Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

lisab7
LIF Infant

Member since 10/10

352 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by dctead

I think the fathers opinion/thoughts/feelings should be taken into consideration, however I believe the decision is ultimately the womans. Her body, her choice..



I agree 100% with this!

Posted 3/5/12 8:45 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Jan1975
.

Member since 8/09

3846 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

No way. This opens up a can of worms legally.

Posted 3/5/12 9:21 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by MrsC614

yes i believe the father should have a choice. but i also believe that life begins at conception, so i guess it depends on what you believe. i just wonder when everyone else believes life begins? i think if the father decides he wants to raise his child, he should have that right. jmo.



Completely 100% agree. I know my opinion is not the popular one, but I don't think any woman should be allowed to have an abortion without consent from the father.

Posted 3/5/12 10:02 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by wingsofsong

Posted by MrsC614

yes i believe the father should have a choice. but i also believe that life begins at conception, so i guess it depends on what you believe. i just wonder when everyone else believes life begins? i think if the father decides he wants to raise his child, he should have that right. jmo.



Completely 100% agree. I know my opinion is not the popular one, but I don't think any woman should be allowed to have an abortion without consent from the father.



Legally the fetus is not an entity until born. Once born then the father has rights. Also the only way to determine paternity for sure is a dna test which can't be done before birth.

The woman takes the brunt of everything. I see no reason that the father have the same rights. Biology dicates rights.

There would be no way I would let anyone else on this planet determine what I do with my own body, baby daddy, government or otherwise.

Posted 3/5/12 10:20 PM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by Jonsgirl04

Posted by NervousNell

Posted by dctead

I think the fathers opinion/thoughts/feelings should be taken into consideration, however I believe the decision is ultimately the womans. Her body, her choice..



Agree



I also Agree with this.



same here

Posted 3/5/12 10:30 PM
 

marianne13
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

887 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by wingsofsong

Posted by MrsC614

yes i believe the father should have a choice. but i also believe that life begins at conception, so i guess it depends on what you believe. i just wonder when everyone else believes life begins? i think if the father decides he wants to raise his child, he should have that right. jmo.



Completely 100% agree. I know my opinion is not the popular one, but I don't think any woman should be allowed to have an abortion without consent from the father.



Wow, so you believe that a woman should only be able to get an abortion with a "permission slip" from the man (whether it be a husband, boyfriend, or 1 night stand guy) who got her pregnant??

Just out of curiousity, how do you believe this sort of law should be enforced? If something this absurd ever became a law (and let's all hope nothing this crazy ever happens to this country), there would be plenty of women who would just say that they don't know who the father is because he was a random 1 night stand (and who can blame them really). What happens then when you can't supposedly locate the father? What if the father refuses to sign a permission slip and bails at 7 months? Then what? Is the child placed in foster care? Is the mother forced to raise him? If so, will she be reimbursed for all child related expenses she incurs until the child is 18?

Posted 3/5/12 11:20 PM
 

MrsC614
My little angel is here <3

Member since 7/09

2851 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by marianne13

Posted by wingsofsong

Posted by MrsC614

yes i believe the father should have a choice. but i also believe that life begins at conception, so i guess it depends on what you believe. i just wonder when everyone else believes life begins? i think if the father decides he wants to raise his child, he should have that right. jmo.



Completely 100% agree. I know my opinion is not the popular one, but I don't think any woman should be allowed to have an abortion without consent from the father.



Wow, so you believe that a woman should only be able to get an abortion with a "permission slip" from the man (whether it be a husband, boyfriend, or 1 night stand guy) who got her pregnant??

Just out of curiousity, how do you believe this sort of law should be enforced? If something this absurd ever became a law (and let's all hope nothing this crazy ever happens to this country), there would be plenty of women who would just say that they don't know who the father is because he was a random 1 night stand (and who can blame them really). What happens then when you can't supposedly locate the father? What if the father refuses to sign a permission slip and bails at 7 months? Then what? Is the child placed in foster care? Is the mother forced to raise him? If so, will she be reimbursed for all child related expenses she incurs until the child is 18?



it would have to depend on the situation. there are plenty of people who get pregnant accidentally, who are in relationships and know who the father is, and then they don't give that person the opportunity to make the decision as well. i think all the more reason to educate woman about birth control, and maybe abstinence. if you have sex, you should be prepared for the possible consequence of a pregnancy. but i think ethically, if you know who the father is, that person should have a say in the matter. it's his child too, one night stand or not. but again, this is a matter of whether or not you believe that the little being inside of a woman is a live human being, or just cells. any argument all comes back to that basic premise. is it a life, or not? forget the legality of it.

Message edited 2012-03-06 00:24:09.490000.

Posted 3/6/12 12:07 AM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by Blu-ize

Also the only way to determine paternity for sure is a dna test which can't be done before birth.






Not true.

Can be done during pregnancy via amnio or CVS.



source

Posted 3/6/12 12:45 AM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by marianne13

Posted by wingsofsong

Posted by MrsC614

yes i believe the father should have a choice. but i also believe that life begins at conception, so i guess it depends on what you believe. i just wonder when everyone else believes life begins? i think if the father decides he wants to raise his child, he should have that right. jmo.



Completely 100% agree. I know my opinion is not the popular one, but I don't think any woman should be allowed to have an abortion without consent from the father.



Wow, so you believe that a woman should only be able to get an abortion with a "permission slip" from the man (whether it be a husband, boyfriend, or 1 night stand guy) who got her pregnant??

Just out of curiousity, how do you believe this sort of law should be enforced? If something this absurd ever became a law (and let's all hope nothing this crazy ever happens to this country), there would be plenty of women who would just say that they don't know who the father is because he was a random 1 night stand (and who can blame them really). What happens then when you can't supposedly locate the father? What if the father refuses to sign a permission slip and bails at 7 months? Then what? Is the child placed in foster care? Is the mother forced to raise him? If so, will she be reimbursed for all child related expenses she incurs until the child is 18?



I'm not saying it CAN be enforced, I think that would be pretty impossible in a lot of situations. But I do believe the father SHOULD have as much say in it as the mother. The child is just as much his as hers.

Message edited 2012-03-06 00:54:53.763000.

Posted 3/6/12 12:54 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Had that 'talk' with my hubby (and every man) when we dated. I used the pill since 18 until my 30s. I demanded rubbers. I made it clear. I get pregnant before marriage I'm inclined not to keep it. I made that simple and up front before sex.

If you can't understand me, talk to me about it or agree with me or think you can talk me out of it... there's the door, Nice knowing you.

That's the father's say.

If i had gotten pregnant, sure we'd talk about it. But its my body. My decision.

Posted 3/6/12 1:24 AM
 

VanderZwang
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/11

740 total posts

Name:
Gail

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by VanderZwang

Ultimatly, its still a medical procedure on a woman.

I dont have a say if my husband wants a vasectamy, or if he has hair implants.

Or a wart removed.

Neither should he have any say about any medical procedure I have.



You really don't feel that the procedures you listed are completely different than abortion? I'm just asking. Because saying a wart removal is in the same category as the removal of a fetus seems to really devalue a human life.

I think that even most who are pro choice would feel that abortion is more than just a medical procedure...and something that involved some serious morality issues whether or not we all agree what exactly a fetus is...



I agree that those are apples and oranges, except for a vasectomy. I think that's about as close to the male equivalent of abortion that you can get. That being said, I agree that if my DH were to want it, he could get a vasectomy without my okay. Granted, it might bring an end to our relationship, but that's still his choice.

ETA: Though, maybebaby, it really depends at what stage you consider a fetus a life. You consider it "life" right at conception, but not everyone feels that way.



It may be as close to abortion as you could get...but it still doesn't involve something that has already been conceived and involved two people. It has to do with future conception, absolutely..

And like you said..i'd like to think that people would be in agreement about those things...sigh...



Sorry havent been at work to respond. I want to be clear that I say the below with respect. The "YOU" part is anyone who is using THEIR beliefs and morals to force them on me (woman).

You ask good questions.

1. I do not believe that "life" starts at conception. For me, its the potential of life, not life. It cant be sustained outside the woman untill, at LEAST 20 something weeks?

2. I believe that, although a VERY difficult decision (and all that goes with having an abortion), yes, its still JUST a medical procedure.

3. I believe that no one, on either side, will dis-suade someone from the other.

4. I believe that a womans life trumps ANY decision over any unborn fetus.

5. I believe by making archaic rules (MUST look at sono, must get parents permission, no 3rd trimester abortion, must do X before getting an abortion) that it makes women second class citizens. It puts womens lives in danger.

6. I believe, again, that a womans life is more important than the unborns.

7. And with that said, I beleieve that abortion must stay legal so WOMEN dont die. Whatever their reason's. It must be legal, and safe, and accessable.

8. I think its TORTURE to FORCE YOUR beliefs (not YOU specifically, but the religious right) on anyone. Since they believe that "life begins at conception", well, then they must make sure any woman considering an abortion MUST do things to maybe save the baby because YOU have a problem with it.

What happens if I dont have a problem with it?

9. I think, most women, CERTAINLY not all, know EXACTLY what they are they doing when they have an abortion. To make them feel worse is just disgusting and deplorable.

10. To force a woman to undergo a medical procedure, just so YOU can feel better, just do YOU can say "we tried", just so YOU can say "I forced my morals on somsone else"....is equivilant to communism.

11. And yes, I believe that I should be able to have an medical procedure without the GOVERNMENTS say. Period. I want my tubes tied? Great. I want an abortion? Great. I want a wart removed? Great.

Every law thats passed that LIMITS womens MEDICAL rights, is a law that makes this a communist state, and MAKES WOMEN second class citizens.

Every law thats passed limiting abortion is FORCING your religion on me. And lets face it, I think most people who are againt abortion are against it because of their religious beliefs. Im not saying ALL.

12. And no. Ultimatly I beleieve that the father should have no say. My body, my rules. My decision.

I submit this for discussion and in NO way want this to come off as disrespectfull. Thats not my intention.

Posted 3/6/12 11:41 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by VanderZwang

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by VanderZwang

Ultimatly, its still a medical procedure on a woman.

I dont have a say if my husband wants a vasectamy, or if he has hair implants.

Or a wart removed.

Neither should he have any say about any medical procedure I have.



You really don't feel that the procedures you listed are completely different than abortion? I'm just asking. Because saying a wart removal is in the same category as the removal of a fetus seems to really devalue a human life.

I think that even most who are pro choice would feel that abortion is more than just a medical procedure...and something that involved some serious morality issues whether or not we all agree what exactly a fetus is...



I agree that those are apples and oranges, except for a vasectomy. I think that's about as close to the male equivalent of abortion that you can get. That being said, I agree that if my DH were to want it, he could get a vasectomy without my okay. Granted, it might bring an end to our relationship, but that's still his choice.

ETA: Though, maybebaby, it really depends at what stage you consider a fetus a life. You consider it "life" right at conception, but not everyone feels that way.



It may be as close to abortion as you could get...but it still doesn't involve something that has already been conceived and involved two people. It has to do with future conception, absolutely..

And like you said..i'd like to think that people would be in agreement about those things...sigh...



Sorry havent been at work to respond. I want to be clear that I say the below with respect. The "YOU" part is anyone who is using THEIR beliefs and morals to force them on me (woman).

You ask good questions.

1. I do not believe that "life" starts at conception. For me, its the potential of life, not life. It cant be sustained outside the woman untill, at LEAST 20 something weeks?

2. I believe that, although a VERY difficult decision (and all that goes with having an abortion), yes, its still JUST a medical procedure.

3. I believe that no one, on either side, will dis-suade someone from the other.

4. I believe that a womans life trumps ANY decision over any unborn fetus.

5. I believe by making archaic rules (MUST look at sono, must get parents permission, no 3rd trimester abortion, must do X before getting an abortion) that it makes women second class citizens. It puts womens lives in danger.

6. I believe, again, that a womans life is more important than the unborns.

7. And with that said, I beleieve that abortion must stay legal so WOMEN dont die. Whatever their reason's. It must be legal, and safe, and accessable.

8. I think its TORTURE to FORCE YOUR beliefs (not YOU specifically, but the religious right) on anyone. Since they believe that "life begins at conception", well, then they must make sure any woman considering an abortion MUST do things to maybe save the baby because YOU have a problem with it.

What happens if I dont have a problem with it?

9. I think, most women, CERTAINLY not all, know EXACTLY what they are they doing when they have an abortion. To make them feel worse is just disgusting and deplorable.

10. To force a woman to undergo a medical procedure, just so YOU can feel better, just do YOU can say "we tried", just so YOU can say "I forced my morals on somsone else"....is equivilant to communism.

11. And yes, I believe that I should be able to have an medical procedure without the GOVERNMENTS say. Period. I want my tubes tied? Great. I want an abortion? Great. I want a wart removed? Great.

Every law thats passed that LIMITS womens MEDICAL rights, is a law that makes this a communist state, and MAKES WOMEN second class citizens.

Every law thats passed limiting abortion is FORCING your religion on me. And lets face it, I think most people who are againt abortion are against it because of their religious beliefs. Im not saying ALL.

12. And no. Ultimatly I beleieve that the father should have no say. My body, my rules. My decision.

I submit this for discussion and in NO way want this to come off as disrespectfull. Thats not my intention.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/6/12 12:03 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by VanderZwang

Sorry havent been at work to respond. I want to be clear that I say the below with respect. The "YOU" part is anyone who is using THEIR beliefs and morals to force them on me (woman).

You ask good questions.

1. I do not believe that "life" starts at conception. For me, its the potential of life, not life. It cant be sustained outside the woman untill, at LEAST 20 something weeks?

2. I believe that, although a VERY difficult decision (and all that goes with having an abortion), yes, its still JUST a medical procedure.

3. I believe that no one, on either side, will dis-suade someone from the other.

4. I believe that a womans life trumps ANY decision over any unborn fetus.

5. I believe by making archaic rules (MUST look at sono, must get parents permission, no 3rd trimester abortion, must do X before getting an abortion) that it makes women second class citizens. It puts womens lives in danger.

6. I believe, again, that a womans life is more important than the unborns.

7. And with that said, I beleieve that abortion must stay legal so WOMEN dont die. Whatever their reason's. It must be legal, and safe, and accessable.

8. I think its TORTURE to FORCE YOUR beliefs (not YOU specifically, but the religious right) on anyone. Since they believe that "life begins at conception", well, then they must make sure any woman considering an abortion MUST do things to maybe save the baby because YOU have a problem with it.

What happens if I dont have a problem with it?

9. I think, most women, CERTAINLY not all, know EXACTLY what they are they doing when they have an abortion. To make them feel worse is just disgusting and deplorable.

10. To force a woman to undergo a medical procedure, just so YOU can feel better, just do YOU can say "we tried", just so YOU can say "I forced my morals on somsone else"....is equivilant to communism.

11. And yes, I believe that I should be able to have an medical procedure without the GOVERNMENTS say. Period. I want my tubes tied? Great. I want an abortion? Great. I want a wart removed? Great.

Every law thats passed that LIMITS womens MEDICAL rights, is a law that makes this a communist state, and MAKES WOMEN second class citizens.

Every law thats passed limiting abortion is FORCING your religion on me. And lets face it, I think most people who are againt abortion are against it because of their religious beliefs. Im not saying ALL.

12. And no. Ultimatly I beleieve that the father should have no say. My body, my rules. My decision.

I submit this for discussion and in NO way want this to come off as disrespectfull. Thats not my intention.



I LOOOOOVE every word of this.

And I just want to throw this out there... my DH and I have 2 children. I don't really want any more. I'm on birth control pills.

My DH wants a vasectomy (sp?).

I don't want him to get one.

He's getting one anyway.

I don't like it but you know what, I don't HAVE TO LIKE IT. If I want more children I'm going to have to find another husband.

I think, in addition to all of VanderZwang's points, that is the overwhelming truth that people are forgetting. We live in a FREE (hahaha) country. We don't have to like what everyone else does. We don't have to approve of what our next door neighbor does so long as it's legal. To think that any one person has the right to say what any other person does (aside from our children) is where the problem begins.

Posted 3/6/12 12:11 PM
 

marianne13
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

887 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by VanderZwang

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by VanderZwang

Ultimatly, its still a medical procedure on a woman.

I dont have a say if my husband wants a vasectamy, or if he has hair implants.

Or a wart removed.

Neither should he have any say about any medical procedure I have.



You really don't feel that the procedures you listed are completely different than abortion? I'm just asking. Because saying a wart removal is in the same category as the removal of a fetus seems to really devalue a human life.

I think that even most who are pro choice would feel that abortion is more than just a medical procedure...and something that involved some serious morality issues whether or not we all agree what exactly a fetus is...



I agree that those are apples and oranges, except for a vasectomy. I think that's about as close to the male equivalent of abortion that you can get. That being said, I agree that if my DH were to want it, he could get a vasectomy without my okay. Granted, it might bring an end to our relationship, but that's still his choice.

ETA: Though, maybebaby, it really depends at what stage you consider a fetus a life. You consider it "life" right at conception, but not everyone feels that way.



It may be as close to abortion as you could get...but it still doesn't involve something that has already been conceived and involved two people. It has to do with future conception, absolutely..

And like you said..i'd like to think that people would be in agreement about those things...sigh...



Sorry havent been at work to respond. I want to be clear that I say the below with respect. The "YOU" part is anyone who is using THEIR beliefs and morals to force them on me (woman).

You ask good questions.

1. I do not believe that "life" starts at conception. For me, its the potential of life, not life. It cant be sustained outside the woman untill, at LEAST 20 something weeks?

2. I believe that, although a VERY difficult decision (and all that goes with having an abortion), yes, its still JUST a medical procedure.

3. I believe that no one, on either side, will dis-suade someone from the other.

4. I believe that a womans life trumps ANY decision over any unborn fetus.

5. I believe by making archaic rules (MUST look at sono, must get parents permission, no 3rd trimester abortion, must do X before getting an abortion) that it makes women second class citizens. It puts womens lives in danger.

6. I believe, again, that a womans life is more important than the unborns.

7. And with that said, I beleieve that abortion must stay legal so WOMEN dont die. Whatever their reason's. It must be legal, and safe, and accessable.

8. I think its TORTURE to FORCE YOUR beliefs (not YOU specifically, but the religious right) on anyone. Since they believe that "life begins at conception", well, then they must make sure any woman considering an abortion MUST do things to maybe save the baby because YOU have a problem with it.

What happens if I dont have a problem with it?

9. I think, most women, CERTAINLY not all, know EXACTLY what they are they doing when they have an abortion. To make them feel worse is just disgusting and deplorable.

10. To force a woman to undergo a medical procedure, just so YOU can feel better, just do YOU can say "we tried", just so YOU can say "I forced my morals on somsone else"....is equivilant to communism.

11. And yes, I believe that I should be able to have an medical procedure without the GOVERNMENTS say. Period. I want my tubes tied? Great. I want an abortion? Great. I want a wart removed? Great.

Every law thats passed that LIMITS womens MEDICAL rights, is a law that makes this a communist state, and MAKES WOMEN second class citizens.

Every law thats passed limiting abortion is FORCING your religion on me. And lets face it, I think most people who are againt abortion are against it because of their religious beliefs. Im not saying ALL.

12. And no. Ultimatly I beleieve that the father should have no say. My body, my rules. My decision.

I submit this for discussion and in NO way want this to come off as disrespectfull. Thats not my intention.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/6/12 12:27 PM
 

marianne13
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

887 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Does anyone really think that any woman who is forced to have a baby (whether it be by the government or by the man who got her pregnant) is really going to try to have a healthy pregnancy? Do you really think she is going to read books, take vitamins, and do everything happy, excited, pregnant women do?

Have you thought about all the ways women could try to intentionally miscarry if their choices are taken away and they don't want a baby? How is that fair for the woman or the fetus?

Message edited 2012-03-06 12:32:46.930000.

Posted 3/6/12 12:31 PM
 

Summergrl73
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/07

510 total posts

Name:
Excited

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

A man's participation in a pregnancy takes about 2 seconds. A woman's takes over 9 months and physically changes her body, restricts her from many activities and takes at least 6 additional weeks to medically recover from. I think that the woman has 100% of the decision on what should be done.

Posted 3/6/12 3:48 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by marianne13

Does anyone really think that any woman who is forced to have a baby (whether it be by the government or by the man who got her pregnant) is really going to try to have a healthy pregnancy? Do you really think she is going to read books, take vitamins, and do everything happy, excited, pregnant women do?

Have you thought about all the ways women could try to intentionally miscarry if their choices are taken away and they don't want a baby? How is that fair for the woman or the fetus?



or suicide.

Posted 3/6/12 3:53 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by MrsC614

yes i believe the father should have a choice. but i also believe that life begins at conception, so i guess it depends on what you believe. i just wonder when everyone else believes life begins? i think if the father decides he wants to raise his child, he should have that right. jmo.


ITA! It doesn't seem all that fair that women hold cards like this. Yes it is my body and my choice but isn't that child half the fathers, so what makes it my choice when it should be OUR choice.

Posted 3/6/12 3:53 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by eroxgirl

I think, in addition to all of VanderZwang's points, that is the overwhelming truth that people are forgetting. We live in a FREE (hahaha) country. We don't have to like what everyone else does. We don't have to approve of what our next door neighbor does so long as it's legal. To think that any one person has the right to say what any other person does (aside from our children) is where the problem begins.



This is how I feel.

You don't agree with having an abortion? Don't!

But don't take away MY RIGHT TO MAKE THAT CHOICE.

I'm not forcing anyone to have an abortion but I shouldn't be forced to not be able to have one either.

It's a matter of human rights and the right to decide what's best for me.

And to answer the OP's question, no, I don't think the father has any right to tell me what I can do to my body.

If he doesn't like that, he can have sex with someone else. He's got the right to make that CHOICE.

Message edited 2012-03-06 16:02:59.430000.

Posted 3/6/12 4:01 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

No, because all of the physical risk is the woman's. The man cannot die from continuing the pregnancy, but the woman can. Also, while it is 50% of his genetic material, 100% of the physical and emoptional burden is on the mother.

Posted 3/6/12 4:02 PM
 

BeachGrl
LIF Adult

Member since 10/11

2140 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

I have also seen the opposite happen which is just as wrong. A woman doesn't tell her boyfriend she is pregnant till about 4 or 5 months, pretty much not giving the MAN his right to his CHOICE, and having the baby regardless of how he felt about it.

I think if we're going to sit here and say the man has no choice bc it's not his body it's happening to, well what about if he CHOOSES not to be a father yet and the woman purposely doesn't tell him she's pregnant till it's too late?! Is that fair??

That's why as much as I see the point about it being her body, I also agree with the 50/50 rule, with it being half his choice too.

If a woman wants the right to choose, then it should be a 2 way street and the man should have the same rights too.

Posted 3/6/12 4:09 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by BeachGrl

I have also seen the opposite happen which is just as wrong. A woman doesn't tell her boyfriend she is pregnant till about 4 or 5 months, pretty much not giving the MAN his right to his CHOICE, and having the baby regardless of how he felt about it.

I think if we're going to sit here and say the man has no choice bc it's not his body it's happening to, well what about if he CHOOSES not to be a father yet and the woman purposely doesn't tell him she's pregnant till it's too late?! Is that fair??

That's why as much as I see the point about it being her body, I also agree with the 50/50 rule, with it being half his choice too.

If a woman wants the right to choose, then it should be a 2 way street and the man should have the same rights too.



As with any parent, he can legally waive his right to being a parent thereby giving him no obligation to the child.

Posted 3/6/12 4:17 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by HoneyBadger

Posted by BeachGrl

I have also seen the opposite happen which is just as wrong. A woman doesn't tell her boyfriend she is pregnant till about 4 or 5 months, pretty much not giving the MAN his right to his CHOICE, and having the baby regardless of how he felt about it.

I think if we're going to sit here and say the man has no choice bc it's not his body it's happening to, well what about if he CHOOSES not to be a father yet and the woman purposely doesn't tell him she's pregnant till it's too late?! Is that fair??

That's why as much as I see the point about it being her body, I also agree with the 50/50 rule, with it being half his choice too.

If a woman wants the right to choose, then it should be a 2 way street and the man should have the same rights too.



As with any parent, he can legally waive his right to being a parent thereby giving him no obligation to the child.



Actually I don't think he can waive child support unless the mom agrees to it (or the court allows it).

Beachgirl:

His choice begins with the choice to have sex. If he doesn't want a child, there are ways for him to help stop that from happening - one being don't have sex. Should he ideally have some say in it? Yes, it would be great if everyone could agree on everything. But that doesn't happen. You can't force a woman to have a baby just as you can't force a woman to have an abortion (unless you live in china??)

Posted 3/6/12 5:13 PM
 

marianne13
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

887 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

Posted by BeachGrl

I have also seen the opposite happen which is just as wrong. A woman doesn't tell her boyfriend she is pregnant till about 4 or 5 months, pretty much not giving the MAN his right to his CHOICE, and having the baby regardless of how he felt about it.

I think if we're going to sit here and say the man has no choice bc it's not his body it's happening to, well what about if he CHOOSES not to be a father yet and the woman purposely doesn't tell him she's pregnant till it's too late?! Is that fair??

That's why as much as I see the point about it being her body, I also agree with the 50/50 rule, with it being half his choice too.

If a woman wants the right to choose, then it should be a 2 way street and the man should have the same rights too.



What should be done in that situation? If the man wants to abort and the woman doesn't? Should she be pinned down and forced to have an abortion? Is that what you mean by a man having rights? That's even more barberic than taking away a woman's right to choose!


Posted 3/6/12 5:30 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Spinoff to abortion post...

The topic of abortion makes my head spin. The thought of a woman being forced to give birth to an unwanted child makes me sad...and i don't really think its realistic to expect that a woman should carry a baby she doesn't want.

But it still doesn't change my feelings about abortion itself. If i feel that an abortion is legalized murder, how can I say its OK? To me its morally horrifying. BUT that is ME. Would I do it? Absolutely not. But I recognize that people have very very different views on exactly when life starts. To me, putting a viability date on it doesn't make sense. I mean we can all say "20 weeks and before is ok, but not after". So a 19 week fetus (which is very much a baby) is OK to abort, yet one week later it's saved from that fate. THAT is what doesn't make sense to me. One week doesn't make much of a difference in terms of how the baby looks, feels, moves, reacts to pain etc...it just morally does not sit right with me and people can think I'm crazy, but I have actually been reduced to tears thinking about it what a baby goes through.

I listed to the replies and words with respect and an open mind. I've written this before in past topics about abortion..but I DO understand why a woman would have one. I've never been a 15 year old girl who became pregnant, nor have I been raped and became pregnant as a result. I can't imagine the torture a woman goes through to have to make that decision.....and I would never ever begin to crucify them for it. I just want to see CHANGE in this country where this topic is concerned. A huge reduction in the need for them as well as women being very proactive with their birth control choices!!

Sorry I got off topic!!

Posted 3/6/12 5:36 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to Overstock post.... post your OS purchases! Jenn627 9/24/10 3 Home
Another abortion spin-off b/c hey...there just aren't enough! MissJones 9/7/08 34 Families Helping Families ™
How much weight does the abortion issue bear in your decision this November? babymakes3 9/6/08 22 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to Pro-Life/Pro-Choice: Do you think there is a difference between being Pro-Choice and Pro-Abortion? HoneyBadger 6/10/08 169 Families Helping Families ™
Do you think the prompt asking "abortion" searchers "Did you mean adoption?" was a political statement DebG 3/22/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Uh-Oh!! S.D. Governor signs Abortion Ban into Law! MrsERod 3/6/06 53 Families Helping Families ™