question regarding TV

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

sleepie76
enjoying every minute

Member since 12/07

3881 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

I was watching that show with my 3 month old too! I mentioned it to my husband when he came home.

They said something like for every hour your child watches tv, they are losing 10 vocabulary words.

TV concerns me a little. If I see her focusing on it for longer than a couple minutes, I shut it off.

But I think it really does come down to total interaction throughout the entire day as opposed to 1 hour of tv.

Posted 12/17/09 10:25 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jprimrose
I love my little munchkins!

Member since 10/05

3939 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

My DS didn't really watch TV until he was 18 months and then he started watching Sesame Street. Now he watches channel 13 and Nick Jr. Of course now at 26 months he is addicted and always asks for me to turn it on. My DD is 12 months and because it is on for my DS she also watches it. She has some interest in it, but not as much as my DS.

I don't think TV is that great for them, but I do let them watch it. Every time it is on I feel a little guilty, but I do agree with other on here that there are some great shows on Channel 13 and Nick Jr. I think it is all about moderation.

Posted 12/17/09 1:34 PM
 

Kate
*****

Member since 5/05

7557 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by dottiemchugh

I have always LOVED tv.. I was glued to the tv as a kid.. no problems here. Ryan is almost 4 and is just like me.. he loves his tv. We watch with him and he is CONSTANTLY talking about what is happening and we ask questions, etc. TV can become interactive if you make it that way. I don't always have the time to do that, but I see nothing wrong with tv in general, and hate that society puts this guilt trip on parents who allow children to watch it.



I agree! Ryan loves TV, and I'm not worried. He's reading and he's only 3.5. Don't think the TV has harmed him a bit.

Posted 12/17/09 2:07 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

When DS was born, I vowed to follow this advice, but shortly after he turned a year, he started to watch some tv.

Actually, I feel the APA almost does a diservice by not discussiong responsible TV viewing at all--there is just a blanket no tv until two rule. Which is difficult for most parents to follow. I think as long as they are watching programming designed for children with an educational component, not getting exposed to violence or commericials at a young age, and not watching too much TV, they are going to be just fine.

Honestly, I usually put the TV on when I need to get dressed or do dishes or such. Am I interacting with DS during these times? No. So what is he missing out on? I suppose he could play with his toys himself, and sometimes he does this, but if he wants to watch a show, and I can't entertain him at the moment, then I don't see an issue with it.

Posted 12/17/09 2:52 PM
 

mrandmrs12
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1687 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

i think like everything else - tv is fine in moderation.

i agree with some other posters that i feel watching shows like diego and other nick jr. shows has HELPED ds talk more and learn about things, animals, etc. I try to watch with him as much as possible so we can talk about it while we watch or whatever. We LOVE super why! DS is so into letters and it is helping him learn them even more.

my personal limit is 1-2 hours of tv per day. LOL - before i was a mom I thought that was soooo long. But now 1-2 hours of tv seems liek nothign!

anyway, as a specialist who works with children (don't want to get into what i do for a living), i do know that tv is not the greatest for visual perception development and eye tracking skills. It can train the eyes to "diverge" instead of "converge" which is what your eyes need to do to read, etc. THIS is why I personally try to limit tv watching.

Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 2:55 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: question regarding TV

I am not a big fan of letting DD watch TV, but with that said, there are certain circumstances where I'm okay with it.

Like, I'm changing the sheet of her crib or putting her laundry away, and need to keep her occupied for 5 minutes, or finish getting myself dressed. Or like now that we are having a VERY difficult time getting her to take her bottles, sometimes the only way she will take it is if we turn the TV on.

DH read, and I'm reading it now a book called Nurture Shock (I think that's the name of it), one of the things they talk about in the book is if you must put your kid in front of a TV, to put on the News or something similar where they can actually SEE the person talking. (I forget the exact reason as I haven't really gotten through that part yet)

Posted 12/17/09 2:57 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by chelle

Well for us...

DD was watching TV at 3 months...she is a TV junkie. The TV is on all day long.

I'm not here to brag, it's just who she is....She is 2.5 years old

She was a VERY early talker, she has beautiful pronunciation, I was having conversations with her at a very early age...she is very smart, understands things and can do things that some can't. IMO, she picked up a ridiculous amount of information from the TV.

I have a lot of interaction with her as well.

But in our case, TV watching did no harm what-so-ever in her developement. In fact, I actually think it helped her in some ways. I'm amazed every day at her advancement.


same thing... I agree....

Posted 12/17/09 2:58 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by MrsRbk

DH read, and I'm reading it now a book called Nurture Shock (I think that's the name of it), one of the things they talk about in the book is if you must put your kid in front of a TV, to put on the News or something similar where they can actually SEE the person talking. (I forget the exact reason as I haven't really gotten through that part yet)



I saw another study that showed DC get more nightmares from watching the news than violent movies. At a certain age, kids know what is make-believe, so they don't internalize robots that transform, or 50 foot tall monsters. However, when the news shows somebody getting shot, or in a bad accident, they turn it inwards, and worry that they or someone they love will have the same thing happen to them.

Posted 12/17/09 3:05 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by MrsRbk

DH read, and I'm reading it now a book called Nurture Shock (I think that's the name of it), one of the things they talk about in the book is if you must put your kid in front of a TV, to put on the News or something similar where they can actually SEE the person talking. (I forget the exact reason as I haven't really gotten through that part yet)



I saw another study that showed DC get more nightmares from watching the news than violent movies. At a certain age, kids know what is make-believe, so they don't internalize robots that transform, or 50 foot tall monsters. However, when the news shows somebody getting shot, or in a bad accident, they turn it inwards, and worry that they or someone they love will have the same thing happen to them.



I've heard of this idea--it was used to criticize the Baby Einstein videos, and the disembodied voices saying words. It is very beneficial for young children, esp. babies to see faces and see the faces while they are speaking. But I agree, I don't think I want DS watching the news.

Posted 12/17/09 3:17 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by cjik

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by MrsRbk

DH read, and I'm reading it now a book called Nurture Shock (I think that's the name of it), one of the things they talk about in the book is if you must put your kid in front of a TV, to put on the News or something similar where they can actually SEE the person talking. (I forget the exact reason as I haven't really gotten through that part yet)



I saw another study that showed DC get more nightmares from watching the news than violent movies. At a certain age, kids know what is make-believe, so they don't internalize robots that transform, or 50 foot tall monsters. However, when the news shows somebody getting shot, or in a bad accident, they turn it inwards, and worry that they or someone they love will have the same thing happen to them.



I've heard of this idea--it was used to criticize the Baby Einstein videos, and the disembodied voices saying words. It is very beneficial for young children, esp. babies to see faces and see the faces while they are speaking. But I agree, I don't think I want DS watching the news.



I used news as an example, the point is that if they are going to watch TV, they should watch something that SHOWS people talking rather than animated charactors talking.

Posted 12/17/09 3:19 PM
 

johnsae
Sip.

Member since 3/06

18677 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

DD didn't pay any attention to TV until she was at least 2. Now she is obsessed with Little Bear and I think it's adorable and pretty harmless.

Posted 12/17/09 3:20 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by pinkandblue

I do not buy into that AT ALL...my dd has been watching TV since she was a baby (educational shows on the kiddie channels) and her speech is AMAZING...she has been talking since an early age and is very advanced in that regard...do what works for you and your childChat Icon



I agree with this. DS is not advanced in speech at all but so many of his words come from being heard and reinforced in his favorite TV shows. For example, he knows the work "backpack" from Dora, which is what he calls his diaper bag, because it looks like a backpack, and he even refers to my pocketbook as a backpack!

To me that shows more than just memorization and rote - it's understanding and applying what he's learned to different contexts. And no matter how much I talk and interact with him all day long I am not made of bright flashy colors and sometimes I don't always appeal to him Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 3:20 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by chelle

Well for us...

DD was watching TV at 3 months...she is a TV junkie. The TV is on all day long.

I'm not here to brag, it's just who she is....She is 2.5 years old

She was a VERY early talker, she has beautiful pronunciation, I was having conversations with her at a very early age...she is very smart, understands things and can do things that some can't. IMO, she picked up a ridiculous amount of information from the TV.

I have a lot of interaction with her as well.

But in our case, TV watching did no harm what-so-ever in her developement. In fact, I actually think it helped her in some ways. I'm amazed every day at her advancement.




This is all trueChat Icon

And my DS is the same wayChat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 3:21 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by davenjess

this is going to sound silly - but i have noticed - at least with the stuff on Nick JR - that they actually DO try to have them interact.... they ask a question and wait for an answer - (or throw in those kid voices answering)..

i don't know how i feel about it...

Chat Icon Chat Icon



I totally agree.

Logan will shout all the answers to Mickey Mouse Clubhouse.

He gets up and dances with the Imagination Movers.

He Pat Pats with the Little Einsteins.

He figures things out with George.

And I swear he uses those things in everyday life.

Posted 12/17/09 3:22 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by sleepie76



They said something like for every hour your child watches tv, they are losing 10 vocabulary words.

.



This canNOT be true.

For starters, it is such a blanket statement and secondly, my child speaks in VOLUMES and I could not imagine him losing 10 words per HOUR when the TV is on A LOT here. He already doesn't shut upChat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 3:24 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by sleepie76



They said something like for every hour your child watches tv, they are losing 10 vocabulary words.

.



This canNOT be true.

For starters, it is such a blanket statement and secondly, my child speaks in VOLUMES and I could not imagine him losing 10 words per HOUR when the TV is on A LOT here. He already doesn't shut upChat Icon



Seriously. Between Logan, Lily and C3 last weekend, if they were losing 10 words per hour it would have been a LOT quieter. Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 3:28 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: question regarding TV

Honestly I think that everyday there is a new fault with something in our lifestyles. I think raise your kid to the best of YOUR ability.

Posted 12/17/09 3:30 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by leighla

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by sleepie76



They said something like for every hour your child watches tv, they are losing 10 vocabulary words.

.



This canNOT be true.

For starters, it is such a blanket statement and secondly, my child speaks in VOLUMES and I could not imagine him losing 10 words per HOUR when the TV is on A LOT here. He already doesn't shut upChat Icon



Seriously. Between Logan, Lily and C3 last weekend, if they were losing 10 words per hour it would have been a LOT quieter. Chat Icon


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Sounds about right Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/09 3:31 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by leighla

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by sleepie76



They said something like for every hour your child watches tv, they are losing 10 vocabulary words.

.



This canNOT be true.

For starters, it is such a blanket statement and secondly, my child speaks in VOLUMES and I could not imagine him losing 10 words per HOUR when the TV is on A LOT here. He already doesn't shut upChat Icon



Seriously. Between Logan, Lily and C3 last weekend, if they were losing 10 words per hour it would have been a LOT quieter. Chat Icon



How in the world would the effectively measure such a thing in a preverbal child? I have doubts.

My son has a speech delay and has been watching modest TV for about a year. Did it cause the delay? We'll never know, but I think probably not. Another boy his age also has a speech delay and he has never watched TV. PPs children are very verbal.

Posted 12/17/09 3:31 PM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by chelle

Well for us...

DD was watching TV at 3 months...she is a TV junkie. The TV is on all day long.

I'm not here to brag, it's just who she is....She is 2.5 years old

She was a VERY early talker, she has beautiful pronunciation, I was having conversations with her at a very early age...she is very smart, understands things and can do things that some can't. IMO, she picked up a ridiculous amount of information from the TV.

I have a lot of interaction with her as well.

But in our case, TV watching did no harm what-so-ever in her developement. In fact, I actually think it helped her in some ways. I'm amazed every day at her advancement.




I could of written this word for word regarding my DS. At 20 months we were having conversations with DS. I am talking full blown adult conversations. I remember it so clearly because I delivered DD when he was 20 months and the nurses at the hospital thought he was 3!

DD will be 19 months on the 27th. She has zero interest in tv. She does have a very large vocabulary and can say some of her abc's and can count to 3..but she is no where close to the speaking ability my son was at her age.

I have said it over and over. I owe alot of what my son picked up early on to Noggin!



.

Posted 12/17/09 4:00 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: question regarding TV

DD watches TV and is very social, smart and vocal. I think that as long as TV is not the primary interaction they are fine. We do lots of other things throughout the day and always have. I have always made an effort to interact with her even as an infant, I would talk to her all day long. People would look at me like I was crazy in stores.

Posted 12/17/09 4:05 PM
 

mooshyboo
So Blessed!

Member since 11/07

6297 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: question regarding TV

I think everything is good in moderation.

Posted 12/17/09 4:05 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: question regarding TV

The reason they believe it interferes with their development is because it keeps them from engaging in play, which is the most important activity in childhood. Through play children learn and practice interacting with others, they try out new skills, scenarios etc and eventually move on to developing imaginative play which is a very important developmental milestone.

Posted 12/17/09 4:06 PM
 

nmp070106
My girls!!

Member since 8/06

5843 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: question regarding TV

Well i guess I am a bad mommy Mads watches TV all day, 123 is on from wake up to sleep time and she really only sits for wow wow and olivia other then that she likes it as background noise............. Emma is starting to watch to at 6 months and neither one of my kids is behind in dedvelopment

Posted 12/17/09 4:11 PM
 

nmp070106
My girls!!

Member since 8/06

5843 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: question regarding TV

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by sleepie76



They said something like for every hour your child watches tv, they are losing 10 vocabulary words.

.



This canNOT be true.

For starters, it is such a blanket statement and secondly, my child speaks in VOLUMES and I could not imagine him losing 10 words per HOUR when the TV is on A LOT here. He already doesn't shut upChat Icon



So agree!! Madison talks all day and if she were to lose words that would be great!!! HAHAHA she picks up alot watching tv or listening!

Posted 12/17/09 4:12 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I just have one question.... JenniferEver 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Follow up to allergy question DramaQueen 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
BabyBoy question for you TAD 5/11/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
STAR question sasha96 5/11/05 2 Home
Silly Reality Question Redhead 5/11/05 19 Families Helping Families ™
I got a question fakie1 5/10/05 86 Families Helping Families ™