question regarding TV

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

question regarding TV

So I was watching the show "The Doctors" today and they were saying that for children under age 2 (specifically ages 8months to 2yrs) watching television can actually harm the development of your child. They explained that the TV does not interact w/ the child and that it can make them talk/learn less. They said the best way to have your child learn is through parental interaction. My DS is only 3 months right now but I was just wondering what you moms thought of this?

Posted 12/16/09 10:39 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

this is going to sound silly - but i have noticed - at least with the stuff on Nick JR - that they actually DO try to have them interact.... they ask a question and wait for an answer - (or throw in those kid voices answering)..

i don't know how i feel about it...

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/16/09 10:42 PM
 

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: question regarding TV

Well that is good to hear. I grew up watching TV and I can't imagine this to be true??

Posted 12/16/09 11:16 PM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by davenjess

this is going to sound silly - but i have noticed - at least with the stuff on Nick JR - that they actually DO try to have them interact.... they ask a question and wait for an answer - (or throw in those kid voices answering)..

i don't know how i feel about it...

Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree...I thought I was going to feel strongly against my kids watching a lot of tv....but I feel tv is VERY different from when we were little...there is more learning and interaction...if all the cartoons were mindless silliness (ie Spongebob) then I would agree with the drs...but bec of Dora, moose, diego, Kai Lan, etc my 2.5 yr can count to 10 in Spanish, knows come chinese words, knows her shapes, colors among other stuff (id like to think I helped with these, but Nick Jr Noggin has def helped!)

Posted 12/16/09 11:16 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: question regarding TV

Yes I believe that is true actually...I have heard it , seen the research...BUT ....I'm suckiest mom of the year then b/c my son's obsessed w/ TV and I'm sure the girls will be too. My reality is that it's neccesary for us to survive Chat Icon

eta- and I agree with Jess...my son has a speech delay ( hmm...due to TV or not Chat Icon ) and shows liek Dora and diego helped him START talking and increased his language a lot.

Message edited 2009-12-17 01:04:08.130000.

Posted 12/17/09 1:03 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: question regarding TV

I think it's right - that they do turn into little zombies in front of the TV, *but* in moderation I also think that it's ok. Everyone, including adults and babies, need some downtime. There are times when Alex is exhausted, has had a really long day, and all she needs is to just vegetate, and that's when I usually turn on the TV for her. I make a point never to let her watch more than a half hour to an hour a day, but there are times that she needs the downtime, as well as I!

Posted 12/17/09 1:06 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: question regarding TV

We watch the TV with DC, and they've been sitting with us watching TV since they were very little.

DS is one of the smartest 6yos I know. He's been reading for years, and his favorite nighttime book is a 2nd grade math book.
He corrects the Closed Captioning on the TV when it's not printing what they're saying. He's enhanced his Spanish from Dora, he knows a few Chinese words from Kai-Lan, he's learned lots of science facts from Sid the Science Kid.

IMO, he would be much less knowledgeable about a lot of things without the TV shows he watches....

Also, watching TV isn't all he does. He plays with DD a lot. He's written his own books with plot lines and illustrations and bound them. He's started his own "company" making confetti products, making product label to put over empty boxes, came up with his own company name.

His teacher even commented to us that he corrected her about the shape of the Earth. She said it was a sphere, and he explained to her that the equator is slightly bigger than around the poles, so it's not really a perfect sphere.... Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 7:29 AM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: question regarding TV

my DC don't sit in front of the TV to watch it but it is always on as background noise and we watch either babybumblee videos (learning) or sesame street.

he really has no interest in Nick Jr.

Posted 12/17/09 7:45 AM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by davenjess

this is going to sound silly - but i have noticed - at least with the stuff on Nick JR - that they actually DO try to have them interact.... they ask a question and wait for an answer - (or throw in those kid voices answering)..



There's many shows like this on Disney and PBS as well (Mickey Mouse, Sesame Street).

DS started loving TV at a very young age (he had a "favorite" show by 5 mos!) and we tried to limit it (still do) bc I was nervous about it but he was defintely watching it consistently before age 1. But I can honestly say his vocabulary has always been substantially above average for his age and he knew the alphabet, colors, numbers etc. well before age 2. I truly think Sesame Street played a decent role in that.

Posted 12/17/09 7:59 AM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: question regarding TV

I've heard the same thing and I do have insane friends who won't even face their baby in the direction of the television.
Right now DS is 6 months old. He actually loves watching the TV. I don't mind, but as others said... in moderation. I usually try and distract him. When he's a little older I'll put on educational programs

Had to Add... Love the blonde guy on "The Doctors" Chat Icon
I remember watching him at my OB's office in the mornings when I was preganant in the waiting room and every morning on maternity leave. Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 8:39 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: question regarding TV

I do not buy into that AT ALL...my dd has been watching TV since she was a baby (educational shows on the kiddie channels) and her speech is AMAZING...she has been talking since an early age and is very advanced in that regard...do what works for you and your childChat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 8:41 AM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: question regarding TV

i am not neccessarily happy with the amount of tv that ds watches, but it is the only way that i can actually get anything done.... and with another baby due in january i really have no choice... i just am very picky on what he watches and while it vocabulary is not the best i dont really blame it on tv...

Posted 12/17/09 8:46 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: question regarding TV

i think if you're watching tv with the kid and interacting with them, its ok. dumping them in front of a tv for hours a day is not ideal.

i think a little tv here and there by themselves is fine. like PP said, sometimes kids need to veg out just like adults do.

Posted 12/17/09 8:50 AM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: question regarding TV

Well for us...

DD was watching TV at 3 months...she is a TV junkie. The TV is on all day long.

I'm not here to brag, it's just who she is....She is 2.5 years old

She was a VERY early talker, she has beautiful pronunciation, I was having conversations with her at a very early age...she is very smart, understands things and can do things that some can't. IMO, she picked up a ridiculous amount of information from the TV.

I have a lot of interaction with her as well.

But in our case, TV watching did no harm what-so-ever in her developement. In fact, I actually think it helped her in some ways. I'm amazed every day at her advancement.

Posted 12/17/09 8:59 AM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: question regarding TV

I don't agree with this at all. My son learned to sing, talk, and dance with Blues Clues and the wiggles. He learned his colors from wiggles, and learned tons of words from Blues Clues. He is above and beyond speech developement for his age and I attribute this to regular conversations and blues clues.

Message edited 2009-12-17 09:01:19.813000.

Posted 12/17/09 9:00 AM
 

JenBenMen
party of five

Member since 9/06

11343 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: question regarding TV

I tend to agree with what was said -coupled with lots of research I did on the topic.

TV is very passive. I look at it this way--if they are STARING at TV those are moments they are NOT looking at a book or playing with toys

So...I limit TV and I would advise to start "limiting" it at a young age since now my 2 yr old asks for TV and its harder when they ask

That being said I do put it on when I need to do things around the house. Sesame Street and Nick Jr are great.

Posted 12/17/09 9:31 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: question regarding TV

IMO, it's all about parent involvement....period.

Some parents may NEVER let their kids watch TV but also those parents also could not interact with their child/teach their child-- so the kid isn't learning anything from anyone OR the TV.

Some parents may let their kid watch a ton of TV but also interact with their kids/teach their kids-- so the child is learning DOUBLY!

Us-- we didn't let DD really watch TV until she was almost 1....and just Sesame Street once a day. She slowly progressed to more TV shows she liked...but still now, the TV is on only about 2 hours a day, and even if it's on she's rarely sitting still watching it, she's playing with other things and will turn to the TV when she hears something of interest. We make a BIG deal about learning in our house, she's a little sponge who likes to learn about anything and everything, so we're very lucky. And her vocab is off the charts, she is very well-behaved, etc.

It's all about who's teaching them what....plopping kids in front of a TV for 10 hours a day and never interating with them and teaching them would probably harm them in terms of learning. But I think MOST parents don't do that!

Message edited 2009-12-17 09:42:29.413000.

Posted 12/17/09 9:41 AM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: question regarding TV

Yea I agree with the Nick Jr thing, they kind of prompt the kids to answer..

I do put Tommy in front of it when I am trying to blow dry my hair etc but I don't leave him there forever...I am sure there are people that use it as a babysitter. I don't.

Posted 12/17/09 9:44 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by JenBenMen

TV is very passive. I look at it this way--if they are STARING at TV those are moments they are NOT looking at a book or playing with toys
.



Define "passive", though. If DC are responding to the questions being asked on the TV show, and they are absorbing the information that is being given to them, and using the knowledge after the show is over, isn't it just as "passive" as listening to Mommy or Daddy, or a teacher, or reading a book? There are many methods of learning, and I think TV can be a useful tool for teaching.

I've never fallen asleep during one of DC's educational shows, but I have dozed off during college classes... so which one is "better"?

Posted 12/17/09 9:44 AM
 

dottiemchugh
<3

Member since 5/05

8261 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

I have always LOVED tv.. I was glued to the tv as a kid.. no problems here. Ryan is almost 4 and is just like me.. he loves his tv. We watch with him and he is CONSTANTLY talking about what is happening and we ask questions, etc. TV can become interactive if you make it that way. I don't always have the time to do that, but I see nothing wrong with tv in general, and hate that society puts this guilt trip on parents who allow children to watch it.

Posted 12/17/09 9:54 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by GoldenRod

I've never fallen asleep during one of DC's educational shows, but I have dozed off during college classes... so which one is "better"?



Chat Icon Chat Icon nice!! =)

Posted 12/17/09 9:56 AM
 

My4GirlsMyLife
My 4 girlies

Member since 2/08

9702 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: question regarding TV

Eva is 16 months ,and she watches tv alot ! Her 3rd word was Dora Chat Icon she now is at the level of a 19 month old ,and says 25-30 words

Posted 12/17/09 10:03 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

Personally, I feel like if you are spending the better part of your day interacting with your child and playing with them and teaching them then watching TV is so not a big deal. My DD is 15 months old and has been watching TV since she was about 3-4 months old and she loves it. Early on it was just Baby Einstein videos but she loved the colors, movement, and music and I got a break to make dinner, do a load of laundry, or even just pee. LOL As she got older she loved Backyardigans, the Tinkerbell movie, and more. Now her favorites are Mickey's Clubhouse and The Fresh Beat Band.

I think anything, including TV, in moderation is fine. TV is not the devil, I grew up watching cartoons when I was a kid and I turned out just fine. Again, as long as you're not sitting them in front of the TV morning, noon, and night without doing anything else with them I don't see a problem with it. To me it's just another form of stimulation. My DD is usually playing with her blocks and toys even while she is watching her cartoon but when we are interacting and playing with her we turn the TV off so she's not distracted and she could careless that the TV is off. A little TV never hurt anyone. I think people tend to overreact about television. I truly don't see the big deal but that's just my opinion. Again, everything in moderation is fine IMO. Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 10:06 AM
 

JenBenMen
party of five

Member since 9/06

11343 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by JenBenMen

TV is very passive. I look at it this way--if they are STARING at TV those are moments they are NOT looking at a book or playing with toys
.



Define "passive", though. If DC are responding to the questions being asked on the TV show, and they are absorbing the information that is being given to them, and using the knowledge after the show is over, isn't it just as "passive" as listening to Mommy or Daddy, or a teacher, or reading a book? There are many methods of learning, and I think TV can be a useful tool for teaching.

I've never fallen asleep during one of DC's educational shows, but I have dozed off during college classes... so which one is "better"?



True. Not all shows are passive. The ones on Nick Jr, sesame street and the like ask for the kids to answer questions so I think those are better

Posted 12/17/09 10:08 AM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

I put the TV on for DS everytime he eats, bc he sits totally still, watching the tv , not distracted by anything. but once he is out of his highchair, he will glance if a song comes on but that's about it.

I'm sure the studies are correct but most shows on Nick JR are ok

Posted 12/17/09 10:10 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I just have one question.... JenniferEver 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Follow up to allergy question DramaQueen 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
BabyBoy question for you TAD 5/11/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
STAR question sasha96 5/11/05 2 Home
Silly Reality Question Redhead 5/11/05 19 Families Helping Families ™
I got a question fakie1 5/10/05 86 Families Helping Families ™