Rent vs Buy?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Rent vs Buy?

Right now we are renting a 1 bedroom apt, but will be moving into a 2 bedroom next year (that's the plan anyway). The rent will be close to $1800 p/m. My BIL and sister recommeded for those prices, we may want to look into a starter home. It will be more, but it would be more worth it. I am a little nervous about the idea of it. For the amount we would be paying for the apartment, does it make more sense to maybe start looking at houses? Would the benefit outweight the increase in monthly price. We are looking at the $300-$350 range. I am very nervous about the idea, basicly because it's such a big step. Was anyone else this nervous about it? Thoughts?

Posted 7/27/08 2:39 PM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

danielleandscott
My new 71 Super Beetle

Member since 5/05

13476 total posts

Name:
Scott

Re: Rent vs Buy?

1st step should be getting pre qualified for a mortgage by a broker to see what you can spend.

2nd step would be to sit down and write down all of the bills you have per month and see what you have left at the end of the month

3rd step would to see what you will be able to put down, so you can figure out what a mortgage payment will be per month. Other than the mortgage you will have to pay:
Taxes
Utilities
Home Owners ins
Cable - Computer - Phone
and have money for in case of an emergency or what eever comes up around the house. At least $10k for that, just in case.

4th step would be to start hitting open houses in the areas that you want to look at. This will give you an idea of what towns you like, school districts you want, and what type of amenities you are looking for. Also ask a lot of questions. This really helped Danielle and I when we were looking.

Good Luck
Scott

Message edited 2008-07-27 14:47:14.603000.

Posted 7/27/08 2:45 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by LittleBlueBug

Right now we are renting a 1 bedroom apt, but will be moving into a 2 bedroom next year (that's the plan anyway). The rent will be close to $1800 p/m. My BIL and sister recommeded for those prices, we may want to look into a starter home. It will be more, but it would be more worth it. I am a little nervous about the idea of it. For the amount we would be paying for the apartment, does it make more sense to maybe start looking at houses? Would the benefit outweight the increase in monthly price. We are looking at the $300-$350 range. I am very nervous about the idea, basicly because it's such a big step. Was anyone else this nervous about it? Thoughts?



we rent- because even at a starter house $1800 is the mortgage but doesn't include any of the other costs associated with running a home- like taxes- which can be an additional $500 month or more, higher prices for electric and gas/heat because the home is bigger than 1 bedroom apartment, etc.

we went from an inexpensive 2 bedroom in NJ to a 3 bedroom townhouse here on LI- more expensive.. and I figure we'll get used to it and keep saving. If you can afford a more expensive rental and still continue to save, do taht until you get used to itand then buy

Posted 7/27/08 2:50 PM
 

Jackie24
~We Did it~

Member since 7/06

6718 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Rent vs Buy?

I agree with Scott, 1800 is alot of money, but if you can still save every month and want to save up for what you really want that may be better as well. Don't forget most starter homes need ALOT of work, as well as unexpected repairs. How do you feel about a condo or townhouse.

Posted 7/27/08 3:03 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by Jackie24

I agree with Scott, 1800 is alot of money, but if you can still save every month and want to save up for what you really want that may be better as well. Don't forget most starter homes need ALOT of work, as well as unexpected repairs. How do you feel about a condo or townhouse.



We are open to a condo/townhouse too.

We would not be able to afford too high taxes. So far the houses we are looking at today are btwn 260-349, big range I know, but we are looking in different areas at once. I am weaning out houses w/ taxes that are too high for us. May look at some short sales too.

The rent would have been cheaper had we stayed in our current complex. We decided to go further west though because of our jobs. Although it's still a heatherwood community, it's more expensive for the same apartment.

Posted 7/27/08 3:56 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Rent vs Buy?

I have a question about condos/townhouses:

Do you get charged for your pet the way you do in apartments?

Posted 7/27/08 4:04 PM
 

Jackie24
~We Did it~

Member since 7/06

6718 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by LittleBlueBug

I have a question about condos/townhouses:

Do you get charged for your pet the way you do in apartments?



not if you own, there are also HOA fees though

Posted 7/27/08 4:07 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Approximately what would be looking at as far as fees/common charges for that?

Posted 7/27/08 4:09 PM
 

Jackie24
~We Did it~

Member since 7/06

6718 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by LittleBlueBug

Approximately what would be looking at as far as fees/common charges for that?



Im sorry the HOA fees usually cover maintenance, when I was looking at condos they ranged from 150-300 per month, but I guess it varies depending where you are looking.

Posted 7/27/08 4:17 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by Jackie24

Posted by LittleBlueBug

Approximately what would be looking at as far as fees/common charges for that?



Im sorry the HOA fees usually cover maintenance, when I was looking at condos they ranged from 150-300 per month, but I guess it varies depending where you are looking.



Our common charges for our condo are $350 for a one-bedroom, which covers maintenance and heat. Our complex has a pool, so a large portion of the charges go towards lifeguards/pool upkeep. Our taxes are not included in that, and are $3500 before STAR. Electricity, sewer charges, etc. are not included. It adds up to quite a bit more than $1800, so if the rent includes electricity you are definitely paying less than you would for most condos and definitely townhomes in decent areas.

Even with a condo, anything that breaks inside you are responsible for. Our first month we needed to replace the dishwasher and several outlets, which added up to over $1000. Last month we had an issue with a heating pipe that cost us several hundred. It is ownership, just like a house, so you need to be prepared for the unexpected expenses.

Also, the houses that you see for the $300,000 range in decent areas generally require a great deal of work.

Message edited 2008-07-27 16:36:48.020000.

Posted 7/27/08 4:35 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Rent vs Buy?

We just bought our first "starter" home earlier this year. The difference from renting to our monthly mortgage/taxes is about an additional $1200.00 per month. HOWEVER that does NOT factor in our utilities, as well as renovations we want to do (luckily the market was good for us when we bought so we got a home in move-in condition).

My husband luckily can swing the mortgage on his salary alone right now since business is good and I pay for mostly everything else, as well as $$$ towards our savings. We also have no debt except my student loans and the mortage.

However, that could change since he is self-employed in construction (being able to afford mortgage himself). We are also going to be having our first child soon and feel that I will always have to work so we can afford to keep our house. At least on Long Island anyways.........

Posted 7/27/08 4:50 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Thanks for the info everyone.

Just wanted to mention though that we don't get anything included in our rent except garbage pick-up and hot water since we rent from a complex, not privately. Unfortunately we have appliances that date back to the stone age (which they were telling us they would be updating this summer, but have not made any arrangements to), so we don't have the option to have energy efficient appliances. Plus, of course, they charge for pets.

We may rent for an additional year if we don't find anything. We do have time on our side. We will look and see if we find something in decent move-in condition and we will discuss what we are even eligible for with my credit union.

I have to say, I would definitely prefer to have a yard for our kids and pet, and not have to deal w/ trying to pry cigarette butts out of my pup's mouth and smell all of the cigarette smoke that seeps into our apartment from surrounding neighbors ( we had a black out before and our air cleaner wasn't working, so our apartment reeks now)...as well as have the equity.

For those who own a small ranch, on average (if you don't mind sharing), what does your LIPA bill come to?

Message edited 2008-07-27 18:48:36.183000.

Posted 7/27/08 6:44 PM
 

babyfaith
Onward and Upward!

Member since 2/08

3210 total posts

Name:

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Buying a 2 bedroom condo or coop may be a good middle ground for you. Many people do that before buying a house. GL!

Posted 7/27/08 6:50 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Rent vs Buy?

We have an "extended ranch" and our LIPA bill is usually under $100.00 a month. We also have gas which runs our heat and appliances and is $184.00 (we have balanced billing). We also use a ton of water and our water bill which covered April- due in August was only $90.00. Our sewer bill (I think that's due every 3 months) is $30.50.


My family and friends have oil and really have struggled with those payments this past winter.

Message edited 2008-07-27 19:05:00.047000.

Posted 7/27/08 7:03 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Rent vs Buy?

I would not buy a house just to buy and not rent.

keep saving your $ for a down payment. only you will know when the time is right for YOU

Posted 7/27/08 7:21 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

I would not buy a house just to buy and not rent.

keep saving your $ for a down payment. only you will know when the time is right for YOU



I totally agree. We never would've been able to have bought our home if we didn't have some generous help with the downpayment from family and primarily a monetary gift left to DH from his late grandmother.

It's really, really scary putting that much money down, not including closing costs. Luckily we didn't have to totally drain our savings which is another scary thought when you are about to become a first-time homeowner.

Posted 7/27/08 8:52 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

I would not buy a house just to buy and not rent.

keep saving your $ for a down payment. only you will know when the time is right for YOU



ITA! Especially with the increase in everything - utilities will end up costing you a pretty penny at the end of each month!

Condo's and Coops may be a better fit for you right now.

Chat Icon

Posted 7/28/08 9:21 AM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by mzsocialworker1

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

I would not buy a house just to buy and not rent.

keep saving your $ for a down payment. only you will know when the time is right for YOU






Totally totally DISAGREE and I'm the big sister so listen to ME girly. Your time IS right for YOU. No one on here knows you better.

Buying our "starter house" was by far the best thing we ever did. If it werent for that equity (and there's no way to save the same amount in 5 years that we made in equity) we would not be able to buy in the price range we are now looking for. BUY NOW! You can do it. Look at S and J? Bought a starter house when he was in his early 20's and unattached and before they had their kids they were able to upgrade to a mansion in Woodbury. Real estate is never a bad investment and FLAME me all you want ladies... I'm in a mood today... but renting is a total waist of money. I don't care what anyone tells you, I'm your sister and we want you to make the best decision for your future, a bunch of people who know nothing about you or your finances cannot offer real advice. You guys aren't spring chickens - your thinking family in the not too distant future. You'll never save in 5 years time what you can make in equity in the right house in the right place - and you can alway renovate the house if you don't want to move per se.

DH and I are fully behind you guys... we wouldn't steer you wrong. Buy so as not to rent. You'll be glad you did. We rented before we bought and again, we would have tossed money out the door... it's nice to now have a down payment based on the equity of several hundred thou and none of it is out of our pocket, it's all from the sale of this house... plus our credit is great b/c we paid our mortgage every month among everything else. Dad can help with renovations that may be needed like he did with us. You'll be fine... I know what your renting costs are vs. what kind of mortgage you are looking for.

Be careful what kinds of questions you ask on here kiddo - just like we FM eachother about all the time. No one knows your situation and what family backing you have (i.e. dad's business, so to some people renovations aren't woth it, but you'll get some deals most aren't privy to) Buy just to buy girly... you'll be fine, it's just scary the first time... everyone goes through it... it's scary every time actually. It's a big step, but an important one.... I mean, you know that my DD has an account JUST for a Real Estate purchase... To me it's more important than college and I don't care who disagrees with me today - and you and I both have Master's degrees... trust me, RE was the best thing. Can't wait for your house warming party - so get busy on mlsli.com.

Message edited 2008-07-30 17:36:49.593000.

Posted 7/30/08 5:33 PM
 

TJLealand3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/07

839 total posts

Name:
Thomas

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by Jackie24

Posted by LittleBlueBug

Approximately what would be looking at as far as fees/common charges for that?



Im sorry the HOA fees usually cover maintenance, when I was looking at condos they ranged from 150-300 per month, but I guess it varies depending where you are looking.



My MIL has a one bedroom co-op in Mineola and pays a common charge of 600+ per month.

Posted 7/30/08 6:29 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by clwp

Buying our "starter house" was by far the best thing we ever did. If it werent for that equity (and there's no way to save the same amount in 5 years that we made in equity)




while I agree with mostly everything you said- I have challenge this

the market has changed- the first 5 years of a mortgage are INTEREST

you pay off very little of the principle in the first 5 years

the market might go up- it might not- it's a risk for a short term situation

but just paying your mortgage doesn't mean you are going to have a ton of extra money to put down on a new home in 5 years

there are alot of people on this site and IRL that are stuck in the wrong house for them b/c they bought just to buy


Posted 7/30/08 8:00 PM
 

Melmel821
Love being a mom!

Member since 5/08

2776 total posts

Name:
Melanie

Re: Rent vs Buy?

I am quite content with renting until I am ready to buy my home. I have no desire for a starter home that will most likely need updates and repairs. I'm am happy that my apartment is in excellent condition. Many 'starter' homes that I've seen needed many updates and repairs. And if I need something I just call the super and it's taken care of. When I'm ready, I will buy a house I love. But if you can find a really nice home in your price range... well that's a different story. But for now, I enjoy renting.

Posted 7/30/08 10:34 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by TJLealand3

Posted by Jackie24

Posted by LittleBlueBug

Approximately what would be looking at as far as fees/common charges for that?



Im sorry the HOA fees usually cover maintenance, when I was looking at condos they ranged from 150-300 per month, but I guess it varies depending where you are looking.



My MIL has a one bedroom co-op in Mineola and pays a common charge of 600+ per month.



Co-ops are very different from condos in terms of common charges. Co-op fees are always higher but include more (taxes, possibly electricity, etc.). Our condo fees are half of those co-ops, but do not include taxes, electricity, etc. Basically all ours include is maintenance. Co-op prices are generally much lower than condos of the same size in the same area.

Posted 7/31/08 8:22 AM
 

KvsGrl
Round 2!!

Member since 1/07

1202 total posts

Name:
Samantha

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by Beth1210

Posted by clwp

Buying our "starter house" was by far the best thing we ever did. If it werent for that equity (and there's no way to save the same amount in 5 years that we made in equity)




while I agree with mostly everything you said- I have challenge this

the market has changed- the first 5 years of a mortgage are INTEREST

you pay off very little of the principle in the first 5 years

the market might go up- it might not- it's a risk for a short term situation

but just paying your mortgage doesn't mean you are going to have a ton of extra money to put down on a new home in 5 years

there are alot of people on this site and IRL that are stuck in the wrong house for them b/c they bought just to buy





I was just going to say this. The market is in the process of correcting itself and they don't expect to see the inflated housing prices that they have in the past 5 years. However, that does not mean it is not a good time to buy, I would just think longer term.

Posted 7/31/08 8:56 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by nov04libride

Posted by TJLealand3

Posted by Jackie24

Posted by LittleBlueBug

Approximately what would be looking at as far as fees/common charges for that?



Im sorry the HOA fees usually cover maintenance, when I was looking at condos they ranged from 150-300 per month, but I guess it varies depending where you are looking.



My MIL has a one bedroom co-op in Mineola and pays a common charge of 600+ per month.



Co-ops are very different from condos in terms of common charges. Co-op fees are always higher but include more (taxes, possibly electricity, etc.). Our condo fees are half of those co-ops, but do not include taxes, electricity, etc. Basically all ours include is maintenance. Co-op prices are generally much lower than condos of the same size in the same area.



I would buy a starter home before buying a co-op. The maintenance/monthly fee are crazy. 1 bedroom in Farmingdale was over $700 a month.

How tight will you be with $1800 a month?

Depending on your town, taxes can be anywhere from $500 to $1000 a month. Then you are other expenses. The yard maintenance and all the gear for it. Tools, etc.. A house has a lot of maintenance expenses (landscaper or buying a lawnmower, plants, fertilizer... or pay for the landscaper to do it, sweeping the chimney, things that break down, thing to replace, etc..).

But IMO $1800 a house is a lot of money "wasted" per month. I would personally stay put until I can have a decent down payment and save faster.

Posted 7/31/08 8:58 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Rent vs Buy?

Posted by Beth1210

Posted by clwp

Buying our "starter house" was by far the best thing we ever did. If it werent for that equity (and there's no way to save the same amount in 5 years that we made in equity)




while I agree with mostly everything you said- I have challenge this

the market has changed- the first 5 years of a mortgage are INTEREST

you pay off very little of the principle in the first 5 years

the market might go up- it might not- it's a risk for a short term situation

but just paying your mortgage doesn't mean you are going to have a ton of extra money to put down on a new home in 5 years

there are alot of people on this site and IRL that are stuck in the wrong house for them b/c they bought just to buy





I agree and would add that one of the reasons the market is in such a crisis is because people felt that real estate is always a good investment and bought more than they could afford, or bought improperly assuming the market would continue to go up.

I also don't agree that you should go to a mortgage broker to see what you can afford. Figure out what YOU can afford and stick to it. What can you pay monthly for your home (including any fees, taxes, etc.) and still have enough for all other bills, repairs/emergency fund and savings.

When we bought our first home we were approved for TWICE what we felt we could comfortably afford and still have money for savings and everything else. The mortgage companies know you will pay your mortgage first if times get tough. If we had listened to them and had taken on a $4K mortgage/tax payment we would have been sunk when the roof needed to be repaired, the oil tanks replaced, we added gutters, landscaping, a foundation drain, my car replaced and next year we'll be adding daycare. We have been able to pay for our home repairs/renovations with cash instead of credit which would have then compounded into more monthly payments, less savings etc. a vicious cycle. Know your own financial limits, don't let someone else tell you what they are.

If it is too tight at the moment, then continue to save until you know you can afford the costs associated with a house.



Message edited 2008-07-31 09:28:12.130000.

Posted 7/31/08 9:27 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Rent vs. Buy- rule of 15 from Today Show Sassyz75 7/9/08 50 Home
I would love your opinions....To rent or to buy? That is the question Jessica 6/4/07 18 Home
Repost from Home board. What is "Rent to buy"? KGools 5/10/07 2 Families Helping Families ™
Rent to Buy Question KGools 5/10/07 7 Home
to rent or to buy that is the question Daybreak 4/23/07 11 Home
Buy small now, or rent for a few more years to afford more? VirginiaDeb 3/3/07 4 Home
Rent vs. Buy- rule of 15 from Today Show Sassyz75 7/9/08 50 Home
I would love your opinions....To rent or to buy? That is the question Jessica 6/4/07 18 Home
Repost from Home board. What is "Rent to buy"? KGools 5/10/07 2 Families Helping Families ™
Rent to Buy Question KGools 5/10/07 7 Home
to rent or to buy that is the question Daybreak 4/23/07 11 Home
Buy small now, or rent for a few more years to afford more? VirginiaDeb 3/3/07 4 Home