Re: Rent vs Buy?
Posted 7/31/2008 9:27:07 AM by NinaLemon


Posted by Beth1210


Posted by clwp

Buying our "starter house" was by far the best thing we ever did. If it werent for that equity (and there's no way to save the same amount in 5 years that we made in equity)




while I agree with mostly everything you said- I have challenge this

the market has changed- the first 5 years of a mortgage are INTEREST

you pay off very little of the principle in the first 5 years

the market might go up- it might not- it's a risk for a short term situation

but just paying your mortgage doesn't mean you are going to have a ton of extra money to put down on a new home in 5 years

there are alot of people on this site and IRL that are stuck in the wrong house for them b/c they bought just to buy





I agree and would add that one of the reasons the market is in such a crisis is because people felt that real estate is always a good investment and bought more than they could afford, or bought improperly assuming the market would continue to go up.

I also don't agree that you should go to a mortgage broker to see what you can afford. Figure out what YOU can afford and stick to it. What can you pay monthly for your home (including any fees, taxes, etc.) and still have enough for all other bills, repairs/emergency fund and savings.

When we bought our first home we were approved for TWICE what we felt we could comfortably afford and still have money for savings and everything else. The mortgage companies know you will pay your mortgage first if times get tough. If we had listened to them and had taken on a $4K mortgage/tax payment we would have been sunk when the roof needed to be repaired, the oil tanks replaced, we added gutters, landscaping, a foundation drain, my car replaced and next year we'll be adding daycare. We have been able to pay for our home repairs/renovations with cash instead of credit which would have then compounded into more monthly payments, less savings etc. a vicious cycle. Know your own financial limits, don't let someone else tell you what they are.

If it is too tight at the moment, then continue to save until you know you can afford the costs associated with a house.




Print Post      Close Window