Spinoff to abortion post...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by maybebaby The topic of abortion makes my head spin. The thought of a woman being forced to give birth to an unwanted child makes me sad...and i don't really think its realistic to expect that a woman should carry a baby she doesn't want. But it still doesn't change my feelings about abortion itself. If i feel that an abortion is legalized murder, how can I say its OK? To me its morally horrifying. BUT that is ME. Would I do it? Absolutely not. But I recognize that people have very very different views on exactly when life starts. To me, putting a viability date on it doesn't make sense. I mean we can all say "20 weeks and before is ok, but not after". So a 19 week fetus (which is very much a baby) is OK to abort, yet one week later it's saved from that fate. THAT is what doesn't make sense to me. One week doesn't make much of a difference in terms of how the baby looks, feels, moves, reacts to pain etc...it just morally does not sit right with me and people can think I'm crazy, but I have actually been reduced to tears thinking about it what a baby goes through. I listed to the replies and words with respect and an open mind. I've written this before in past topics about abortion..but I DO understand why a woman would have one. I've never been a 15 year old girl who became pregnant, nor have I been raped and became pregnant as a result. I can't imagine the torture a woman goes through to have to make that decision.....and I would never ever begin to crucify them for it. I just want to see CHANGE in this country where this topic is concerned. A huge reduction in the need for them as well as women being very proactive with their birth control choices!! Sorry I got off topic!! i pretty much agree with this like i've said before, it all depends on what you believe. there is no right or wrong answer here. we all believe in this topic differently.
|
|
Posted 3/6/12 5:46 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by marianne13 Posted by BeachGrl I have also seen the opposite happen which is just as wrong. A woman doesn't tell her boyfriend she is pregnant till about 4 or 5 months, pretty much not giving the MAN his right to his CHOICE, and having the baby regardless of how he felt about it. I think if we're going to sit here and say the man has no choice bc it's not his body it's happening to, well what about if he CHOOSES not to be a father yet and the woman purposely doesn't tell him she's pregnant till it's too late?! Is that fair?? That's why as much as I see the point about it being her body, I also agree with the 50/50 rule, with it being half his choice too. If a woman wants the right to choose, then it should be a 2 way street and the man should have the same rights too. What should be done in that situation? If the man wants to abort and the woman doesn't? Should she be pinned down and forced to have an abortion? Is that what you mean by a man having rights? That's even more barberic than taking away a woman's right to choose! i think you're getting a little ahead of yourself here with this statement. no one is saying they would FORCE someone to have an abortion because the father doesn't want the child. if the father doesn\t want the child, then he can opt out. i think in a situation where the father wants to have the child, it would only be fair that his opinion be considered, because ethically and morrally, that child is just as much his as hers, and he should have the right to have his child. but as far as him not wanting the child, and forcing a woman to have an abortion, no one said or implyed that. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 5:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Yes |
|
Posted 3/6/12 6:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by BeachMom No. Ultimately it is the woman who has to carry the child and it is a medical procedure on a woman. Once men have the option of having kids then they have a say.
|
|
Posted 3/6/12 6:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by marianne13 Does anyone really think that any woman who is forced to have a baby (whether it be by the government or by the man who got her pregnant) is really going to try to have a healthy pregnancy? Do you really think she is going to read books, take vitamins, and do everything happy, excited, pregnant women do? Have you thought about all the ways women could try to intentionally miscarry if their choices are taken away and they don't want a baby? How is that fair for the woman or the fetus? ITA |
|
Posted 3/6/12 6:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by marianne13 Posted by BeachGrl I have also seen the opposite happen which is just as wrong. A woman doesn't tell her boyfriend she is pregnant till about 4 or 5 months, pretty much not giving the MAN his right to his CHOICE, and having the baby regardless of how he felt about it. I think if we're going to sit here and say the man has no choice bc it's not his body it's happening to, well what about if he CHOOSES not to be a father yet and the woman purposely doesn't tell him she's pregnant till it's too late?! Is that fair?? That's why as much as I see the point about it being her body, I also agree with the 50/50 rule, with it being half his choice too. If a woman wants the right to choose, then it should be a 2 way street and the man should have the same rights too. What should be done in that situation? If the man wants to abort and the woman doesn't? Should she be pinned down and forced to have an abortion? Is that what you mean by a man having rights? That's even more barberic than taking away a woman's right to choose! No not at all, I just meant that the situation works both ways and I have personally seen a man get trapped into having a child even when he didn't want to bc he wasn't made aware of the pregnancy till it was too late to do anything about it. His wants and opinion were completely disregarded, and I just felt that was unfair. Just as if it is unfair for a woman to be forced to have a baby if she didn't want to. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 8:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Yes |
|
Posted 3/6/12 8:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by Summergrl73 A man's participation in a pregnancy takes about 2 seconds. A woman's takes over 9 months and physically changes her body, restricts her from many activities and takes at least 6 additional weeks to medically recover from. I think that the woman has 100% of the decision on what should be done. Well maybe she should be more careful about having unprotected sex if these consequences are too much for he to possibly have to deal with. *I am against abortion except in the event of rape or if continuing the pregnancy endangers the mothers life. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 9:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by cds58019 Posted by Summergrl73 A man's participation in a pregnancy takes about 2 seconds. A woman's takes over 9 months and physically changes her body, restricts her from many activities and takes at least 6 additional weeks to medically recover from. I think that the woman has 100% of the decision on what should be done. Well maybe she should be more careful about having unprotected sex if these consequences are too much for he to possibly have to deal with. Are you wagging your finger with one hand on your hip while saying that? That's the image in my mind. FYI, not all pregnancies are due to purposely unprotected sex. Condoms slip off and break, BC pills fail. We should just go back to the days of chastity belts and scarlet letters I think. Public stonings as well. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 9:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by Porrruss Posted by cds58019 Posted by Summergrl73 A man's participation in a pregnancy takes about 2 seconds. A woman's takes over 9 months and physically changes her body, restricts her from many activities and takes at least 6 additional weeks to medically recover from. I think that the woman has 100% of the decision on what should be done. Well maybe she should be more careful about having unprotected sex if these consequences are too much for he to possibly have to deal with. Are you wagging your finger with one hand on your hip while saying that? That's the image in my mind. FYI, not all pregnancies are due to purposely unprotected sex. Condoms slip off and break, BC pills fail. We should just go back to the days of chastity belts and scarlet letters I think. Public stonings as well. Nope, no finger wagging here. But all those products come right out and tell you tht they are only 96% or 99% effective. Meaning if you use their product you are aware that there's still that slight chance that something could happen. And if you still take that risk then you should deal with the consequences. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 10:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by HoneyBadger As with any parent, he can legally waive his right to being a parent thereby giving him no obligation to the child. Actually I don't think he can waive child support unless the mom agrees to it (or the court allows it). Barb, when I said legally, I meant through court. And yes, you can waive your right to being a parent and then not be held responsible for child support. I know someone who went through this with her ex. He was ready to legally relinquish all his rights to his unborn child thereby forsaking any responsibility. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 11:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by HoneyBadger As with any parent, he can legally waive his right to being a parent thereby giving him no obligation to the child. Actually I don't think he can waive child support unless the mom agrees to it (or the court allows it). Barb, when I said legally, I meant through court. And yes, you can waive your right to being a parent and then not be held responsible for child support. I know someone who went through this with her ex. He was ready to legally relinquish all his rights to his unborn child thereby forsaking any responsibility. Ok got it. I thought you were saying that a man can relinquish all financial responsiblities based on his own post-decision to not have a child. I believe unless the mother/guardian of a child agrees, I don't think it can be done. I know someone who has considered it but on the advice of her lawyer won't do it. Message edited 2012-03-07 00:09:03.347000. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 11:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff to abortion post... Posted by cds58019 Nope, no finger wagging here. But all those products come right out and tell you tht they are only 96% or 99% effective. Meaning if you use their product you are aware that there's still that slight chance that something could happen. And if you still take that risk then you should deal with the consequences. So then are you saying you never had sex until you were ready to start TTCing? Because, if you've had premarital or even sex for the sake of just having a roll in the hay and not for the intent to conceive you've been incredibly lucky and should count your blessings you've never had a condom break, right? Lots of people have sex, not to start a family but just because sex feels freakin' GREAT and we like doing it. To say "oh well, you knew the chances you were taking at the time, sucks for you" if someone experiences an accident (broken condom, failed bcp, etc) seems awfully harsh considering regardless of what others do you still have a right to choose whether or not you would have an abortion. I'm not saying I'm pro-abortion, I am pro-choice. I just can't in my heart of hearts force someone to have a baby they don't want to have, regardless of whether or not they knew the consequences beforehand. |
|
Posted 3/6/12 11:50 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spinoff to Overstock post.... post your OS purchases! | Jenn627 | 9/24/10 | 3 | Home |
| Another abortion spin-off b/c hey...there just aren't enough! | MissJones | 9/7/08 | 34 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| How much weight does the abortion issue bear in your decision this November? | babymakes3 | 9/6/08 | 22 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spinoff to Pro-Life/Pro-Choice: Do you think there is a difference between being Pro-Choice and Pro-Abortion? | HoneyBadger | 6/10/08 | 169 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Do you think the prompt asking "abortion" searchers "Did you mean adoption?" was a political statement | DebG | 3/22/06 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Uh-Oh!! S.D. Governor signs Abortion Ban into Law! | MrsERod | 3/6/06 | 53 | Families Helping Families ™ |



like i've said before, it all depends on what you believe. there is no right or wrong answer here. we all believe in this topic differently.







