shiloh jolie pitt

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

mosa77
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

2122 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

shiloh jolie pitt

i dont think there is anything wrong with letting your child dress how they want but i am thinking this is alittle much she could at least be wearing girls boardshorts and a rash gaurd or something

External Image

Posted 8/6/10 12:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

july4mrsO
Happy boy!

Member since 5/10

2867 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

yeah I have to agree this is a bit much. Being a tomboy is fine but this is beyond that. Oh well, to each their own

Posted 8/6/10 12:30 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

not directing this at you specifically...

I really don't understand why everyone cares so much about what this child wears & looks like and whatnot.

Clearly her parents have a more lax idea of parenting and letting her express herself -- what's the big deal? She always seems to be having fun and being a kid in pics, seems healthy, and happy.

I know the idea of a topless child can be a bit taboo, but I think it's so much more common outside of the U.S. and that family spends a lot of time in Europe.

I remember being in Punta Cana, and there were tons of Europeans there and MANY pre-pubescent girls from toddlers to almost 10 year olds, were walking around the pool area with just bottoms on. While it seemed slightly shocking to me, tons of people didn't even blink an eye.

Not something I'd want my kid to do, but don't care if someone else does.

Posted 8/6/10 12:32 PM
 

curliegirl
He's here!!!!

Member since 3/06

10128 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue.

And just for S&G...I wonder what people would say if they saw my 3 year old son at the beach or pool in a pink bikini and pigtails......?????

Message edited 2010-08-06 12:53:36.143000.

Posted 8/6/10 12:37 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Their kid, their rules.

My daughter is currently sitting in a princess costume with matching princess heels. Many people don't agree with letting a 3 year old wear heels.....but I didn't ask them, so it's not their business.

If my daughter wasn't the girliest girl that ever girled.....and she wanted to dress like that, I'd let her.

Posted 8/6/10 12:41 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by curliegirl

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue...



What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking

Posted 8/6/10 12:45 PM
 

GinaR
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

1976 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by MrsPJB2007

not directing this at you specifically...

I really don't understand why everyone cares so much about what this child wears & looks like and whatnot.

Clearly her parents have a more lax idea of parenting and letting her express herself -- what's the big deal? She always seems to be having fun and being a kid in pics, seems healthy, and happy.

I know the idea of a topless child can be a bit taboo, but I think it's so much more common outside of the U.S. and that family spends a lot of time in Europe.

I remember being in Punta Cana, and there were tons of Europeans there and MANY pre-pubescent girls from toddlers to almost 10 year olds, were walking around the pool area with just bottoms on. While it seemed slightly shocking to me, tons of people didn't even blink an eye.

Not something I'd want my kid to do, but don't care if someone else does.




I totally agree with this.

Posted 8/6/10 12:46 PM
 

MeNBobs
*****

Member since 4/07

3765 total posts

Name:

Re:

Posted by MrsPJB2007

not directing this at you specifically...

I really don't understand why everyone cares so much about what this child wears & looks like and whatnot.

Clearly her parents have a more lax idea of parenting and letting her express herself -- what's the big deal? She always seems to be having fun and being a kid in pics, seems healthy, and happy.

I know the idea of a topless child can be a bit taboo, but I think it's so much more common outside of the U.S. and that family spends a lot of time in Europe.

I remember being in Punta Cana, and there were tons of Europeans there and MANY pre-pubescent girls from toddlers to almost 10 year olds, were walking around the pool area with just bottoms on. While it seemed slightly shocking to me, tons of people didn't even blink an eye.

Not something I'd want my kid to do, but don't care if someone else does.




All this.

Was this an arranged photo shoot or did some pap climb a tree 5 miles away and zoom in on little children having fun in what they thought was their private yard. I know paps are pretty bad and it's one thing to get photos of kids with their famous parents in public places but to solely focus on the children is disgusting.

Message edited 2011-09-11 16:14:49.690000.

Posted 8/6/10 12:49 PM
 

curliegirl
He's here!!!!

Member since 3/06

10128 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue...



What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking



Not really sure, but anything is possible.
Definitely not concerned about her becoming a lesbian...if she is, she is.

I guess I'm thinking more along the lines of identity crisis, or her being targeted by crazies out there.

I guess that's why I left it open ended, I'm not really sure, I just think for her being the child of two major celebrities, it all just might be too much for her.....whether she prefers dressing like a boy BECAUSE of the media attention they receive or not, I just think it's a little.......off....

And to answer my own question from above. You all KNOW if you saw my son running around in a pink bikini at 3, 5 or older, you would have an issue with it and it would likely have repercussions around town.......

Message edited 2010-08-06 12:52:52.320000.

Posted 8/6/10 12:51 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by curliegirl

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue...



What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking



Not really sure, but anything is possible.
Definitely not concerned about her becoming a lesbian...if she is, she is.

I guess I'm thinking more along the lines of identity crisis, or her being targeted by crazies out there.

I guess that's why I left it open ended, I'm not really sure, I just think for her being the child of two major celebrities, it all just might be too much for her.....whether she prefers dressing like a boy BECAUSE of the media attention they receive or not, I just think it's a little.......off....



I know a little girl in my child's class who did the same thing. She preferred to wear boys clothes & only boys' clothes. The issue is it becomes a gender identity problem later on.

The mom thought she was doing the right thing by letting her daughter "express" herself, trying to be open to the possibility that her daughter identifies with a different gender. It became a huge issue with other kids, teasing, etc. When the mom went to the school counselor & psychologist, they recommended that she cut out buying boy's clothes, underewar, etc because it was causing issues for her. She started transitioning her to unisex clothes & colors like purple, etc. It's helped her tremendously but she's having a hard time with her friends starting to bail on her (she's only friends with boys)

In the end, yes their child, their choice - but having seen a little girl struggle with social problems, it is heartbreaking.

Posted 8/6/10 12:57 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by curliegirl

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue...



What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking



Not really sure, but anything is possible.
Definitely not concerned about her becoming a lesbian...if she is, she is.

I guess I'm thinking more along the lines of identity crisis, or her being targeted by crazies out there.

I guess that's why I left it open ended, I'm not really sure, I just think for her being the child of two major celebrities, it all just might be too much for her.....whether she prefers dressing like a boy BECAUSE of the media attention they receive or not, I just think it's a little.......off....

And to answer my own question from above. You all KNOW if you saw my son running around in a pink bikini at 3, 5 or older, you would have an issue with it and it would likely have repercussions around town.......



She's a multi millionaire she can do whatever she wants Chat Icon

I read this on Im Not Obsessed today and I don't know if this is Angelina's way of justifying Shiloh or not this is just how Shiloh is ...

"I have a very strong-willed four-year-old girl who tells me what she wants to wear and I let her be who she is. "I think people think kids should be a certain way, but I feel they should wear what they feel like wearing and they should express themselves. Shiloh cried one night and said, 'Please cut my hair off. I don't want to have long hair.' I'm not going to leave it long just because somebody thinks I should."

Posted 8/6/10 12:57 PM
 

Disneygirl
Disney cruise bound!

Member since 5/05

8126 total posts

Name:
D

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by curliegirl

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue...



What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking



Not really sure, but anything is possible.
Definitely not concerned about her becoming a lesbian...if she is, she is.

I guess I'm thinking more along the lines of identity crisis, or her being targeted by crazies out there.

I guess that's why I left it open ended, I'm not really sure, I just think for her being the child of two major celebrities, it all just might be too much for her.....whether she prefers dressing like a boy BECAUSE of the media attention they receive or not, I just think it's a little.......off....



I know a little girl in my child's class who did the same thing. She preferred to wear boys clothes & only boys' clothes. The issue is it becomes a gender identity problem later on.

The mom thought she was doing the right thing by letting her daughter "express" herself, trying to be open to the possibility that her daughter identifies with a different gender. It became a huge issue with other kids, teasing, etc. When the mom went to the school counselor & psychologist, they recommended that she cut out buying boy's clothes, underewar, etc because it was causing issues for her. She started transitioning her to unisex clothes & colors like purple, etc. It's helped her tremendously but she's having a hard time with her friends starting to bail on her (she's only friends with boys)

In the end, yes their child, their choice - but having seen a little girl struggle with social problems, it is heartbreaking.



But on the other hand would forcing her to wear dresses and putting her in pigtails solve the problem? If she is having a gender identity problem then that's what she's having regardless of what she's wearing. How many documentaries have we seen on people saying they were born in the wrong body? When you look back at childhood pictures a lot of them were dressed gender appropriate as a child but that obviously didn't "fix" them and certainly didn't prevent them from having a problem free childhood.

Posted 8/6/10 1:05 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by Disneygirl

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by curliegirl

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue...



What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking



Not really sure, but anything is possible.
Definitely not concerned about her becoming a lesbian...if she is, she is.

I guess I'm thinking more along the lines of identity crisis, or her being targeted by crazies out there.

I guess that's why I left it open ended, I'm not really sure, I just think for her being the child of two major celebrities, it all just might be too much for her.....whether she prefers dressing like a boy BECAUSE of the media attention they receive or not, I just think it's a little.......off....



I know a little girl in my child's class who did the same thing. She preferred to wear boys clothes & only boys' clothes. The issue is it becomes a gender identity problem later on.

The mom thought she was doing the right thing by letting her daughter "express" herself, trying to be open to the possibility that her daughter identifies with a different gender. It became a huge issue with other kids, teasing, etc. When the mom went to the school counselor & psychologist, they recommended that she cut out buying boy's clothes, underewar, etc because it was causing issues for her. She started transitioning her to unisex clothes & colors like purple, etc. It's helped her tremendously but she's having a hard time with her friends starting to bail on her (she's only friends with boys)

In the end, yes their child, their choice - but having seen a little girl struggle with social problems, it is heartbreaking.



But on the other hand would forcing her to wear dresses and putting her in pigtails solve the problem? If she is having a gender identity problem then that's what she's having regardless of what she's wearing. How many documentaries have we seen on people saying they were born in the wrong body? When you look back at childhood pictures a lot of them were dressed gender appropriate as a child but that obviously didn't "fix" them and certainly didn't prevent them from having a problem free childhood.



ITA agree. look and Chastity Bono err I mean Chaz Bono for all intents and purposes she grew up femmine and now she's a man. It's gonna happen regardless. As long as Shiloh's happy and her parents and siblings love her then I personally think that's all that matters.

Posted 8/6/10 1:09 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

First off, I think its DISGUSTING that this photo was printed. The fact that the world is now discussing what a 4 year old wears is so sad.

But its out there and we all have our opinions.

DD is the same age as Shiloh, Suri, and Kingston. She is OBSESSED with leggings. Despite the 90 degree heat, she wants to wear leggings. She wears them to bed. She wears them every day. She doesn't think of them as pants.

A year ago- it was dresses. ONLY DRESSES. In fact, her deterrent for sleeping in our bed was wearings pants (thanks Barb).

I agree with her mom. If DD wanted me to cut her hair- I would. If this is truly a gender identiy, then she will have social problems transitioning when she is 4 or when she is 14 or 24. The question is how long do you let the child struggle internally? Are high school kids much more understanding? Not when I went to HS.

I also think of Chastity Bono whose parents put her in dresses and bows. I think of her 10 year struggle with drugs. I'd rather my child deal with teasing externally then her own internal battles of feeling ashamed of who she is.

And if its just a phase, she'll grow out of it.

Barb, your story broke my heart, but I know plenty of kids that get teased. I was tall and wore glasses. Trust me- I know from getting teased. But my mom always told me to be true to myself and be proud of who I am- and that's how I got through that.

Posted 8/6/10 1:25 PM
 

curliegirl
He's here!!!!

Member since 3/06

10128 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

To ME personally, this is not appropriate and COULD, in the future, become an issue...



What could be the issue in the future? That she's a lesbian? Not being a jerk, I'm legimately asking



Not really sure, but anything is possible.
Definitely not concerned about her becoming a lesbian...if she is, she is.

I guess I'm thinking more along the lines of identity crisis, or her being targeted by crazies out there.

I guess that's why I left it open ended, I'm not really sure, I just think for her being the child of two major celebrities, it all just might be too much for her.....whether she prefers dressing like a boy BECAUSE of the media attention they receive or not, I just think it's a little.......off....

And to answer my own question from above. You all KNOW if you saw my son running around in a pink bikini at 3, 5 or older, you would have an issue with it and it would likely have repercussions around town.......



She's a multi millionaire she can do whatever she wants Chat Icon

I read this on Im Not Obsessed today and I don't know if this is Angelina's way of justifying Shiloh or not this is just how Shiloh is ...

"I have a very strong-willed four-year-old girl who tells me what she wants to wear and I let her be who she is. "I think people think kids should be a certain way, but I feel they should wear what they feel like wearing and they should express themselves. Shiloh cried one night and said, 'Please cut my hair off. I don't want to have long hair.' I'm not going to leave it long just because somebody thinks I should."



I don't see her fame and fortune having anything to do with anything.
And as parents, it is our responsibility to think in the best interest of our children, and being a celebrity should make a parent more sensitive to every move their child makes.

Can letting your child dress differently than the norm have negative side effects? Absolutely! Can those side effects last a LIFETIME? Without question.

Angelina states that her daughter begged to cut her hair off. Does that mean she couldn't give her a neutral pixie cut or something less masculine?
She can certainly not dress her in a frilly dress and mary janes, but does she have to go to the polar opposite and put the girl in a suit and boys swim trunks? No, she does not.
Again, as parents, it is up to us to GUIDE our children in a safe direction, not force them to fit some stereotypical mold, but to let them express who they want to be WITHIN REASON.

As another poster stated, these kids can get tortured for going to an extreme, I had a client tell me the same story about her daughter, who now has hardly any friends in school and probably has lasting damage from it.

Just because our child wants to do something does that give them free reign to do it and us no boundaries for our kids?????

And as far as teasing goes, we have ALL seen the horrific outcome of severe teasing/bullying, is that any better for our children if we let them do as they please?

So Chastity Bono wouldn't have had drug problems if she wore camo to school, only been mildly teased? And that teasing would have just made her a better person, not led down the same path of drugs or worse?

Am I missing something or is it not up to US to THINK for our children as they grow, not just be there alongside them to help them be "free" and explore their personalities?????

Years ago I wanted to wear my pajamas to school. Did my mom let me? Hell no! She dressed me appropriately and off I went, and guess what? I got over it! And I'm not an axe murderer, I do not have a drug problem, and I have not seen a therapist because of it.
I have actually grown into an adult that PREFERS to be mildly different and unique, and that is what my parents TAUGHT me, to BE different in my beliefs,v think outside of the box and stand up for what I believe is right no matter what..... not that dressing a certain way was going to get me there any differently.

Message edited 2010-08-06 13:36:10.097000.

Posted 8/6/10 1:26 PM
 

DirtyBlonde
*****

Member since 11/07

7344 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by MeNBobs
Was this an arranged photo shoot or did some pap climb a tree 5 miles away and zoom in on little children having fun in what they thought was their private yard. I know paps are pretty bad and it's one thing to get photos of kids with their famous parents in public places but to solely focus on the children is disgusting.



THIS is what bothers me about this picture.

She's a kid. Who cares what she wears.

Posted 8/6/10 1:29 PM
 

sami
So very blessed!! Thank u !!

Member since 8/06

6524 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

She is so cute.... I dont like how she dresses but whatever!

Posted 8/6/10 1:35 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by curliegirl

So Chastity Bono wouldn't have had drug problems if she wore camo to school, only been mildly teased? And that teasing would have just made her a better person, not led down the same path of drugs or worse?



No I don't think a lack of camoflauge pants led Her drug problem . it Probably stemmed from her parents lifsytle and their own drug use and eventual divorce. I don't think frills & bows can drive a 10 year old to drugs. But that's a discussion for another thread.

Posted 8/6/10 1:35 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by curliegirl

So Chastity Bono wouldn't have had drug problems if she wore camo to school, only been mildly teased? And that teasing would have just made her a better person, not led down the same path of drugs or worse?



No I don't think a lack of camoflauge pants led Her drug problem . it Probably stemmed from her parents lifsytle and their own drug use and eventual divorce. I don't think frills & bows can drive a 10 year old to drugs. But that's a discussion for another thread.



I know from watching first hand that that gender confusion can definitely lead to drug abuse. I'm sure there were many factors in Chastity Bono's case- it was just an example of inner turmoil that people face.

My best friend came out in college. I used to go to the L/B/G/T support groups with him. I heard people talk about knowing they were gay or in the wrong gender since they were 4 years old. It was heartbreaking to hear their stories. Many of them did go down a path of drugs. Others didn't.

I'm just of the mindset- let people be who they will be. I'd just rather my child face adversity from the outside rather than within.

Message edited 2010-08-06 13:44:02.840000.

Posted 8/6/10 1:42 PM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

I knew this would become debatable.


Not my kid, BUT I think its a bit too much. I also wouldn't allow my child to do this. Sorry, JMO though.

Too add to those questioning why we care or judge celebrities, hello, this is a celebrity & entertainment board. People like me enjoy following and judging celebrities. Hate if you want, but its the truth. I follow these celebrities a lot and care.

Also, on a side note, I dont know if this was "Shiloh's" doing. I feel like from day one they've molded her into the tomboy role. Even at 6-9-12 months she was dressed like a tomboy (when clearly she was far too young to know what to wear). Another reason this is so confusing.

Message edited 2010-08-06 13:48:26.377000.

Posted 8/6/10 1:45 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

not a big deal at all to me ...people should worry about their family and their kids.....

Posted 8/6/10 1:48 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by MrsPJB2007

I know the idea of a topless child can be a bit taboo, but I think it's so much more common outside of the U.S. and that family spends a lot of time in Europe.

I remember being in Punta Cana, and there were tons of Europeans there and MANY pre-pubescent girls from toddlers to almost 10 year olds, were walking around the pool area with just bottoms on. While it seemed slightly shocking to me, tons of people didn't even blink an eye.

Not something I'd want my kid to do, but don't care if someone else does.




This isn't just a topless kid in the pool due to cultural influence though - between the toplessness, the swim trunks and the hair cut, it's cross dressing. It's obviously unusual, therefore people take notice.

I do agree though, that the important part is that she's healthy and happy. I'm not sure what I would do if I were a parent and had a child that badly wanted to dress unusually, so I try not to judge.

Posted 8/6/10 1:52 PM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

Posted by Palebride

Their kid, their rules.

My daughter is currently sitting in a princess costume with matching princess heels. Many people don't agree with letting a 3 year old wear heels.....but I didn't ask them, so it's not their business.



ITA. Whatever...

Same here except it's my SON who's walking around in the princess dress.. actually he is wearing two right now. He still finds flatulents hysterical so I'm guessing he's all boy, despite the tiaraChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/6/10 1:57 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

a gender identity issue goes much deeper than a persons clothes or hair. To cite that as a reason to not let her be who she wants is really off base, IMO. Its very possible that they wanting to dress like a boy is the result of an already existing gender identity issue or maybe shes just a tomboy.

She is FOUR, leave her alone, who cares. Im not her parent, she seems happy, so therefore not my business.

Message edited 2010-08-06 14:10:49.600000.

Posted 8/6/10 2:09 PM
 

jewels
Stop and smell the flowers

Member since 7/06

1538 total posts

Name:

Re: shiloh jolie pitt

I have mixed feelings about this. I agree with letting the child express herself but it's kind of striking to me that she is actually dressed in clothes from the boy's department and not picking out things that are more her style from the girl's department. With the hair too, it's not a short girl's style cut, it's reallly like a boy's cut. I do not think this in any way will make her a lesbian - to me that is rediculous. But I do kinda think it could create some identity issues. In the end she's not my kid and I don't hear what she says to her parents so I'm not really judging. These are just my thoughts.

Posted 8/6/10 2:13 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt take their daughters, Zahara and Shilohgrocery shopping at Stop & Shop in New York GossipQueen 4/21/09 16 Celebrities & Entertainment
Forbes Power List: Angelina Jolie No. 3; Brad Pitt No. 10 GossipQueen 6/12/08 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Angelina Jolie Splits Pants at Premiere; Brad Pitt Covers Her Up GossipQueen 11/12/07 14 Celebrities & Entertainment
Angelina Jolie, Brad Pitt, Zahara and Shiloh take a walk in New Orleans MrsQ 2/22/07 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Shiloh Jolie-Pitt makes her debut! chelle 12/13/06 19 Celebrities & Entertainment
Baby Shiloh Jolie-Pitt looks like... MommaG 10/22/06 9 Celebrities & Entertainment