Re: Pro-Choice Exemptions?
Posted 10/12/2012 3:45:47 PM by maybebaby
Posted by rojerono
Posted by EatingMyVeggies
Posted by maybebaby
I just think that its so horrific...to me its no different at that point than killing an infant. That is how I feel, and I KNOW how impossible it would be to start regulating and saying who can and who can't and for what reason etc...
But its just horrifying. Sorry, I think someone who can do that for no good reason has no soul.
I know, I agree. It bothers me greatly. It's such a weird zone because in one sense, I want women to be in control of their bodies, but on the other hand, I don't like the idea of late abortions.
I would hope that prior to having a late abortion, she'd receive counseling or explore adoption options.
This is why I had to edit my own response earlier.
I just cannot support the idea that a woman should be able to CHOOSE to terminate a pregnancy at any stage. I mean.. what is the difference then between 33 weeks and 39 weeks? 39 weeks and 40 weeks? I mean.. there HAS to be a line somewhere.. doesn’t there? I don’t want to impose MY morality on anyone else.. but some things should be held sacred, shouldn’t they? Should a woman be able to waddle into a clinic or hospital the day before her due date and INSIST that they kill her unborn child because .. I dunno.. she’s po’d at her boyfriend and wants to hurt him and since it’s her body she has the right? Does pro-choice REALLY mean until a baby is expelled from the host it has no right to the protection of society? We have fetal protection laws.. are those a conflict with a woman’s right to choose?
I just.. I guess I cannot consider myself fully pro-choice. I guess I’m pro-choice with caveats.. or maybe I’m very liberal pro-life?
You make very good points.
I have many many pro choice friends who've had healthy debates about this issue.
what I always realize is that EVERY single one of them has their "cut off" point. Some believe it shoudnl't be done after 20 weeks. some say 1st trimester only. Some think its ok whenever as long as its medically necessary.
Its just interesting that people can be pro-choice but then say "well only up to 20 weeks" or "only up to 12 weeks". I mean, if you feel that BAM at 21 weeks its now a terrible thing that shouldn't be done, what makes it so different the week before?
And you can't really say at the point of viability. That point is becoming earlier and earlier with modern medicine.
Just interesting!
|