Pro-Choice Exemptions?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maymama that was me. so what am I? I am not pro life because I do believe that in certain instances, abortion is absolutely the only decision. I am pro choice but I do not believe that people should partake in risky behavior (ie sex without some form of BC) and then turn to abortion to solve "the problem". That is really the only instance that I do not agree with abortion. I get it, shit happens and abortion is there for a reason. Its just NOT BC. ETA - i would never tell anyone NOT to get an abortion. I just do not personally agree with it as the result of taking no precautions to prevent an unwanted pregancy. Based on your opinions as stated, I would consider you a moderate pro-life advocate. You aren't fanatical in your belief that zygotes are humans, but you also don't seem to think that women should be in control of their own bodies if their 'choices' are not aligned with your own opinions or morality. This is not in anyway a slam against you, I think you are 100% entitled to your opinion, but I would not consider that opinion pro-choice based on MY understanding of the movement. :) |
|
Posted 10/12/12 12:36 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by BunnyWife I agree with the above. No exemptions.
|
|
Posted 10/12/12 12:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? So for those who think NO exemptions... |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby So for those who think NO exemptions... a woman should be able to choose at say 33 weeks that she no longer wants her baby. She can go and have an abortion at that point for no other reason than, well, it just doesn't fit into her life? I know I'm pro-life. But I can also put myself in others shoes and understand why they would make the choice in a horrible situation where a child isn't going to live at birth, or their life is in jeopardy. But it should still be ok just because its her body? I can't understand and will never ever be able to wrap my head around that. an example like that may be rare but i'm sure its been done. It makes me physically sick. Talk about ZERO regard for human life. I don't agree with it and I'd hate to think of it, but I still say she should be able to do so. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby So for those who think NO exemptions... a woman should be able to choose at say 33 weeks that she no longer wants her baby. She can go and have an abortion at that point for no other reason than, well, it just doesn't fit into her life? I know I'm pro-life. But I can also put myself in others shoes and understand why they would make the choice in a horrible situation where a child isn't going to live at birth, or their life is in jeopardy. But it should still be ok just because its her body? I can't understand and will never ever be able to wrap my head around that. an example like that may be rare but i'm sure its been done. It makes me physically sick. Talk about ZERO regard for human life. I don't agree with it and I'd hate to think of it, but I still say she should be able to do so. I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I know, I agree. It bothers me greatly. It's such a weird zone because in one sense, I want women to be in control of their bodies, but on the other hand, I don't like the idea of late abortions. I would hope that prior to having a late abortion, she'd receive counseling or explore adoption options. Message edited 2012-10-12 15:23:38.553000. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby So for those who think NO exemptions... a woman should be able to choose at say 33 weeks that she no longer wants her baby. She can go and have an abortion at that point for no other reason than, well, it just doesn't fit into her life? I know I'm pro-life. But I can also put myself in others shoes and understand why they would make the choice in a horrible situation where a child isn't going to live at birth, or their life is in jeopardy. But it should still be ok just because its her body? I can't understand and will never ever be able to wrap my head around that. an example like that may be rare but i'm sure its been done. It makes me physically sick. Talk about ZERO regard for human life. I don't agree with it and I'd hate to think of it, but I still say she should be able to do so. I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I think most human beings would agree that a woman who just 'feels like' terminating her pregnancy at 33 weeks 'has no soul' ......howver, you said it youself, you know how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason ......... Again, Pro CHOICE is not Pro Abortion - it's Pro "being able to decide for myself what is best for me and not having to let the government decide FOR me" |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby So for those who think NO exemptions... a woman should be able to choose at say 33 weeks that she no longer wants her baby. She can go and have an abortion at that point for no other reason than, well, it just doesn't fit into her life? I know I'm pro-life. But I can also put myself in others shoes and understand why they would make the choice in a horrible situation where a child isn't going to live at birth, or their life is in jeopardy. But it should still be ok just because its her body? I can't understand and will never ever be able to wrap my head around that. an example like that may be rare but i'm sure its been done. It makes me physically sick. Talk about ZERO regard for human life. I don't agree with it and I'd hate to think of it, but I still say she should be able to do so. I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I agree but it's her decision that she has to live with for the rest of her life. Not yours or mine. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Also - isn't there already a regulation regarding late term? I thought you couldn't have one past 20 something weeks unless it was a life threatening situation? Message edited 2012-10-12 15:25:03.470000. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Pro-Choice Exemptions? Also,maybebaby - I think the question you posed is a great one. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:25 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? i have no exceptions that i place on other people. Message edited 2012-10-12 15:26:52.157000. |
Posted 10/12/12 3:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I know, I agree. It bothers me greatly. It's such a weird zone because in one sense, I want women to be in control of their bodies, but on the other hand, I don't like the idea of late abortions. I would hope that prior to having a late abortion, she'd receive counseling or explore adoption options. I would hope so too. and i'm sorry..I didn't mean to add to a thread that was posted specifically for pro-choice, i just get really upset reading that people believe there should be zero exemptions. why would ANY woman carry a baby that far along and then have the OK to terminate because a change of mind (im not referring to cases where the baby is sick or she is is danger). I will never ever forget the blog I read where the woman aborted the twin son because she already had a son at home. I sat there with tears rolling down my face. Such a lack of morality and compassion for her own child. Disgusting. No one can ever convince me that "well its her body in the end..". Whatever happened to basic decent morals and people recognizing right from wrong? |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by MarisaK Also - isn't there already a regulation regarding late term? I thought you couldn't have one past 20 something weeks unless it was a life threatening situation? You can't, but people have answered there should be no exemptions. I remember reading a thread a while back with people saying it was OK to abort until full term if the woman so chose. I found that sickening. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by rojerono I do not support late term abortion unless it is for a medical necessity or non-viable fetus. Maybe that makes me a hypocrite but I guess I have my own line in the sand. This is how I feel- but I am totally pro choice and choose to believe that late-term abortions are rare (whether that's true or not) |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by Ophelia i have no exceptions that i place on other people. eta: I may not like it but pro-choice is exactly that, being for anothers choice to do as they see fit with their body and their life. I totally get that, I do..I really can understand why people are pro-choice. And god help me for saying this...as much as i'm against abortion, i'm sure in lots of instances its better that the child wasn't born into a terrible situation. I just feel like there has to be a point at while we stop saying "not my body, i don't care what you do with yours" because to ME at a certain point it becomes so much more than that. A baby suffering through a late term abortion goes through such pain and such an awful process...its disturbing and its just not right. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I know, I agree. It bothers me greatly. It's such a weird zone because in one sense, I want women to be in control of their bodies, but on the other hand, I don't like the idea of late abortions. I would hope that prior to having a late abortion, she'd receive counseling or explore adoption options. I would hope so too. and i'm sorry..I didn't mean to add to a thread that was posted specifically for pro-choice, i just get really upset reading that people believe there should be zero exemptions. why would ANY woman carry a baby that far along and then have the OK to terminate because a change of mind (im not referring to cases where the baby is sick or she is is danger). I will never ever forget the blog I read where the woman aborted the twin son because she already had a son at home. I sat there with tears rolling down my face. Such a lack of morality and compassion for her own child. Disgusting. No one can ever convince me that "well its her body in the end..". Whatever happened to basic decent morals and people recognizing right from wrong? Don't be sorry. It's good to have opinions and passion for what you believe in. I get equally as disgusted when I hear men politicians talking about a woman's body as if it were a company and he were the CEO. When I think the possibility of a woman being forced to have a baby against her will, I get a disturbing feeling. There may not be right or wrong answer here...just passionate people on both sides. I don't know what the answer is...I wish I did. I just prefer the gov't not interfering. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby Posted by MarisaK Also - isn't there already a regulation regarding late term? I thought you couldn't have one past 20 something weeks unless it was a life threatening situation? You can't, but people have answered there should be no exemptions. I remember reading a thread a while back with people saying it was OK to abort until full term if the woman so chose. I found that sickening. Here are the current laws: http://www.guttmacher.org/statecenter/spibs/spib_OAL.pdf |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? And i am a bit sensitive to this topic in general, it just strikes a chord with me. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I know, I agree. It bothers me greatly. It's such a weird zone because in one sense, I want women to be in control of their bodies, but on the other hand, I don't like the idea of late abortions. I would hope that prior to having a late abortion, she'd receive counseling or explore adoption options. This is why I had to edit my own response earlier. I just cannot support the idea that a woman should be able to CHOOSE to terminate a pregnancy at any stage. I mean.. what is the difference then between 33 weeks and 39 weeks? 39 weeks and 40 weeks? I mean.. there HAS to be a line somewhere.. doesn’t there? I don’t want to impose MY morality on anyone else.. but some things should be held sacred, shouldn’t they? Should a woman be able to waddle into a clinic or hospital the day before her due date and INSIST that they kill her unborn child because .. I dunno.. she’s po’d at her boyfriend and wants to hurt him and since it’s her body she has the right? Does pro-choice REALLY mean until a baby is expelled from the host it has no right to the protection of society? We have fetal protection laws.. are those a conflict with a woman’s right to choose? I just.. I guess I cannot consider myself fully pro-choice. I guess I’m pro-choice with caveats.. or maybe I’m very liberal pro-life? |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I know, I agree. It bothers me greatly. It's such a weird zone because in one sense, I want women to be in control of their bodies, but on the other hand, I don't like the idea of late abortions. I would hope that prior to having a late abortion, she'd receive counseling or explore adoption options. I would hope so too. and i'm sorry..I didn't mean to add to a thread that was posted specifically for pro-choice, i just get really upset reading that people believe there should be zero exemptions. why would ANY woman carry a baby that far along and then have the OK to terminate because a change of mind (im not referring to cases where the baby is sick or she is is danger). I will never ever forget the blog I read where the woman aborted the twin son because she already had a son at home. I sat there with tears rolling down my face. Such a lack of morality and compassion for her own child. Disgusting. No one can ever convince me that "well its her body in the end..". Whatever happened to basic decent morals and people recognizing right from wrong? Don't be sorry. It's good to have opinions and passion for what you believe in. I get equally as disgusted when I hear men politicians talking about a woman's body as if it were a company and he were the CEO. When I think the possibility of a woman being forced to have a baby against her will, I get a disturbing feeling. There may not be right or wrong answer here...just passionate people on both sides. I don't know what the answer is...I wish I did. I just prefer the gov't not interfering. thank you I appreciate that. I don't know what the right answer is. I honestly don't think its a good idea for abortion to be outlawed. I think it would be a terrible situation all around actually. I just think there needs to be exemptions but that too is pretty impossible. Sigh. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? No one wants to see abortion used as birth control, but that ideal is impossible to legislate. And frankly, it's a matter best left for that woman and her conscience. In NYS, I think the current law is 24 weeks unless the mother's life is in danger. While I personally think it's too far along, I refuse to tell another woman what to do with her uterus. There are circumstances that I cannot begin to imagine would cause someone to have to make that choice at that point. Message edited 2012-10-12 15:48:14.940000. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by rojerono Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by maybebaby I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc... But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul. I know, I agree. It bothers me greatly. It's such a weird zone because in one sense, I want women to be in control of their bodies, but on the other hand, I don't like the idea of late abortions. I would hope that prior to having a late abortion, she'd receive counseling or explore adoption options. This is why I had to edit my own response earlier. I just cannot support the idea that a woman should be able to CHOOSE to terminate a pregnancy at any stage. I mean.. what is the difference then between 33 weeks and 39 weeks? 39 weeks and 40 weeks? I mean.. there HAS to be a line somewhere.. doesn’t there? I don’t want to impose MY morality on anyone else.. but some things should be held sacred, shouldn’t they? Should a woman be able to waddle into a clinic or hospital the day before her due date and INSIST that they kill her unborn child because .. I dunno.. she’s po’d at her boyfriend and wants to hurt him and since it’s her body she has the right? Does pro-choice REALLY mean until a baby is expelled from the host it has no right to the protection of society? We have fetal protection laws.. are those a conflict with a woman’s right to choose? I just.. I guess I cannot consider myself fully pro-choice. I guess I’m pro-choice with caveats.. or maybe I’m very liberal pro-life? You make very good points. I have many many pro choice friends who've had healthy debates about this issue. what I always realize is that EVERY single one of them has their "cut off" point. Some believe it shoudnl't be done after 20 weeks. some say 1st trimester only. Some think its ok whenever as long as its medically necessary. Its just interesting that people can be pro-choice but then say "well only up to 20 weeks" or "only up to 12 weeks". I mean, if you feel that BAM at 21 weeks its now a terrible thing that shouldn't be done, what makes it so different the week before? And you can't really say at the point of viability. That point is becoming earlier and earlier with modern medicine. Just interesting! |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:45 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by maybebaby Posted by Ophelia i have no exceptions that i place on other people. eta: I may not like it but pro-choice is exactly that, being for anothers choice to do as they see fit with their body and their life. I totally get that, I do..I really can understand why people are pro-choice. And god help me for saying this...as much as i'm against abortion, i'm sure in lots of instances its better that the child wasn't born into a terrible situation. I just feel like there has to be a point at while we stop saying "not my body, i don't care what you do with yours" because to ME at a certain point it becomes so much more than that. A baby suffering through a late term abortion goes through such pain and such an awful process...its disturbing and its just not right. I worked on the partial birth abortion case that went to the highest level a few years ago. the IDEA of what these babies go through is horrible. but I have to tell you that almost ALL PBA's (late term abortions generally speaking) are not women who woke up at 30 weeks to a swift kick and were like "that's it, you're out of here". these are women who go through agony themselves. I agree that any women would woud just opt to do this is just lacking in any compassion or morality- probably the same woman that would beat her child to death or neglect it to death if it went to full term. I don't think a woman who can choose a PBA just cuz is a woman who is fit to be a mother at all (yes I am personally judgmental) but publically, there is no way that I can know that and that is between them and their God (or devil). and I am very sorry to read about your loss. it must be very very raw for you.
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? If I thought there were (healthy) women who were pissed off in their 3rd trimester running to get abortions for health pregnancies, then I would have some reservations about it too. |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions? Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by MrsProfessor What about late-term abortions? I consider myself strongly pro-choice but what about an instance where the child could live on its own? I do think there needs to be some kind of window. Otherwise, I support no exemptions. And I suspect the number of women using it as birth control is very small. I support the choice for late term abortions. Previous debate: http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic.aspx?ID=59601 Thank you so much for this... |
|
Posted 10/12/12 3:48 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |











