shiloh jolie pitt
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by JessInCA This isn't just a topless kid in the pool due to cultural influence though - between the toplessness, the swim trunks and the hair cut, it's cross dressing. It's obviously unusual, therefore people take notice. I do agree though, that the important part is that she's healthy and happy. I'm not sure what I would do if I were a parent and had a child that badly wanted to dress unusually, so I try not to judge. I guess I just think people wouldn't get their panties in a bunch over this crap if we STOPPED looking at & buying magazines that invade the child's privacy. This is an image NONE OF US would know about -- if some sleazy pap didn't sneak around and get it. Then no one could scrutinize it and make such a big deal and continue this round and round debate about whether it's okay or not. In the end, how they raise her is none of our business. While I do enjoy looking at celebrities and what not -- I do NOT consider the children part of that. IMO they are off limits. Whatever happened to that unspoken rule among celebrities and the papparazzi that kids are NOT part of it? If Shiloh has some type of gender identity crisis when she gets older, then that is something her family can deal with if the time comes. But having her picture splashed everywhere with all sorts of stories of whether it's okay or not is definitely not going to help that. People sit there and say "but this will be an issue when she's older," but just the very nature of strangers like us talking about it, is what can lead to this. As far as she's concerned, she's 4 years old and loving & living life...as any 4 year old should. People like us and the tabloids constantly talking about it, will only perpetuate this supposed identity crisis, when she's old enough to see these stories. Where's Chris Crocker when you need him? LEAVE SHILOH ALOOOONE! ![]() Message edited 2010-08-06 14:18:46.807000. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 2:17 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by DirtyBlonde Posted by MeNBobs Was this an arranged photo shoot or did some pap climb a tree 5 miles away and zoom in on little children having fun in what they thought was their private yard. I know paps are pretty bad and it's one thing to get photos of kids with their famous parents in public places but to solely focus on the children is disgusting. THIS is what bothers me about this picture. She's a kid. Who cares what she wears. I agree. what kind of ******* would do that. I think this was a private thing and some jackoff with a telescopic lens was paid WAY TOO MUCH MONEY to give us the opportunity to discuss child psychology. nasty.
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by curliegirl To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue. And just for S&G...I wonder what people would say if they saw my 3 year old son at the beach or pool in a pink bikini and pigtails......????? Well said, ITA You would be blasted. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by Ayne11 "I have a very strong-willed four-year-old girl who tells me what she wants to wear and I let her be who she is. "I think people think kids should be a certain way, but I feel they should wear what they feel like wearing and they should express themselves. Shiloh cried one night and said, 'Please cut my hair off. I don't want to have long hair.' I'm not going to leave it long just because somebody thinks I should." I'm sorry but i don't buy this. This is coming from someone who THRIVES on controversy, being odd (kissing her brother very intimately, for ex), etc. There is no way this child is coming up with ALL of this ON HER OWN. NO WAY. Oh, and I assume Maddox was such a high fashion kid too on HIS OWN... They are SEEING this and getting these ideas from someone somewhere or she is doing it, period.She can't just have a normal child, after all, she doesn't want normalcy. Just think of Maddox and his clothing, hair, etc. What CHILD dresses like that, WHO is buying him the clothes, where would he GET the idea (if she were to claim it was his idea)? KWIM? Message edited 2010-08-06 15:16:37.787000. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by Goobster Posted by Ayne11 "I have a very strong-willed four-year-old girl who tells me what she wants to wear and I let her be who she is. "I think people think kids should be a certain way, but I feel they should wear what they feel like wearing and they should express themselves. Shiloh cried one night and said, 'Please cut my hair off. I don't want to have long hair.' I'm not going to leave it long just because somebody thinks I should." I'm sorry but i don't buy this. This is coming from someone who THRIVES on controversy, being odd (kissing her brother very intimately, for ex), etc. There is no way this child is coming up with ALL of this ON HER OWN. NO WAY. Oh, and I assume Maddox was such a high fashion kid too on HIS OWN... They are SEEING this and getting these ideas from someone somewhere or she is doing it, period.She can't just have a normal child, after all, she doesn't want normalcy. Just think of Maddox and his clothing, hair, etc. What CHILD dresses like that, WHO is buying him the clothes, where would he GET the idea (if she were to claim it was his idea)? KWIM? I don't buy her quote for one minute. I don't know Shiloh personally but if my 4 year old spoke like this I would think it was a genius. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt I will preface this by saying I am a liberal. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by Ayne11 Posted by Goobster Posted by Ayne11 "I have a very strong-willed four-year-old girl who tells me what she wants to wear and I let her be who she is. "I think people think kids should be a certain way, but I feel they should wear what they feel like wearing and they should express themselves. Shiloh cried one night and said, 'Please cut my hair off. I don't want to have long hair.' I'm not going to leave it long just because somebody thinks I should." I'm sorry but i don't buy this. This is coming from someone who THRIVES on controversy, being odd (kissing her brother very intimately, for ex), etc. There is no way this child is coming up with ALL of this ON HER OWN. NO WAY. Oh, and I assume Maddox was such a high fashion kid too on HIS OWN... They are SEEING this and getting these ideas from someone somewhere or she is doing it, period.She can't just have a normal child, after all, she doesn't want normalcy. Just think of Maddox and his clothing, hair, etc. What CHILD dresses like that, WHO is buying him the clothes, where would he GET the idea (if she were to claim it was his idea)? KWIM? I don't buy her quote for one minute. I don't know Shiloh personally but if my 4 year old spoke like this I would think it was a genius. I'm not saying that I agree or disagree with how Shiloh is dressed, but there is no reason why she couldn't ask her mother to cut her hair off at 4 years old... my 2.5 year old can say the same thing and I don't think she's a genius for it... she just talks a lot.. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt I don't mind the topless, my parents are european and I ran around the beach always topless as a little girl, it's more the board shorts that are obviously boys boy shorts, I feel like this can slowly turn into somewhat of an identity crisis...kids go through a lot in their formative years and I think this just adds confusion..I'm all about letting a child be a child and a free spirit and make their own decisions...I actually welcome it, but I also think this is just going to confuse her in the end... |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt I'm not liberal enough to think that's appropriate for my kid - And I'm not ashamed to say that either .......... |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by DirtyBlonde Posted by MeNBobs Was this an arranged photo shoot or did some pap climb a tree 5 miles away and zoom in on little children having fun in what they thought was their private yard. I know paps are pretty bad and it's one thing to get photos of kids with their famous parents in public places but to solely focus on the children is disgusting. THIS is what bothers me about this picture. She's a kid. Who cares what she wears. I agree with all of this. However, I get the feeling that a lot of these photos with these particular children are staged. There are tons of celebrities with children who rarely have their kids accessible to the paps. And if you do, it's when they are in public - going to and from a car, the airport, etc. I think if Angelina wanted to keep these kids from the spotlight, she certainly could. Message edited 2010-08-06 15:46:15.637000. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt / Posted by dpli I agree with all of this. However, I get the feeling that a lot of these photos with these particular children are staged. There are tons of celebrities with children who rarely have their kids accessible to the paps. And if you do, it's when they are in public - going to and from a car, the airport, etc. I think if Angelina wanted to keep these kids from the spotlight, she certainly could. Good point Message edited 2010-08-06 16:14:29.080000. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 3:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt I do not agree with letting her dress this way. Sorry, and I don't belive Angelina for a second..... just letting Shi be Shi, She probably is a tomboy she probably likes hanging out with her brothers but I think AJ caught on to this and encouraged it to the point we are at now. It is not about a 4 year old it is that this woman uses her children as an extension of herself (Kate,Joan Crawford) i think that we can't begin to understand the shallowness and calculating personality of this woman. I think she enjoys the novelty of it all, and I think that she is a sicko. Shame on Brad for letting her play out her shock value nonsense on her child....... I am all for individuality but you wear girls clothing end of story - I am not saying dresses and ruffels and Pink - but you are wearing a bathing suit - or as a pp said board shorts and a rash guard. I am the parent and what I say goes. And just like voting .. driving ect when you are 18 you can dress, and be what ever gender you want to be - but while I am in charge you are a girl. You can be a butchy girl - but you will be a girl. Message edited 2010-08-06 16:29:36.500000. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 4:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by irishbaby I do not agree with letting her dress this way. Sorry, and I don't belive Angelina for a second..... just letting Shi be Shi, She probably is a tomboy she probably likes hanging out with her brothers but I think AJ caught on to this and encouraged it to the point we are at now. It is not about a 4 year old it is that this woman uses her children as an extension of herself (Kate,Joan Crawford) i think that we can't begin to understand the shallowness and calculating personality of this woman. I think she enjoys the novelty of it all, and I think that she is a sicko. Shame on Brad for letting her play out her shock value nonsense on her child....... I am all for individuality but you wear girls clothing end of story - I am not saying dresses and ruffels and Pink - but you are wearing a bathing suit - or as a pp said board shorts and a rash guard. I am the parent and what I say goes. And just like voting .. driving ect when you are 18 you can dress, and be what ever gender you want to be - but while I am in charge you are a girl. You can be a butchy girl - but you will be a girl. Wow. Spot on IMO. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 4:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by Goobster Posted by Ayne11 "I have a very strong-willed four-year-old girl who tells me what she wants to wear and I let her be who she is. "I think people think kids should be a certain way, but I feel they should wear what they feel like wearing and they should express themselves. Shiloh cried one night and said, 'Please cut my hair off. I don't want to have long hair.' I'm not going to leave it long just because somebody thinks I should." I'm sorry but i don't buy this. This is coming from someone who THRIVES on controversy, being odd (kissing her brother very intimately, for ex), etc. There is no way this child is coming up with ALL of this ON HER OWN. NO WAY. Oh, and I assume Maddox was such a high fashion kid too on HIS OWN... They are SEEING this and getting these ideas from someone somewhere or she is doing it, period.She can't just have a normal child, after all, she doesn't want normalcy. Just think of Maddox and his clothing, hair, etc. What CHILD dresses like that, WHO is buying him the clothes, where would he GET the idea (if she were to claim it was his idea)? KWIM? I have to agree. If I truly thought Shiloh was really pushing for this who cares...she's 4...kids go through all kind of phases. But IMO Angelina has always been a weirdo...I kinda think she thrives on the attention she gets from being out there to the tenth power and it seems to *me* thats whats going on here with Shiloh but what they heck do I know
|
|
Posted 8/6/10 4:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt seriously who the he!! cares and why is it anyone's business?! |
|
Posted 8/6/10 4:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt i think angelina is crazy....enough said |
|
Posted 8/6/10 5:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Who cares what this child is wearing? Is it criminal for a girl to wear boys clothes? There are plenty of adults who say they always knew they were born in the wrong body, since they were very small children and always wanted to wear boys clothes or vice versa. Im not saying that this is def the case but it def could be. So, should her parents force her to wear girls clothes and potentially cause her harm by making her feel like the way she identifies herself is not acceptable? Please, as long as the child is wearing clothes, nobody should care. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 5:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by Ayne11 Posted by curliegirl To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue... What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking My aunt let me girl cousin dress like a boy and play GI Joe's when she was little just like her two older brothers who she wanted to be like. Fast forward now to her 20's and she is a mess with emotional issues. Wishes my aunt dressed her like a girl and did girl things with her. I personally wouldnt do it. I think it can be confusing and create issues later on like it did with my cousin. That being said, not my kid so I dont really care. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 5:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by mbg1007 Who cares what this child is wearing? Is it criminal for a girl to wear boys clothes? There are plenty of adults who say they always knew they were born in the wrong body, since they were very small children and always wanted to wear boys clothes or vice versa. Im not saying that this is def the case but it def could be. So, should her parents force her to wear girls clothes and potentially cause her harm by making her feel like the way she identifies herself is not acceptable? Please, as long as the child is wearing clothes, nobody should care. To be honest I don't know what I would do if that was my kid - but I do find it odd that Shiloh has been dressing this way for quite some time - like what 2,3,4 year old picks out their own clothes? I don't ever remember going shopping and picking out clothes until maybe middle school age. Unless she takes the clothes from her brother's closet? I don't know, I find it a little strange that she is basically cross dressing at 4...but again I don't have kids, and if it was my kid I don't know what I would do...but I wouldn't be surprised if Angelina has something to do with it just b/c I think she likes attention and to be different...JMO |
|
Posted 8/6/10 5:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by mbg1007 Please, as long as the child is wearing clothes, nobody should care. Well she's not in the pic. Little girls generally wear bathing suits that cover top and bottom, no? Such as her sister in the pic. What if she continues to want to wear boy trunks in the pool as the years go on? Habits do form. Then once she starts developing she will be told she has to put a shirt on? When is the line drawn? Message edited 2010-08-06 17:57:48.730000. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 5:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Posted by Nik211 Posted by mbg1007 Who cares what this child is wearing? Is it criminal for a girl to wear boys clothes? There are plenty of adults who say they always knew they were born in the wrong body, since they were very small children and always wanted to wear boys clothes or vice versa. Im not saying that this is def the case but it def could be. So, should her parents force her to wear girls clothes and potentially cause her harm by making her feel like the way she identifies herself is not acceptable? Please, as long as the child is wearing clothes, nobody should care. To be honest I don't know what I would do if that was my kid - but I do find it odd that Shiloh has been dressing this way for quite some time - like what 2,3,4 year old picks out their own clothes? I don't ever remember going shopping and picking out clothes until maybe middle school age. Unless she takes the clothes from her brother's closet? I don't know, I find it a little strange that she is basically cross dressing at 4...but again I don't have kids, and if it was my kid I don't know what I would do...but I wouldn't be surprised if Angelina has something to do with it just b/c I think she likes attention and to be different...JMO Those outfits are WAYYYY too put together for a child to decide that's the outfit to wear, kwim? They are very fashionable and put together in a fashion sense, so this child is not picking out random clothes from her brother's closet. No way. This topic really bugs me so much. I feel bad for the child, I really do. I think her mother's putting all of her own issues on Shiloh. Message edited 2010-08-06 18:01:16.060000. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 6:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt They should put her in girls bathing suit - she is a girl. I know some will disagree with me but when she is older and grows breasts she will need to wear a top with her swimsuit... |
|
Posted 8/6/10 6:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt That is inappropriate for 2 reasons. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 6:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Actually, she wasn't dressing like this at 2. There was just a pic in a magazine that showed her in a girly dress and sandals at that age. Angelina has said that she wants to be like her brothers. She also has a sister who dresses girly so its not like she's only exposed to boy things. As for her put together outfits, should her mother not buy her nice boy stuff just bc she wants to dress like a boy? and as for being covered up by a top (other than for sun damage issues),cmon, she's 4, she's not 14. I'm sure when she starts to develop she will put on a shirt, it may be a boys shirt but it will still be a shirt. I'm not an angelina fan but I really think people are overeacting just a little bit. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 6:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: shiloh jolie pitt Sorry. Im traditional and old school. We all are grateful that she is healthy. She is head strong - so what. A four year old should not be running a household. Aside from the paparazzi issue, I think she should be covered. This is coming from a parent whose daughter will not be permitted to wear clothing with words gracing her rear end. |
|
Posted 8/6/10 6:40 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt take their daughters, Zahara and Shilohgrocery shopping at Stop & Shop in New York | GossipQueen | 4/21/09 | 16 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Forbes Power List: Angelina Jolie No. 3; Brad Pitt No. 10 | GossipQueen | 6/12/08 | 0 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Angelina Jolie Splits Pants at Premiere; Brad Pitt Covers Her Up | GossipQueen | 11/12/07 | 14 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Angelina Jolie, Brad Pitt, Zahara and Shiloh take a walk in New Orleans | MrsQ | 2/22/07 | 0 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Shiloh Jolie-Pitt makes her debut! | chelle | 12/13/06 | 19 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Baby Shiloh Jolie-Pitt looks like... | MommaG | 10/22/06 | 9 | Celebrities & Entertainment |






They are SEEING this and getting these ideas from someone somewhere or she is doing it, period.








