Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Forum Opinion Poll
No, 21 is a good age 89 49.17%
Yes, it should be older 13 7.18%
Yes, it should be younger 67 37.02%
The gov't shouldn't dictate when someone should drink 7 3.87%
Other 5 2.76%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by nicrae

While I understand the "if you are old enough to fight for you country, you should be old enough to drink" concept, I don't think it should be lowered.

I teach high school and and the majority of seniors are not mature enough to handle being allowed to drink legally. Do they do it anyway? Sure but if it only saves 10 lives by keeping the legal age at 21 then personally I think it is worth it.



But they are mature enough to carry an assault rifle and kill folks?

And we allow them to enter into legal contracts.

And we allow them to command a 3,000 pound vehicle going 65 on the LIE.




Posted 10/10/11 10:53 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

VanderZwang
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/11

740 total posts

Name:
Gail

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by JennZ

Yes, lowered. My thought is, if you can die for our country at war at 18, you should be able to drink at 18.



EXACTLY this.

Posted 10/10/11 10:55 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

I think if 18 is the cut off to be considered an adult then yes, it should be lowered.

Posted 10/10/11 11:02 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by nicrae

While I understand the "if you are old enough to fight for you country, you should be old enough to drink" concept, I don't think it should be lowered.

I teach high school and and the majority of seniors are not mature enough to handle being allowed to drink legally. Do they do it anyway? Sure but if it only saves 10 lives by keeping the legal age at 21 then personally I think it is worth it.



But they are mature enough to carry an assault rifle and kill folks?

And we allow them to enter into legal contracts.

And we allow them to command a 3,000 pound vehicle going 65 on the LIE.







ITA. And the fact that at 18, you can do pretty much ANYTHING else (anything else legal, of course) it kinda puts drinking on a pedastal, KWIM? Because they can't do it, they want to do it even more. And like everyone else said, it's not like 18 year olds AREN'T drinking, it's that they are not doing so legally, which is even MORE dangerous IMO.

Posted 10/10/11 11:05 AM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by nicrae

While I understand the "if you are old enough to fight for you country, you should be old enough to drink" concept, I don't think it should be lowered.

I teach high school and and the majority of seniors are not mature enough to handle being allowed to drink legally. Do they do it anyway? Sure but if it only saves 10 lives by keeping the legal age at 21 then personally I think it is worth it.



But they are mature enough to carry an assault rifle and kill folks?

And we allow them to enter into legal contracts.

And we allow them to command a 3,000 pound vehicle going 65 on the LIE.







Honestly I think there is a big difference between a 18 year old high school senior and a 18 year old graduate. So not I don't think a high school student is mature enough to carry an assault rifle or marry.

I think driving is a totally different subject area.

Posted 10/10/11 11:20 AM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Not sure where exactly I stand, but here are some of my general thoughts.

I don't believe that it should be lowered only because of the argument that at 18 you can fight for your country. I would rather raise the age that you can fight for your country. I think at 18 you are sending off young boys to fight, and I don't think that is always good. My DH went to the army at 18. He is paying for it now. He wasn't able to complete college while in the military, and now is struggling trying to go to school, work and spend time with family. I don't think boys necessarily know what they are getting into at 18 when they sign up for the military. I've asked him if we had a boy, whether he would be supportive if his son wanted to sign up for the miltary. He said he would strongly encourage him to get his college degree first, and then if he still wanted to go, he would be supportive.

As for drinking, I never met an 18 year old who couldn't find a way to drink. What they can't do, is go on a date to a nice restaurant and order a bottle or a few glasses of wine. I don't know--when a person is responsible to drink really varies case by case. I think parents know best for their kid, but they can only control if the kids are living at home, and even then, not always. So really, I don't know how I feel about this issue. Whether or not it is lowered, I think education and more severe penalities for drinking and driving are necessary. Personally, I'd be for requiring all cars to have a breathalizer to start them. Or at least, all cars used by anyone under the age of 25.

For the driving age, it isn't practical to raise the driving age in most places. maybe in NYC or places with really good public transportation, but not many places in the country have easy to use public transportation. I would be for better drivers' education, and more severe penalities for speeding, driving and texting/talking, DUIs, etc

Posted 10/10/11 11:27 AM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

I think it should be 18. I've never understood how we're all legally adults at 18, but still can't drink or purchase alcohol for 3 more years.

Posted 10/10/11 11:32 AM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by Mrs213

Posted by DiamondGirl

Drinking age 18, driving age 21



How would anyone under 21 get to college or work?



Public transportation, car pooling, heel-toe express. I'm 25 and I've never owned a car and yet I manage to get around.



Not feasible on the east end- the bus routes take you 2 hrs to travel 15 miles and they don't even run on Sundays. If you live in Queens or Nassau sure but it would never fly in areas that aren't as sparsely populated...

Posted 10/10/11 11:56 AM
 

Sweetheart409
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

2219 total posts

Name:

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by JennZ

Yes, lowered. My thought is, if you can die for our country at war at 18, you should be able to drink at 18.



ita!!!!
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/10/11 12:06 PM
 

Sweetlax22
LIF Adult

Member since 5/10

1904 total posts

Name:

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

I think 18 should be the age , however I still think the "zero" tolerance as far as BAC should still be in place until the age of 21. Even one drink = no driving.

Posted 10/10/11 12:26 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

One of the reasons the drinking age was raised in NY is because kids from New Jersey were getting themselves killed driving home from NY after going out and getting drunk... and since I live in Staten Island and am attached to New Jersey by 3 bridges, I care about this point a lot.

I don't think the age should be lowered, although I would make an exception for anyone under 21 in the military. If you're willing to die for me, I'd be happy to serve you a drink beforehand. And if you've gone through military training, you have some discipline!

Posted 10/10/11 1:01 PM
 

Jan1975
.

Member since 8/09

3846 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by JennZ

Yes, lowered. My thought is, if you can die for our country at war at 18, you should be able to drink at 18.



Totally agree, but along the same note, I feel there should be steeper penalties for drunk driving as well as better education in schools regarding drinking and driving.



I agree with both of you.

I know that when I was in college we would binge drink before we went out because we knew we might not be able to get a drink while we were out. My friends and I were very lucky that nothing bad ever happened to us.

Binge drinking leads to hospitalization and even death. I think that if we teach people to be more responsible about drinking and impose harsher penalities for DUI then it would benefit everyone.

I know there was a movement awhile ago from many colleges to lower the drinking age to avoid binge drinking.article

Posted 10/10/11 1:05 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

I think it should be left as it is at 21.

Posted 10/10/11 1:31 PM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by jam11308

I'm conflicted. I completely agree with the argument about being old enough to fight for your country; however, if it was allowed at 18, I don't know if teens can handle that freedom & the freedom of suddenly being able to drive on their own. We already have too many DWI incidents & I imagine quite a few involving teen drivers...if they're suddenly allowed to drink & drive I don't know how many of them will know when to draw the line & not get behind the wheel or in a car with a drunken driver. I don't think there are any easy answers to this...





I agree

Posted 10/10/11 3:58 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

I understand an 18 yo is not mature.

But why consider them adults in the court of law but then children when it comes to alcohol?

If we consider 21 to be the age to be mature then let's move the majority back at 21 also.

You can't have your cake and eat it too.

Posted 10/10/11 4:01 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

If you lower the age, I think it would take out the "rebellious" factor for so many teens.

From 18-20 after high school, I feel like so many college students feel they want to just drink like crazy because it's "forbidden" and therefore automatically makes it desirable.

Lower the age to 18 and it won't make it such a big deal when they are out on their own in school, feeling like they have to binge drink to stay cool.

I know among my friends, we drank like crazy as freshmans in college because we thought it was just so cool to find someone to buy it for us and then we over did it because it wasn't something we did regularly.

Posted 10/10/11 4:16 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by eroxgirl

One of the reasons the drinking age was raised in NY is because kids from New Jersey were getting themselves killed driving home from NY after going out and getting drunk... and since I live in Staten Island and am attached to New Jersey by 3 bridges, I care about this point a lot.




This actually isn't true. The federal government required all states to raise the drinking age to 21 in return for federal money for highways and transportation. Every single state in the union raised the drinking age in response.

Posted 10/10/11 4:59 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

I think sending 18 year olds off to war is criminal. I don't think 18 year olds should be soldiers, drink, drive or vote.

They might look like young adults but they are kids.

My nephew went into the Navy. He was asked to leave for so many reasons (administrative discharge)..all of which amounted to his maturity level.

18 year old brains are not fully developed so no I would not lower the drinking age.

I agree with a breathalyzer in the car up until age 25.

Yes, I was young once and I did stupid things and for some reason I'm still here but so many don't get that chance.

Not worth it.

Posted 10/10/11 5:25 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by Mrs213

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by Mrs213

Posted by DiamondGirl

Drinking age 18, driving age 21



How would anyone under 21 get to college or work?



Public transportation, car pooling, heel-toe express. I'm 25 and I've never owned a car and yet I manage to get around.



Not feasible on the east end- the bus routes take you 2 hrs to travel 15 miles and they don't even run on Sundays. If you live in Queens or Nassau sure but it would never fly in areas that aren't as sparsely populated...



Good point. I can see how it might not be practical in non metro areas but I say make it that you can only drive to school or work or something like that.

Teens driving scares me based on my experiences as a teen. Drinking, drag racing etc. I did not get my licsense until 21. I live in Queens but went to school upstate. I made it work (but then again my friends drove so that helped a lot).

Posted 10/10/11 5:27 PM
 

tink23
Step by step....

Member since 6/11

1061 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

ITA with everything you said.

Posted 10/10/11 7:02 PM
 

KCCL
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/11

641 total posts

Name:

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Leave it at 21 and raise the age to join the military to 21.

Posted 10/10/11 7:06 PM
 

tink23
Step by step....

Member since 6/11

1061 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Dang iPhone! I agree with you, mamabear.

Posted 10/10/11 7:06 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by DiamondGirl

Drinking age 18, driving age 21



Chat Icon

Posted 10/10/11 8:33 PM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by JennZ

Yes, lowered. My thought is, if you can die for our country at war at 18, you should be able to drink at 18.



ita!

Posted 10/10/11 9:18 PM
 

babycakes18
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

1281 total posts

Name:
Dani

Re: Should the legal drinking age be changed?

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by JennZ

Yes, lowered. My thought is, if you can die for our country at war at 18, you should be able to drink at 18.



Totally agree, but along the same note, I feel there should be steeper penalties for drunk driving as well as better education in schools regarding drinking and driving.



I totally agree with this. I think that if you are driving while drunk....your license then should be revoked until you are 25. Non-negotioble....no plea bargains....mandatory penalty.

Posted 10/10/11 9:25 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
The legal drinking age in the US should be... SweetestOfPeas 8/19/08 114 Families Helping Families ™
College presidents seek debate on lower drinking age GoldenRod 8/18/08 9 Families Helping Families ™
At what age did your child stop drinking from a bottle MatteosMom 5/21/07 21 Parenting
ata what age did your DC start drinking from a regular cup? KartveliT 3/18/09 2 Parenting
Has anyone's skin type (oily, normal, dry) really changed with age? beautyq115 7/25/08 2 Fashion & Beauty!
At what age was your DC completely off formula and drinking milk? apb17 11/9/07 10 Parenting