Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by JennyPenny

Being that it is only her second week- I would let her go. If she was with you for a long time I would say cut a little slack- but she seems unreliable.



ITA. Like PP said, she has not built up enough of a trust and repoire with you so that you know that she is reliable.

If she is doing this in the first 2 weeks, I would let her go.

Posted 3/3/09 1:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

too many issues.

make a pros and cons list.

Posted 3/3/09 2:01 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by kelsept

Yeah, my husband and i really agonized over the DWI..we liked her so much, we interviewed like 20 ppl and she just really stood out, mom of 5 kids, lots of experience..
I just?? She called me when i was out in the field last week and asked me to bring her home a coffee? A particular kind etc..lol! My mom told me to get rid of her too and find another fast. I have another one i really like with great references..she was just an extra 200 a week. I think I am going to contact her. My DD is my everything and you are right, i should be more pickyChat Icon

OMGChat Icon wow she has some nerveChat Icon I kind of wanted to give her a benefit of the doubt, like I do with everyone else in life, but WOW. I would def let her go.Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/09 2:02 PM
 

shellybean
Love my Baby Boy!

Member since 4/07

5191 total posts

Name:
mich

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by dediko

Posted by shellybean

Posted by kelsept

Yeah, my husband and i really agonized over the DWI..we liked her so much, we interviewed like 20 ppl and she just really stood out, mom of 5 kids, lots of experience..
I just?? She called me when i was out in the field last week and asked me to bring her home a coffee? A particular kind etc..lol! My mom told me to get rid of her too and find another fast. I have another one i really like with great references..she was just an extra 200 a week. I think I am going to contact her. My DD is my everything and you are right, i should be more pickyChat Icon



well maybe you can find one that is inbetween the prices....Is annay the same as a babysitter, or does she clean for you too..what do you pay

No nannies are not supposed to clean(and you can't expect them to), they are supposed to concentrate 100% of their attention on your child(ren) and clean up after them , tidy up their room(s) and maybe even do their laundry, but that's about it.



ok so what the difference between a nanny and babysitter? LOL

Posted 3/3/09 2:04 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

I think the economy being what it is, some people may be more negotiable.

The coffee thing is ballsy IMO. I would never call my boss & ask him to pick me up a Starbucks.

Posted 3/3/09 2:11 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Oh wow, I'll be honest, I was originally going to say "wait on your decision, the weather was out of her control, and unfortunately I've had BAD dental issues so I'd want someone to understand that dental problems don't follow my schedule". But once I read the DWI issue, I was Chat Icon and now the coffee thing has pushed me over the edge. Pull a Donald and tell her "YOU'RE FIRED".
Not over the coffee, per se, but the absolute inappropriateness of that request - her lack of discretion really is a red flag and it tells me you're going to have major issues managing her in the future.
The sad upside of this economy is that there are LOTS of awesome nannies on the market right now with so many corporate layoffs...
Best of luck!!!!

Posted 3/3/09 2:21 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

I would let her go...you can't take the chance with her unreliability--especially so early in the relationship. The extra 200 per week is so worth it IMO.

Posted 3/3/09 2:27 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by shellybean

Posted by dediko

Posted by shellybean

Posted by kelsept

Yeah, my husband and i really agonized over the DWI..we liked her so much, we interviewed like 20 ppl and she just really stood out, mom of 5 kids, lots of experience..
I just?? She called me when i was out in the field last week and asked me to bring her home a coffee? A particular kind etc..lol! My mom told me to get rid of her too and find another fast. I have another one i really like with great references..she was just an extra 200 a week. I think I am going to contact her. My DD is my everything and you are right, i should be more pickyChat Icon



well maybe you can find one that is inbetween the prices....Is annay the same as a babysitter, or does she clean for you too..what do you pay

No nannies are not supposed to clean(and you can't expect them to), they are supposed to concentrate 100% of their attention on your child(ren) and clean up after them , tidy up their room(s) and maybe even do their laundry, but that's about it.



ok so what the difference between a nanny and babysitter? LOL

Nanny is someone who takes care of your child full time on regular bases other than mom and dad.
babysitters tend to watch children on more of an as-needed basis, like weekends and evenings.
As rule(at least in Manhattan) most nannies or babysitters will not clean your house( I never did and was never asked to do so) You hire a housekeeper to clean a house and nanny or babysitter to take care of children(and clean ONLY for them)

Posted 3/3/09 2:31 PM
 

shellybean
Love my Baby Boy!

Member since 4/07

5191 total posts

Name:
mich

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

oh ok, so basically a full time person...thanks

Posted 3/3/09 2:31 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

I don't think you are asking too much. I think she should go.

Posted 3/3/09 2:36 PM
 

AOMom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/06

856 total posts

Name:
j

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Personally, once I found out that she had a DWI I would have fired her. I honestly wouldn't care what her reasoning is.

Since we're obviously looking at the situation from the current state, I wouldn't keep her based solely on the reliability factor. Don't get me wrong, if I were a nanny and we had 14 inches of snow I wouldn't have shown up....but to leave early because your teeth hurt? I can understand the time off for actual dental work, but just because they hurt? No way.

I wouldn't, however, worry about the cold bottles. DD had milk protein intolerance and acid reflux and was never affected by the temperature of the bottle. In fact, her GERD did better with cold and room temperature bottles than warm. Little things like that you'll probably need to overlook- nobody is going to care for your child the exact same way you would.

Hope you find someone reliable quickly Chat Icon



Posted 3/3/09 2:44 PM
 

bethb
LIF Toddler

Member since 10/08

402 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by colette

Pull a Donald and tell her "YOU'RE FIRED"[/QUOTE

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/09 2:47 PM
 

MrsPornStar
Partners in crime

Member since 10/05

14656 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by dediko

Posted by kelsept

Yeah, my husband and i really agonized over the DWI..we liked her so much, we interviewed like 20 ppl and she just really stood out, mom of 5 kids, lots of experience..
I just?? She called me when i was out in the field last week and asked me to bring her home a coffee? A particular kind etc..lol! My mom told me to get rid of her too and find another fast. I have another one i really like with great references..she was just an extra 200 a week. I think I am going to contact her. My DD is my everything and you are right, i should be more pickyChat Icon

OMGChat Icon wow she has some nerveChat Icon I kind of wanted to give her a benefit of the doubt, like I do with everyone else in life, but WOW. I would def let her go.Chat Icon



I totally agree. I wanted to give her a second chance, but once I read about the coffee that was it for me.

Maybe you could negotiate a price with the nanny you really liked.

Posted 3/3/09 2:49 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by MrsPornStar

Posted by dediko

Posted by kelsept

Yeah, my husband and i really agonized over the DWI..we liked her so much, we interviewed like 20 ppl and she just really stood out, mom of 5 kids, lots of experience..
I just?? She called me when i was out in the field last week and asked me to bring her home a coffee? A particular kind etc..lol! My mom told me to get rid of her too and find another fast. I have another one i really like with great references..she was just an extra 200 a week. I think I am going to contact her. My DD is my everything and you are right, i should be more pickyChat Icon

OMGChat Icon wow she has some nerveChat Icon I kind of wanted to give her a benefit of the doubt, like I do with everyone else in life, but WOW. I would def let her go.Chat Icon



I totally agree. I wanted to give her a second chance, but once I read about the coffee that was it for me.

Maybe you could negotiate a price with the nanny you really liked.



ITA! She's only there 2 weeks. Just tell her, it's not working. I'm sure you can find someone to negotiate with.

Posted 3/3/09 3:10 PM
 

kelsept
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/07

833 total posts

Name:
Kelley

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Thanks everyone!! I really appreciate all the responsesChat Icon

Posted 3/3/09 4:06 PM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

who asks their BOSS to get them a coffee??!! you have every right to be picky when it comes to your child..if she is taking advantage of you like this in the first 2 weeks, who knows what is to come!?

Posted 3/3/09 4:10 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Wow...I didn't know what to think at first bc I don't have a Nanny or any experience with them. The dental problem could be unfortunate timing but the coffee thing is so ballsy and inappropriate - and she works for you for 2 weeks, it's not like you've built up a relationship. But the fact that you said something to her about heating your DD's bottles and instead of replying that she would do it from now on, she tells you that your DD likes them like that? That seriously makes me wonder what other things she would do her own way, against your wishes. The bottle isn't even the issue, it's more if I was watching someone's child and the parent said they wanted something a certain way, why wouldn't I? My reply wouldn't be to support going against their wishes. Could you go to your boss when he or she tells you something and tell them how it works?

The DWI...maybe it was a 1x drinking/driving thing but maybe not...how do you know? The story sounds plausible but I can also see it being BS. Not worth the risk with your precious child.

Chat Icon It must be so stressful to deal with worrying about this. Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-03-03 21:10:08.807000.

Posted 3/3/09 9:08 PM
 

cantbelieveit
Love these kids!

Member since 10/05

4708 total posts

Name:
Tammy

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

I wouldn't keep her, maybe if she was doing this after a long time ok. But all those days in just a short time. I was a nanny for a family for 6 years and only called in sick once when I was up all night with a stomach virus. As a nanny one should understand that when you miss work, one of the parents miss work and that is irresponsible. Good luck! I may know of a good nanny if you need oneChat Icon lol

Posted 3/3/09 9:49 PM
 

Arodisi
"My 3 Sons!"

Member since 3/06

3515 total posts

Name:
KT

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

even if you called her and said "do you want anything while im out" just to be nice, she should have never asked you to get her a coffee and a specific kind at that. she should have made herself a cup if she really wanted one.
i have a cleaning lady 1x and i told her from the beginning if she wanted a drink (water, coffee) to help herself to it. even so, in the year that she has been working here, i have not seen her take a drink once (i actually kinda feel bad lol)...

Posted 3/3/09 9:52 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Me being me...I would probably give her the benefit of the doubt...

But then again...I tend to let people take advantage of me....

For me the kicker is the bottle thing. The thing is that I dont see anything wrong with giving DC a cold bottle. (I think they did a study that it doesnt give them cramps..but that is irrelevant) You want DC bottles warmed up and that should be the end of it...She shouldnt be taking it upon herself to do things so blantantly her way...KWIM?

Posted 3/3/09 9:56 PM
 

michele31
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3372 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Honestly, I would call the other person you liked and speak with her. Right now people are not spending an extra $200 a week for a nanny. In fact, there are a lot of nannies out of work because of the economy.
She may be willing to take an extra $50 a week to get a job.
I would understand the medical issues but honestly, she should be doing the appointments after hours or on a Saturday. And if not possible, she should have sat down with you and discussed what would work best.
Getting sick happens to all of us. Her calling you for coffee, the cold bottles, the DWI disclosure AFTER you hired her..that does not.

Posted 3/3/09 10:11 PM
 

sydniesmom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/08

700 total posts

Name:
susan

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

listen to ur own gut feelings. i think that u want to get rid of her and u should. good luck!!

Posted 3/3/09 10:22 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Fire her...it's her first week and she's already asking for time off like that..not a good sign. Sorry you have to go through thisChat Icon

Posted 3/3/09 10:40 PM
 

FelAndJon
needs to update her avatar pic

Member since 6/05

10212 total posts

Name:
Felice (aka LuckyBride2004)

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

Posted by Elizabeth

Wow...I didn't know what to think at first bc I don't have a Nanny or any experience with them. The dental problem could be unfortunate timing but the coffee thing is so ballsy and inappropriate - and she works for you for 2 weeks, it's not like you've built up a relationship. But the fact that you said something to her about heating your DD's bottles and instead of replying that she would do it from now on, she tells you that your DD likes them like that? That seriously makes me wonder what other things she would do her own way, against your wishes. The bottle isn't even the issue, it's more if I was watching someone's child and the parent said they wanted something a certain way, why wouldn't I? My reply wouldn't be to support going against their wishes. Could you go to your boss when he or she tells you something and tell them how it works?

The DWI...maybe it was a 1x drinking/driving thing but maybe not...how do you know? The story sounds plausible but I can also see it being BS. Not worth the risk with your precious child.

Chat Icon It must be so stressful to deal with worrying about this. Chat Icon



I agree with all this. I had a nanny for a little over a year and I know how stressful this must be for you. You put all your trust in this person then once it goes a little badly, you start to question everything. I am so sorry you are going through all this but given that this is only the 2nd week, I think you need to look for someone new. If she is this way already, imagine how she will be once she is really comfortable!
I think the breaking pooint for me is that she did not listen to you and follow your rules on how to give the bottles. I would constantly worry what else she is doing or not doing as you directed.

Posted 3/3/09 10:55 PM
 

Chicken92305
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/06

684 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Problems with nanny-What would you do?!

i would absolutely fire her...this is just like any other job...not to compare a nanny to say an office worker, or any other type of job but she would have been fired a long time ago if she worked anywhere else...this isnt any different!
she doesnt seem reliable, responsible(the bottle issue omgChat Icon ) i actually just fired our weekly babysitter for not showing up on time ( at least 20 min late and not making up for the lost time) not showing up at ALL Chat Icon and not doing what she was supposed to do, which was to just play with my kids and clean up after them (for 2 hours) she did not take babysitting serious and to me, its just like any other "job" your nanny knows whats expected of her, her job responsibilities, the time and days you NEED her, the instructions given to her for your DC (warming the bottles) there are MANY MANY other great people out there, you are not being too hard on her at all IMO she blew it!!!! and its only her second week?!?!?! to me, she should be making every effort to do what is asked of her and be there every single day!!!! i really hope you find someone else!! Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/09 10:59 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Gallbladder problems Jacquie 3/18/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
sleep problems Samlove 3/15/06 3 Parenting
Speaking of cat problems-is it me, or do they all seem to be in heat???? aliasPook 3/15/06 1 Home
I am having problems sleeping on my left side tiki03 3/10/06 6 Pregnancy
Gargoyle problems iN NC! nrthshgrl 3/2/06 10 Families Helping Families ™
OK Here's our sleep problems monkeybride 3/1/06 19 Parenting