Re: Spinoff to abortion post...
Posted 3/6/2012 12:03:28 PM by ReiRei13
Posted by VanderZwang
Posted by maybebaby
Posted by jilliibabii
Posted by maybebaby
Posted by VanderZwang
Ultimatly, its still a medical procedure on a woman.
I dont have a say if my husband wants a vasectamy, or if he has hair implants.
Or a wart removed.
Neither should he have any say about any medical procedure I have.
You really don't feel that the procedures you listed are completely different than abortion? I'm just asking. Because saying a wart removal is in the same category as the removal of a fetus seems to really devalue a human life.
I think that even most who are pro choice would feel that abortion is more than just a medical procedure...and something that involved some serious morality issues whether or not we all agree what exactly a fetus is...
I agree that those are apples and oranges, except for a vasectomy. I think that's about as close to the male equivalent of abortion that you can get. That being said, I agree that if my DH were to want it, he could get a vasectomy without my okay. Granted, it might bring an end to our relationship, but that's still his choice.
ETA: Though, maybebaby, it really depends at what stage you consider a fetus a life. You consider it "life" right at conception, but not everyone feels that way.
It may be as close to abortion as you could get...but it still doesn't involve something that has already been conceived and involved two people. It has to do with future conception, absolutely..
And like you said..i'd like to think that people would be in agreement about those things...sigh...
Sorry havent been at work to respond. I want to be clear that I say the below with respect. The "YOU" part is anyone who is using THEIR beliefs and morals to force them on me (woman).
You ask good questions.
1. I do not believe that "life" starts at conception. For me, its the potential of life, not life. It cant be sustained outside the woman untill, at LEAST 20 something weeks?
2. I believe that, although a VERY difficult decision (and all that goes with having an abortion), yes, its still JUST a medical procedure.
3. I believe that no one, on either side, will dis-suade someone from the other.
4. I believe that a womans life trumps ANY decision over any unborn fetus.
5. I believe by making archaic rules (MUST look at sono, must get parents permission, no 3rd trimester abortion, must do X before getting an abortion) that it makes women second class citizens. It puts womens lives in danger.
6. I believe, again, that a womans life is more important than the unborns.
7. And with that said, I beleieve that abortion must stay legal so WOMEN dont die. Whatever their reason's. It must be legal, and safe, and accessable.
8. I think its TORTURE to FORCE YOUR beliefs (not YOU specifically, but the religious right) on anyone. Since they believe that "life begins at conception", well, then they must make sure any woman considering an abortion MUST do things to maybe save the baby because YOU have a problem with it.
What happens if I dont have a problem with it?
9. I think, most women, CERTAINLY not all, know EXACTLY what they are they doing when they have an abortion. To make them feel worse is just disgusting and deplorable.
10. To force a woman to undergo a medical procedure, just so YOU can feel better, just do YOU can say "we tried", just so YOU can say "I forced my morals on somsone else"....is equivilant to communism.
11. And yes, I believe that I should be able to have an medical procedure without the GOVERNMENTS say. Period. I want my tubes tied? Great. I want an abortion? Great. I want a wart removed? Great.
Every law thats passed that LIMITS womens MEDICAL rights, is a law that makes this a communist state, and MAKES WOMEN second class citizens.
Every law thats passed limiting abortion is FORCING your religion on me. And lets face it, I think most people who are againt abortion are against it because of their religious beliefs. Im not saying ALL.
12. And no. Ultimatly I beleieve that the father should have no say. My body, my rules. My decision.
I submit this for discussion and in NO way want this to come off as disrespectfull. Thats not my intention.
|