Re: Spinoff--why does everyone hate Haley on AI?
Posted 5/13/2011 12:08:12 PM by bea559
Posted by eroxgirl
I don't get it.
I don't understand (and I apologize to amL220 for using your words specifically but you posted right before I started typing ) how people think they see self-centeredness in the 3 or 4 minutes you get of her NOT singing per show. Not to mention that to have this kind of career, you NEED to be self-centered, because you don't get very far worrying about anyone else in that business.
I will say that she doesn't know how to take criticism and keep smiling... but she wants to win and what's wrong with that? I don't want anyone who doesn't want to win up there. I don't want anyone who doesn't THINK they can win up there. She's been beaten down a lot -- a lot more than some of the others too.
I mean James did a bad job 2 weeks ago and he got praised for his emotion. Lauren punked out on the highest note in her song 2 weeks ago and they barely said a word about it. For weeks and weeks, Scotty's been a one-trick pony and he gets smothered in praise.
Ryan asked who was the best during round 1 on Tuesday night and all Randy could say was that Haley was the worst. Even if it was true, that wasn't what was asked and it HAD to hurt. She shows her frustration where others may just smile, but to me, that means she's real and not trying to fake it.
Not a prob
I didn't want to use "self-centered" - cause you are 100% right - that is a part of having a career in the music industry.
I guess I just don't feel she is grateful for her experience. It's just the vibe I get from her video packages and performances.
Voice-wise, she screams and yells and growls IMO. It just isn't for me.
Neither is country music but I find myself enjoying those performances in comparison to hers...
I think I am getting too old for Idol lol I'll stick to the 90's alternative on my ipod
|