don't enjoy her singing as much as the remaining contestants.

Also, I really dislike the way she carries herself during the judges' critiques. As a viewer, I get the impression that she thinks she's the best up there and that the judges have some nerve saying she wasn't perfect when she thinks she is. I don't feel she shows confidence. I feel she's very self-centered, like the whole show has gone to her head in a bad way. If she showed more appreciation for the experience, I probably wouldn't dislike her as much.

Posted 5/13/11 11:29 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I don't get it.

I don't understand (and I apologize to amL220 for using your words specifically but you posted right before I started typing Chat Icon ) how people think they see self-centeredness in the 3 or 4 minutes you get of her NOT singing per show. Not to mention that to have this kind of career, you NEED to be self-centered, because you don't get very far worrying about anyone else in that business.

I will say that she doesn't know how to take criticism and keep smiling... but she wants to win and what's wrong with that? I don't want anyone who doesn't want to win up there. I don't want anyone who doesn't THINK they can win up there. She's been beaten down a lot -- a lot more than some of the others too.

I mean James did a bad job 2 weeks ago and he got praised for his emotion. Lauren punked out on the highest note in her song 2 weeks ago and they barely said a word about it. For weeks and weeks, Scotty's been a one-trick pony and he gets smothered in praise.

Ryan asked who was the best during round 1 on Tuesday night and all Randy could say was that Haley was the worst. Even if it was true, that wasn't what was asked and it HAD to hurt. She shows her frustration where others may just smile, but to me, that means she's real and not trying to fake it.

Posted 5/13/11 11:46 AM
 

kelkel09
Love my twins!!!

Member since 6/10

5183 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

i think she has had a few really good performances. Most times though, I just feel like she is screaming and doesn't sound good.

i also don't like how she has an attitude with the judges. They are tough on her (and I think they should even be tougher on the other constestants to help make them better) but I think she should learn how to take constructive criticism without rolling her eyes and stuff.

Posted 5/13/11 11:54 AM
 

bea559
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/10

457 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

Posted by eroxgirl

I don't get it.

I don't understand (and I apologize to amL220 for using your words specifically but you posted right before I started typing Chat Icon ) how people think they see self-centeredness in the 3 or 4 minutes you get of her NOT singing per show. Not to mention that to have this kind of career, you NEED to be self-centered, because you don't get very far worrying about anyone else in that business.

I will say that she doesn't know how to take criticism and keep smiling... but she wants to win and what's wrong with that? I don't want anyone who doesn't want to win up there. I don't want anyone who doesn't THINK they can win up there. She's been beaten down a lot -- a lot more than some of the others too.

I mean James did a bad job 2 weeks ago and he got praised for his emotion. Lauren punked out on the highest note in her song 2 weeks ago and they barely said a word about it. For weeks and weeks, Scotty's been a one-trick pony and he gets smothered in praise.

Ryan asked who was the best during round 1 on Tuesday night and all Randy could say was that Haley was the worst. Even if it was true, that wasn't what was asked and it HAD to hurt. She shows her frustration where others may just smile, but to me, that means she's real and not trying to fake it.



Not a prob Chat Icon

I didn't want to use "self-centered" - cause you are 100% right - that is a part of having a career in the music industry.

I guess I just don't feel she is grateful for her experience. It's just the vibe I get from her video packages and performances.

Voice-wise, she screams and yells and growls IMO. It just isn't for me.

Neither is country music but I find myself enjoying those performances in comparison to hers...

I think I am getting too old for Idol lol I'll stick to the 90's alternative on my ipod


Chat Icon

Posted 5/13/11 12:08 PM
 

BriBri2u
L'amore vince sempre

Member since 5/05

9320 total posts

Name:
Mrs. B

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I can't stand the smug attitude she has when she isn't getting praised. She's done it before the other night as well.

She was the worst in the first round this week - she screamed the entire song out and she stood there rolling her eyes & talking back to the judges.

That rubs people the wrong - you've been performing on national tv for a little over 2 months and all the sudden your Celine Dion & above the critiscm. Chat Icon Thats going to turn a lot of people off.

I truly believe James should have stayed over her. He is more talented and knows who he is (I'm no fan of his style of music either...I prefer Scotty over all of them).

Haley just got comfortable in a genre the last month or so. Before that she was all over the spectrum.

She can sing, some of my favorite recent performances have been hers. Her mannerisms and facial expressions make me cringe the entire time she is performing though, I can't watch her perform.

Posted 5/13/11 12:20 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I think, for me, there are too many moments where I feel like i'm listening to mediocre karaoke when i hear her sing...I don't think her voice is anything special at all, and I just scratch my head at why she is up there.

I don't feel she has that "star power" that so many past winners have. I just can't imagine her with top hits or really selling out shows...but who knows, i guess she is there for a reason. I don't hate her, but certainly don't think she deserves to be there!

Posted 5/13/11 1:30 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I wondered this myself. I didn't see a real smugness in her and wondered why she was hated so much. BUT--I will say for the first time, I did see something last night that bugged me. When James just started singing his last song, they showed a scene of the other 3, and Haley was smiling a little, started mouthing the words to the song and did an air piano thing with her hands. She seemed kind of happy and focused on herself instead of paying attention to the emotional moment for James. BUT--that was the first time I really saw anything I didn't like about her personally. Also--I've been keeping an eye out trying to look for something because I know so many people hate her.

Posted 5/13/11 2:00 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I think smug describes her perfectly and that is why I don't care for her. I would prefer a more humble person to win AI.

There is a difference between confidence and arrogance.

Posted 5/13/11 2:25 PM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

to me, she has not found her true "style"

she is constantly playing chamelion...every week it is different.

not to say that her performances are not entertaining...they certainly are...but i feel like you need to be confident in your genre for american idol.

Posted 5/13/11 3:36 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

i like her.

Posted 5/13/11 5:36 PM
 

MarsB
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

1456 total posts

Name:
Martha

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I like her voice and style! IMO, it's just a tv show and I don't care enough to strongly like or dislike any of them. I take it for what it is, an entertaining contest broadcast on tv. If it was based solely on singing talent, then I'd have to go with Scotty. Again, just my opinion.

Posted 5/13/11 5:44 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

Posted by eroxgirl

I don't get it.

I don't understand (and I apologize to amL220 for using your words specifically but you posted right before I started typing Chat Icon ) how people think they see self-centeredness in the 3 or 4 minutes you get of her NOT singing per show. Not to mention that to have this kind of career, you NEED to be self-centered, because you don't get very far worrying about anyone else in that business.

I will say that she doesn't know how to take criticism and keep smiling... but she wants to win and what's wrong with that? I don't want anyone who doesn't want to win up there. I don't want anyone who doesn't THINK they can win up there. She's been beaten down a lot -- a lot more than some of the others too.

I mean James did a bad job 2 weeks ago and he got praised for his emotion. Lauren punked out on the highest note in her song 2 weeks ago and they barely said a word about it. For weeks and weeks, Scotty's been a one-trick pony and he gets smothered in praise.

Ryan asked who was the best during round 1 on Tuesday night and all Randy could say was that Haley was the worst. Even if it was true, that wasn't what was asked and it HAD to hurt. She shows her frustration where others may just smile, but to me, that means she's real and not trying to fake it.



I completely agree. I think she's the best of the bunch and I don't think you can really tell a person's personality and whether or not they are a diva based on the little they give us. Her voice is amazing and regardless of how often she changes up her style she is pretty consistently good. The same cannot be said of others.

Message edited 2011-05-13 17:52:00.003000.

Posted 5/13/11 5:51 PM
 

have2hide
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

555 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I do like her voice & she's pretty.. to me, it's just unappealing when a person "knows it"

Every time she's in a shot, you can see her eyes constantly checking herself out on the monitors.. nobody else does it that I've noticed. I think that's why people seem to think she's full of herself.

Posted 5/13/11 6:09 PM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I am with you on this her voice I think is the best .. She should win.. I dont think she is smug either

Posted 5/13/11 6:14 PM
 

VickiRG510
I'M A MOMMY!

Member since 3/09

1042 total posts

Name:
Vicki

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I think overall she is good. Probably the stronger voice of them all. However i dont like her because i think she isnt likable. She has an aloofness to her. To me its shown from day one not just from the other night. Whjere she came across like a total witch. Take the criticism & learn from it. Wether they do it to others is not her problem. Just listen & do what you will. It would benefit her much more then coming across as she did.

Posted 5/13/11 8:33 PM
 

nicopico13
that year flew!

Member since 11/09

3008 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I liked her in the beginning, but I totally see the attitude and thats why I don't care for her now. She does have a unique voice, I'll give her that, but I would rather see someone else win. She doesn't take criticism well at all, doesn't seem genuine and just comes off as very witchy IMO.

Posted 5/13/11 8:44 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I used to really dislike her as a contestant & I wasn't impressed with her singing--- but over the past few weeks she's grown on me--- I don't think she deserves to win, but I think she's improved a lot.

Posted 5/13/11 11:28 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

Posted by drpepper318

I used to really dislike her as a contestant & I wasn't impressed with her singing--- but over the past few weeks she's grown on me--- I don't think she deserves to win, but I think she's improved a lot.



ITA!!!!!!!

I think she should've been gone from the beginning, but she has certainly shown a different side over the past few weeks.

Posted 5/14/11 4:06 AM
 

SecretTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

2284 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

She has an incredible voice. I really like her. I don't understand how she is self-centered. She has an assertive attitude. She is from Chicago and not down south like a bunch of the others.

Posted 5/14/11 8:52 AM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I like her- I think she is a way better singer than Lauren..

Posted 5/14/11 2:27 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

Posted by Diana712

I am with you on this her voice I think is the best .. She should win.. I dont think she is smug either



ITA

I don't think Lauren is ready to be an AI. Scotty, sorry....just not an AI to me. I think Haley is the one who should win.

Posted 5/14/11 4:45 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I simply don't she's any good. Her voice annoys me

Posted 5/15/11 9:25 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?

I just don't think she's a good singer, and really should have been booted long ago. I'm baffled that she has had such staying power.

As for the criticism, it was well-deserved IMO, but I do agree there has not been much criticism this season in general. So in that sense, maybe it wasn't so fair.

Posted 5/15/11 10:04 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
x Michi 6/2/05 13 Families Helping Families ™
I HATE MOSQUITOS!! KPtoys 5/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Embarrassing thing you'd hate to admit. Lichi 5/25/05 24 Families Helping Families ™
gilmore girls - i hate tivo!!! saraH 5/17/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
I HATE being a flippin' infant!!! Shorty 5/13/05 22 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff: what do you hate of your so? Tany 5/13/05 39 Families Helping Families ™