Pro-Choice Exemptions?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by Bearcat Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by MrsProfessor What about late-term abortions? I consider myself strongly pro-choice but what about an instance where the child could live on its own? I do think there needs to be some kind of window. Otherwise, I support no exemptions. And I suspect the number of women using it as birth control is very small. I support the choice for late term abortions. Previous debate: http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic.aspx?ID=59601 Thank you so much for this... Yes. Thank you. What a story...
|
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? I don't think past 18 weeks unless medically necessary. I do believe in restrictions to an extent. There was a poster on here who had someone in her family who got one at 24 weeks. To me, that was just irresponsible on the part of the doctor. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? I am pro-choice and I have ZERO exemptions to abortion. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 4:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by nrthshgrl If I thought there were (healthy) women who were pissed off in their 3rd trimester running to get abortions for health pregnancies, then I would have some reservations about it too. I believe it happens often enough to make the exception to those women who have to make the heart-wrenching decision to abort a child that won't survive birth, that won't survive much more than a few months or will threaten the life of the mother. I do understand that the VAST MAJORITY (maybe even ALL) of the people who are given late term abortions are doing so with dread and fear and angst and would give their own lives to have to NOT go through it and have a healthy child instead. And for those women there SHOULD be an exception. But the idea that even a minor handful of women could decide to terminate their 3rd trimester pregnancy.. just because they CAN.. is enough for me to say that I can't fully support Pro-Choice in EVERY instance. We live in such a gray world.. It's enough that I can't commit in either direction to pro-choice or pro-life. Message edited 2012-10-12 16:11:32.660000. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 4:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by rojerono ........ And for those women there SHOULD be an exception. The problem is WHO makes the exception? Who makes the law? WHO decided? Who tells you what you can and cant do? (not snarky by the way) Because of THAT there can be no exception. Message edited 2012-10-12 16:29:31.097000. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Pro-Choice Exemptions? I make no exceptions. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 4:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by MrsProfessor What about late-term abortions? I consider myself strongly pro-choice but what about an instance where the child could live on its own? I do think there needs to be some kind of window. Otherwise, I support no exemptions. And I suspect the number of women using it as birth control is very small. I support the choice for late term abortions. Previous debate: http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic.aspx?ID=59601 To clarify, I'm referring to a woman who gets into a pregnancy and then changes her mind, as opposed to a situation where complications arise. I don't think a woman should be allowed to abort 25 weeks in because she's no longer interested in having a kid. But then again, it's not for me to make decisions for others.
|
|
Posted 10/12/12 4:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by Paramount Posted by rojerono ........ And for those women there SHOULD be an exception. The problem is WHO makes the exception? Who makes the law? WHO decided? Who tells you what you can and cant do? (not snarky by the way) Because of THAT there can be no exception. I didn't take it as snark And I get it, I do. And I want to 100% support a woman's right to make decisions relevant to her own body. For the most part, I do. If you want to have 15 kids out of wedlock by different fathers.. I might think you are nuts.. but God bless you. If you want to have 25 abortions because you are highly fertile, can't keep your legs closed and don't believe in birth control.. well I will judge you to be a moron, but choosing that path is yours. I don't have to AGREE with a person to support their decision and right to CHOOSE what they think is best. But something in me can't support it in all cases. A woman who is 30 weeks pregnant and faced with the fact that her child is not able to live outside of the womb? I feel for her and I support her right to choose to terminate the pregnancy rather than live another second with that kind of reminder of loss - I could not deprive her of the right to begin the grieving process immediately.. without a living reminder in her body of what she is about to suffer. But the idea that some scumbag might determine one morning that the baby inside of her - one that could draw breath and live without her as a host given the opportunity - should be killed just because she has a bug up her ass one day.. I just can't - I have tried to justify it in my own head, but I simply can not. I also can't abide the idea of some beaurocrat deciding what I can and cannot do with my own body. I do not know the appropriate solution. I do not have a good answer. If I were making a law relevant to this it would be 400000000 pages long to account for the million different scenarios that could POSSIBLY come up. I guess it's a good thing that I don't make the law! Message edited 2012-10-12 17:22:46.580000. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 5:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by MarisaK I said this in a different post: "....People have this idealistic version of how this all happens - there are too many variables here. Too many tiny little pieces to determine and control - This right is black and white to me - You can't regulate this - So, I can get an abortion if I was raped? Ok great - but are you going to force me to PROVE I was raped? How do I do that? How LONG does that take? And WHY should I have to AGAIN be a victim? Why should I be forced to relive that? In a court room? Do I need an attorney? Or can I just walk into the hospital and claim I was raped? Because if that's the case do you know how many false claims there will be? How many lives ruined? How much the credibility of all true rape victims will be tarnished? So I can get an abortion if my life is at risk? What if Dr. #1 says it is, and Dr. #2 says it's not? WHO's opinion counts? and WHO makes the final decision? ...." I feel very strongly about this - and very strongly about NOT voting Romney/Ryan because of this ...... HOW do you 'regulate' this? HOW do you come up with, and then implement and enforce these so called 'controls' ? Who makes the decisions? It's just too much, too many pieces to the puzzle ....... Besides the fact - you can't tell someone "Oh you're on abortion #3? Sorry, you filled your quota - " Because that means that your medical information would NO LONGER BE PRIVATE information ........and there goes ANOTHER liberty flushed down the drain .......
|
|
Posted 10/12/12 6:21 PM
|
|
|
Pro-Choice Exemptions? I am pro-choice, but do not agree with late term abortions, pretty much anything after the first trimester unless it is a medical reason. I also do not believe a woman should be allowed to have multiple because she can't use contraception and/or get her tubes tied. In this day and age it's kinda easy to know around when you are ovulating. 1st time OK woops, 2nd time, OMG I can't believe this is happening again. 3rd time, your an idiot, I am sorry, Message edited 2012-10-12 19:00:12.643000. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 6:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by rojerono Posted by nrthshgrl If I thought there were (healthy) women who were pissed off in their 3rd trimester running to get abortions for health pregnancies, then I would have some reservations about it too. I believe it happens often enough to make the exception to those women who have to make the heart-wrenching decision to abort a child that won't survive birth, that won't survive much more than a few months or will threaten the life of the mother. I do understand that the VAST MAJORITY (maybe even ALL) of the people who are given late term abortions are doing so with dread and fear and angst and would give their own lives to have to NOT go through it and have a healthy child instead. And for those women there SHOULD be an exception. But the idea that even a minor handful of women could decide to terminate their 3rd trimester pregnancy.. just because they CAN.. is enough for me to say that I can't fully support Pro-Choice in EVERY instance. We live in such a gray world.. It's enough that I can't commit in either direction to pro-choice or pro-life. I thought that abortion isn't legal past 24 weeks ( bad enough) , but I don't think it is legal in the third trimester anywhere. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 8:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by PennyJ923 I am pro-choice, but do not agree with late term abortions, pretty much anything after the first trimester unless it is a medical reason. I also do not believe a woman should be allowed to have multiple because she can't use contraception and/or get her tubes tied. In this day and age it's kinda easy to know around when you are ovulating. 1st time OK woops, 2nd time, OMG I can't believe this is happening again. 3rd time, your an idiot, I am sorry,
|
|
Posted 10/12/12 8:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby So for those who think NO exemptions... a woman should be able to choose at say 33 weeks that she no longer wants her baby. She can go and have an abortion at that point for no other reason than, well, it just doesn't fit into her life? I know I'm pro-life. But I can also put myself in others shoes and understand why they would make the choice in a horrible situation where a child isn't going to live at birth, or their life is in jeopardy. But it should still be ok just because its her body? I can't understand and will never ever be able to wrap my head around that. an example like that may be rare but i'm sure its been done. It makes me physically sick. Talk about ZERO regard for human life. I don't agree with it and I'd hate to think of it, but I still say she should be able to do so. But the child can live outside of its mother's womb at that point? How is it not murder? Although, I assume the legislatures think that way since abortion is not legal at that point. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 8:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? There's a difference between what I morally believe and what I want legislated. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 8:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by bookworm There's a difference between what I morally believe and what I want legislated. Morally, I don't think abortion is right. I think people ought to take responsibility for their own sexual activity and not kill babies because they can't handle that. I also think the government should mind its own business. I like the laws the way they are regarding 1st trimester cut-offs and exceptions for birth defects and health of the mother. I think people who have multiple abortions are disgusting. That doesn't mean I want to pass laws to address it. I 100% agree. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 8:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by bookworm I also think the government should mind its own business. I like the laws the way they are regarding 1st trimester cut-offs The cutoff is 24 weeks...it used to be 28 weeks after roe vs wade in the 70s because that was deemed the point of viability. And 24 weeks is well into the second trimester, only 3 weeks shy of third trimester! I don't know. Many infants are now viable at 21 weeks with the advancement of technology and medicine. Not to say they don't face certain health problems/learning problems but it's kind of crazy how far care for preemies has come! |
|
Posted 10/12/12 9:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby So for those who think NO exemptions... a woman should be able to choose at say 33 weeks that she no longer wants her baby. She can go and have an abortion at that point for no other reason than, well, it just doesn't fit into her life? . [ Wow! That 33 weeks statement kind of freaked me out. I am pro-choice and I still believe I am pro-choice even though I think late term abortions should not be performed unless for medical reasons. My daughters were born at 34 weeks and I know somebody who had their child around 25 weeks. It really puts things in perspective when you think in terms of that. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 10:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by eroxgirl No exemptions. We should not be legislating morality, because your morality may not be mine. I reserve the right to think you're a horrible person based on the choices you make, but I support your right to have that choice in the first place. Wow! nicely said! |
|
Posted 10/12/12 11:49 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |








To clarify, I'm referring to a woman who gets into a pregnancy and then changes her mind, as opposed to a situation where complications arise. I don't think a woman should be allowed to abort 25 weeks in because she's no longer interested in having a kid. But then again, it's not for me to make decisions for others.






