Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Lucky09
2017!

Member since 1/06

7539 total posts

Name:
DW

Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

My friend won't be returning to work after having her baby.

So, she is taking her full 6 weeks maternity leave (assuming a vaginal birth), reporting back to work and promptly giving 2 weeks notice. She will work out the 2 weeks.

She says she is doing this so as not to "burn any bridges" but to me, I think this is worse than calling during her maternity leave and saying she isn't coming back.

Also, how unfavorably to companies look at employees who take their full maternity leave (and get paid) and then don't come back? Do you think this would impact her using them as a reference in the future?

Thanks for reading! Chat Icon

Posted 10/1/09 4:54 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

couldbtwins
I love you so much!

Member since 10/08

1761 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I don't know how companies would look at it from a HR perspective, and I know women do this, I wouldn't feel comfortable handling it this way.

Posted 10/1/09 4:57 PM
 

Dani77
It's FUN to be ONE

Member since 7/09

4363 total posts

Name:
Danicia

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I honestly do not agree with this at all. My friend did this last year to her job, and I really did just find it wrong. If she is planning on leaving before even going on FMLA then she should state that to her job prior. The only reason why she is going to return to work for those two weeks is so they will pay for the FLMA for the 6 weeks that she is out...

I think this is one reason why the FMLA is sooo hard for so many people and why they are so strict. I think it's not right... but, JMO

Posted 10/1/09 4:57 PM
 

Lucky09
2017!

Member since 1/06

7539 total posts

Name:
DW

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

For the record, I don't agree with it at all either.

Posted 10/1/09 4:58 PM
 

Sneezy
Thankful for my miracle!

Member since 5/05

1939 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I know a few people who have done this and I think it stinks. Someone did it in my office last year and they were pi$$ed. Her job went undone for three months and then just when they thought there was a reprieve in sight, she quit. It screwed everyone else who had to pick up her slack. In addition, they could have replaced her months before and avoided the backlog of work and extra hours for everyone else in the first place.

A really crummy thing to do IMHO.

Posted 10/1/09 5:04 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I agree, it's not right but if she hates her job but needs the money, she's gotta do what she's gotta do. I think maternity leave is crap in the US anyway so I don't feel bad for the companies.

I don't love my job but I will be waiting at least a year after I come back from maternity leave to look for another job because I don't want to leave on bad terms.

Posted 10/1/09 5:12 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Here in the UK if you don't come back to work and work something like six weeks you may be liable to pay your company back your entire maternity leave payment. Might that be the kind of reason she is doing that? She is better to just not go back, how to infuriate your co-workers and make them think their workload is going to get better. Strange.

Posted 10/1/09 5:42 PM
 

MrsO
Big Brothers to Be

Member since 1/07

4521 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I think she should take her 12 week fmla leave and then after she gets paid the 6 weeks say she isnt coming back. I think she has a right to get her 6 weeks paid but then tell them. I don't think it is right to show up to work and then say I'm leaving.

Posted 10/1/09 5:43 PM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Posted by MrsO

I think she should take her 12 week fmla leave and then after she gets paid the 6 weeks say she isnt coming back. I think she has a right to get her 6 weeks paid but then tell them. I don't think it is right to show up to work and then say I'm leaving.



Agree with this.

I don't agree that career wise it's the smartest thing to do but this isn't the first time I've heard of this. That's like a friend of mine didn't quit her job until after she got her bonus, the day she got her bonus is the day she quit.....or when I was hired at my current job we use to get a week off for christmas...so the boss who hired me gave his two week notice the week before we had off the week of christmas...I was stuck learning the ropes within a week from him, then was left on my own! Sucks sometimes but some people gotta do what they gotta do.....

would I do it....no.



Posted 10/1/09 6:11 PM
 

spa118
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

2157 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I don't think we should judge anyone for their decisions. I think in the end, people have to do what is right for them. In the end, you need to take care of yourself and your family, and the company will survive without her.
No, its not the most considerate thing in the world, but if that is what she needs to do, I think we need to cut her some slack.

My sister took a job when she was 3 months preggo, knowing that she was going to be a SAHM after the baby was born. She told them at 5 months and worked almost til the end. People frown on that (I did too at the time), but that $ allowed her to stay home for a while.

Posted 10/1/09 6:12 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Posted by spa118

I don't think we should judge anyone for their decisions. I think in the end, people have to do what is right for them. In the end, you need to take care of yourself and your family, and the company will survive without her.
No, its not the most considerate thing in the world, but if that is what she needs to do, I think we need to cut her some slack.

My sister took a job when she was 3 months preggo, knowing that she was going to be a SAHM after the baby was born. She told them at 5 months and worked almost til the end. People frown on that (I did too at the time), but that $ allowed her to stay home for a while.



Everyone is free to make decisions regarding their own life.

But in the end you have to balance those decisions with the longer impact they have.

Feel free to **** over your job/co-workers, just don't expect a good recommendation from them.

And don't be shocked if a future employer learns of this and decides to pass on you.

Posted 10/1/09 6:21 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Posted by shiv

I agree, it's not right but if she hates her job but needs the money, she's gotta do what she's gotta do. I think maternity leave is crap in the US anyway so I don't feel bad for the companies.

I don't love my job but I will be waiting at least a year after I come back from maternity leave to look for another job because I don't want to leave on bad terms.



part of me thinks this way. IF she's entitled to those 6 weeks b/c she's earned it by working there, then she's entitled to take it and get paid. Giving notice when she comes back prevents them from docking her any benefits (like health insurance premiums) paid while she was on leave.

do i agree with it, no. but i can understand why its done. Considering i get 6 weeks full salary and have to max out vacation time for the rest of it, and take the rest unpaid, part of me feels companies deserve it for not having better leave plans for their employees.

Posted 10/1/09 7:06 PM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I am planning on not going back to my job but i will go in and let them know in person after my 6 weeks paid disability is up.

Some people may not agree with this as well, but I am working up to the last day and I deserve my disability. If I quit before my leave, I wont get my disability.

From an HR standpoint, most companies do not allow their HR department to give out any information, just employment dates, position, and sometimes salary. They can be sued if they give a bad reference.

Posted 10/1/09 7:09 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Posted by Michelle1123

I am planning on not going back to my job but i will go in and let them know in person after my 6 weeks paid disability is up.

Some people may not agree with this as well, but I am working up to the last day and I deserve my disability. If I quit before my leave, I wont get my disability.

From an HR standpoint, most companies do not allow their HR department to give out any information, just employment dates, position, and sometimes salary. They can be sued if they give a bad reference.



That is true. They are not allowed to give a bad reference.

I had a co-worker that did that and no one where I was got annoyed because they were screwing people left and right on disability and maternity leave. Trust me, employers are the first to screw you when it serves them. I know this first hand.

I think if you earned it you deserve it. I am not keen on hurting your co-workers (mine let us all know on the DL and we started covering her cases and taking over-no biggie when she didn't return) but in this economy, many people need all the money they can get and I don't judge people without knowing their entire situation. JMO.

Posted 10/1/09 7:36 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

When I had my DD, my boss knew I wasn't going to come back. She was fine with it, but never told HR or her boss.

I had DD, called HR to let them know and start my leave. At the end of the 8 weeks, when they called for my start date, I told them I wasn't coming back.

I had no problem getting a new job once I decieded to go back to work.

Posted 10/1/09 7:42 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I think most people who decide to stay home do this. It's their perogative. a company will lay you off and kick you right out of the door, who cares about the compnay. HR can not give a bad reference based on something like that because they could be sued. I really don't see what the big deal is. everyone is entiled to their maternity leave pay, and to decide to stay home after the fact. My cousin went back to work for a couple months, got her huge bonus, transferred the $ to another account and quit. such is life!

Message edited 2009-10-01 20:39:36.023000.

Posted 10/1/09 8:39 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

morally, some people might think it's wrong - but if she resigns now, she doesn't get paid for those 6 weeks, and maybe she really wants that money as a cushion. i'm not going to judge her for it. legally, she is doing nothing wrong.

Posted 10/1/09 9:33 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Posted by racheeeee

Here in the UK if you don't come back to work and work something like six weeks you may be liable to pay your company back your entire maternity leave payment. Might that be the kind of reason she is doing that? She is better to just not go back, how to infuriate your co-workers and make them think their workload is going to get better. Strange.



This is a good point...my understanding is that here in the states the employer has the right to receive reimbursement for medical coverage and benefits paid out while on leave when the employee volunterily does not return to work. I've been out of benefits for a while so I may be wrong.

Personally, I would allow for more time when I return rather than give 2 weeks notice upon my return. Companies are very careful about reference checks but please keep in mind one very powerful question "would you hire this person again" - I am sure her employer will say no as is their right and they are protected to answer as such.

It's one thing if she comes back and just can't do it...it's another if she has no intention of returning but takes advantage of benefits. She can do it but it might come back to smack her in the face.

Message edited 2009-10-01 22:24:13.983000.

Posted 10/1/09 10:23 PM
 

gck0708
She is love!

Member since 11/08

1863 total posts

Name:
Grace

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I think that's a little risky. And I definitely don't think she's going to avoid burning bridges.

If she were going back to work for 2 months, then maybe. It would seem, then, that she gave it a good shot but it's just not working out.

But 2 weeks seems completely premeditated and from an employer or HR standpoint I would not be impressed.

Posted 10/2/09 4:02 AM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I've known a number of people who have done it without burning bridges. One of the girls here was actually hired back as a part time consultant.

Some people had planned it beforehand and some people decided while they were out they would be able to swing being a SAHM financially and decided that's what they wanted to do.



Posted 10/2/09 8:19 AM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I planned on doing that. I called to tell them before my leave was over that I wasn't coming back and offered to come back for 2 weeks. They said it wasn't necessary. My leave was unpaid and I wasn't using their insurance.

I didn't want to say anything prior to going on leave because there are so many factors that could have changed. If DH lost his job, I would've needed the job. So many peopple I know have planned on going back, and were laid off soon after returning. I don't think the companies felt bad about that.

Posted 10/2/09 12:54 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

I know in my old job, which gave 3 months paid maternity, there were a lot of women that did this. My boss got so annoyed that they were thinking of having the women sign a contract of some sort that if they would stay with job for a minimum of 1 year after returning from maternity leave.

Posted 10/2/09 1:06 PM
 

mishka
love my little emmy monster

Member since 8/09

1473 total posts

Name:

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

for me...my answer would depend on the situation.

for my current job - i would have no problem coming back, staying 2 weeks, quitting. They give us nothing, expect the world, and would throw any employee under the bus if need be. In this situation - I wouldn't feel as obligated.

if a job worked with me during my pregnancy/leave, paid me appropriately (for example gave full pay for std)...i would feel more obligated to either tell them beforehand or stay for a little afterwards to see if i could handle work.

Posted 10/2/09 2:24 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

Honestly, companies expect that women who go on leave may not come back. I think it's about covering your butt. What if she tells them now that she's not coming back, loses her 6wks pay and position and then in that timeframe something changes - her DH loses her job, etc. My thought is, you really never know, and in this economy, I would do everything I could to hang on to my position until I was 100% certain I didn't need it.

In her case, I'll play like I was coming back and give notice 5 wks PP - I wouldn't go back in.

Posted 10/2/09 2:26 PM
 

charon54
My two boys!

Member since 5/05

7279 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Please settle a debate re: Maternity Leave

While most companies won't give real references out, everything comes around eventually. People move around in the same industry circles. I often interview people where I know someone personally who they worked for or someone who they worked with at their previous job and I always check with that person. Because it's a personal relationship, they have no trouble giving me the skinny. So I would be nervous about that. It isn't the most ethical thing to do.

Posted 10/2/09 3:19 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
HR People- Maternity leave question Shelly 11/4/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
Regarding Maternity leave.... KittyCat 9/28/05 2 TTC
Women on maternity leave (before the baby is here) MrsR 9/6/05 5 Pregnancy
Spinoff to maternity leave~ 05mommy09 7/22/05 2 Pregnancy
Spinoff to maternity leave~ 05mommy09 7/22/05 4 Parenting
Maternity leave question sunny 7/21/05 8 Pregnancy