Powdered vs. liquid formula

Posted By Message

mommy2b
LIF Infant

Member since 12/09

364 total posts

Name:

Powdered vs. liquid formula

I'm trying to decide which is best for my newborn. What are the pros and cons of each and how concerned should I be about BPA in these products? I've heard that the powdered formula has far less BPA than the liquid. Thanks!

Posted 9/15/11 12:22 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

phoenix913
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3034 total posts

Name:
V

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

We started out with the 2 oz newborn nursettes b/c they were super easy and convenient. We then switched to the big bottles of RTF. We are now on powder.

The main reason I like the powder is b/c it doesn't need to be refrigerated so it can be served right away (we keep a pitcher of room temp water on the counter). It's also a little easier to travel with, again b/c it doesn't need to be kept cold. I'm pretty sure the powder is a little cheaper too when you price it out by ounce.

One thing I don't like about powder is sometimes no matter how hard I shake I can't get it all to dissolve and that drives me nuts.

I didn't do any research into the BPA levels so I can't help there.

Posted 9/15/11 8:20 AM
 

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

With my oldest we started out with powder after I nursed him but it was making him extra gassy. We switched to rtf until he was 8 months & then went back to powder. The rtf was so expensive & we would go through a case every week, costing approx $160 a month. The powder was half the cost & it was mire convient since it was room temp.

When I had #2, we went right to powder & used Target brand.

Posted 9/15/11 8:27 AM
 

mrsprop
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/09

768 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

DD#1 was not into BF so we did Enfamil powder with no problems. We were at costco and saw tha they have a generic brand made by kirkland (costco's ). So we tried it and had no problems and it is 1/2 the price of enfamil.

Posted 9/15/11 8:44 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

Honestly the price difference was so ridiculous that we went right to powder.
It's a bit more work- but really not that much more work for what you save.

I never heard of BPA in formula Chat Icon

Posted 9/15/11 9:38 AM
 

skinny
3 boys and a princess!

Member since 11/08

8178 total posts

Name:
Momma

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

We had to use liquid at first because the boys were preemies. Powered isn't recommended for preemies. My dr told us the reason but I can't remember it. We switched to powdered as soon as we could.

It is just so much easier. Going out for the day? No problem. Put some water bottles in your bag and just put some powder in a contrainer. No need to worry about ice. Soooo much easier.

Posted 9/15/11 9:46 AM
 

Tiggeruth
I am a mom :-)

Member since 6/06

3433 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

powder is cheaper and its so much eaiser to make as needed at the right temperature and not have to worry about refridgerating and then reheating

Posted 9/15/11 9:48 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

Posted by skinny

We had to use liquid at first because the boys were preemies. Powered isn't recommended for preemies. My dr told us the reason but I can't remember it. We switched to powdered as soon as we could.

It is just so much easier. Going out for the day? No problem. Put some water bottles in your bag and just put some powder in a contrainer. No need to worry about ice. Soooo much easier.



Yes I think the reason for the preemies is that RTF is sterile and Powdered is not.

Posted 9/15/11 9:58 AM
 

Kristi71208
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

81 total posts

Name:
Kristi

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

we use the powder...main reason being that it's so much more convienent to travel with...no need for ice packs or insulated bags. room temp water in the bottles and shake. so easy. also the powder is considerably cheaper then the RTF.

DD is on similac sensitive, i'm not sure if this is the case for other brands but the similac powder is a completely different color and has a totally less pungent odor than the similac RTF...

Posted 9/15/11 10:15 AM
 

MrsRitaB
Love of my life! <3

Member since 4/10

4669 total posts

Name:
Ri

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

i only use the liquid when out and only because i got it all for free

Posted 9/15/11 10:38 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

I couldn't stand the smell of the liquid Chat Icon So I steered away from it. Although, the nursettes were REALLY convenient for your diaper bag! But so was the powder and a bottle of room temp. water.

Posted 9/15/11 10:41 AM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

from a dietitian standpoint

There is a small difference between the two with regards to fat absorption, but IMO - it's not a big deal. The reason why most shy away from powder is for fear that parents don't mix it properly (you would be amazed how often I see this). But powder is def. most convent IMO and cheaper. Its 100% fine. The only time I would say the liquid is better is for those 3A feedings and using those 2oz bottles from the hospital! LOL!

Posted 9/15/11 3:14 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Powdered vs. liquid formula

The first few weeks we used RTF Similac since we were used to the nursettes in the hospital and I supplemented with BM.

Then the reality of how much we would go through set in and how much more cost effective powder was. I love the convenience of just filling up my small formula dispenser with enough powder to fill three 8 oz bottles. Sooooo much easier when we are out and about.

Posted 9/15/11 9:47 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
RTF formula vs. Powdered Formula - I finally did the math... MrsJ 8/2/06 7 Parenting
If you use formula, did you start with a liquid multivitamin plus fluoride supplement at 6 mths? Goobster 5/27/09 17 Parenting
Small sample can of Similac Soy powdered formula up for grabs! Stefanie 3/21/09 0 Parenting
Is it ok to leave cans of liquid formula in the car in the cold weather? jessbaby 10/23/08 3 Parenting
What are the differences between powdered formula and ready to serve? mitabtrfly 7/19/07 26 Parenting
Hey mommies, Where is there the best deal on diapers and powdered formula? BigB 6/28/07 15 Parenting